">Forum Views ()
">Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Court says strip search of Ariz. teenager illegal
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Search
Search:
Court says strip search of Ariz. teenager illegal
By JESSE J. HOLLAND,Associated Press Writer AP - Friday, June 26
WASHINGTON - The Supreme Court ruled Thursday school officials violated an Arizona teenage girl rights by strip-searching her for prescription-strength ibuprofen, saying U.S. educators should not force children to remove their clothing unless student safety is at risk.
ADVERTISEMENT
In an 8-1 ruling, the justices said that Safford Middle School officials violated the Fourth Amendment ban on unreasonable searches with their treatment of Savana Redding. However, the court also ruled that the Arizona school officials cannot be held financially liable for their search.
Redding was 13 when the educators in rural eastern Arizona conducted the search. They were looking for pills _ the equivalent of two Advils. The district bans prescription and over-the-counter drugs and the school was acting on a tip from another student.
The school's search of Redding's backpack and outer clothes was permissible, the court said. But the justices said that officials went too far when they asked to search her underwear.
A 1985 Supreme Court decision that dealt with searching a student's purse has found that school officials need only reasonable suspicions, not probable cause. But the court also warned against a search that is "excessively intrusive."
"What was missing from the suspected facts that pointed to Savana was any indication of danger to the students from the power of the drugs or their quantity, and any reason to suppose that Savana was carrying pills in her underwear," Justice David Souter wrote in the majority opinion. "We think that the combination of these deficiencies was fatal to finding the search reasonable."
Redding said she was pleased with the court's decision. "I'm pretty excited about it, because that's what I wanted," she said. "I wanted to keep it from happening to anybody else."
"The court's decision sends a clear signal to school officials that they can strip search students only in the most extraordinary situations," added her lawyer, Adam Wolf of the American Civil Liberties Union Foundation.
In a dissent, Justice Clarence Thomas found the search legal and said the court previously had given school officials "considerable leeway" under the Fourth Amendment in school settings.
Officials had searched the girl's backpack and found nothing, Thomas said. "It was eminently reasonable to conclude the backpack was empty because Redding was secreting the pills in a place she thought no one would look," Thomas said.
Thomas warned that the majority's decision could backfire. "Redding would not have been the first person to conceal pills in her undergarments," he said. "Nor will she be the last after today's decision, which announces the safest place to secrete contraband in school."
The court also ruled the officials cannot be held liable in a lawsuit for the search. Different judges around the nation have come to different conclusions about immunity for school officials in strip searches, which leads the Supreme Court to "counsel doubt that we were sufficiently clear in the prior statement of law," Souter said.
"We think these differences of opinion from our own are substantial enough to require immunity for the school officials in this case," Souter said.
The justices also said the lower courts would have to determine whether the Safford Unified School District No. 1 could be held liable.
A schoolmate had accused Redding, then an eighth-grade student, of giving her pills.
The school's vice principal, Kerry Wilson, took Redding to his office to search her backpack. When nothing was found, Redding was taken to a nurse's office where she says she was ordered to take off her shirt and pants. Redding said they then told her to move her bra to the side and to stretch her underwear waistband, exposing her breasts and pelvic area. No pills were found.
A federal magistrate dismissed a suit by Redding and her mother, April. An appeals panel agreed that the search didn't violate her rights. But last July, a full panel of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals found the search was "an invasion of constitutional rights" and that Wilson could be found personally liable.
Justices John Paul Stevens and Ruth Bader Ginsburg dissented from the portion of the ruling saying that Wilson could not be held financially liable.
"Wilson's treatment of Redding was abusive and it was not reasonable for him to believe that the law permitted it," Ginsburg said.
The case is Safford Unified School District v. April Redding, 08-479.
(This version CORRECTS SUBS graf bgng, The justices also ... etc. to correct 'United' to 'Unified'.)
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Sign in to recommend this article »
0 users recommend
Related Articles: World
UK-World SummaryReuters - Friday, June 26
Nigerian rebels say they attacked Shell pipelineReuters - Thursday, June 25
Bomb kills at least 72 in BaghdadReuters - Thursday, June 25
Ahmadinejad compares Obama to BushReuters - Friday, June 26
Feds arrest head of anti-gang group in LAAP - Thursday, June 25
Most Popular – World
Viewed
Botox helps Australian stroke victim to walk again
US company makes first batch of swine flu vaccine
Saturn moon may harbour life-giving ocean: study
Sarah Jessica Parker welcomes surrogate twins
Nixon was ready to 'cut off head' of S. Vietnam leader
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Friday, 26 June 2009 G8 ministers seek firm stance on Iran
Russia orders retrial in Politkovskaya case
UN tribunal sets up Hariri website for tip-offs
Berri elected Lebanon speaker for fifth term
Two alleged ETA members arrested near Paris
Farrah Fawcett dead at 62: O'Neal
NATO to start offensive soon in south Afghanistan
| International
|
Britain's Woolworths relaunches as online store
Hamas leader rejects freak Israel offer of state
| International
|
Steelmaker Corus says could axe up to 2,045 jobs
Indonesian court clears Facebook mum
"20/20" To Air Barbara Walters Exclusive Report On Farrah Fawcett On Thursday
Zimbabwe's Mugabe attacks West on sanctions, aid
| International
|
US economy contraction offers hope of rebound
Expanded Update: Cancer Claims Life Of 'Charlie's Angels' Star
Microsoft, Publicis join forces for online ads
Turbid Jordan trickles the promised land
Swedish court rules out Pirate Bay retrial
Israel gives Abbas forces freer hand in W.Bank cities
Farrah Fawcett Dies Of Cancer At Age 62
Ten dead in Czech floods, central Europe on alert
| International
|
Martina Navratilova Being Sued By Ex Partner
Risks battle rewards as Iraq opens up its oilfields
| International
|
Will.I.Am Releases Statement Regarding His Involvement In Perez Hilton's Alleged Assault
Iran's Mousavi vows threats will not stop him
USAID giving $1 million to Africa climate project
Heidi Klum Sues Internet Trader For Cheapening Her Perfumes On eBay
Jerusalem gay parade ends peacefully
| International
|
Recession, expensive oil slow CO2 growth in 2008
Black Eyes Peas Hold #1 And #2 Spots On Billboard Hot 100
Billy Bob Thornton's Daughter Indicted For Murder Of Baby
EU to help China test carbon capture
Oscar Awards Adds More Nomination Slots For Best Picture
Jonathan Rhys Meyers Arrested In Paris Airport Over Drunken Brawl
No contest plea in pregnant Utah girl's beating
Palm loss narrower than expected, shares leap
| Technology
|
Vietnam asks for support against 'terrorism'
White House hunting for $20B for highways, transit
Microsoft, VivaKi team up in digital and TV advertising
| Technology
|
Major provisions of House climate and energy bill
Cambodian PM warns Thailand in border temple row
Court says strip search of Ariz. teenager illegal
Myanmar links US Suu Kyi swimmer to exile groups
SC gov with family as questions grow over absence
New UN rights envoy to Cambodia pledges 'constructive' talks
Taiwan opposition launches 'Free Chen' campaign
RI club owner in fatal fire case out of prison
Republican Lazio planning run for NY governor
Turkish president Gul meets with China's Hu
Peng edged out in Wimbledon thriller
Napolitano to Europe, Kuwait for terrorism talks
Hong Kong tycoon hoped feng shui could get back husband
Analysis: Why do politicians cheat?
Pakistan PM urges Obama aide to halt drone strikes
Court rules for defendants on crime lab reports
VW mulling stake in Suzuki: report
S.Korea central bank extends FX swap deal with Fed
India's Tata Steel reports 60% drop in profit
PC makers race to comply with China's Web filter
Steelmaker Corus could axe up to 2,045 jobs
Head of India's Infosys quits for gov't post
Patti Blagojevich: Time in jungle 'life altering'
UBS appoints new chief executive for Asia business
Pakistan targets 325 bln rupees in T-bill auctions
Fashion thumbs nose at crisis at Paris men's shows
Elite Indonesia troops tortured Papuans
FACTBOX-Recent comments by Taiwan officials on economy, policy
Farrah Fawcett, 1970s sex symbol, dies aged 62
| Entertainment
|
Forking out a 'Fortuyn' for Dutch politician's artefacts
Sinopec seeks capacity, reserves with Addax bid
Transformers $60.6 million debut topples record
| Entertainment
|
Confed tourists in SAfrica adapt to crime fears
Enter Moscow's answer to Batman
Estefans join Miami Dolphins as minority owners
Attorney General Argues For Leniency For Crack Felons; Considering "Alternatives" To Prison
Expanded Update: Cancer Claims Life Of 'Charlie's Angels' Star
E. Coli Concerns Prompts Colorado Company To Recal 41,000 Pounds Of Beef Shipped To 13 States
Update: South Carolina Voters Say Adulterous Sanford Should Resign
Governor Cautious About Giuliani's Proposed Constitutional Convention For NY Senate Standoff
Homebuilder Lennar Reflects Gloomy State Of Housing Sector As Loss Widens
Obama Honors Imprisoned Cuban Dissidents
Farrah Fawcett Dies Of Cancer At Age 62
Pakistan Demands End To U.S. Air Strikes
U.S. Economy Shows Sign Of Recovery As Q1 GDP Contracts By 5.5%
G8 ministers hammering out Iran statement
Two weeks after: Iran rallies fade, elite split
| International
|
US-TECH Summary
Two weeks after
Texas cricket mogul pleads not guilty to fraud
Doctor flees Iran over Neda killing: report
| International
|
Bomb kills 10, wounds 25 in Baghdad
| International
|
US teens spend more time watching TV than on computer
Analysis: Iran's 2-sided rule _ turban and helmet
Update: Celebrities And Fans Around The World Mourn Michael Jackson's Death
UBS to seek to raise capital by 2.5 billion euros
Few iPhone apps likely to get wide usage: AdMob report
Michael Jackson Passes Away At 50
China intellectuals seek release of dissident
| International
|
Iran opposition leader says he won't give up fight
Pop icon Michael Jackson dead: TMZ.com website
Michael Jackson Hospitalized For Cardiac Arrest
Two killed in first suicide bombing in Pakistan Kashmir
| International
|
Iraqi bombings kill scores ahead of US withdrawal
Third of open ocean sharks face extinction: study
Microsoft, VivaKi team up in digital and TV advertising
Hulk Hogan's Ex-Wife Responds To Hairdresser's Drug Allegations
Microsoft unveils Windows 7 prices, free upgrades
Iran opposition leader defiant amid pressure to back down
Amnesty urges Thailand to open lese-majeste trial
| International
|
Israel marks third anniversary of soldier's capture
Questions and answers about the climate bill
Climate bill showdown: Obama, Dems pressing hard
Recession, expensive oil slow CO2 growth in 2008
LG Elec aims to sell up to 5 million LED TVs in 2010
Major provisions of House climate and energy bill
Guantanamo reforms in defense budget: US lawmaker
Embattled South Carolina Governor to repay trip expenses
Google slammed as China, U.S. quarrel over Internet
| Technology
|
Financier Stanford pleads not guilty, bond set
Pre helps Palm beat expectations, shares rise
| Technology
|
Iowa town struggles to understand slaying of coach
Memphis mayor resigns to focus on run for Congress
Manhattan DA endorses ex-deputy to replace him
Aliases hinder probe of Houston officer's slaying
Former Wash. inmate sues state for labor shackling
Court: Hustler wrong to print dead woman's photos
NZ economy shrinks for 5th straight quarter in Q1
S.Korea to raise power costs by 3.9 pct this week
Taiwan dlr rebounds from 1-mth low after rate move
S.Korea asks banks to control mortgage loan growth
Taiwan keeps certificate of deposit rates intact
Tears flow for pop's 'Peter Pan'
S.Korea T-bonds rebound on U.S., July auction plan
S.Korea c.bank sees June c/a surplus over $3 bln
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Mystery surrounds Michael Jackson's sudden death
| Entertainment
|
Seoul shares rise;shipbuilders, steel issues gain
"Transformers" in high gear already
Farrah Fawcett, 1970s sex symbol, dies aged 62
| Entertainment
|
King of Pop Michael Jackson dies, aged 50
S.Korea May c/a surplus more than halves
Stars in shock at Jackson's death
Transformers in high gear already
| Entertainment
|
Not 's job to 'fix China': CEO
Pop icon Michael Jackson dead: official
NBC sets fall schedule dates
| Entertainment
|
A buoyant 'Twelfth Night' floats in Central Park
Old Boy proceeds despite legal scuffle
| Entertainment
|
LA Times: Michael Jackson hospitalized
Noah Wyle in alien-fighting role at TNT
| Entertainment
|
RI club owner in fatal fire case out of prison
Jeri Ryan gains Leverage at TNT
| Entertainment
|
ABC, NBC airing Farrah Fawcett specials
Lebanon's Hariri set to become prime minister
| International
|
Israel plays down reports of imminent Gaza deal
| International
|
Pakistani violence spreads to Kashmir
| International
|
Ireland grants rights to same-sex partnerships
| International
|
Turkey's military says plot report is smear campaign
| International
|
OSCE makes last Georgia patrol, issues warning
| International
|
Zimbabwe's Mugabe attacks West on sanctions, aid
| International
|
Thai official to avoid temple issue in Cambodia
Indonesia radio becomes voice for tolerance
NKorean leader boosts public appearances this year
China marks anti-drug day with executions
SKorea to set up peacekeeping force: military
Brothers charged in Ariz. diversity office bombing
California Senate rejects cash-saving proposal
China hospital dumps 8 unclaimed bodies
UN troubleshooter in Myanmar to discuss Ban visit
U.N. Human Rights Chief Blasts America's Torture Programs, Terror Prisons
Outrage as French rugby player admits assault lie
Memorial service set for operator in DC crash
G8 Deplores Iran's Election Violence
AP source: GM to build small car in Michigan
Sanford To Pay Back Tax Payers For 2008 Argentina Trip
Vietnam fishermen say trade hit by Chinese patrols
Facing Impeachment, Imprisoned Federal Judge To Resign
Spokane cops arrest alleged meat thief ringleader
China's Li facing Pole challenge at Wimbledon
Former Venture Capitalist Julius Genachowski Confirmed As FCC Chairman
Alaska governor visits troops in Kosovo
In Wake Of Ensign Extramarital Scandal, GOP Elects Sen. Thune As Policy Head
Steelers owner Rooney now ambassador to Ireland
Blagojevich Corruption Trial Set For June 3, 2010
Despite Anticipated Close Vote, House Democrats Begin Debate On Landmark Energy Bill Friday
Utility Crew Digs Up Human Remains Near Cemeteries
Michael Jackson Dies In Los Angeles
Japan's consumer prices log record fall
Pakistani c.bank sells 59.4 bln rupees of T-bills
China bank loans to top 1 trillion yuan in June
Jackson death forces cuts to 'Bruno' comedy: report
Gay rights movement: 40 years since Stonewall riots
Michael Jackson's death hits tour promoter, ticket holders
| Entertainment
|
'Realism' rubbery idea in French art show in Brazil
Showbiz diva Liza Minnelli returns to Paris
Selected Discography for Michael Jackson
Hundreds of Jackson fans converge on hospital
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights