">Forum Views ()
">Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
British, French nuclear subs collide in Atlantic: officials
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Search
Search:
British, French nuclear subs collide in Atlantic: officials
AFP - Tuesday, February 17
LONDON (AFP) - - British and French nuclear submarines collided in the middle of the Atlantic earlier this month, officials admitted Monday, while insisting the embarrassing accident had not posed an atomic risk.
ADVERTISEMENT
In what experts called an unprecedented incident, Britain's HMS Vanguard and France's Le Triomphant hit each other deep underwater in the middle of the ocean on February 4, according to British press reports.
The crash caused damage but no leaks from the vessels. Each is some 150 metres (490 feet) long and can carry up to 48 nuclear warheads on a maximum of 16 missiles. A total of 250 sailors were onboard at the time.
Confirming the reports, Britain's First Sea Lord Admiral Sir Jonathan Band said the submarines "were conducting routine ... patrols in the Atlantic Ocean.
"Recently, the two submarines came into contact at very low speed. Both submarines remained safe and no injuries occurred," he told reporters.
"We can confirm that the capability remained unaffected and there has been no compromise to nuclear safety."
The British sub returned to its Faslane base in western Scotland under its own power on Saturday, he said, where it is reportedly undergoing repairs.
France's defence ministry said on February 6 that Le Triomphant was damaged when it hit an object, possibly a sinking cargo container, while submerging. It returned to base at Ile-Longue, near Brest in northwest France.
The sonar dome on the front of the vessel was damaged, the navy said at the time, adding the incident had not resulted in injuries among the crew and did not jeopardise nuclear security at any time.
On Monday, the French navy confirmed a British submarine was involved.
"This is the first incident of its kind in more than 400 patrols that we have carried out," navy spokesman Captain Jerome Erulin told AFP.
Stephen Saunders of military information group Jane's said there were three possible causes.
The first was a possible procedural error: the submarines should have been subject to "NATO waterspace management" which "deconflicts" such incidents, even if France is not part of NATO's military command structure, he said.
Secondly the two vessels may not have been able to hear each other because of high-tech engineering designed to make them undetectable to enemies.
Thirdly was simple bad luck. "Even if two submarines do find themselves in the same area, it is still bad luck to have run into each other -- i.e. to be in the same place at the same depth," Saunders said.
France and Britain are two of the world's five declared nuclear powers, along with the United States, China and Russia.
France has maintained a sea-based nuclear deterrent force since 1971 and currently has three nuclear-armed submarines in operation. A fourth will come into service next year.
HMS Vanguard, launched in 1992, is one of four British nuclear submarines, one of which is always on deterrent patrol.
Britain is planning to renew the system, named Trident, at a cost of about 20 billion pounds (now 30 billion dollars, 22 billion euros).
A French anti-nuclear group meanwhile attacked military authorities for taking so long to admit the collision.
"It appears obvious that once again the first reflex of the nuclear lobby is to hide the truth," said Sortir du Nucleaire (Get Out of Nuclear).
"Nothing therefore has changed since the state lies about the Chernobyl cloud" in 1986, when the nuclear reactor in Ukraine melted down and sent a cloud of radioactive pollution into the atmosphere, it added.
Saunders said the collision highlighted a serious management issue. "The damage, while embarrassing, can be repaired. No doubt there are a number of technical issues to be investigated," he said.
"But the root of the problem appears to be procedural. These submarines should not have been in the same place at the same time."
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Recommend this article
Average (0 votes)
Sign in to recommend this article »
Most Recommended Stories »
Related Articles: World
British soldier killed in AfghanistanAFP - 59 minutes ago
Petraeus flies into Uzbekistan for talks: officialsAFP - 1 hour 5 minutes ago
Escaped French prisoners captured: ministryAFP - 1 hour 23 minutes ago
Trade to top Obama agenda in first foreign tripReuters - 1 hour 29 minutes ago
Elderly New Yorkers angry as crisis hits poorestReuters - 1 hour 36 minutes ago
Enlarge Photo
A file photo of France's "Le Triomphant" nuclear submarine. British and French nuclear submarines collided in the Atlantic Ocean earlier this month, officials admitted Monday, confirming an embarrassing accident involving highly sensitive technology.
Most Popular – World
Viewed
Earth-like planets in our galactic neighborhood
Seductive chemicals hidden in sloppy kisses
AIDS: 'Major advance' seen in revolutionary gene therapy
Climate change could be even worse than feared
Mexico wins new kissing record
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Tuesday, 17 February 2009 Madonna, Guy Ritchie File Joint Custody In New York
Khmer Rouge torture chief regretful on eve of trial
| International
|
Online File Sharing Site Founders Face Trial Over Allegedly Breaking Swedish Copyright Laws
Israeli govt to consider Hamas prisoner swap, truce
| International
|
Hague tribunal accepts new Karadzic indictment
| International
|
Pirate Bay copyright test case begins in Sweden
| Technology
|
Mobile industry highlights positives amid gloom
| Technology
|
New York Gov. Paterson Under Fire For Staff Pay Raises
TRG Adds 550 Jobs To West Virginia Call Centers
Feb 16 Highlights Of Low Points In U.S. Economy
Hong Kong woman's airport hysterics an online hit
| Technology
|
Lawyer Shortage Hits Local Federal Prosecutors' Offices
Web-based program improves diabetics' self care
| Technology
|
Major Storm Brings Snow, Heavy Rain To Southern California
Chrysler President Forecasts 10 Million Auto Sales In The U.S. For 2009
Salma Hayek, Francois-Henri Pinault wed in France
| Entertainment
|
Italian Minister Pushes For Surgical Castration Of Rapists
Blood Pressure Medication May Reduce Symptoms Of Post Traumatic Stress Disorder
Japan finance minister to quit in blow to PM Aso
| International
|
Bottom-up approach needed in Afghanistan: report
| International
|
Sudan, Darfur rebel faction in first step to talks
| International
|
Killing Fields torturer on trial in Cambodia
| International
|
Court recognizes French role in deporting Jews
| International
|
Muslim TV Station Exec Charged, Detained For Beheading Wife
Three Texas Schools In Lockdown Before Suicidal Dad Could Say Goodbye To Student
Freescale aims to sell Google Android netbooks in Q2
| Technology
|
Pakistani Militants Delay Execution Of American Hostage
Hillary Clinton's First State Trip To Asia Meets North Korean Defiance
SanDisk enlists mobile carriers in memory card drive
| Technology
|
Scientists Explore 1,300-Year-Old Pit Homes Near Las Vegas
Taiwan's Acer dials up smartphones for growth
| Technology
|
Justin Timberlake named most stylish man in America
| Entertainment
|
American Idol to take on Lost
| Entertainment
|
Nine Inch Nails to tour with Jane's Addiction
| Entertainment
|
Rap mogul Suge Knight injured in fracas
| Entertainment
|
British soldier killed in Afghanistan: ministry
Escaped French prisoners captured: ministry
Obama offers support for Turkey-Iraq relationship
Czech lawmakers prepare Lisbon Treaty vote
Israel cautions anew against a nuclear-armed Iran
British, French nuclear subs collide in Atlantic: officials
GM, Chrysler race to meet restructuring deadline
Livni: Give up parts of 'Land of Israel'
EU could move against budget deficits: commissioner
Israel to consider Hamas prisoner swap and truce
Oscars guessing game goes online
EU foiled in bid to force France, Greece to allow GM crop
Israel honours German officer from "The Pianist"
US-TECH Summary
Taiwan's Acer dials up smartphones for growth
Iran moves to boost its air defense capabilities
SanDisk enlists mobile carriers in memory card drive
Freescale aims to sell Google Android netbooks in Q2
Petraeus flies into Uzbekistan for talks: officials
Facebook reassures users in wake of service terms change
NY governor proposes Internet tax on downloads
iPhone application helps Blackjack cheaters
Taiwan's Acer moves into mobile phones
Mobile phone operators to boost 'chat' services
Clinton calls for coordinated economic response
Trade to top Obama agenda in first foreign trip
SanDisk enlists mobile carriers in memory card drive
Japanese PM to be first Obama guest
Crippled US auto firms to report on restructure plans
Khmer Rouge genocide trial opens in Cambodia
Taiwan's Acer moves into mobile phones
Mexico urges 'firm' US moves on trafficking
Clinton says US committed to ridding NKorea of nukes
First solar-powered phone goes on display
Japan finmin to quit over "drunk" claim
Pelosi says U.S. won't press allies on Guantanamo inmates
Microsoft, Nokia hit back at Apple with virtual stores
Malaysia: Woman legislator quits over nude photos
Three Texas Schools In Lockdown Before Suicidal Dad Could Say Goodbye To Student
Newest US troops in dangerous region near Kabul
Radio Signals Provide Evidence Of 1,300-Year-Old Pit Homes In Las Vegas
Clinton warns NKorea on missile launch
China tycoon's mistress contest ends in tragedy: report
Police maintain order in central China after clash
Chinese president says economic crisis deepening
South Korean won falls 1.9 pct vs dollar
Seoul shares close at 3-wk low; techs, banks fall
Young Hollywood hits Fashion Week amid tough times
S.Korea T-bond futures tumble on won, extra budget
Seoul shares extend falls, down 4 pct
Hyundai says claims made against IPIC units valid
South Korea dismisses talk of FX crisis
Korea Hot Stocks
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Japan's finance minister to resign over slurred speech
3rd time's a charm: Met gives winning 'Trovatore'
"American Idol" to take on "Lost"
China to boost graduate migration in jobs drive: state media
Nine Inch Nails to tour with Jane's Addiction
Justin Timberlake named most stylish man in America
India's multiplex boom could be The End for single screens
'The Reader' puts Holocaust back in Oscars spotlight
Rap mogul "Suge" Knight injured in fracas
Young Hollywood hits Fashion Week amid tough times
Salma Hayek, Francois-Henri Pinault wed in France
Complaints will not affect Iraq election result
Sudan and Darfur rebels agree to hold peace talks
Israel engaged in covert war inside Iran: report
| International
|
Lady GaGa To Give Her "Raunchiest" Ever Performance On Wednesday's BRIT Awards
German FM in Iraq as Europe joins rebuilding effort
Sudan, Darfur rebels agree to hold peace talks
| International
|
Lil Wayne Faces $1.3 Million Lawsuit For Cancelled Gig
German foreign minister arrives in Baghdad
Darfur rebel group signs accord
NATO says Pakistan deal with militants a concern
| International
|
Rap Music Mogul Suge Knight Hospitalized After Early Morning Brawl
Israel seen engaged in covert war inside Iran
Michael Phelps Dodges Bong Charges Over Lack Of Evidence
Seaborne gunmen attack Equatorial Guinea capital
| International
|
Iraqi women get posts, but want power and respect
Kosovo leader marks anniversary with Serbia warning
| International
|
British soldier killed in Afghanistan
Zimbabwe court charges MDC official for plot
| International
|
Britons on trial over airliner bomb plot
| International
|
French 'spider-man' scales skyscraper in HK
US backs Japan on NKorea, invites PM to White House
Nokia to sell phones with Skype software
| Technology
|
Iraqi shoe-thrower goes on trial Thursday
Nokia and Qualcomm tie up after years in court
| Technology
|
Microsoft in talks to buy Israel's 3DV: report
| Technology
|
Bill Gates grant to extend mobile banking to poor
NASA Looking For A New Administrator
The Economic Stimulus And How It May Affect Americans
New products show rivals playing catch-up with Apple
Acco Brands Reduce Employee Pay To Avoid Lay Offs
Nokia to sell phones with Skype software
Low-Income Housing Project Designed To Reduce Energy Costs By 30% Opens In Bronx
Mobile phone makers agree to create standard charger
Large Inventories Hobble Businesses, Particularly Carmakers
Cyberattacks On U.S. Government Computer Networks Up 40 Percent In 2008
Report: Justice Department Removes Prosecutors In Ted Stevens Corruption Case
Japanese Prime Minister Taro Aso To Be Obama's First Foreign Guest At White House
Coleman Asks Court To Reconsider Ruling; Franken Meets With Mayors As 'Senator-Elect'
Nokia to sell phones with Skype software
GM Seeks Cut In Retiree Health Care To Ensure Financial Lifeline With Federal Government
Oscar voters wrestle with best actor choice
| Entertainment
|
Coldplay and Duffy lead field on eve of BRITs
| Entertainment
|
Afghan TV set to unveil model contest
| Entertainment
|
UN: Afghan civilian deaths rose 40 percent in 2008
"Killing Fields" torturer on trial in Cambodia
Japan finance chief quits over alleged drunkenness
Swiss hostage: Philippines ordeal now "difficult"
Khmer Rouge genocide trial opens in Cambodia
China bans actors from medical shows
Pakistani stocks end 1 pct higher; rupee weakens
Coldplay and Duffy lead field on eve of BRITs
Tamil MPs say Sri Lanka ignoring civilian safety
Japan's finance minister quits over G7 debacle
Police: Rap producer injured in Ariz. hotel fight
Mobile phone makers promise standardised charger
Australia wildfire death toll reaches 200
"Withnail and I" farmhouse sells at auction
ADB blacklists 41 firms, 38 people for corruption
Race, class fuel social conflict on French Caribbean islands
US fund withdraws bid for bigger Sapporo stake
Islamic TV founder charged with beheading wife: reports
Taiwan regulator to ease rules on fundraising
A rebellious Marc Jacobs smirks at economic crisis
Thailand approves fund to help tourism operators
Ice boating: extreme speed sport in Poland's lake district
Taiwan dlr at 5-1/2-yr low on econ outlook, c.bnk
Ticket to flirt: Germans aim to get love life 'on track'
China shares fall back on profit-taking
Muslim TV Station Exec Arrested, Charged With Beheading Wife
Beaver Found Living In Detroit River For First Time In Almost 100 Years
"Smash-Me Bernie" Doll A Hit At New York Toy Fair
Chinese Man With 5 Mistresses Loses Big After Staging Mistress Elimination Contest
Woman Hospitalized In Critical Condition After Chimp Attack At Friend's House
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights