">Forum Views ()
">Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Pakistan army fights, but can it win?
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Australia
China
India
Indonesia
Japan
Malaysia
Philippines
Thailand
Vietnam
Search
Search:
Pakistan army fights, but can it win?
By CHRIS BRUMMITT,Associated Press Writer AP - Friday, May 8
ISLAMABAD - Pakistan's army has a rare window of support for its latest campaign against Taliban militants near the Afghan border, and U.S. hopes are pinned on the military for bringing stability to both countries.
ADVERTISEMENT
But so far, refugees say, the military is relying on helicopter gunships, aerial bombings and artillery while avoiding close combat _ tactics it has used before with little success.
While it is still early in the battle for the Swat Valley, some fear the campaign will follow the pattern of previous offensives in the frontier zone, which have been more limited and ended inconclusively after heavy collateral damage in towns and villages and massive displacement of the population.
"If the government, the army wants to control and crush the Taliban, why don't they send ground troops to flush them out?" said Yar Mohammad, a 50-year-old stone mason who fled the valley and was in a refugee camp Thursday. "Why are they only shelling, which hurts the public most of all and creates anti-government feeling?"
Washington, anxious to stop the spread of the insurgency in Pakistan and Afghanistan, has given the army billions of dollars in aid and embedded about 30 U.S. military trainers with forces in the northwest.
While analysts say the money is sharpening the army's counterinsurgency capabilities, they caution the force must abandon its obsession with archrival India to be effective.
For more than 50 years, Pakistani soldiers have been preparing for conventional land battles on the plains of the Punjab against Hindu India rather than going door-to-door against fellow Pakistani Muslims on the mountainous border. It currently has more than 100,000 of its 500,000 troops stationed on the Afghan frontier. Most of the rest are on the Indian frontier, experts say.
"They are trying to shift the priorities, but still the mindset is always toward India," said retired general and military analyst Talat Masood.
"They can't ignore the past legacy and current tensions," he said, referring to the aftermath of last year's Mumbai terror attacks where both nations moved troops to the border.
Fighting in the Swat Valley and surrounding districts began last week after a three-month-old peace deal collapsed.
According to military figures, scores of militants have been killed. There has been no official word on civilian casualties, but at least 45,000 people _ and probably many more _ have fled, creating a humanitarian emergency.
The Swat Taliban are estimated to have up to 7,000 fighters _ many with training and battle experience _ equipped with rocket-propelled grenades, explosives and automatic weapons. They are up against some 15,000 troops who, until recent days, had been confined to their barracks under the peace deal.
The battle represents the most sustained operation in the border region since a six-month campaign in Bajur and Mohmand districts ended with a declaration of victory in March. While it did drive out or kill many militants, the army razed towns and some 500,000 people were forced from their homes. They have yet to return.
Since then there have been several militant attacks in the districts. Last month, the commander of the Taliban contingent in the area made a defiant radio broadcast over an illegal FM radio station vowing to implement hardline Islamic law.
"If you look at what went on in Bajur it seems to me the army was tired of taking casualties and used artillery to flatten places," said Shaun Gregory, from the Pakistan Security Research Unit at the University of Bradford in Britain. "That is not much of a strategy either for winning hearts or minds or defeating militancy."
Military spokesman Maj. Gen. Athar Abbas dismissed criticism of that operation and the one in Swat, saying the strikes were targeting areas where militants were confirmed to be. He noted operation was still ongoing and that tactics were evolving.
Gen. Ashfaz Parvez Kayani, the chief of Pakistan's army, last week promised tough action, saying he was "aware of the doubts being voiced about the intent as well as the capability of the army to defeat the militancy in the country." On Thursday, he vowed to commit enough resources to the Swat campaign to beat the insurgency.
In Washington, a senior U.S. defense official said it was too early to gauge the success or scope of the Swat operation, but noted that most of the offensives in the tribal regions since the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks were not sustained.
"They are kind of like raid-style or punishment-type operations, not true, full-scale offensives," said the official, who spoke on condition of anonymity because he was not authorized to speak to the media. "The fighting they did in Bajur was helpful, but it was only in one area as opposed to a full-scale sweep."
Several of the offensives, including the one in Swat, ended with hasty peace deals amid public and political criticism of the heavy handed military approach. A commonly held feeling in the Muslim nation that the United States _ not the Taliban _ is the country's main enemy added to doubts about the need to fight the militants.
This time around, however, analysts say, the country is more united behind the military approach. The Taliban have been blamed for scuttling the deal by moving out of Swat into neighboring Buner district even after the government imposed Islamic law.
It is now hard for politicians previously skeptical of the need to battle the Taliban to maintain that position.
Still, most of those escaping the battle zone in recent days have complained more about military operations than the Taliban actions. High civilian casualties and the sight of up to one million refugees in the northwest with no hope of returning home could very quickly erode support for the military.
_____
Associated Press reporters Pauline Jelinek in Washington and Riaz Khan in Mardan, Pakistan, contributed to this report.
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Sign in to recommend this article »
0 users recommend
Related Articles: Asia Pacific
NKorea vows to strengthen nuclear deterrentAFP - 2 hours 43 minutes ago
World must pressure China over Tiananmen: dissidentsAFP - Friday, May 8
Boxing champ Pacquiao returns home to hero's welcomeAFP - Friday, May 8
Mexico relieved but world swine flu fears persistAFP - Friday, May 8
Pakistan army fights, but can it win?AP - Friday, May 8
Most Popular – Asia Pacific
Viewed
Court okays breast removal for transsexual teen: report
Porsche to merge with Volkswagen
Berlusconi: My marriage is 'finished or about to finish'
Obese young men have less hope of marriage: study
US banks need to up capital to meet 'stress tests'
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Friday, 8 May 2009 Singapore's most-wanted militant arrested after escape
| International
|
Egypt brushes off reports on nuclear traces
| International
|
Huge U.S. camp arises in Afghan Desert of Death
| International
|
U.S. calls for credible 2010 Sudan election
| International
|
Visionary or plane crazy? Airbus contest to decide
| Technology
|
Moms trust Ellen DeGeneres with kids: poll
| Entertainment
|
Rock 'n' roll survivor Duff McKagan back on the road
| Entertainment
|
Pakistan forces bomb Taliban in Swat after PM speech
| International
|
Probe confirms US killed Afghan civilians: reports
Asian countries pledge common fight against flu
| International
|
Pope prepares to start Mideast trip
A year on, China quake survivors face uncertain future
| International
|
Venezuela soldiers seize oil service companies
| International
|
Ex-U.S. soldier found guilty in Iraqi rape and deaths
Porpoise is 2nd to give birth in captivity
Singapore's most wanted militant arrested in Malaysia
| International
|
Iraq: Firm once known as Blackwater exits Baghdad
Venezuela to nationalize oil service companies
China vice premier says world economy to worsen: report
| International
|
Afghan suicide attack kills 12 civilians
US banks need to up capital to meet 'stress tests'
Blair says Israel-Palestinian talks must address core issues
Obama budget to slash 'stunning' waste in US
Washington committed to seeking Syria-Israel deal
Pills that are Gazans' little helpers
| International
|
Kiefer Sutherland arrested on assault charge
Unsafe, salvaged cars cause havoc in Kabul
| International
|
US banks scramble to raise capital after stress tests
US bank tests 'considerable comfort' to investors: Bernanke
Obese young men have less hope of marriage: study
Global auto sector faces big shakeup
Obama vows to cut 'stunning' government waste
Google CEO says he expects more government scrutiny
| Technology
|
Activision eyes Guitar Hero TV series, tour
| Technology
|
Ex US-soldier found guilty of rape, murder
Google CEO says he expects more government scrutiny
Update: Gunman In Connecticut University Shooting Surrenders
Heart Attack-Stricken Mississippi Mayor Dies After Reelection Defeat
Virtual Earth gets 3D Photosynth views
Xerox unveils new color printer
Illinois Police Sergeant Arrested For Death Of Ex-Wife
Thousands flee as fires gut California homes
Kentucky Jury Convicts Discharged Soldier For Rape, Murder Of Iraqi Family
GE to spend $6 bln on high-tech health sector
American Tourist Caught Swimming Away From Burmese Opposition Leader's Lakeside Home
Lawsuit Alleges California's KeyPoint Credit Union Discriminates Against Deaf Customers
Brazil rejects extradition of Italian leftist
Clinton buries disputes for new Russia ties
Microsoft buying Canadian online game company
Connecticut School In Lockdown As Cops Look For Gunman Who Shot Dead Student
Charles Manson's last hideout burns in California
Hackers taking advantage of Windows 7: Microsoft
EU holds landmark summit with ex-Soviet states
Merkin Sued For $557.8 Million By Liquidating Trustee
9 people injured in blast at Md. shopping center
Microsoft to buy game maker BigPark
Georgia opposition seeks Saakashvili talks
$75 Billion In Capital Needed By 10 Banks According To Stress Tests
US swine flu victims had chronic health problems
Toledo Point-Shaving Scandal Indicts Six Former Players, Two Businessmen
Google tightens bonds with YouTube users
Aristocrat guilty of Kenya manslaughter
Feds ready to build virtual fence along border
Future of journalism debated in US Senate
Thomson Reuters says profits rise in first quarter
Microsoft to buy game maker BigPark
Ryan O'Neal offers grim outlook on Farrah Fawcett
| Entertainment
|
Star Trek looks to enter new box-office galaxy
| Entertainment
|
NKorea vows to strengthen nuclear deterrent
One of last Wizard of Oz Munchkins dies
| Entertainment
|
World must pressure China over Tiananmen: dissidents
Kiefer Sutherland charged with assault in NY
| Entertainment
|
Boxing champ Pacquiao returns home to hero's welcome
The Simpsons get the (postal) stamp of success
| Entertainment
|
Mexico relieved but world swine flu fears persist
No kung-fu, Asian beauties in Malaysia Cannes film
| Entertainment
|
Pakistan army fights, but can it win?
Spinal Tap roars Back From the Dead
| Entertainment
|
New Zealand cops lock down city in gunman standoff
LA judge rejects Polanski bid to dismiss sex case
| Entertainment
|
NZ police lock down city in standoff with gunman
Quake survivor Panda bounds into China's theaters
| Entertainment
|
Gul sinks Australia in Twenty20
Thousands of civilians flee Pakistani war zone
Russia warns Japan against 'inflated hopes' in islands dispute
World Bank sees Cambodian GDP recovery in 2010
ExxonMobil starts work on Shanghai technology centre
Taiwan dlr up on fund inflows, but c.bank caps gains
Former coal mine aids Arctic climate research
S.Korea bonds down, recent falls may renew interest
Store admits it boobed in bra dispute
Korea Hot Stocks
Sikh police want bullet-proof turbans
Seoul shares dip; Hyundai E&C up after stake sale
Carreras retires from opera
Vietnamese war hero fires salvo over mining plan
Ryan O'Neal offers grim outlook on Farrah Fawcett
China warns EU on protectionism
LA judge rejects Polanski bid to dismiss sex case
Taiwan promises to regulate foreign aid
Chris Brown's lawyer wants LAPD records
Hitachi hikes annual net loss forecast to $8.0 bln
LA judge denies Polanski's bid to toss sex case
'24' star Sutherland charged over head-butt claim
US braces for more summer car breakdowns
Iraqi relatives urge death for U.S. rape soldier
Pope hopes Catholic Church can help Mideast peace
| International
|
U.N. experts prepare to investigate war crimes in Gaza
| International
|
US says Afghan strikes death toll exaggerated
Conservative rival raps Iran president on economy
Leading figures sit out Afghan presidential poll
| International
|
US unemployment hits 8.9 pct as 539,000 jobs lost
Contractor's slaying of Afghan man divides
British store admits it boobed in bra row
Russia says it's ready to move forward on NATO ties
| International
|
International peacekeeper killed in Sudan's Darfur
| International
|
Georgian opposition agrees to talks on stalemate
| International
|
Villagers list 147 dead in Afghan strike
| International
|
Powerful Croat MP gets 10 years for war crimes
| International
|
Obama budget rescinds energy industry tax breaks
Wall Street pares gains after jobs data
Layoffs slow to 539K in April; jobless rate rises
Danny Gokey, `American Idol' crews visit Milwaukee
Wildfire raging near Calif. city; 30,000 evacuated
Don't rewrite WWII history: Medvedev
Ex-soldier could get death in Iraq rape, slayings
Amid turmoil, new Illinois governor nears 100 days
'Babyface' look can help black CEOs, study says
Obama envoy urges NKorea to open dialogue with US
Sherpa presumed dead in avalanche on Mt. Everest
East Asia agrees on strategy to fight swine flu
Financial crisis inspires Tori Amos' latest album
| Entertainment
|
25 dead as typhoon hits Philippines: officials
Pakistan kills 'more than 140' militants
Researchers urge crackdown on junk food TV ads
| Entertainment
|
China: School rebuilding on track in quake zone
U.S. warns North Korea of consequences for nuclear test
US denies report that 147 died in Afghan violence
AFC president wins bitter fight for key FIFA seat
Chinese parents protest tainted milk deaths
Bachchan: Hollywood warming to Indian escapism
Japan's Toshiba announces biggest loss
Agent's Hollywood success? Mom gets the credit
Toyota posts first loss, sees worse ahead
S.Korea utilities in China coal talks, seek hefty discount
San Miguel bids for Philippines power plant
Toyota sees losses growing this year
AIG close to selling Tokyo building: source
S.Korea bond traders see no rate change next week
Bollywood boycott dulls Indian screens
Financial crisis inspires Tori Amos' latest album
Bachchan: Hollywood warming to Indian escapism
2 rare elephants found dead in Indonesian jungle
Bachchan: Bollywood seeks higher profile in China
Agent's Hollywood success? Mom gets the credit
Hindsight: Be careful what you search for
List of top 15 cable TV shows for April 27-May 3
`Store Front' documents retail face of NY City
New `Trek' crew roams beyond `hailing frequencies'
New threat to Iraq's antiquities
US-TECH Summary
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights