Forum Views () 
Forum Replies ()  
 
 
Read more with google mobile :
Israel rejects independent inquiry into Gaza war  
 
 
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
  
 
  
Navigation
Primary Navigation
 
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
 
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
 
Search
 
 
Search:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Israel rejects independent inquiry into Gaza war
 
 
 
 
 
 
 By AMY TEIBEL,Associated Press Writer AP - Thursday, September 17
JERUSALEM - Israel on Wednesday rejected U.N. calls to open an independent inquiry into its conduct during last winter's Gaza Strip military offensive and said it would launch a diplomatic offensive to block any attempt to bring its soldiers before an international war crimes tribunal.
ADVERTISEMENT
 
  
The defiant tone came a day after a U.N. investigation accused Israel and Palestinian militants of war crimes and possible crimes against humanity. While the report criticized rocket attacks by Hamas and other armed groups on Israeli towns, the bulk of the findings focused on Israeli actions.
The report, headed by South African jurist Richard Goldstone, said Israel used disproportionate firepower and disregarded the likelihood of civilian deaths in the offensive, which killed hundreds of civilians and caused widespread damage to Gaza.
It said that if Israel doesn't allow an independent investigation, the case should be referred to international war crimes prosecutors.
The report provoked a furor in Israel. The Foreign Ministry said it was "appalled and disappointed," and President Shimon Peres called it a "mockery of history." Radio stations devoted heavy chunks of air time to interviews with outraged officials and critical legal experts. "Classic Anti-Semitism," blared the headline of an opinion piece in the Israel Hayom daily.
The findings of the U.N. investigation echoed the conclusions of a string of human rights reports released in recent months. But the U.N. report could carry much more weight, both because it was authored by a widely respected former war crimes prosecutor and because it could ultimately lead to charges against Israel before the International Criminal Court.
Israel is not a member of the Netherlands-based ICC, but in theory the court could still attempt to prosecute its officials. To do so, it would need an order from the U.N. Security Council, but Israel's ally the United States would likely block any such request.
Alternatively, the Palestinian Authority has sought membership in the ICC, but since it is not a state, the court has not yet determined whether to accept the request. If the Palestinians are accepted, the ICC could proceed with prosecutions of Israeli and Hamas officials without a Security Council order since the alleged crimes took place in Gaza.
The ICC prosecutors office said Wednesday it was "examining all issues related to its jurisdiction" in the Gaza case, including the validity of the Palestinian membership.
Israeli Foreign Ministry spokesman Yigal Palmor said his country would take action to protect its soldiers and commanders from prosecution abroad and denounced the suggestion of an ICC jurisdiction. He said Israeli diplomats would lobby Security Council members against further action.
"Every time a democracy will want to take measures to defend itself from terror, it will have to take into consideration a wide international legal campaign against its leaders and officials, based on the propaganda of the terrorists," he said.
Israeli officials refused to cooperate with the five-month investigation, saying it was ordered by a U.N. body with a clear anti-Israeli bias. Israel's military has conducted its own inquiries, but so far has cleared itself of any systematic wrongdoing.
"This report was conceived in sin and is the product of a union between propaganda and bias," government spokesman Mark Regev said. "Israel is a country with a fiercely independent judiciary ... Everything done by the military in Israel is open to judicial review by the independent judiciary."
Goldstone is a former South African judge who prosecuted war crimes in Rwanda and the former Yugoslavia. Goldstone, who is Jewish and has close ties to Israel, was well aware that his work would draw fire. As a condition for heading the inquiry, he insisted that the panel look at the actions of Palestinian militants.
His daughter, Nicole, told Israel Army Radio in a telephone interview from her home in Canada that her father agonized over whether to take the assignment. She said her father's presence softened the report's observations on Israel.
"He thought that ... he did the best thing possible for everyone, including Israel," she said. "I have no doubt that whatever emerged would have been much worse if he had not been there." Speaking in halting Hebrew, she said she had great love for the country.
Israel launched the three-week war in late December to quash Palestinian militants in Gaza who had bombarded southern Israel for years with rocket and mortar fire.
Some 1,400 Palestinians were killed in the conflict, including hundreds of civilians, and thousands more were wounded. Thirteen Israelis also died, including four civilians.
Peres, who won the Nobel Peace Prize for helping craft an interim 1993 peace agreement with the Palestinians, said the Goldstone report "makes a mockery of history."
"It draws no distinction between the attacker and the attacked," Peres said. "The report essentially grants legitimacy to acts of terrorism, shooting and killing, and ignores the right and duty of any country to self defense, as outlined in the U.N. charter."
In Gaza, Hamas' prime minister, Ismail Haniyeh, welcomed the report's harsh condemnation of Israel and called on the U.N. to charge Israeli leaders with war crimes. At the same time, he rejected the accusations that his group was guilty of war crimes for firing rockets into civilian areas in Israel.
"The Palestinian people and resistance was in self-defense," he said.
The U.N. investigators recommended the Security Council require both sides to launch credible probes into the conflict within three months, and to follow that up with action in their courts.
If either side refuses, it said the U.N. should refer the evidence for prosecution by the International Criminal Court, a permanent war crimes tribunal, within six months.
Even if there is no legal action, the U.N. report could damage Israel's public image, with people linking the state of Israel and war crimes.
Pro-Palestinian activists have sought before to try Israeli military officials outside of their homeland on war crimes charges connected to operations in Gaza. A retired general dodged a British arrest warrant in 2005 by staying on his plane at London's Heathrow airport after a tip-off that police were waiting to detain him over a deadly Israeli air strike in Gaza.
Activists also tried to take legal action in Spain and New Zealand.
 
 
 
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
 
 
     
Sign in to recommend this article »
0 users recommend
 
Related Articles: World
Protesters burn photos of UN judges in SarajevoAP - Thursday, September 17
Mall magnate, Pacers owner Melvin Simon dies at 82AP - Thursday, September 17
Foul-mouthing boss not grounds for firing in SpainAP - Thursday, September 17
Syria's president in Turkey for Israel talksAP - Thursday, September 17
THE INFLUENCE GAME: Health interests fund senatorsAP - Thursday, September 17
 
 
 
 
Most Popular – World
 
 
 
 
 
 Viewed
 
 
 
 
Iraq shoe-thrower flies out after release
 
 
'Dirty Dancing' star Patrick Swayze dead at 57
 
 
Remains of Jesus-era synagogue found in Israel
 
 
Obama lashes out at Wall Street
 
 
Mafia sank boat with radioactive waste: official
 
 
View Complete List »
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy 
- Terms of Service 
- Community 
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy 
- Help
        
    
   
 
Other News on Thursday, 17 September 2009 Iran opposition leaders to attend anti-Israel rally  
Barroso wins second term as EU commission chief  
Spain's Zara to start selling its clothes over the Internet  
Ozone hole smaller in 2009 than 2008: WMO  
Some 750,000 paedophiles prowling Internet: UN  
Israel rejects independent inquiry into Gaza war  
Algerian appeals sentence over Paris metro bombs  
British unemployment hits 14-year high  
Electric cars star at Frankfurt fair  
IAEA's poor nations split on Iran's attack ban bid
| International
|  
Iran will not tolerate threats during talks: aide  
Iraqi Green Zone attack suspects released  
U.S. keeps Venezuela, Bolivia atop narcotics list
| International
|  
China's Lenovo unveils homegrown smartphone  
China has 63 mln Internet businesspeople: reports  
Iraqi official: Talks with Syria over attacks fail  
Iraq leader seeks investment as rockets fall
| International
|  
Gunmen kill 10 patients at Mexico rehab clinic
| International
|  
Iran replaces reformist cleric for annual sermon  
Somali rebels call for foreign reinforcements
| International
|  
Europe's farmers dump milk to protest low prices
| International
|  
Don't leave poor behind, World Bank chief tells G20
| International
|  
Iran says ready for any possible gasoline sanction  
Emmy Countdown: Workers busy at Nokia Theatre  
No sign of settlement deal after U.S.-Israel talks  
Behind the snags, drama, hype: Meet the Boeing 787
| Technology
|  
EU in informal talks on Microsoft, Yahoo deal: source
| Technology
|  
Calif. courts shuttered Wednesday to save money  
Kansas senators drop roadblock of Obama nominees  
US ambassador walks streets of Kabul  
Comcast plans to bring TV shows to your phone
| Technology
|  
Officials assure residents about jail contract  
Rights group: Free Myanmar prisoners before polls  
Chinese envoy holds talks in North Korea  
NC crash kills ex-White House photog Kightlinger  
Military van shot near US gold mine in Indonesia  
Ohio woman arrested for spanking stranger's child  
SKorea: Any US-NKorea talks must deal with nukes  
Police foil 'terror' attacks in China's Xinjiang  
Court sets execution date for DC sniper mastermind  
Japan's new leader vows economic, diplomacy shift  
Funeral held for former Blagojevich fundraiser  
Colo. man denies link to terror plot after NY trip  
Hatoyama elected Japan's leader, names Cabinet  
Senator's plan joins heated U.S. healthcare debate  
FBI Director says no imminent danger from NYC case  
Sweden promised accessed to suspects in Pakistan  
Australian cat strays 2,400 miles, returns home  
China tire row need not spark trade war: US official  
Taiwan Mobile buys cable TV firm in billion-dollar deal  
Air France holds talks with Japan Airlines: source  
Nissan launches 2 new cars in India  
Rain swears off "scary, horrible" dieting  
China state companies invest $35.7B abroad in 2008  
Japan chip makers agree on deal, cash infusion  
Beyonce sued by Abercrombie & Fitch over fragrance
| Entertainment
|  
Patrick Swayze made peace with death, memoir shows
| Entertainment
|  
Japan chip makers agree on merger, cash infusion  
Pakistani stocks end on highest closing this year  
Leno show loses 7 million viewers on second night
| Entertainment
|  
Beyonce sued by Abercrombie & Fitch over fragrance  
TV's `Newlywed Game' features first gay couple  
Al Jazeera breaks Arab TV taboo by showing Israeli team  
Ben Hur spectacular premieres in London  
German writer Enzensberger wins Danish prize  
Emmy Countdown: Workers busy at Nokia Theatre  
For director Jason Reitman, risky films pay off  
President's opinion of Kanye West sparks debate  
Danish daily prints soldier's book despite protest  
EU in informal talks on Microsoft, Yahoo deal: source  
Obama: No decision yet on Afghanistan troop count  
Two EU cars attacked with Molotov cocktails in Kosovo  
Murdoch's Sky Italia sues Berlusconi's Mediaset  
Nanoparticles could pose threat to humans: scientists  
Gazans welcome UN war crimes report  
Bright start for Japan's new PM as economy improves
| International
|  
Comcast plans to bring TV shows to your phone  
Biden confident in stable Iraq amid rocket attacks  
Iraq leader seeks investment as rockets fall  
Israel defense chief: Iran not an existential threat
| International
|  
Iraqis venture out near Ramadan end, violence drops  
PC sales down 2.4 pct in second quarter: IDC  
Australian charged with raping daughter for 30 years
| International
|  
Google acquires Web security firm reCAPTCHA  
Behind the snags, drama, hype: Meet the Boeing 787  
Teens cleared of plotting UK Columbine massacre
| International
|  
Indonesia police believe key militant dead: sources
| International
|  
Honduras candidates back negotiated solution to coup
| International
|  
China's cancer villages bear witness to economic boom
| International
|  
FBI question Colorado man linked to NY raid  
US envoy confident of closing Guantanamo on time  
More bones found at US kidnap suspect's home: police  
Transcript: Copilot pleaded for chopper to fly  
Man accused of trading dad's car for $50 in crack  
Pa. man gets 8 years for sex with Russian orphans  
Australia intercepts boat carrying 48 asylum-seekers  
Indonesia police raid Java house; 3 dead  
US military deaths in Afghanistan region at 757  
McHugh confirmed as Army secretary  
Rockets vie in simulated lunar landing contest  
Canada says won't review Nortel-Ericsson deal
| Technology
|  
US-Japan ties to 'stand test' of change: Clinton  
A look at who's in, out for Kennedy seat  
Clinton pledges to boost Bangladesh trade  
Police says shots fired during raid in Indonesia  
China invests $750 mln in Mauritius  
Indonesia police attack suspected militant hideout  
China could undermine US military power in Pacific: Gates  
Japanese PM pledges big change  
Top UN official in Sri Lanka to push for rights probe  
Bank of Japan maintains stimulative policy  
WRAPUP 1-Tension grows over South Korea rate policy  
Lindsay Lohan's brief: make Ungaro 'cooler'  
S.Korea state think-tank calls for liquidity control  
Indian firm eyes European electric car market  
S.Korea needs macro-, micro-policy for property -official  
S.Korea economy faces high uncertainty -fin min  
Taiwan dollar at fresh 3-mth high on econ hopes  
Seoul shares hit near-15-mth high on foreign buying  
S.Korea T-bonds fall on retail sales data  
 S.Korea dept store sales jump in Aug  
Whip It remarkable directing debut for Barrymore
| Entertainment
|  
Burt Reynolds hopes his fight with drugs helps others
| Entertainment
|  
Michael Caine on warpath in "Harry Brown"  
Mary Travers of "Peter, Paul and Mary" dies, age 72  
Beyonce sued by Abercrombie & Fitch over fragrance
| Entertainment
|  
Gene Simmons promises high-impact Boom from Kiss
| Entertainment
|  
China's Ai Weiwei: artist with politics on mind  
Teen spirit elevates Youth in Revolt
| Entertainment
|  
Website offers emails from beyond the grave  
Blast during counter-terror operation in Indonesia  
Fashionistas ask: Crisis? what crisis?  
Michael Caine on warpath in Harry Brown
| Entertainment
|  
Spike Lee, Robert De Niro in New York frame of mind
| Entertainment
|  
Mary Travers of Peter, Paul and Mary dead at 72  
Sony Pictures takes side of Defendor
| Entertainment
|  
"Whip It" remarkable directing debut for Barrymore  
Teen spirit elevates "Youth in Revolt"  
Mary Travers of Peter, Paul and Mary dies, age 72
| Entertainment
|  
Paul McCartney voted Americans' favorite Beatle
| Entertainment
|  
Mall magnate, Pacers co-owner Mel Simon dies at 82  
Suicide attack kills 6 Italian troops, 10 Afghans  
Somali rebels issue demands to free French hostage  
Karzai defends Afghan vote, blast hits Italian troops
| International
|  
Taiwan lab develops panda robot  
Russian airline Aeroflot plans 2,000 job cuts  
U.S. military shuts largest detainee camp in Iraq
| International
|  
Implanted tooth helps blind US woman recover sight  
China anniversary puts security jitters on show
| International
|  
Six Italian soldiers 'killed in Kabul attack'  
Karzai defends Afghan vote  
3 bodies in Kabul blast on NATO convoy: AFP reporter  
Huge blast heard in Afghan capital: witnesses  
Iran Guards warn against protests during anti-Israel rallies
| International
|  
Biden presses Iraqis to agree on oil
| International
|  
Goldstone rejects bias charges over UN Gaza report  
Iran says venue for nuclear talks not fixed  
Air raid on refugees kills 87 in Yemen: sources
| International
|  
Afghan paralysis over fraud-hit election  
Suicide car bombers hit main AU base in Somalia
| International
|  
Skype founders sue eBay, investors
| Technology
|  
Twitter funding would value it at $1 billion: report
| Technology
|  
The Nation's weather  
Lab technician arrested in slaying of Yale student  
Virtual reality used for blind to map real world
| Technology
|  
Italy antitrust chief warns Google of heavy fines
| Technology
|  
Ark. football player, 16, gets his 'last game'  
Ebay petitions EU to stop blocks on Internet trade
| Technology
|  
Fed judge expected to rule on G-20 protest suit  
Terror mastermind Noordin 'dead in Indonesia raid'  
White House holds off on decisions on Afghanistan  
A look at health care plans in Congress  
Panel begins inquiry into financial meltdown  
Deep divisions over long-awaited health care plan  
House bill would kill subsidized student loans  
New health proposal is industry's favorite so far  
Japan's new PM to tackle record jobless rate  
Japan's new govt to review airline turnaround plan  
Japan's new finance head faces tough economic road  
SKorean firm wins bln dlr Saudi power plant deal  
Emmy Awards faces conundrum as best watched by less
| Entertainment
|  
Malaysian manufacturing down 22.4 pct in July  
S.Korea fin min says not time to raise interest rate  
French ship builder eyes Asia naval defense market  
Terror mastermind Noordin dead: Indonesia police  
Despite stroke, humorist Keillor not slowing down  
S.Korea fin min says won's rise natural on funds  
Press group urges Rudd to resist Indonesia "blackmail"  
"I'm a born stage animal": opera star Waltraud Meier  
Four suspected militants killed in Indonesian raid  
The Police staying off the beat: drummer  
At Gaza's only spa, the well-heeled find relief  
Boy's films confront Down's syndrome stigma in Serbia  
The manga that poured French wine into Asia  
Artists take over plush London mansion  
Luxury auto sector defies industry crash  
Gene Simmons promises high-impact "Boom" from Kiss  
Biography reveals Queen Mum's private letters  
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro  
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found  
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever  
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production  
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time  
AMD to Start Production of piledriver  
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs  
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia  
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air  
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch  
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent  
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up  
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform  
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis  
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets  
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights