Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
AP INVESTIGATION: SC gov's plane use questioned
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Search
Search:
AP INVESTIGATION: SC gov's plane use questioned
By JIM DAVENPORT,Associated Press Writer AP - Monday, August 10
COLUMBIA, S.C. - South Carolina Gov. Mark Sanford used state aircraft for personal and political trips, often bringing along his wife and children _ contrary to state law regarding official use, an Associated Press investigation has found.
ADVERTISEMENT
According to state budget law, "Any and all aircraft owned or operated by agencies of the State Government shall be used only for official business."
Records reviewed by the AP show that since he took office in 2003, the two-term Republican has taken trips on state aircraft to locations of his children's sporting events, hair and dentist appointments, political party gatherings and a birthday party for a campaign donor.
On March 10, 2006, a state plane was sent to pick up Sanford in Myrtle Beach and return him to Columbia, the state capital, at a cost of $1,265 _ when his calendar showed his only appointment in Columbia was "personal time" at his favorite discount hair salon. He had flown to Myrtle Beach on a private plane and attended a county GOP event.
The trip home on the state aircraft took off at 1:50 p.m. and arrived in Columbia at 2:35, enabling the governor to keep his plans for a 3 p.m. haircut across town. There were no other appointments on his official schedule that afternoon; the trip back to Columbia would have taken about three hours by car.
Also, on five of the last six Thanksgiving weekends, Sanford used a state plane to fly himself, his wife and their four sons from the family's plantation in Beaufort County to Columbia for the state Christmas tree lighting. The cost for those flights alone: $5,536, including $2,869 for flying the plane empty to pick them up.
Sanford, 49, has been under increased scrutiny since he admitted in June to having a mistress in Argentina. He's vowed to stay in office and says he is trying to reconcile with his wife, though she moved out of the governor's official residence on Friday with their sons and plans to spend the school year at the family's beach house.
The governor has made a political career out of being outwardly thrifty _ known to demand that state employees use both sides of Post-It notes. He has frequently railed against government spending, and attempted for months to block federal stimulus money for South Carolina schools.
Last month, the AP revealed how Sanford had flown first class and business class on commercial airlines at taxpayer expense, despite a law requiring lowest-cost travel.
On many occasions, records show, the governor mingled his non-official travels with official business.
For example, on March 23, 2005, Sanford flew on a state plane from Columbia to Mount Pleasant, near the beach house, where the governor was scheduled for a 5 p.m. appointment with a dentist. Later that day, he had a TV interview before speaking at a Republican Party event for Charleston, Berkeley and Dorchester counties along with U.S. Sens. Lindsey Graham and Jim DeMint.
Such mingling also is problematic under South Carolina regulations.
Aeronautics Division rules say that "under no circumstances shall aircraft owned and operated by" the division "be used for personal or politically partisan purposes." But there's no clear enforcement mechanism for such violations; the division says it simply lets citizens know that statements attesting to official use of the planes are open to public inspection.
Still, misuse of state resources arguably could subject Sanford to civil or criminal penalties under the state's ethics laws, which are enforced by the South Carolina Ethics Commission. Any public official found to have used state property for personal financial gain is subject to as much as a $5,000 fine and five years in prison. Only incidental use that does not result in additional public expense is exempt.
On April 29, 2006, a state plane flew Sanford from Greenville, not far from where one of his sons was in a soccer tournament, to Charleston, so the governor could attend a National Republican Senatorial Committee meeting on Kiawah Island.
"That's personal use and political use. That's not what the state plane is for," said former Gov. Jim Hodges, a Democrat who said he occasionally mingled official state business with political and public events while using state aircraft, but only if the main purpose of the trip was official business.
Peggy Kerns, ethics director for the National Conference of State Legislatures, said she knows of no state that allows its property to be used for personal or campaign purposes. "It's like a no-brainer," she said.
Government watchdogs said federal officials have to repay the cost of flying government planes for personal or campaign events and said they didn't know of a state that permitted planes to be used for such trips.
The AP review also raises questions about how South Carolina polices the use of its aircraft and reveals a system rife with shoddy record keeping and violations of laws that require the public be able to see documents.
In South Carolina, governors are able to use aircraft run by different agencies: a King Air twin turboprop run by the Aeronautics Division that can seat nine passengers, and smaller, slower propeller-driven planes managed by the Department of Natural Resources.
As governor, Sanford has flown 353 hours aboard the larger plane and an additional 73 hours on the smaller, propeller planes _ a total cost of nearly $373,000, according to Sanford's office and other state records.
Sanford's children spent more time on the bigger state plane than the children of the past two governors, records show. At least one of Sanford's sons was aboard 43 flights during his first term alone. That compared with 11 during Hodges' single term and 12 during David Beasley's one term.
Overall, flights that included his children cost taxpayers more than $50,000, or about 14 percent of his total travel on state planes.
"If it was somewhere the governor was going, sometimes the kids tagged along. There is no additional cost to the taxpayers for the kids to be on the plane if it's somewhere the governor is headed anyway," said Sanford spokesman Joel Sawyer, who stepped down Aug. 5.
Additional matches of flight documents and Sanford's schedule show:
_ An Oct. 14, 2004 pickup in Bishopville, where his schedule shows his son Marshall's private school football team was playing. Afterward, the plane took him to Charlotte, N.C., for a commercial flight to Dallas, where his schedule placed the governor at a lake house in Texas for a gathering of Republican donors.
_ A Nov. 14, 2006 flight to Mount Pleasant, where he attended a book signing. He then flew to Aiken for the 65th birthday party for a business owner who had donated more than $12,000 to his campaign.
_ A July 8, 2005 use of the state's turboprop to fly from Charleston to Greenville, where Sanford lists the official use of the King Air for a round-table discussion with business leaders, interviews and "Greenville County Bronze Elephant Dinner," a county GOP event.
Sawyer said the governor had fewer hours on Aeronautics Division planes in his first term than his two predecessors: 229 hours, compared with Beasley's 303 hours and Hodges' 310 hours. Sawyer characterized the review of Sanford's flight schedule as "continued cherry picking," a term he used when the AP examined the commercial flights.
"Every time the governor used the plane it was for an official state purpose and that state purpose was documented," Sawyer said.
He also said Sanford's schedule doesn't chronicle all his official activities. "The governor's schedule is not reflective of everything he's doing that day," he said.
Former state Rep. Margaret Gamble, a watchdog on political travel issues, said Sanford should get the benefit of the doubt on a case-by-case basis. For instance, one of Sanford's flights took him from Anderson to Marion County for a soldier's funeral and then to Greenwood so he could get to a McCormick County GOP fundraiser. "Maybe he had a prior commitment," she said, but needed to go to the funeral, too, and the plane was the only way to keep his promise."
Other governors have faced questions about aircraft use, including Beasley for using a state helicopter to get to a speech and then back for a golf game. John Crangle, state director for government watchdog group Common Cause, said governors "have been given almost unlimited latitude to do as they please, to come and go as they please or when they want to and to use the state's resources for travel when they want."
He said the AP research indicates Sanford repeatedly made mistakes.
"This was the Wild West for the governor's travel when basically anything was permitted or done and accepted as normal," Crangle said.
In fact, state law requires the Aeronautics Division to collect and keep sworn statements from aircraft users certifying flights were for official business within 48 hours of flights. Sanford's office routinely filed that paperwork days or weeks late and the division destroys documents more than three years old.
"They're actually destroying data that the Legislature gave them no permission to destroy. That's like destroying evidence," said state Sen. David Thomas, a Republican congressional candidate who has begun holding legislative hearings into Sanford's use of state funds.
The same law requires the agency to post those records on its Web site. That was done briefly earlier this month, but the Aeronautics Division pulled the link to the records as the commission that oversees its operation reviews the law. Until July 1, the agency reported to Sanford's cabinet.
And the law required the natural resources agency to keep official statements on flights, which it never has. Governors appoint the entire board overseeing the agency.
"The situation is one that's dramatically out of control and needs to be completely overhauled," Crangle said.
Added Thomas: "It's an overwhelming ethical issue here. To me, this is clear misuse of state property."
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Sign in to recommend this article »
0 users recommend
Related Articles: World
Obama attending first US-Canada-Mexico summitAP - Monday, August 10
AP INVESTIGATION: SC gov's plane use questionedAP - Monday, August 10
Briton in Iraqi custody after contractor killingsAP - Monday, August 10
Blasts hit Majorca restaurants, ETA suspectedAFP - Monday, August 10
Clinton presses Angola to sweeten trade tiesAP - Monday, August 10
Most Popular – World
Viewed
Scientists decode HIV genome structure: study
Three new bank failures bring to 72 number of collapsed US banks
Taiwan's Jay Chou goes to Hollywood: report
Manson murders back in spotlight 40 years on
Explosions at besieged 'terror hideout' in Indonesia
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Monday, 10 August 2009 Iran judiciary looks to calm prison abuse outrage
Publicis to buy Razorfish from Microsoft for $530m
Publicis to buy Razorfish from Microsoft for $530m
Briton, Australian killed in Iraq shooting
Burglars steal $15m from Saudi princess
51 US soldiers in Iraq diagnosed with swine flu
Israel summons U.S. envoy over settlement dispute
U.N. says violence threatens Afghan poll
| International
|
Majorca hit by bomb, ETA claims attack: reports
Israel summons U.S. envoy over settlement dispute
| International
|
Iran military says opposition chiefs should face trial
Israel warns Hezbollah over assassination report
Bill Clinton to lead investor mission to Haiti
| International
|
Honduras snubs OAS leader, cancels visit
| International
|
Wait for sex and marriage? Evangelicals conflicted
AP INVESTIGATION: SC gov's plane use questioned
UN: Violence hampering Afghan vote
Clinton: No illusions Iran will return to talks
GOP senator warns against pulling a 'Rumsfeld'
Australia crush England to level Ashes
U.S. says evidence Taliban chief dead "pretty conclusive"
Special Olympiacs getting well wishes for Shriver
40 inmates hurt in riot at Calif.'s Chino prison
Snakebites kill 6,000 Bangladeshis each year
Official: Closing Gitmo prison can be done by Jan.
7.1-magnitude quake hits off eastern Japan
Car fleeing Calif. police hits pickup, killing 7
Strong quake jolts Tokyo; trains halted briefly
Bodies of 4 kidnapped Pakistani police found
IMF upgrades South Korea economy forecast
New Zealand house price decline eases in July-survey
'G.I. Joe' commands box office with $56.2M debut
G.I. Joe movie leads worldwide invasion
| Entertainment
|
Rapid change in late-night viewing
"G.I. Joe" movie leads worldwide invasion
'G.I. Joe' commands box office with $56.2M debut
'Cosi' rounds off Guth's Mozart trilogy in Salzburg
Greek Woman Accused Of Setting Fire Briton's Private Parts
Chinese Bride Challenges Record For World's Longest Wedding Gown With 7,093-Foot-Long Dress
Gaza: Israeli planes strike in response to mortars
Britain's MI6 not complicit in torture, says chief
Bombs in Baghdad and northern Iraq kill 41
| International
|
Mark Lester did not father Jackson's children: report
String of bombings kill at least 40 in Iraq
500 children a year abducted from Britain: report
U.S. targets Afghan drug lords tied to Taliban: report
| International
|
Chavez claims Colombian troops entered Venezuela
Bomb blasts hit Majorca, ETA suspected: authorities
Opium takes over entire Afghan families, villages
Iran Guard wants former president, moderates tried
| International
|
50 suspected Afghan drug lords targeted by US: report
China breaks up large underground bank ring
| International
|
Israel summons U.S. envoy over settlement dispute
| International
|
Palestinian Fatah seeks renewal, rejuvenation
Homeless Holocaust survivor leaves $100,000 gift
China's east coast battered by typhoon
| International
|
Venezuela, Colombia tensions high ahead of summit
| International
|
Honduras says OAS visit on again
| International
|
43 people killed in landslides in northern India
NYPD: Bodies of plane pilot, adult passenger remain missing
Tonga ferry disaster: Search temporarily halted
Hyundai boss goes to NKorea to seek worker's release
Immune system cancer found in young 9/11 officers
9 killed, 9 missing as typhoon hits Japan
Hazardous waste sites ready for last cleanup phase
Focus on Xie and Nehwal at badminton Worlds
AP INVESTIGATION: Border police being busted more
9 killed as Typhoon Etau hits western Japan
Ponting eager for date with Ashes destiny
Memorial service held for slain Calif. teen
Report: 5 dead, 10 missing as typhoon hits Japan
About 250 inmates injured in riot at Calif. prison
North Korean leader appears in "full control": US
White House: Afghan war not in crisis
British, Australian security contractors shot dead in Iraq
Cabbie crashes into church with 5 locked inside
'G.I. Joe' commands box office with $56.2M debut
DEALTALK-Debt deals propping up foreign banks in S.Korea
Hyundai chief to visit N.Korea over detained worker
Japanese economic data lift recovery hopes
New Zealand central bank buys NZ$6 mln in June
Japan core machinery orders up 9.7 percent in June
Korea Hot Stocks-Hyundai Marine up, Hanjin Shipping falls
Seoul shares rise but blue chips losing glow
China's sports hope to turn professional
S.Korean bonds fall before auctions, rate vote
ING sells office building in S.Korea for $327 mln
Beatles copyrights in McCartney's (distant) sights
Doubts grow about Islamist's death in Indonesia
Death of Indian 'queen' triggers royal squabble
Lou Reed, The Killers rock Chicago's Lollapalooza
'Twilight' sinks fangs into Teen Choice Awards
G.I. Joe movie leads worldwide invasion
| Entertainment
|
Reality show "Shark Tank" cashes in on recession
Beatles copyrights in McCartney's (distant) sights
| Entertainment
|
"There Goes the Neighborhood" borders on creepy
Tara Reid heads to pub for "Last Call"
Songwriters encouraged to explore new genres
| Entertainment
|
R&B singer Keri Hilson took detour to stardom
Album sales testing new lows in summer doldrums
Lou Reed, The Killers rock Chicago's Lollapalooza
| Entertainment
|
Indians to refine business skills at 'finishing schools'
There Goes the Neighborhood borders on creepy
| Entertainment
|
Reality show Shark Tank cashes in on recession
| Entertainment
|
R&B singer Keri Hilson took detour to stardom
| Entertainment
|
Tara Reid heads to pub for Last Call
| Entertainment
|
British insurer enters takeover talks
Media: Iran purges Intelligence Ministry officials
Iraq bombs kill 40, fears of sectarian strife grow
| International
|
DNA tests to identify British, Aussie WWI troops
Taliban attack near Kabul kills police, civilians
| International
|
Clinton to push Congo, U.N. on atrocities on women
| International
|
Afghan govt compound 'under rocket attack'
Iran will strongly resist West vote interference: official
| International
|
Iraq bomb attacks kill 47
South America split over U.S. bases plan in Colombia
| International
|
Mallorca moves to limit bomb damage to tourism
| International
|
Israel bombs Gaza tunnel in retaliatory strike
Don't brush with baldness: put down that comb
Military, militants battle in tribal Pakistan
Drugs deaths, swine flu dominate North America summit
Israel bombs Gaza tunnel in retaliatory strike
| International
|
Pakistan pledges to curb militancy, pounds insurgents
Hordes of schoolkids put Stasi memorial in the red
| International
|
Iraq bombs kill 40 as fears grow
Somali Islamists pull teeth from sinners: residents
| International
|
Bombs in Baghdad and northern Iraq kill 41
Saudi Arabia arrested thousands without trial: HRW
| International
|
US commander says Taliban gaining upper hand: report
1 dead as 6 Taliban attack town south of Kabul
Former Khmer Rouge guard describes dumping corpses
First U.S. wireless pacemaker gives patient freedom
| Technology
|
Ga. terrorism defendant to call on family at trial
Australia pledges $8 mln for native languages
Israeli foreign minister suggests consul resign
Twenty-eight dead as typhoons hit East Asia
Verdicts in Myanmar's Suu Kyi trial may be delayed
Public spied on 1,500 times a day in UK, study finds
| Technology
|
Clinton, Angola sign agreement to combat HIV/AIDS
New Zealand sets greenhouse gas emissions target
The Nation's Weather
China cracks billion-dollar money laundering gang
Veterinarians using stem cells to treat animals
Bomb blast kills 6 Taliban while planting IED
US troops killed in Iraq and Kuwait
13 dead as typhoon brings floods, landslides to Japan
Philippines frees 2 rebels to revive peace talks
US troops killed in Afghanistan and Africa
1st trial to start in Texas `fight club' case
Clinton shifts focus to human rights in Africa
Chinese group to sell stake in Lenovo parent
China property sales soar, triggering bubble fears
China shares fall amid fears of credit reduction
Bln-dlr money-laundering ring smashed in China: report
S.Korea fin min says no need for more property measures-report
Pakistan inflation falls to 19-month low
Indian car sales jump in July
'Great Depression 2.0' avoided: Krugman
Seoul shares end flat but foreign buying continues =2
Closing arguments set in C-Murder's La. trial
Lady Gaga shows off tattoo during Asia tour
Singapore farmers see green shoots in new food policy
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Songwriters encouraged to explore new genres
Indian FM slams 'dubious' Australian colleges
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights