Forum Views () 
Forum Replies ()  
 
 
Read more with google mobile :
Seven reasons Fox hasn't signed an Idol judge
|  
 
 
 
 
	
	
		
Edition:
		
U.S.
		
		
	
	
		
			
				
					
					
						
					
				
				
					
					
						
					
				
				
					
					
						
					
				
			
		
	
	
	
		
			
				
				
			
		
	
 
	
 
	
 
 
	
		 
		
		 
		
		
		
	
	
    	
		 
		
		 
		
		
		
 
	
 
	
		
Article
    
Comments (1)
               
      
	
Save
Email
Print
Reprints
 
      
	
	
    	
		 
		
		 
		
		
		
 
	
		 
		
		 
		
		
		
	  
 
 
 
 
				
				
					
					
Most Popular
					
Most Shared
					
				 
			
			
	
               
      
		
		
		
Florida AG proposes tougher illegal immigrant curbs
	11 Aug 2010 
	
Scientists find new superbug spreading from India
	11 Aug 2010 
	
Attractive women overlooked for certain jobs?
	09 Aug 2010 
	
Europe Factors-Shares seen extending sell-off
	1:18am EDT 
	
Cancer cells slurp up fructose, US study finds
	02 Aug 2010 
	
Cisco sees "unusual uncertainty," sales disappoint
	11 Aug 2010 
	
In unusual program, volunteers prep cadavers for med school
	11 Aug 2010 
	
Seven reasons Fox hasn't signed an "Idol" judge
	1:26am EDT 
	
Nikkei hits 13-month low as economy worry weighs
	3:14am EDT 
	
Foreign firms helped by U.S. bailouts: panel
	2:16am EDT 
	
	
		
		
      
               
      
		
		
		
Scientists find new superbug spreading from India
	11 Aug 2010 
	
Landslides complicate Pakistan flood relief efforts
| Video
		
	09 Aug 2010 
	
Florida AG proposes tougher illegal immigrant curbs
	11 Aug 2010 
	
Cancer cells slurp up fructose, US study finds
	02 Aug 2010 
	
Devoted crowds throng Hezbollah's Lebanon theme park
	11 Aug 2010 
	
Japan satisfied by Apple moves on overheating iPods
	1:09am EDT 
	
Analysis: Turkey investors may tolerate fiscal reform delay
	11 Aug 2010 
	
In unusual program, volunteers prep cadavers for med school
	11 Aug 2010 
	
Quick brain scan could screen for autism
	10 Aug 2010 
	
Attractive women overlooked for certain jobs?
	09 Aug 2010 
	
	
		
		
      
		 
		
		 
		
		
		
	
	
    	
		 
		
		 
		
		
		
 
		
	
Seven reasons Fox hasn't signed an "Idol" judge
	
     
        
            
          		
                 
            
 Digg This
            
 Tweet This
            
Share on LinkedIn
            
 Share on Facebook
            
    
               
      
 
      
               
      
	
Related News
	
		
		
Busy mogul Nick Cannon finds time for pillow talk with Mariah
Wed, Aug 11 2010
Reality, nonfiction Emmy races produce odd rivals
Sun, Aug 8 2010
"American Idol" judge job poses opportunities, risks
Fri, Aug 6 2010
Nigel Lythgoe returns to "American Idol"
Thu, Aug 5 2010
Hollywood exposed as bad-boy allegations mount
Thu, Aug 5 2010
	
      
               
      
    
Related Topics
        
            
                
Fashion »
                
Entertainment »
                
Television »
                
        
    
      
               
      
 
      
               
      
 
                        
      
 
        
By James Hibberd
        
        Thu Aug 12, 2010 1:26am EDT
        
    
LOS ANGELES (Hollywood Reporter) - Simon Cowell declared he's leaving "American Idol" back in January.
Now it's a few weeks before the "Idol" judging panel goes before the cameras on the show's audition trail, and there's still no replacement named.
Oh, and Fox needs to replace Ellen DeGeneres too. And probably Kara DioGuardi.
Why is hiring a TV talent show judge (or two, or three) taking so long?
Sources say there are at least seven variables at play:
1. Chasing celebrities: If Fox tried to replace Cowell with somebody like Cowell -- a snarky record producer with a well-trained ear for spotting talent -- all this would have been over months ago. And with far less interesting results. Fox is intent on hiring somebody so famous that they don't need to judge "Idol." And anybody who fits that bill is going to want...
2. Money: Top-pick Elton John wanted too much. Now, by one report, Jennifer Lopez's deal fell apart due to her so-called "unreasonable" demands. Sources close to the matter tell The Hollywood Reporter, however, that "nothing is off the table" regarding Lopez and that Fox has not given up on her. At the end of his run, Cowell was making an estimated $36 million a year judging "Idol," but was also a proven ratings draw. Fox has to weigh how much they want to pay a famous face for a job the person has never attempted. Lopez asked for north of $20 million -- plus her own  hair, makeup, styling team and her own "dressing room compound" (not dissimilar to Cowell's posh trailer). But the network does not want to pay Simon dollars for a newcomer who is going to be the show's, ahem, X factor.
3. A crowded kitchen: Any major "Idol" decision is like a Quickfire Challenge on "Top Chef" -- cooks, cooks, running everywhere, all with their own list of ingredients. The word "chaos" is oft-used to describe these ongoing conversations. You have Fox president of alternative entertainment Mike Darnell, along with entertainment chairman Peter Rice. There's 19 Entertainment chief and "Idol" creator Simon Fuller, along with returning executive producer Nigel Lythgoe. Don't forget Fremantle Media president and "Idol" executive producer Cecile Frot-Coutaz. And producers and network executives aren't the only ones with a vote...
4. The roommate factor: If hired as an "Idol" judge, the single biggest impact on your experience will be the person sitting beside you. Any celebrity intent on joining "Idol" wants to have suitable fellow judges -- either for ego reasons ("You consider him on par with me?") or for comfort ("I want somebody I'll get along with"). Lopez has this concern, as well. And getting judges who agree to work with one another is only part of the equation. There's also...
5. The chemistry set: Could "Idol" have two female judges? More than one black judge? Another Brit? What are their ages? Gay or straight? Fox and Co. have the headache of trying to create on paper a formula for success. Not to mention there's...
6. Fear of commitment. Cowell made this job look easy. Stroll from his trailer onto the "Idol" set, insult a few people, walk back to his Bentley. But participating in a season of "Idol" is a significant commitment. A month in the fall, then about four months after the first of the year, with plenty of live shows. Again, not a problem for a record producer longing for the gig, but if you're a celebrity who records albums and tours, it's a serious investment. Especially when....
7. Being the new "Idol" judge is like trying to play James Bond after Sean Connery or, at least, being the second Becky on "Roseanne." The advantages are obvious. Yet for anybody sensitive about their portrayal in the media -- and what celebrity isn't? -- the disadvantages are all-too apparent: DeGeneres and DioGuardi were ripped by some critics -- and they weren't in the position of replacing Cowell, the man who defined the job. Lopez and Tyler, since their names were published as potential judges, also resulted in some backlash. (Some suggest that gauging this backlash is the reason the names were leaked in the first place). Becoming a "Idol" judge: It's the worst best job in the world!
			
Fashion
			
Entertainment
			
Television
			
 
	 
     
    
Comments
    
See All Comments (1)  |  Post Comment
 
    
    
        
Aug 12, 2010 2:01am EDT
        
Jennifer Lopez cannot sing her way out of a paperbag and has zippo talent as an actress too. Her famous behind is well behind her now so one of her requirements must have been she cannot be filmed from the side. Fox don’t even think of her as a viable judge candidate she is tone deaf period. Save the over 20 beans and let Marc Anthony keep paying the bills for this dud.
        LatinoVet
        Report As Abusive
        
 
        
 
 
        
 
    
    
 
See All Comments (1)
    
    
 
 
     
    
 
       
Add a Comment
       
       
        
     
    
*We welcome comments that advance the story directly or with relevant tangential information. We try to block comments that use offensive language or appear to be spam and review comments frequently to ensure they meet our standards. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters.
   
 
  
  
	
		
	
	
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
	
	
© Copyright 2010 Thomson Reuters
Editorial Editions:
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
United States
 
Reuters
	
Contact Us
	
Advertise With Us
	
Help
	
Journalism Handbook
	
Archive
	
Site Index
	
Video Index
	
Reader Feedback
 
	
Mobile
	
Newsletters
	
RSS
	
Podcasts
	
Widgets
	
Your View
	
Analyst Research
Thomson Reuters
	
Copyright
	
Disclaimer
	
Privacy
	
Professional Products
	
Professional Products Support
	
Financial Products
	
About Thomson Reuters
	
Careers
Online Products
	
Acquisitions Monthly
	
Buyouts
	
Venture Capital Journal
	
International Financing Review
	
Project Finance International
	
PEhub.com
	
PE Week
	
FindLaw
 Reuters on Facebook
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
 
	
 
 
 
 
 
 
    
 
 
 
 
Other News on Thursday, 12 August 2010 Twenty-three die in ambush in South Sudan oil state  
Hackers siphon cash from British bank accounts  
U.S. failed to plan for Guantanamo convicts  
BP to start Libyan drilling this year  
Rwanda's Kagame wins election by landslide
|  
Plastic Logic cancels QUE electronic reader  
US suffers widest trade gap in 20 months  
Germany to keep close eye on Google "Street View"  
Poverty robs Yemeni children of their young years  
23 die in ambush in South Sudan oil state
|  
WHO list reveals flu advisors with industry ties  
Ethiopia eyes end of food aid within five years: PM
|  
U.N. appeals for $460 million for flooded Pakistan  
Islamic charities versus the US in battle for Pakistan aid  
Thailand to indict top Red Shirts for terrorism  
Thai Supreme Court rejects Thaksin's asset appeal  
China sentences to death two leaders of prostitution ring  
Many Americans don't want government to push fast Internet
|  
S.Korea beat Nigeria 2-1 in friendly  
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary  
Rock band Weezer honors "Lost" star on new album  
Former Sex Pistol headlines Hungary festival  
Air China's Shenzhen signs Airbus purchase  
South India star makes Bollywood's most expensive film  
Macau casino makes a showy splash, but will punters come?  
Tiger Woods' TV allure: the "train wreck" factor  
Old Spice hunk exchanges roles in Tyler Perry films  
ICBC buyout plan sends Hong Kong unit shares soaring  
Busy mogul Nick Cannon finds time for pillow talk with Mariah  
India central bank seeks more banks for rural areas  
Fantasia's dad speaks out
|  
Eminem fends off Taylor Swift on U.S. singles chart
|  
Canada rockers Arcade Fire heat up U.S. album chart
|  
Rock band Weezer honors Lost star on new album
|  
Karroubi: Iran sanctions strengthening government  
U.N. warns of second wave of Pakistani flood deaths
|  
US-TECH Summary  
U.S. braces for Kandahar fight, anti-corruption battle
|  
U.S. sentences bin Laden's cook to 14 years  
Russia admits fires burned on Chernobyl-hit land  
Stem cells used to treat killer skin disease  
IBM, Oracle end lawsuit over poaching executives  
Keep or close Guantanamo? Military jurors weigh in
|  
US court says Germany can be sued over Hitler-era bonds  
Russia urges no panic over Chernobyl-hit regions  
Top Iraqi officer warns US must stay past 2011  
England, Argentina put World Cup trauma behind them  
U.S. sentences bin Laden's cook to 14 years
|  
Google to serve ads on DIRECTV satellite dish programs  
US sticks to Iraq withdrawal timetable  
AP Exclusive: Aid workers' last moments  
U.S. upbeat on Iraq despite violence, deadlock
|  
Cisco revenue climbs but profit disappoints  
Astronauts remove failed cooling pump in ISS spacewalk  
Chechen rebels claim small blast near Gazprom HQ
|  
Smartphone apps help keep the faith on Ramadan  
Many Americans don't want government to push fast Internet  
Fake candidate mocks Australian vote campaign  
India considers BlackBerry suspension over security  
No Ramadan respite as unrest rocks Indian Kashmir  
U.S. braces for Kandahar fight, anti-corruption battle  
Myanmar designates constituencies for rare election  
Hollywood greens up with environmental database  
Politician-boxer Pacquiao to train at parliament  
Nearly 200 of Japan's oldest citizens 'missing'  
India officials meet over BlackBerry security
|  
UN aid push for Pakistan as US steps up relief  
Japan satisfied by Apple moves on overheating iPods
|  
Leonardo DiCaprio attacker pleads not guilty  
China's golden skating pair to host wedding on ice  
IBM, Oracle end lawsuit over poaching executives
|  
Fantasia's dad speaks out  
Rains bring new misery to China mudslide town  
Outback Australians first voters in August 21 election  
Mahindra becomes preferred bidder for Ssangyong  
Lea Michele has Justin Timberlake on her mind  
Seoul shares end down; econ concerns hit POSCO  
Seven reasons Fox hasn't signed an "Idol" judge  
S.Korea c.bank holds rates, but next rise seen soon  
UK PM backs ban on sale of cheap alcohol: report  
Korea Hot Stocks-SK Energy, GS down on oil field concerns  
Zsa Zsa Gabor home from hospital with new hip  
Emmy voters favor fresh, complex drama series  
Gloom reigns as US recovery slows  
Does "Lost's" demise make it Emmy's sure thing?  
S.Korea freezes key interest rate at 2.25 pct  
"Eat Pray Love" an unappetizing combo  
Strike shuts down Japanese mine in Bolivia  
"Mad Men" links up with smoking charity for auction  
China Everbright Bank on track to raise $3.2 bln  
Hollywood greens up with environmental database  
PAKISTAN  
Judge removes herself from Lindsay Lohan case
|  
Emmy voters favor fresh, complex drama series
|  
S.Korea c.bank: price stability "very important"  
Seven reasons Fox hasn't signed an Idol judge
|  
Lea Michele has Justin Timberlake on her mind
|  
Eat Pray Love an unappetizing combo
|  
Mad Men links up with smoking charity for auction
|  
Zsa Zsa Gabor home from hospital with new hip
|  
Hollywood greens up with environmental database
|  
Does Lost's demise make it Emmy's sure thing?
|  
Top TV Salaries: Winfrey, Seacrest, Sheen, Laurie
|  
Japan satisfied by Apple moves on overheating iPods  
Iran woman facing stoning death appears on state TV  
European stocks fall, London drops 0.26%  
Drought ruins Russia wheat, U.S. says no world crisis
|  
Russia says Chernobyl-area radiation normal  
GM profits surge past $1 bln as IPO looms  
Iraq general says army not ready for U.S. pullout  
Israel said to reject Palestinian formula for talks
|  
French trial hears of chef's body found in freezer  
Global equities rocked by economic recovery fears  
Claims of Afghan civilian deaths spark protest  
Austerity hits Greek economy harder than forecast
|  
Sixteen UK tourists stuck in Costa Rican mountains  
In Afghanistan, stillness among the chaos  
First use of tools pushed back a million years  
Low prices drive second quarter phone sales up 14 pct: Gartner  
Ecuador rocked by 6.9 quake, no major damage
|  
Medics killed in Afghan ambush, aid group says
|  
Penpix: The main players in al Qaeda's Saharan operations
|  
Car bomb explodes in Colombian capital
|  
Italy's Berlusconi offers olive branch to rebels
|  
Deadly Typhoon Dianmu cuts across Japan  
Radical Indonesia cleric silent over terror claims  
Pakistani president tries to comfort flood victims  
Hidden trillions widen China's wealth gap  
French star Bardot says 'no one' can play her  
China says foreign firms get fair anti-trust shake  
Pakistan floods destroy crops, could cost billions  
Giant panda has second set of twins in Japan  
China offers to help N.Korea crack down on crime  
Scott Pilgrim movie speaks to gamer generation
|  
India meeting on BlackBerry ends without decision  
George Michael charged with drug, driving offences  
India industrial output grows at slow pace  
Low prices drive second quarter phone sales up 14 pct: Gartner
|  
Pakistan's forex reserves ease to $16.46 bln  
French star Bardot says 'no one' can play her  
Celebrity publicist sought in Mel Gibson case  
Seoul shares end at 1-mth low; econ fears hit POSCO  
Jetblue folk hero electrifies news media, ad firms  
Extreme tourists set off to walk through Africa  
George Michael charged with possessing drugs
|  
Cancer gets first TV comedy twist in The Big C
|  
Jetblue folk hero electrifies news media, ad firms
|  
"Scott Pilgrim" movie speaks to gamer generation  
Judge removes herself from Lindsay Lohan case
|  
Low prices drive second quarter phone sales up 14 pct: Gartner  
Celebrity publicist sought in Mel Gibson case
|  
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro  
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found  
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever  
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production  
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time  
AMD to Start Production of piledriver  
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs  
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia  
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air  
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch  
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent  
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up  
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform  
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis  
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets  
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights