Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Dems go after antitrust exemption for insurers
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Dems go after antitrust exemption for insurers
By DAVID ESPO,AP Special Correspondent -
Thursday, October 22
Send
IM Story
Print
WASHINGTON – Democrats launched a drive at both ends of the Capitol on Wednesday to strip the insurance industry of its decades-old exemption from federal antitrust laws, part of an increasingly bare-knuckled struggle over landmark health care legislation sought by President Barack Obama.
If enacted, the change would put an end to "price-fixing, bid-rigging and market allocation in the health and medical malpractice" insurance areas, said Sen. Patrick Leahy, D-Vt., chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee. Leahy said he would seek a vote on the plan when the Senate debates health care legislation in the next few weeks.
Leahy made his comments at virtually the same time the House Judiciary Committee voted 20-9 to end an industry exemption that dates to 1945. Three Republicans supported the move.
Senior Democratic officials in the House said the leadership was inclined to incorporate the measure into the broader health care bill expected to be brought to the floor for a vote within a few weeks. No final decision has been made, they added.
In response, an industry official said Democrats were targeting a problem that does not exist.
The events coincided with a vote in the Senate to sidetrack legislation averting a 21 percent cut in Medicare payments for doctors in January and raising their fees by $247 billion over a decade. The 47-53 vote was 13 short of the 60 needed to advance the bill, reflecting concerns that the measure would have raised deficits. The result was a defeat for Democrats and an embarrassment for the American Medical Association, which had mounted a seven-figure advertising effort to assure passage of one of its top priorities.
Republicans grumbled that Senate Democrats timed the offensive on antitrust matters to obscure their defeat on the bill setting pay rates for doctors, a measure that GOP leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., called "the Senate's first vote on health care this year."
Even so, taken together, the threats to revoke long-standing antitrust protections reflect the fury Democrats have projected in response to recent insurance industry attempts to influence the shape of legislation. The events occurred less than a week after the insurers' trade association issued a report saying a measure in the Senate Finance Committee would produce sharp increases in premiums for millions of people who currently have insurance.
Democrats and the White House reacted angrily, attacking the study as flawed and politically motivated.
Responding to the day's developments, the industry said the legislation was based on a misperception of existing law. "We believe that health insurers have not been engaging in anticompetitive conduct and that McCarran-Ferguson does not provide a shield for such conduct," Karen Ignagni, president and CEO of American's Health Insurance Plans, wrote to Rep. John Conyers, the Michigan Democrat who chairs the Houses Judiciary Committee.
"Thus, the bills attempt to remedy a problem that does not exist," she wrote.
The McCarran-Ferguson Act of 1945 gives states authority to regulate the insurance industry for antitrust matters, and the companies are exempt from federal jurisdiction.
To buttress its case, industry officials circulated a paper from JPMorgan, the investment bank. "Ultimately, just using the terms antitrust and health insurers in the same sentence makes a great headline, but in practice given the narrow scope of the act, we doubt a repeal has meaningful implications for the publicly traded companies," it said.
The industry holds a large conference beginning on Thursday several blocks from the Capitol.
The White House had no reaction. Instead, aides pointed to Obama's statement last weekend that insurers are earning "profits and bonuses while enjoying a privileged exception from our antitrust laws, a matter that Congress is rightfully reviewing."
The developments came as Democrats struggled in both houses of Congress to enact Obama's call for legislation to expand health care to millions who lack insurance, provide greater consumer protections to millions more, and rein in the cost of medical care in general.
In the Senate, Reid, key committee chairmen and White House aides are at work crafting legislation the Senate can vote on later this fall.
The House is also on track for a vote this fall, although weeks of private negotiations among Democrats have yet to produce agreement on a bill.
Among the most controversial unresolved issues concerns proposals for the government to sell insurance in competition with private companies. The House bill is certain to include such a provision. Although the rank and file have yet to come to an agreement on key details, officials said the leadership was counting carefully to see if it had the votes to establish a system that would pay doctors 5 percent more than they receive for treating Medicare patients. Hospitals and other providers would be paid at Medicare rates, without the additional 5 percent, they said.
It is unclear what type of so-called "public option" will be incorporated into the Senate measure, where Democratic moderates are wary of the idea, even though public polling consistently shows its popularity.
Until recently, the insurance industry has played a noncommittal role as legislative proposals developed in both houses of Congress. AHIP announced months ago it supported comprehensive health care reform and Obama called on Ignagni to speak at a televised White House event designed to showcase widespread agreement that the time had come to change the current system.
Essentially, industry offered a trade. It agreed to abandon practices such as denying coverage on the basis of pre-existing medical conditions if the legislation required nearly universal coverage, a step that would give it access to millions of new customers. At the same time, it vigorously opposes any legislation that would allow the government to sell insurance.
The tone began to change when the Finance Committee voted to excuse an estimated two million lower income Americans from a requirement to purchase insurance, at the same time it greatly reduced the penalties for those who were still covered, but refused to buy coverage.
___
Associated Press writer Erica Werner contributed to this report.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Chavez urges 3-minute showers to conserve water Reuters - Thursday, October 22
UN details 'devastating' impact of Afghan opium AFP - Thursday, October 22
Galleon funds to close amid insider trading scandal AFP - Thursday, October 22
Honduras regime uses noise attack as U.S. cuts visas Reuters - Thursday, October 22
Record numbers get behind UN drive against poverty AFP - Thursday, October 22
News Search
Top Stories
Galleon funds to close amid insider trading scandal
'Sahrawi Gandhi' awarded New York peace prize
Tropical storm Rick threatens flash floods in Mexico
Wells Fargo profit jumps to record $3.2 bln
Deutsche Bank posts three-fold rise in quarterly profit
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Data confirms 'modest' AIDS vaccine breakthrough
Australian burglar betrayed by leech
British airport operator sells London airport
Rights group in hot water over Israel criticism
Balloon boy parents ready to surrender to police: lawyer
More Most Viewed »
Boyzone singer Gately dies in Spain
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Thursday, 22 October 2009 Israelis say deal near with U.S. on Mideast talks
Deutsche Bank posts three-fold rise in quarterly profit
Tropical storm Rick threatens flash floods in Mexico
Vatican move to welcome Anglicans splits critics
Swiss Authorities Admit To Tipping Off U.S. About Roman Polanski
South Sudan finds no sign of feared Ebola outbreak
Wells Fargo profit jumps to record $3.2 bln
Six hostages freed in Paris siege
Six hostages freed in Paris supermarket siege
Appeals Court Rules Judge Wrongly Imprisoned Soap Star Brenda Dickson
Second Afghan vote 'will not be perfect': UN envoy
Iran makes bomb arrests, Pakistan vows help
Burberry Suing Pet Accessories Store For Copyright Infringement
"Dr. No" Villain Joseph Wiseman Dies At 91
Industrialised nations' CO2 emissions rose in 2007: UN
Bomb kills journalist, wounds another in Iraq
Rio police kill 7; total of 33 dead in drug war
| International
|
Israeli police arrest convicted American pedophile
Draft agreement on Iran uranium deal: IAEA chief
Asia demand for ivory, sharks' fins set for scrutiny
Iraq's parliament fails to agree on election law
| International
|
Iran, powers get draft deal for approval by Friday
Bomb kills US soldier in Afghanistan: NATO
Hostages held at gunpoint in Canada office building
| International
|
Disaffected Anglican dioceses may switch to Rome: group
| International
|
Bomb hits Bangladesh MP's car, several hurt
| International
|
Microsoft's Bing seals Facebook, Twitter deals
| Technology
|
Google, labels partner on music search: sources
| Technology
|
Pakistan hits Taliban as schools ordered shut
Chinese group says Google violating copyrights
Canada allows Internet throttling as last resort
| Technology
|
Lawyer denies reports Lockerbie bomber dead
Cambodian PM offers to host fugitive Thai ex-PM
Skype working on business sector expansion
| Technology
|
Gore: China, US must cooperate on climate change
Key lawmaker backs FCC on eve of Web rule
| Technology
|
US 'jihadist' charged in anti-American plots
Wikipedia founder in HP online magazine print deal
| Technology
|
AZ Councilman makes remarks insensitive to Jews
US, China to meet next week for trade talks
Cambodia leader: Ousted Thai PM is always welcome
Safety board issues wake-up call on sleep disorder
Fearing fresh attacks, Pakistan shuts schools
Second Afghan vote 'will not be perfect': UN envoy
Pakistan advance into Taliban leader's hometown
U.S. revokes more visas to pressure Honduran solution
Marine pleads guilty in hero hoax, to be sentenced
Woman in W.Va. torture case now says she lied
AP NewsAlert
Even Help From Higher Power Fails To Stop Ministerial Layoffs
Beige Book: Economy Leveling Off, But Still Has Weakness
Microsoft Hopes XP Users Switch To Windows 7
Massachusetts Man Charged With Terrorism, Plotting To Attack Shopping Malls
Suspected Jihadist Arrested For Plotting Mall Attack
Poll: Crist's Conservative Rival Gains Ground In Senate Race
India economy seen growing 6.5 pct this year
Secret CIA Prison In Lithuania To Be Investigated
Longworth House Building Evacuated
US seeks progress in high level trade talks with China
Tankers Collide In Gulf Of Mexico
Colorado Residents Charged With Illegal Interstate Traffic, Sale Of Bobcats, Pelts
India's Tata Motors buys out Spain's Hispano
India court suggests arbitration for feuding Ambanis: report
Electric cars take on hybrids at Tokyo show
China says economic recovery 'consolidated'
China signals economic shift to curb overcapacity
Tokyo car show spurned as foreign firms eye China
China wants to boost trade at Asian summit
New managers vow to resurrect storied HK studio
Veiled Iranian women suspected of drug smuggling
Hollywood film recreates Russia-Georgia war
Horror movie marks MTV's drive into scripted shows
| Entertainment
|
Canadian author named new president of PEN
Sesame Street seeks Gaza access
Japan dolphin hunting town threatens to sue over 'The Cove'
Europe's 'Hot d'Or' porn film awards return
Taiwan group says China trip cancelled over Kadeer film
Migrant workers face abuse in SKorea: Amnesty
100,000 Italian women protest 'offensive' Berlusconi
Families divided as Bhutan refugees start new lives
Lil Wayne appears for DNA hearing in NYC gun case
For sale: Stage where James Dean's career began
No Surprise Here: Simon Cowell's Mother Admits He Was A "Difficult Child"
Colorado Residents Charged With Illegal Interstate Traffic, Sale Of Bobcats, Pelts
Canadian Sex Workers Seek Safer Work Environment
Blue Roses Hit Japan Stores, Sell For Up To $33 Per Stem
Armed Robbery Suspect Used Bra To Disguise Face
Faux Spokesman Hoped To Highlight Organization's "Absurd" Climate Stance
Police Detectives Save Bronx Cat Trapped In Car Engine
Scientists Developing Tools To Give Future 100-Year-Olds A Body 50 Years Younger
Blood Sucking Leeches Lead Police To Criminal
Astronomers Find 32 New Extrasolar Planets
UN details 'devastating' impact of Afghan opium
Berlusconi in Russia on 'private' visit, meets Putin
eBay net profit slides for fourth quarter in a row
Gates says moving ahead on Afghan troop policy
| International
|
Galleon funds to close amid insider trading scandal
'Sahrawi Gandhi' awarded New York peace prize
Pakistani brigadier, driver killed in shooting
| International
|
More Internet users sharing status updates: report
Gates pledges nuclear umbrella to counter North Korea
| International
|
China mulls military rescue of hijacked sailors
| International
|
Iraqi lawmakers deadlocked over election law
Rio police kill 7; total of 33 dead in drug war
| International
|
UN pushes draft Iran nuclear deal
Israelis say deal near with U.S. on Mideast talks
| International
|
Microsoft, Google integrating Twitter into search
Canada gunman surrenders after 10-hour standoff
| International
|
Key U.S. lawmaker backs FCC on eve of Web rule
Honduras regime uses noise attack as U.S. cuts visas
| International
|
Iran arrests suspects in attack on military chiefs
Australia sheik charged over Afghan widow hate mail
| International
|
Canada allows Internet "throttling" as last resort
Iraqi lawmakers stuck over election law
HP partners with university to print digital books
Wikipedia founder in HP online magazine print deal
RIM launches new Bold, but challenge looms for Storm
Skype working on business sector expansion
Microsoft launches Windows 7, eyes PC sales rebound
| Technology
|
Windows 7 may help kickstart delayed corporate spend
| Technology
|
Microsoft, Google seal Twitter search deals
| Technology
|
Like Windows 7, Vista got good reviews too
| Technology
|
Hulu trying out models to boost revenue: NBC
| Technology
|
US committed to defence of SKorea: Gates
Taiwan school pupils 'made to eat fire': TV report
Judge: Notices must be in formats blind can read
Gates pledges nuclear umbrella to counter N. Korea
Key U.S. lawmaker backs FCC on eve of Web rule
| Technology
|
Video makers release tape of Philly ACORN visit
Woman in W.Va. torture case now says she lied
Kan. lawmaker agrees to new 'rap' on YouTube
Multiple fires rage in NKorea, satellite images show
Dems go after antitrust exemption for insurers
US warns of 'slow, painful' talks with Myanmar
Marine gets 18 months confinement for hero hoax
US will never have 'normal' ties with a nuclear NKorea
Housing regs to add protections for gays
Gang crackdown, lurid mob trials transfix China
2nd trial begins in Seattle Jewish center shooting
Navy petty officer to face punishment in hazing
Pohang outgun Umm-Salal, Al Ittihad rout Nagoya
US House demands Vietnam free bloggers
Indonesia's Yudhoyono unveils rainbow cabinet
First Year Enrollment In Medical Schools Up By 2%
Feds Plan To Sharply Cut Pay, Perks For Bailout Firms
Nicole Kidman highlights violence against women
S.Korea fin minister sees property prices stabilising
No plan for foreign bank liquidity controls -S.Korea fin min
Bahamas declares mistrial in John Travolta extortion
| Entertainment
|
Michael Buble still tops on U.S. album chart
| Entertainment
|
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Former KISS drummer: men get breast cancer too
Former KISS drummer: men get breast cancer too
| Entertainment
|
Mockingbird actress Collin Wilcox Paxton dies
| Entertainment
|
"The Big Man" on life with and without Springsteen
Nicole Kidman highlights violence against women
Hulu trying out models to boost revenue: NBC
Disney project aims to play films on any device
List of new Indonesian Cabinet appointees
Hulu trying out models to boost revenue: NBC
| Entertainment
|
R. Kelly sets album date, claims R&B chart record
The Big Man on life with and without Springsteen
| Entertainment
|
R. Kelly sets album date, claims R&B chart record
| Entertainment
|
Indonesian president announces new Cabinet
Michael Buble still tops on U.S. album chart
Validity of DNA test argued in Lil Wayne gun case
Joshua Bell plays for Poland's Jewish Museum
Iran, Israel traded barbs at nuclear talks: delegate
Microsoft launches Windows 7
Security big worry as Afghans gear up for run-off
| International
|
Credit Suisse joins surge in bank profits
Two Koreas held secret talks for summit: report
| International
|
Newspaper, Internet titans duel at Web 2.0 Summit
Afghan MP sees role as king-maker in runoff
US-TECH Summary
Ethiopia appeals for food aid for 6.2 million
| International
|
U.S. sees Israel drill helping Europe missile shield
| International
|
Senior Iranian MP casts doubt on atom fuel deal
| International
|
Dalai Lama to visit disputed Indian state on November 8
| International
|
Smear trial tarnishes French political elite
| International
|
Karadzic boycott throws war trial start into doubt
| International
|
China authors says Google violated copyrights
| Technology
|
Nokia sues Apple for patent infringement
| Technology
|
Cheney: Stop the 'dithering' as troops face danger
One size fits all phone chargers on the way: ITU
| Technology
|
Australian PM sickened by hate mail sent to war widows
Court rejects Calif. plan to cut prison population
FCC staff recommends open Internet rule
| Technology
|
Family row stops NKorea succession talk: researcher
Microsoft befriends Twitter in Google search duel
French fund invests in YouTube rival Dailymotion
| Technology
|
Australia denies 'terrorists' on asylum boats
Navajos may try to buy popular Arizona ski resort
Japan urges US to respect 'democracy' over base
'Balloon boy' parents heard crying in 911 call
Thailand rejects US pressure over 'Merchant of Death'
Mass. man accused of plot to kill shoppers, troops
Malaysian couple arrested for beating maid
Remains found in Utah not poet Everett Ruess
3 Tijuana drug figures plead guilty in US
India's Congress party wins state polls
Insecurity, jobs drive Sri Lanka's boat people
FACTBOX-S.Korea's recent overseas energy investments
Taiwan jobless rate falls from record highs
Taiwan's AU Optronics returns to profit
Japan's trade surplus hits 18-month high
China's economy revs up with 8.9% growth
Toshiba launches portable fuel-cell for mobiles
India's Tata mulls checks on world's cheapest car
Kidman: Hollywood probably contributes to violence
Seoul shares end 1.4 pct lower on LG Elec, banks
Trade ministers to begin talks on Pacific deal
Myanmar allows first mobile phones in remote capital
Drag queen movie challenges Russian attitudes
McCartney to launch Europe tour in Hamburg
Once-tame Baghdad zoo now a roaring success
Kidman: Hollywood probably contributes to violence
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights