Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Analysis: Facebook fund tests SEC resolve
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Analysis: Facebook fund tests SEC resolve
Reuters - Thursday, January 6
Send
IM Story
Print
By Joseph A. Giannone and Sarah N. Lynch
NEW YORK/WASHINGTON - The efforts by Facebook to raise as much as $1.5 billion outside of regulated markets is the latest test of the walls between private and public markets.
Goldman Sachs this week approached its best private wealth clients with a tantalizing offer: a special fund that will own shares in the fast-growing social networking giant. Goldman gets to offer clients a hot investment opportunity, while Facebook gets to remain a private company.
It is the latest in a growing trend: the blurring of public regulated markets and hands-off private markets.
That trend had drawn the attention of the Securities and Exchange Commission, which now must determine if it can build an enforcement case cracking down on investors and companies potentially skirting the rules on the books, or if it needs to clarify those rules itself.
"You have a lot of people who could probably create private markets that rival the public ones to deliver large amounts of capital to big companies without triggering all the burdens of being a public company," said Donald Langevoort, a professor of securities regulation at Georgetown University.
Small companies traditionally launch with the ultimate goal of completing an initial public offering and obtaining a listing on a national exchange. Yet reporting requirements and other regulatory hurdles have made that path less attractive, while new technology and alternative sources of capital make going public less critical.
That has contributed to a rise in online trading platforms that match buyers and sellers of privately held companies.
SecondMarket Inc, an online platform that hosts the trading of shares in Facebook and other private companies, on Monday told Reuters it received a request for information from the SEC on Friday. The SEC declined to comment on a potential probe into private market trading.
Under U.S. securities law, if a company's private shares are held by more than 500 holders of record, the company is required to register with the SEC and file public disclosure statements. But the rules generally define the term "record holder" as the name displayed on the company's stock record, and not the beneficial owner of the stock.
That means firms like Goldman Sachs can potentially skirt public disclosure rules through the use of a special investment vehicle. These funds can offer numerous investors the opportunity to buy stock, but the shares are all listed in the name of Goldman Sachs and only count as one shareholder of record.
Some securities lawyers say the SEC could choose to intervene if it concludes Facebook intends to skirt disclosure rules.
"It would not strike me as unusual for the SEC to be thinking about it and having to come to grips with it, because of the public notoriety around this transaction," said Stanley Keller, a lawyer at Edwards Angell Palmer & Dodge in Boston.
"When you combine this deal with the secondary market activity taking place, it makes it more problematic for Facebook avoiding crossing over the 500-holder threshold."
Google, another fast-growing Internet company, had also avoided an IPO until trading activity in employee options drew the scrutiny of the SEC. Google went public in 2004.
Several securities law experts note the Facebook fund, if unchallenged, could have major ramifications for other private companies and for Wall Street.
But if companies are closely following all the rules for offering private shares, there may not be much the SEC can do on the enforcement side.
"Assuming they took the steps that were necessary to comply with existing rules and regulations, absent fraud or other extenuating circumstances, even though the SEC may not like it, there's probably not much they can do," said Brian Breheny, a former SEC deputy director of corporation finance who is now a partner at law firm Skadden Arps.
This is not the first time the SEC has been faced with the issue of whether it needs to update its registration rules for over-the-counter equities. In 2003, some investors urged the SEC to count beneficial owners amid concerns that companies were intentionally deregistering their securities to avoid disclosure rules.
Lawyer Stephen Nelson, who represented those investors, said he thinks many of those same issues are still relevant. He said the recent financial crisis underlined that regulators need as much information as possible to effectively police markets.
"When you have entities out there like Facebook, unregistered and not providing information to the SEC about their activities, the more of that kind of stuff that goes on, the dumber your regulators get and the worse their decision-making gets," he said. "And that scares me."
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
US-TECH Summary Reuters - 41 minutes ago
AT&T plans 20 new phones, major Android push Reuters - 41 minutes ago
LG Electronics sees flat North America TV sales in 2011 Reuters - 58 minutes ago
Comcast rolls out video app for iPad; eyes live TV Reuters - 1 hour 1 minute ago
RIM's PlayBook software unit QMX shifts into gear Reuters - 1 hour 3 minutes ago
News Search
Top Stories
William and Kate get archbishop, procession for wedding
US private-sector jobs boom spurs recovery hopes
Fired-up Obama foes take over US House
China vows to help Europe beat debt crisis
First EU bond for Ireland attracts strong demand: HSBC
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Falling blackbirds baffle Arkansas officials
Hasta la Vista: Arnie quits as California governor
Goldman deal 'values Facebook at $50 billion'
Spain lotto winner nearly loses millions by tossing tickets
Brazil's 2010 trade surplus lowest in 8 years: official
More Most Viewed »
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo!
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Entertainment
Photos
Yahoo! News Network
Copyright © 2011 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Thursday, 6 January 2011 Israeli strike foils rare Russian president visit
William and Kate get archbishop, procession for wedding
US-TECH Summary
U.S. foe, Sadr, returns to Iraq after exile
New mass death of birds in Sweden
Fired-up Obama foes take over US House
Panasonic to reveal Internet TV technology: report
Israel says Palestinian alternatives a "mirage"
Hundreds pregnant in UK despite contraceptive implant
US private-sector jobs boom spurs recovery hopes
AT&T plans 20 new phones, major Android push
Kidnapped Hungarian peacekeeper freed in Sudan's Darfur
French ex-minister Morin to run for president
Internet activists hit Tunisia government wesbites
Greek guerrilla group claims Athens court blast
|
China vows to help Europe beat debt crisis
Radical cleric Sadr returns to Iraq as hero
Parrot makes 'smart' car radio for Internet Age
Egypt church bomb hints at al Qaeda gaining toehold
Afghanistan says attacks against VP thwarted
U.S. to help south Sudan if it chooses independence
|
Mattel partners with THQ in new licensing deal
Israel says Palestinian alternatives a mirage
|
Russian Internet firm builds social networking empire
Mongolian spy chief blasts British 'insult'
Analysis: Facebook fund tests SEC resolve
U.S. seeks China's help in reining in North Korea
US probe after Goldman investment in Facebook
Pakistan governor buried as clerics warn against grief
Panasonic to reveal Internet TV technology: report
N.Korea calls for 'unconditional' talks with South
AT&T plans 20 fast Web phones this year
Wozniacki, Rezai power into Hong Kong final
'Roustabout' world's worst job: survey
U.S. downplays Chinese stealth fighter status
AT&T plans 20 new phones, major Android push
|
Time called on British beer measures
Indonesian maid shows wounds to Saudi court
'Babe' creator Dick King-Smith dies at 88
Intel's new chips to yield one-third of 2011 revenue
|
China TV channel turns back clock with 'red' programming
Comcast rolls out video app for iPad; eyes live TV
|
New twist in California gay marriage legal battle
RIM's PlayBook software unit QMX shifts into gear
|
Google wins court challenge on government contract
|
Panasonic to reveal Internet TV technology: report
|
LG Electronics sees flat North America TV sales in 2011
|
American Air holds ground in travel agent spat
|
China vows to help Europe beat debt crisis
Pakistan stocks gain; security concern limits rise
Top Citigroup managers blamed in fraud claims
Top Chinese official promises to buy Spanish debt
Taiwan cbank: bond maturity could spark fund outflows
Japan new car sales see first rise in seven years
Cambodian telecoms sector begins consolidation
Motorola unveils tablet computer, the Xoom
Mali says 'foreigner' attacked French embassy
US probe shares out 'systemic' blame for oil spill
William and Kate get archbishop, procession for wedding
US private hiring boosts hopes for jobs report
Seoul rejects North Korea's talks offer as propaganda
|
Samsung, LG place 3D bets with cheaper TVs
Jackson doctor 'ordered aide to remove evidence'
Dutch firefighters battle chemical blaze
Zoellick: G20 must act to stabilize food prices
|
Starbucks revamps logo, hints at life beyond coffee
Nvidia challenges Intel with PC central processors
U.S. to send 1,400 extra troops to Afghanistan: report
|
N.Korea calls for 'unconditional' talks with South
Microsoft links up with ARM in new tablet drive
Premiership managers fight to survive
Chavez backers, foes rally for Venezuela parliament
|
Sharp's Galapagos tablet U.S.-bound later in 2011
Autism-vaccine study was 'fraud,' journal says
U.S. protests Vietnamese police attack on diplomat
|
Microsoft Windows adapting to mobile world
Republicans take over U.S. House and dilute cuts
Struggling Japan PM tries to seize policy initiative
|
Panasonic readies "smart" TV, tablet thrust
Draining flooded Australia mines could take weeks
|
Sony beefs up content for 3D, pushes connected TV
Motorola gadget to make smartphones like computers
Pakistan governor buried, clerics warn against grief
|
Microsoft sold over 8 million Kinects in 60 days: CEO
Relief agency slams Haiti quake recovery quagmire
|
Autism-vaccine study was a 'fraud', journal says
LG unveils first tablet through T-Mobile USA
U.S. envoy to Libya ensnared in WikiLeaks uproar
|
US, China pledge cooperation
Malkovich plays Casanova and sings on Vienna stage
Motorola unveils tablet computer, the Xoom
Australian navy thwarts pirate attack on British ship
Seoul rejects North Korea's talks offer as "propaganda"
Samsung, LG place 3D bets with cheaper TVs
Finger injury hurts Ogilvy's treble bid
Panasonic readies "smart" TV, tablet thrust
Samsung Electronics to boost 3D TV line-up
Siberian tiger attacks, kills bus driver in China
Battery factory poisons 24 children in China
Corrected: LG Display in LCD screen supply deal with Sony
LinkedIn plans to go public in 2011: sources
|
At 80, world's oldest clown has no plans to quit
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
RIM announces 4G tablet, touts corporate interest
|
LG Electronics sees flat North America TV sales in 2011
"Twilight" and Katy Perry among People's Choice winners
Microsoft sold over 8 million Kinects in 60 days: CEO
|
No-sex zone threatened after Philippines scandal
Motorola gadget to make smartphones like computers
|
"American Idol" best days may be over: poll
Horrified Michael Jackson children saw father motionless
Microsoft links up with ARM in new tablet drive
|
Britney Spears inspires "Country Strong" character
Beatles being paid directly by iTunes in deal
GM invests $5 million in wireless charging startup
|
Co-host of Roger Ebert's new movie show speaks out
Sony beefs up content for 3D, pushes connected TV
|
Beatles being paid directly by iTunes in deal
|
Malkovich plays Casanova and sings on Vienna stage
Nvidia challenges Intel with PC central processors
|
Seoul shares end down on banks, but shipyards help
AT&T plans 20 new phones, major Android push
|
Sumitomo, Nippon Sharyo get Taiwan rail car order
China to build $1.5 bn trading centre in Thailand
Hacked iTunes accounts for sale online in China
Pakistani c.bank to buy govt paper to inject liquidity
China, Taiwan launch new economic committee
Taiwan tax evaders barred from taking taxi-cabs
GM invests $5 million in wireless charging startup
Foreign selling of S.Korea bonds at record in Dec
Pakistan
Sony beefs up content for 3D, pushes connected TV
S.Korea's Asiana to buy six Airbus A380s
Motorola gadget to make smartphones like computers
adding interaction to Connected TV
Microsoft sold over 8 million Kinects in 60 days: CEO
Twilight and Katy Perry among People's Choice winners
|
Horrified Michael Jackson children saw father motionless
|
LG unveils first tablet through T-Mobile USA
American Idol best days may be over: poll
|
Beatles being paid directly by iTunes in deal
|
Co-host of Roger Ebert's new movie show speaks out
|
Betty White says she is trying to cut down on work
|
Britney Spears inspires Country Strong character
|
More catfights in new season of Jersey Shore
|
Paula Abdul dances back into hearts of viewers
|
Anna Nicole Smith boyfriend likely to escape jail
|
Mubarak says Israel must revise position on talks
Iraqis look to U.S. foe Sadr to help stabilise state
|
Israeli troops kill 2 Palestinians on Gaza border
AT&T added 50 percent more China clients in 2010
German industrial orders jump by 5.2%
Fear stalks Egypt's churches over Coptic Christmas
|
US sending 1,400 more Marines to Afghanistan
Renault spy scandal threat to 'strategic assets'
HTC Q4 net more than double, more gains ahead
U.S. woman arrested in Iran for spying: report
|
Egypt warns Israel against new Gaza war
Security tight as Nigerian oil state goes to polls
|
Microsoft sold 8 mln Kinects in first two months
Autism-MMR vaccine study was an 'elaborate fraud'
Israel says Turkey like Iran before revolution
Israelis bribed to admit U.S. goods to Gaza: WikiLeaks
|
Passengers overpower hijacker on Norway-Turkey flight
Ouattara says rival Gbagbo ordered Ivory Coast violence
|
China's Youku streams Hollywood hit in film deal
EU says up to U.N. to inspect Iran's nuclear
Record high food prices stoke fears for economy
|
Radical cleric Sadr returns to Iraq as hero
Former boss feared Pakistan suspect's extremism
|
Chaos at hearing of alleged Pakistan assassin
Former boss feared Pakistan suspect's extremism
Chaos over Pakistan 'assassin' court appearance
Great Wall named top dangerous location in Beijing
In Jakarta, even death can be quite expensive
U.S. to temporarily send 1,400 more Marines to Afghanistan
Korea primed for deep Asian Cup run
Lottery jackpot winner to claim winnings in Wash.
England on verge of Ashes series win
Encore for Malaysia's hit Islamic talent show
Millions more people flying in Philippines
Man in custody following standoff at Arizona mall
Draining flooded Australia mines could take weeks
Beirut's iconic 'Glass Cafe' takes its last bow
Artday app adds culture to smartphones
Apple launches app store for Macs, a la iPhone
|
Analysis: Microsoft embrace boost for ARM, worry for Intel
|
China pledges to enhance yuan flexibility
GameStop's holiday sales disappoint, shares drop
|
Pakistani stocks end up; rupee firms; o/n rates flat
Pakistan's forex reserves jump to record $17.2 bln
Asia Naphtha-S.Korea Honam buys H2 Feb cargoes at firm premiums
Indonesia rights body denounces torture in Papua
AIG's Taiwan unit fined for punishing union member
India police clear Citibank CEO in fraud case
Japan backs firms' green city projects abroad
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights