">Forum Views ()
">Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Think twice about 'green' transport, say scientists
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Asia Pacific
World
Search
Search:
Think twice about 'green' transport, say scientists
AFP - Monday, June 8
PARIS (AFP) - - You worry a lot about the environment and do everything you can to reduce your carbon footprint -- the emissions of greenhouse gases that drive dangerous climate change.
ADVERTISEMENT
So you always prefer to take the train or the bus rather than a plane, and avoid using a car whenever you can, faithful to the belief that this inflicts less harm to the planet.
Well, there could be a nasty surprise in store for you, for taking public transport may not be as green as you automatically think, says a new US study.
Its authors point out an array of factors that are often unknown to the public.
These are hidden or displaced emissions that ramp up the simple "tailpipe" tally, which is based on how much carbon is spewed out by the fossil fuels used to make a trip.
Environmental engineers Mikhail Chester and Arpad Horvath at the University of California at Davis say that when these costs are included, a more complex and challenging picture emerges.
In some circumstances, for instance, it could be more eco-friendly to drive into a city -- even in an SUV, the bete noire of green groups -- rather than take a suburban train. It depends on seat occupancy and the underlying carbon cost of the mode of transport.
"We are encouraging people to look at not the average ranking of modes, because there is a different basket of configurations that determine the outcome," Chester told AFP in a phone interview.
"There's no overall solution that's the same all the time."
The pair give an example of how the use of oil, gas or coal to generate electricity to power trains can skew the picture.
Boston has a metro system with high energy efficiency. The trouble is, 82 percent of the energy to drive it comes from dirty fossil fuels.
By comparison, San Francisco's local railway is less energy-efficient than Boston's. But it turns out to be rather greener, as only 49 percent of the electricity is derived from fossils.
The paper points out that the "tailpipe" quotient does not include emissions that come from building transport infrastructure -- railways, airport terminals, roads and so on -- nor the emissions that come from maintaining this infrastructure over its operational lifetime.
These often-unacknowledged factors add substantially to the global-warming burden.
In fact, they add 63 percent to the "tailpipe" emissions of a car, 31 percent to those of a plane, and 55 percent to those of a train.
And another big variable that may be overlooked in green thinking is seat occupancy.
A saloon (sedan) car or even an 4x4 that is fully occupied may be responsible for less greenhouse gas per kilometer travelled per person than a suburban train that is a quarter full, the researchers calculate.
"Government policy has historically relied on energy and emission analysis of automobiles, buses, trains and aircraft at their tailpipe, ignoring vehicle production and maintenance, infrastructure provision and fuel production requirements to support these modes," they say.
So getting a complete view of the ultimate environmental cost of the type of transport, over its entire lifespan, should help decision-makers to make smarter investments.
For travelling distances up to, say, 1,000 kilometres (600 miles), "we can ask questions as to whether it's better to invest in a long-distance railway, improving the air corridor or boosting car occupancy," said Chester.
The paper appears in Environmental Research Letters, a publication of Britain's Institute of Physics.
The calculations are based on US technology and lifestyles.
It used 2005 models of the Toyota Camry saloon, Chevrolet Trailblazer SUV and Ford F-150 to calibrate automobile performance; the light transit systems in the San Francisco Bay Area and Boston as the models for the metro and commuter lines; and the Embraer 145, Boeing 737 and Boeing 747 as the benchmarks for short-, medium- and long-haul aircraft.
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Sign in to recommend this article »
0 users recommend
Related Articles: Climate Change
Think twice about 'green' transport, say scientistsAFP - Monday, June 8
US, China need to lead on climate: US senatorAFP - Friday, June 5
US role in new climate treaty hinges on ChinaAP - Thursday, June 4
US may not be ready with numbers for climate dealAP - Thursday, June 4
Related Articles: Entertainment & Lifestyle
'Up,' surprise hit 'Hangover' rule at US box officeAFP - Monday, June 8
Riyadh goes to the movies -- for the first timeAFP - Monday, June 8
Cirque du Soleil celebrates 25th with creepy crawliesAFP - Sunday, June 7
US comedian goes commando in IraqAFP - Sunday, June 7
Actor James Franco pulls out of UCLA grad speechAP - Sunday, June 7
Enlarge Photo
A metro train pulls into a station. You worry a lot about the environment and do everything you can to reduce your carbon footprint -- the emissions of greenhouse gases that drive dangerous climate change.
Related Full Coverage
climate change
climate change
All Full Coverage
Most Popular – Entertainment
Viewed
Life, health insurers invest big in tobacco
Carradine may have died from sex act: Thai police
President Obama's French food tested by 'taster'
Susan Boyle out of London clinic: brother
Wall Street ponders if rally can run further
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Monday, 8 June 2009 Eighteen killed in Acapulco drug shootout
| International
|
Barclays to sell fund management arm to BlackRock
Peru looks for missing police, troops patrol jungle
| International
|
Clinton says U.S. mulls relisting N.Korea
Kim Jong-Il's son tips brother as next leader: report
Frantic search for survivors of China landslide
Korean Air says bottom hit in cargo demand
Family upset over photos of Carradine's body
| Entertainment
|
New Zealand house price decline slows in May
Up retains altitude, tops box office again
| Entertainment
|
Toyota targets bln-dlr cost cut for small cars: report
Riyadh goes to the movies -- for the first time
U.S. allies hand Lebanon's Hezbollah election blow
Conservatives hand centre-left defeat in EU vote
Swedish Pirate Party enters EU parliament: partial results
Hariri coalition claims victory in Lebanon vote
British PM suffers, as far-right surges in EU vote
Hopes worst of crisis over fuel market rally: bank body
Britain's Brown faces revolt after poll rout
| International
|
North Korea jails U.S. journalists, warns U.N
| International
|
Gabon President Omar Bongo dead: France
EU set to veer right at EU parliamentary polls
U.S. allies hand Lebanon's Hezbollah election blow
| International
|
Tymoshenko announces Ukraine presidential bid
President Obama's French food tested by 'taster'
Crews find more bodies from Air France crash
| International
|
EU vows economic leadership after assembly vote
| International
|
Ukraine's PM Tymoshenko to run for president
Military: Rocket or mortar hits Baghdad Green Zone
Main Ahmadinejad rival says supporters targeted
Baghdad blast kills seven, wounds 24: police
| International
|
Think twice about 'green' transport, say scientists
US role in new climate treaty hinges on China
US may not be ready with numbers for climate deal
Police call for help in China bus blaze probe
Obama returns from landmark Middle East, Europe trip
NKorea bans ships off port from Wednesday: Japan
North Korea jails U.S. journalists and warns U.N
Swine flu leaves US mayor quarantined in China
China to require PCs with software to block sites: report
| Technology
|
US considers returning N.Korea to terror list
Villagers fight Taliban after Pakistan mosque blast
Singapore News
Singapore News
Singapore News
Korea Hot Stocks
Taiwan dollar eases; c.bank has limited impact
Korea Hydro selling 5-yr dlr bonds this wk -source
Taiwan Data Watch-May trade data
Japanese corporate spend seen in record decline
RBNZ faith in OCR; market rises worry-Bollard intvw
Billy Elliot dances away with 10 Tony Awards
| Entertainment
|
Seoul shares open flat; banks fall, LG Display up
Think twice about 'green' transport, say scientists
Family upset over photos of Carradine's body
| Entertainment
|
Up retains altitude, tops box office again
| Entertainment
|
'Up,' surprise hit 'Hangover' rule at US box office
Q&A: Julian Marley carries on the family tradition
| Entertainment
|
Official: 4 rare elephants poisoned in Indonesia
Teen chef signs TV deal
| Entertainment
|
Gainesville, Fla., names plaza after Bo Diddley
Rock band Sugar Ray back in the ring as indie act
| Entertainment
|
Indonesia detains 69 Afghan migrants
Actor James Franco pulls out of UCLA grad speech
Four militants killed in Gaza border battle: medics
Two dead, 12 missing in Ukraine coal mine accident
Berlin refuses loan request from retailer Arcandor
Top economies signal recession may be easing: OECD
Saudi woman minister needs permission to be on TV
Khmer Rouge jailer says ordered killing of children
| International
|
Egypt university dorm quarantined over H1N1 cases
Israelis kill three gunmen and horse on Gaza border
Angry Pakistani villagers fight, surround Taliban
| International
|
Iran expects 'record' turnout for vote
NATO to reduce Kosovo force by Jan: U.S. official
| International
|
7 killed in Baghdad bus bombing: security sources
Gabon's Bongo dies in Spain: report
| International
|
Israelis kill three gunmen, horse on Gaza border
| International
|
Angry Pakistani villagers fight and surround Taliban
Sweden's free-Web Pirate Party captures Euro seat
| Technology
|
India to increase troops along China border
Military spouses seek residency benefits
Security lockdown in Kashmir over rape protests
8 illegal immigrants killed in rollover in Arizona
Kim sacrifices himself for NKorea: state media
Suspect in abortion doctor death warns of violence
Political killings rock Pakistan's Karachi
Chrysler dealers scramble to unload vehicles
Bangladesh ups security for judges after threats
Stowaway from Ethiopia found among Dulles baggage
Thailand says FBI can observe Carradine probe
Shanghai aims to become 'Broadway of the East'
Gay rights activist calls for march on Washington
Khmer Rouge prison chief: babies were 'smashed'
Residents ask why SC fire warnings took so long
Bear cub spotted with head stuck in feeder
Former President Carter plans Gaza visit this week
Burned Maine topless coffee shop seeks donations
More oil, gas fields must be developed: Petronas CEO
Seoul unveils $18 bln plan for river development
China Eastern, Shanghai Airlines told to merge: report
WRAPUP 2-Taiwan exports slump at slower pace in May
Japan's current account surplus falls 54.5%
Global airlines to lose 9 billion dollars in 2009
US airlines cutting flights to China: state media
China raises export tax rebates
EU drops plans to allow mixing to make rose wine
Notable quotes from 2009 Tony Awards
What shows won what awards at the 2009 Tonys
`Billy Elliot' wins 10 Tonys; `Carnage' best play
Pianists from Japan, China win Cliburn
`Up' maintains No. 1 box-office altitude with $44M
'Slumdog' kids perform on Hong Kong TV, at mall
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights