Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Pregnancy denial syndrome: a case for defence?
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Asia Pacific
World
Pregnancy denial syndrome: a case for defence?
AFP - Sunday, August 1
Send
IM Story
Print
Pregnancy denial syndrome: a case for defence?
PARIS (AFP) - – Whether the French woman who killed eight of her newborns suffered from a syndrome known as pregnancy denial may determine if she faces major prison time or intensive psychiatric care.
The woman, 45-year-old Dominique Cottrez, has said that she was aware of her pregnancies, the prosecutor handling the case said last week.
The admission, he suggested, means that she cannot invoke the syndrome in her defence.
But Cottrez's lawyer, Frank Berton, countered Friday that the state had been "too hasty" in reaching that conclusion.
"Many psychiatrists will disagree. Just because one is conscious of a pregnancy does not mean that one isn't in denial," he told journalists.
The syndrome has already been used as a defence in other infanticide cases here -- legitimately so, said Sophie Marinopoulos, a psychiatrist at Nantes maternity hospital in western France.
"To my knowledge women do not organise their pregnancies in order to kill their children. It is a case of psychological suffering," she told AFP.
For Israel Nisand, an obstetrician at the Univeristy Hospital in Strasbourg who has testified in court, the problem is all too real.
"When you don't know what it is, of course these women will look like monsters," he said.
Experts distinguish between three types of pregnancy denial.
With so-called pervasive denial, "not only the emotional significance by the very existence of the pregnancy is kept from awareness," notes Laura Miller of Brigham and Womens Hospital in Boston.
In the case of psychotic denial, unacknowledged pregnancy occurs in women with severe mental illness, sometimes compounded by abuse.
Women with "affective denial," however, are intellectually aware of their condition "but continue to think, feel, and behave as though they were not pregnant," according to Miller.
A woman addicted to drugs potentially harmful to a foetus, for example, may enter this state of mind to assuage guilt feelings.
In all three types, weight gain, changes in the breasts, and even labour pains can all be misconstrued or explained away in the mind of the woman.
Partners and family may also fail to notice changes, especially when the expectant mother is -- as was the case with Cottrez -- severely overweight.
In a study published in Psychosomatic Medicine, Susan Hatters Friedman of Case Western Reserve University in Ohio and colleagues examined records for 31,475 deliveries at the university hospital from 1998 through 2003.
The key tipoff to potential cases of pregnancy denial was women who had not sought any form of prenatal care before delivery.
When combined with other criteria, they found a total 61 cases of denial, a rate of about one in 500.
Instances of complete denial -- including some in which women did not realise they were pregnant until delivery -- were far rarer, about one in 2,500. None involved infanticide.
There were an additional 20 cases of a distinct syndrome called pregnancy concealment in which women consciously hide their condition from family and friends.
Research in Germany and France has yielded similar statistics.
Contrary to expectations, the profile to emerge from the US study was not one of first-time pregnancies among economically deprived teenagers living with parents.
Women were more likely to be well into their twenties, to work and to have no record of family of spousal abuse.
"It can affect women of different ages, education levels and social standings," said Felix Navarro, a physician and president of the French association for the recognition of pregnancy denial.
Pregnancy denial came to public attention in France last year after another dramatic case of infanticide.
Veronique Coujault killed three of her newborns, keeping two of the bodies in her freezer and burning the third. As with Cottrez, the husband said he was unaware of what was happening.
But Roland Coutanceau, a forensic psychiatrist and expert witness in France, is skeptical that the syndrome was a factor for either woman.
"I don't believe in pregnancy denial. We don't need it to explain what happened," he told AFP.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Eerie Munch prints get US National Gallery retrospective AFP - Sunday, August 1
Serbian film 'Tilva Ros' wins Sarajevo festival AFP - Sunday, August 1
Movie tax cuts 'help struggling California economy' AFP - Sunday, August 1
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary Reuters - Saturday, July 31
As Emmys host, Jimmy Fallon aims not to offend Reuters - Saturday, July 31
News Search
Top Stories
'Overwhelming emotion' as Chelsea Clinton marries
Debate on death and taxes heats up as billionaires fall
Dibaba wins women's 10,000m
New BP boss off to Russia to mend fences: report
Engineers prepare to seal ruptured oil well
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Calcium supplements linked to heart attacks: study
Engineers prepare to seal ruptured oil well
'Overwhelming emotion' as Chelsea Clinton marries
US growth slows fueling fears over recovery
US Fed official warns of 'Japanese-style' stagnation
More Most Viewed »
Parachuting donkey shocks Russian beachgoers
Argentine students crack three-decade-old murder mystery
World's first full face transplant man appears on TV
Paris Hilton caught with cannabis in handbag
Calcium supplements linked to heart attacks: study
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo!
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
World Cup 2010
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Sunday, 1 August 2010 'Flash floods kill at least 65 in Afghanistan'
New BP boss off to Russia to mend fences: report
Hackers pick up where Facebook privacy leaves off
Afghan official: 3 die in Kunduz suicide bombing
Mexico police free journalists seized by drug gangs
|
Dibaba wins women's 10,000m
Chelsea Clinton tying the knot in lavish, secretive wedding
MSF suspends aid to south Sudan region after attacks
|
Colombia says never thought to attack Venezuela
|
Pakistan spy chief scraps UK trip on "terror" remarks
Tseng on song at British Open
Two China mine industry accidents kill 17, trap 24
Sri Lankan, Hawaiian sites make world heritage list
Kashima maintain J-League lead
Teen Dutch sailor to head off Wednesday for solo world bid
All Blacks destroy Wallabies in Tri Nations rout
Movie tax cuts 'help struggling California economy'
"Black box" recovered from Pakistan crash site
British sculptor's cast-iron humans conquer Austrian Alps
'Reliance, Universal in talks for Indian theme park'
Roadside bomb kills six in Afghanistan
Russia fires cover 100,000 hectares
British police hold two over MI6 parcel bomb
|
UAE to suspend some Blackberry services
British PM facing rough ride in Pakistan
Bomb found at Britain's MI6 spy agency
Israel strikes Gaza tunnels after rocket launch
|
Hacker makes mobile phone snooping affordable
Debate on death and taxes heats up as billionaires fall
Six Afghan civilians die in roadside bomb blast
|
Frenchman, 80, freed after year in wife's laundry prison
Israel strikes Gaza tunnels after rocket launch
Brazil offers asylum to Iranian woman facing stoning
|
US-TECH Summary
Brazil offers asylum to Iranian woman facing stoning
Mexican police free journalists seized by drug gangs
|
Japan mobile phone makers to roll out 'augmented reality'
6 Afghans killed when minibus hits roadside bomb
Iraq civilian death toll almost doubles in July
|
Hack attack hits ATM jackpots
MSF suspends aid to south Sudan region after attacks
Philippines says arrests key massacre suspect in south
|
Mysterious 'insurance file' posted on WikiLeaks
South Korean killed by North Korean mine: report
|
Indian troops enforce strict curfew in Kashmir
Top security as Chelsea Clinton ties the knot
UAE to suspend Blackberry service on security fears
|
Philippines says arrests key massacre suspect in south
Heat on coach after Wallabies defeat
Philippine president steps into airline row
South Korean killed by North Korean mine
Seven hours the magic number for sleep: study
Ex-Aussie PM threatens legal action over leaks claim
Philippines remembers Cory Aquino, democracy icon
Greek tourism reels from fuel shortage, strikes
Bedbugs take bite out of Big Apple
Drifting N.Korean mine kills S.Korean
Malaysia 'Imam Idol' seeks to put friendly face on Islam
Pregnancy denial syndrome: a case for defence?
Eerie Munch prints get US National Gallery retrospective
Tens of thousands march in Sweden Gay Pride
Sex sells at China computer game show
Trade ban prompts N.Korea to find Chinese partners: report
Rowers break 114-year-old Atlantic crossing record
Serbian film 'Tilva Ros' wins Sarajevo festival
China's manufacturing activity slows in July
S.Korea trade surplus widens in July
Growth in Chinese manufacturing continues to slow
24 remain trapped in flooded coal mine in NE China
Japanese user claims Twitter's 20 billionth tweet
Israeli warplanes hit Gaza after new rocket attack
Death toll climbs as Russia forest fires spread
Floods wreak havoc across Pakistan, over 1,000 killed
|
Japan robot brings visitors home by video-phone
Dutch troops leave Afghanistan after four years
Indian police fire on protest in Kashmir, two dead
|
China, Vietnam, Iran win UNESCO heritage honours
WikiLeaks guilty, at least morally: Robert Gates
|
Iran rebuffs Obama's call to free U.S. detainees
Pakistan president to visit Britain amid terror row
|
Iraq civilian death toll almost doubles in July
Mugabe lashes out at West over Zimbabwe sanctions
|
Qaeda says held talks on hostage killed in Sahara
|
6 Afghans killed when minibus hits roadside bomb
Anxiety grips Kenya's Rift Valley farms over vote
|
Pakistan flood toll tops 1,000 as cholera emerges
Pakistan flood toll tops 1,000
Flood toll in China's northeast rises to 100
Floods wreak havoc across Pakistan, over 1,000 killed
Hong Kong people rally to save Cantonese language
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Chelsea Clinton weds at exclusive New York estate
Aussie PM struggles with election campaign
Jazz singer Jarreau leaves hospital in France
Yellow lobster pulled from RI's Narragansett Bay
Folau double sinks NRL leaders Dragons
3 inmates escape from northwest Arizona prison
'Overwhelming emotion' as Chelsea weds in white
N.Korea renews retaliation threats ahead of US envoy trip
Random House sees e-book sales jumping: CEO
|
Chinese rescuers battle to save 24 trapped in mine
Bangladesh garment workers in new clashes with police
Philippines govt intervenes to resolve airline row
Jazz singer Jarreau leaves hospital in France
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights