Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
AP IMPACT: Politics can drive stimulus priorities
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Search
Search:
AP IMPACT: Politics can drive stimulus priorities
By EILEEN SULLIVAN and MATT APUZZO,Associated Press Writers AP - Wednesday, August 26
WASHINGTON - A sleepy Montana checkpoint along the Canadian border that sees about three travelers a day will get $15 million under President Barack Obama's economic stimulus plan. A government priority list ranked the project as marginal, but two powerful Democratic senators persuaded the administration to make it happen.
ADVERTISEMENT
Despite Obama's promises that the stimulus plan would be transparent and free of politics, the government is handing out $720 million for border upgrades under a process that is both secretive and susceptible to political influence. This allowed low-priority projects such as the checkpoint in Whitetail, Mont., to skip ahead of more pressing concerns, according to documents revealed to The Associated Press.
It wasn't supposed to be that way. In 2004, Congress ordered Homeland Security to create a list, updated annually, of the most important repairs at checkpoints nationwide. But the Obama administration continued a Bush administration practice of considering other, more subjective factors when deciding which projects get money.
The results:
_ A border station in Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano's home state of Arizona is getting $199 million, five times more than any other border station. The busy Nogales checkpoint has required repairs for years but was not rated among the neediest projects on the master list reviewed by the AP. Napolitano credited her lobbying as Arizona governor for getting the project near the front of the line for funding under the Bush administration. All it needed was money, which the stimulus provided.
_ A checkpoint in Laredo, Texas, which serves more than 55,000 travelers and 4,200 trucks a day, is rated among the government's highest priorities but was passed over for stimulus money.
_ The Westhope, N.D., checkpoint, which serves about 73 people a day and is among the lowest-priority projects, is set to get nearly $15 million for renovations.
The Whitetail project, which involves building a border station the size and cost of a Hollywood mansion, benefited from two key allies, Montana Sens. Max Baucus and Jon Tester. Both pressed Napolitano to finance projects in their state. Tester's office boasted of that effort in an April news release, crediting Baucus and his seat at the head of the "powerful Senate Finance Committee."
Customs officials would not discuss that claim. Asked to explain Whitetail's windfall, they provided a one-page fact sheet that contains no information about Whitetail's needs and is almost identical to the fact sheet for every other Montana project.
It's hardly a recent phenomenon for politicians to use their influence to steer money to their home states. Yet Obama said the stimulus would be different. He banned "earmarks," which lawmakers routinely slip into bills to pay for pet projects, and he told agencies to "develop transparent, merit-based selection criteria" for spending.
Customs and Border Protection, the Homeland Security agency overseeing border projects, allowed the AP to review the list but will not make it public or explain its justifications for deviating from it.
Releasing that information would allow the public to see whether less important projects are getting money. The Transportation Department, for instance, was recently criticized by its internal watchdog for spending $1.1 billion on airport construction that didn't meet financing standards.
Without the lists, the public and members of Congress don't know when the administration bumps a project ahead of others ranked more important.
Customs officials said they wouldn't release the master list because it was just a starting point and subject to misunderstanding. They acknowledged there's no way for the public to know whether they are cherry-picking projects.
"There's a certain level of trust here," said Robert Jacksta, a deputy customs commissioner.
Some discrepancies between the stimulus plan and the priority list can be attributed to Congress, which set aside separate pools of money for large and small border stations. That guaranteed that a few small, probably lower-rated projects would be chosen ahead of bigger, higher-priority projects. But it doesn't explain all the discrepancies, because even within the two pools, Homeland Security sometimes reached way down on the list when selecting projects.
Many of the nation's 163 border checkpoints, known as land ports, are more than 40 years old and in need of upgrade and repairs. After the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks, those needs became more pressing and complex as officials beefed up border security. There is far more work to be done than money to complete it.
To prioritize, officials score each project on traffic volume, security vulnerability, construction needs and other factors. The resulting list represents "an objective and fair method for prioritizing projects," officials wrote in a 2005 summary.
That's the process the Obama administration described in a news release announcing $720 million in stimulus money for borders. But it didn't say that officials can choose projects out of order for many reasons.
Trent Frazier, who oversees the border projects, said the list Congress required is more like a meal plan. The administration can decide when to eat each dish, as long as everything eventually gets eaten.
Explaining why one project might get pushed ahead, Frazier said, "You just really liked pizza and you wanted to accelerate it."
In the case of the stimulus, officials said the Nogales, Ariz., project was construction-ready, a requirement of the recovery law. Officials also consider the economy, which means if the government expects local businesses to close and border traffic to decrease, it can delay paying for that project.
In one instance, officials said they reached deep into the list to provide $39 million for repairs in Van Buren, Maine, because flooding made the facility a safety hazard. In another, they are spending $30 million in Blaine, Wash., a lower-rated project that is unusual because it includes covering the costs of a state road project. With the 2010 Olympics coming to nearby Vancouver, Canada, officials worried the border would be strained without the project.
Officials said they could similarly justify every decision they've made. They would not provide those justifications to the AP. Frazier said the department would answer questions on a case-by-case basis, working through Congress to explain decisions to the public.
But even some in Congress say they aren't getting answers. Rep. Henry Cuellar, D-Texas, said he has yet to hear a good explanation about why highly ranked projects such as Laredo were snubbed.
More than $116 billion in freight passed through Laredo last year, according to the Transportation Department. It is one of the busiest border stations in the country. Unemployment in the metropolitan area is 9.4 percent.
"For the sake of fairness, if you have a list, there's some sort of expectation that you're going to follow that list," Cuellar said.
Tester, who said he pressed the Obama administration to get money for Montana projects, said border crossings in his state had been unfairly ignored.
"The northern border tends to be forgotten, and it shouldn't be," Tester told the Great Falls Tribune after announcing $77 million for Montana posts in the stimulus.
Whitetail, Mont., an unincorporated town with a population of 71, saw only about $63,000 in freight cross its border last year. County unemployment is an enviable 4 percent.
"I think, absolutely, it's going to create jobs and build the infrastructure," Tester said.
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Sign in to recommend this article »
0 users recommend
Related Articles: World
Kerry lauds Kennedy as 'best senator'AP - Thursday, August 27
Britain considers new high-speed rail to ScotlandAP - Thursday, August 27
One of two French agents in Somalia freedAFP - Thursday, August 27
Powerful Iraqi Shiite leader has died in IranAP - Thursday, August 27
Kennedy successor to be chosen by special electionAP - Thursday, August 27
Most Popular – World
Viewed
Profile of swine flu begins to emerge: study
Jackson killed by drugs cocktail: court
NASA calls off Discovery launch
High bidder 'can't pay' for crypt atop Monroe
Oil hits $75 for first time in 10 months
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Wednesday, 26 August 2009 Afghan bomb blast kills 36: police
extends reach into Arab world with Maktoob buy
Oil hits $75 for first time in 10 months
British PM upbeat after talks with Israel's PM
High bidder 'can't pay' for crypt atop Monroe
Frenchman hurt by 'exploding iPhone'
Israel's Netanyahu says seeking settlements formula
| International
|
Analysis: Iraq's premier must work to keep job
Yahoo to launch Arabic portal with Arab partner
Russia says nothing suspicious found on Arctic Sea
| International
|
Diplomats: Iran's enrichment program stagnates
Britain threatens to cut Internet for online pirates
UK, Israel warn Iran over nuclear program
| International
|
Iraq recalls envoy to Syria over truck bombings
Biel tops Pitt as 'most dangerous' celebrity on Web
European court raps Italy over G8 Genoa protests
| International
|
Iran resumes mass trial of opposition figures
UK proposes cutting Web access to file sharers
Head of troubled Darfur peacekeeping force resigns
| International
|
Karzai ahead in early Afghan election results
Qaeda-linked group claims bloody Baghdad attack
Netbook pioneer Asustek eyes recovery; bets on China
Iraq suspends decision to pull down blast walls
White House, Congress projects record deficits
Remains found in Alaska could be 1,000 years old
NKorea report says a senior military official dies
Transients board locomotive in Colo., get arrested
NKorea invites US envoys for talks, report says
Union wants ban on lithium batteries in cargo
Calif. school still closed after pipe bomb attack
Official: Explosion hits southern Afghan city
Official: Huge explosion hits southern Afghan city
Obama reappoints 'bold' Bernanke as Fed chairman
Pakistani Taliban say chief Baitullah Mehsud dead
Chinese president visits restive Xinjiang region
China mine blast kills 14: govt
3 dead in barn after standoff in northeast Tenn.
Karzai, Abdullah at 40 percent in partial returns
Man convicted in brutal slayings of Tenn. couple
Malaysian court puts caning of woman on hold
Hikers rescued in Alaska after journey into wild
Papa John's founder finds his beloved 1971 Camaro
Russia, Mongolia create uranium joint venture
HCL Technologies quarterly profit surges 110 pct
Daewoo to make $1.7 bln investment in Myanmar
Jessica Biel tops list as most risky star in cyberspace
| Entertainment
|
Pete Townshend plans new musical Floss
| Entertainment
|
Canada police know woman with accused model killer
| Entertainment
|
Orthodox Church condemns Madonna gig in Bulgaria
Los Lonely Boys to release 1969 tribute EP
| Entertainment
|
Bulgaria's church deplores Madonna concert
Caillat has a 'Breakthrough' with sophomore CD
LaToya Jackson appearing on '20/20' next month
Budget impasse forces Shyamalan movie from Pa.
Q&A: After `300,' Gerard Butler is still battling
Head of troubled Darfur peacekeeping force resigns
Russia seizes Norwegian yacht: border guards
North, South Korea hold rare talks on split families
| International
|
US ranks 28th in Internet connection speed: report
US inches toward dialogue with NKorea
Zimbabwe's Mugabe treated in Dubai hospital: paper
| International
|
NASA calls off Discovery launch
New ETA arms caches found in France
Iraq focuses bombings blame on operatives in Syria
Sony adds wireless e-reader as Kindle rival
Profile of swine flu begins to emerge: study
GM still wants to sell Opel: sources
Top reformist confesses in Iran political trial
YouTube to share ad money with more video makers
U.S. limits visas in Honduras, stepping up pressure
| International
|
Sony unveils new e-reader in Kindle challenge
Oil price hits ten-month peak at 75 dollars
Indonesian police arrest suspect over hotel blasts
| International
|
Australia Aborigines ask U.N. for refugee status
| International
|
Multitaskers distracted by everything: study
Iran puts leading reformers on trial over unrest
Chavez threatens break with Colombia
| International
|
Armstrong twitters up Dublin bike ride
Bomb kills 40 in Afghanistan's Kandahar: police
The Pirate Bay back online after fine threat
German prosecutors seek life for 'veil martyr' killer
Argentine farmers call new anti-government strike
| International
|
Iraq and Syria recall envoys over bombing claims
Sony adds wireless e-reader as Kindle rival
Sony unveils new e-reader in Kindle challenge
Sony adds wireless e-reader as Kindle rival
| Technology
|
YouTube to share ad money with more video makers
| Technology
|
Attorney: Alleged Iowa coach shooter incompetent
Car bomb blasts in Afghanistan kill at least 41
Tongans hold funeral service at sea for ferry dead
Chicken owner shoots own leg while hunting opossum
Taiwan FM offers resignation over typhoon blunder
Indonesian police arrest suspect over hotel blasts
'Drats!' Valve trouble postpones shuttle launch
US inches toward dialogue with NKorea
Most China organ transplants come from death row
Obamas visit top adviser's home, then go to dinner
Rocket launch: SKorea fails to contact satellite
MEMO FROM MARTHA's: Chief golfs with his chef
Karzai, top rival run about even in Afghan returns
LA school board approves school choice plan
N.Korea may invite U.S. for nuclear talks
New park offers X-rated views of NYC hotel guests
California Catholics try TV to draw churchgoers
Video allegedly shows 'executions' in Sri Lanka: report
Workers at home where chaplain fell criticized
Drunk man found at grocery store eating avocados
China Life first half profit up 15 percent
Toyota to cut production capacity at Japan factory
Toyota to slash world production capacity: reports
Seoul shares up 0.4 pct; NCSoft, Korea Beral spike
S.Korea Aug consumer sentiment hits 7-yr high
Air China sees first half profit more than double
Chris Brown sentenced in LA for assault
| Entertainment
|
Korea Hot Stocks
Sale falls through on crypt above Marilyn Monroe
| Entertainment
|
Seoul shares open up; NCSoft, Samsung Techwin gain
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Epson pleads guilty to price-fixing, to pay 26 mln dlr fine
Extract distilled from human stupidity
| Entertainment
|
India says Delhi talks aimed at building WTO consensus
NJ court appearance for comic Artie Lange delayed
Sale falls through on crypt above Marilyn Monroe
Chris Brown sentenced in Rihanna assault case
Ga. judge: Accused Miley Cyrus stalker 'a danger'
Billboard names Beyonce as 'Woman of the Year'
Argentina legalizes personal marijuana possession
Abdul to host 'VH1 Divas' Sept. 17 concert special
B'way's 'West Side Story' has a minor lyric change
Paisley, Underwood return as hosts of CMA Awards
Karzai widens lead in Afghan vote
French hostage in Somalia freed 'without violence'
Karzai leads in Afghan poll, run-off indicated
| International
|
Google Maps tracking traffic flow
German firms most bullish since crisis began
Russia admits mystery ship may have had suspect cargo
Advertising giant WPP profits slump in first half
Toll in Kandahar bomb at least 40: police
Abbas to call election if talks with Hamas fail
| International
|
Singer Chris Brown sentenced for Rihanna assault
Iran's Khatami says trial confessions invalid
| International
|
Bomb kills 40 in Afghanistan's Kandahar: police
Iraqi Shi'ite party leader dies, successor eyed
| International
|
Swelling US deficit threatens Obama reforms
Forensic experts unearth 60 Bosnian war victims
| International
|
French hostage escapes from rebels in Somalia
| International
|
Russia eyes landmark purchase of French assault ship
| International
|
Madagsacar leaders still deadlocked over top job
| International
|
Pakistani forces launch air attack on Taliban
| International
|
US-TECH Summary
Nokia to launch mobile financial service
| Technology
|
Nokia bets on Linux in iPhone battle: sources
| Technology
|
House gets guerrilla ad treatment
| Technology
|
IBM, Indian outsourcers win services deal from BP
| Technology
|
Official: Dalai Lama to visit Taiwan
Thai tennis star launches new herbal Viagra
Malaysian opposition wins bellwether vote
Kennedy successor to be chosen by special election
Upstart party has already changed Japan politics
Sen. Kennedy's death leaves 1 Kennedy sibling
Hope, reality collide in post-Katrina New Orleans
Ted Kennedy: Senator, family patriarch, dead at 77
Koreas to hold first Red Cross talks in 2 years
Text of Obama statement on Kennedy
UN says ex-rebels breached Nepal peace agreement
Israeli PM resists US pressure over settlements
Interrogation probe steams those on right and left
Most lawmakers and analysts welcome Bernanke news
Russia deploys air defence over N.Korea missile tests
AP IMPACT: Politics can drive stimulus priorities
Schwarzenegger mourns loss of `Uncle Teddy'
Pakistani Taliban seen as regrouping
House gets guerrilla ad treatment
| Entertainment
|
Taiwan dollar ends slightly lower on outflows
CNOOC says 1H profit down 55 pct on lower prices
S.Koreans most upbeat since 2002 but president cautions
Thai interest rate unchanged amid recovery doubts
Japan trade surplus rises for second month
Pakistan's medium-term outlook still fragile
SKorea to ratify EU free trade deal soon: Speaker
Indonesian police detain suspect in hotel bombings
Disputed time in Jackson case could be key
'Prince of Jihad' arrested in Indonesia: police
Mongolia tax repeal clears way for $4 bln mine
Peter Horton: 'thirtysomething' lacked big 'but'
Vietnam says inflation slowing
US race row raises questions over Bollywood spin
Seoul shares post highest close in 13 months =2
In greying Japan, youth may turn out to rock the vote
Mexico players fight for pre-Hispanic game site
'Bamboo schools' bring hope to Nepal's poor
Lee Young-ae marries businessman in US
"Extract" distilled from human stupidity
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights