Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Broadway sings blues over synthesizer invasion
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Asia Pacific
World
Broadway sings blues over synthesizer invasion
AFP - Friday, July 30
Send
IM Story
Print
Broadway sings blues over synthesizer invasion
NEW YORK (AFP) - – While audiences at Broadway's "West Side Story" thrill to the on-stage drama, musicians in the orchestra pit are fighting a battle every bit as vicious as the Sharks-Jets rivalry.
This is gang warfare of a high-minded sort, pitting some of New York's best live musicians against a synthesizer they fear will usurp the job of playing Leonard Bernstein's pulsating score.
Sophisticated synthesizers and computer-manipulated recordings are increasingly taking over orchestras. Sounding almost like real players, while costing much less, they're especially popular with provincial or touring companies.
But until mid-July -- when "West Side Story's" producers announced that a synthesizer was replacing three live violinists and two cellists, or half the orchestra's string section -- staff violinist Paul Woodiel thought that at least the classics would be immune to the trend.
"It was the last straw for me," Woodiel told AFP.
"I was a student and a friend of Leonard Bernstein and it's almost certain he wouldn't have allowed this. This isn't dinner theater, it's not Las Vegas. It's Broadway and Leonard Bernstein was the greatest American musician."
Woodiel's own job was spared, but he caused a stir through the tight-knit Broadway world with a New York Times piece denouncing the "inert, artificial" synthesizer invasion.
The producers did not respond to AFP requests to be interviewed.
Synthesizers have in fact been around for decades, notably in pop music. What's changing is the ability of the machines to enter the far more sophisticated domain of classical orchestras.
"The computer gives you so much more power now. There's ridiculous stuff," says Mike Levine, editor of Electronic Music Magazine.
There are computer programs able to read and play back music scores -- a boon to composers who can now hear their work as they write -- and software allowing conductors to control the tempo of the machine, in the same way that they direct live players.
"It has gotten very, very good with something like drums and bass and strings," Levine said. "With piano they can model almost anything."
Levine said the growing use of synthesizers is positive for basement bands and other music industry start-ups, but a menace to jobs in large, labor-intensive ensembles like orchestras.
"It's all about money and the producers want to make as much money as possible," Levine said. "They always did."
Critics see synthesizers as little better than some barbarian force trampling the classical music landscape.
But one virtual music pioneer, Paul Henry Smith of the Fauxharmonic Orchestra, says the technology will only improve and in any case cannot be stopped.
Smith's system uses so-called digital sampling, feeding from a store of more than two million individual notes recorded in an almost endless variety of tones and styles. "It's kind of insane," he says.
"We don't quite know what's going to happen with this, but computer technology is just so malleable that the likelihood of it going away is probably nil."
Like many new technologies, virtual music poses growing ethical questions.
New York Post arts writer Barbara Hoffman says using a synthesizer in "West Side Story" amounts to cheating theatergoers.
"When you pay over 100 dollars a ticket you should hear real music the way Leonard Bernstein intended it," she said. "Something as sacred as that score, one of the most beautiful scores ever written -- it's blasphemous."
But it remains unclear whether audiences around the country realize what's going on, or necessarily care.
Sarah Franklin, a talented 24-year-old violinist, joined a five-month North America tour for a revival of the musical "Camelot" with an orchestra of just four people.
"There was me on the violin, one cello, one French horn and a conductor with a computer," she said. The computer, using a software called Notion, played the rest of the semi-virtual orchestra.
Frequently the program crashed, abruptly leaving the three live musicians to play by themselves. But despite the glitches, most audience members were none the wiser, Franklin said.
"When people saw us down in the pit afterwards, they'd say, 'It sounded like there were so many more of you!'"
The musicians would wriggle out of the embarrassing situation by pretending that the rest of their colleagues had quickly left the theater.
"We got fed up with explaining and we didn't want to ruin it for them. They didn't need to know," Franklin said.
True aficionados can immediately tell the difference between real and manufactured music.
Woodiel compares playing alongside a synthesizer to "making love with a corpse."
Even Smith readily concedes that today's virtual instruments cannot match live string players "by a long shot."
But advocates argue that axing salaried musicians in favor of a machine during today's economic uncertainty can extend the life of a flagging production, thereby saving many other jobs.
Smith, who studied with Bernstein and researched digital sound at Massachusetts Institute of Technology, says the most important benefits are subtle.
He sees virtual orchestra programs as a new instrument in their own right, as well as a tool for composers to "get their ideas into sound" and bring new material to human orchestras -- thereby creating work.
"It's not always a bad boy," Smith said. "It's a branching out and expanding of possibilities."
Peter Reit, who plays French horn in Broadway's "Phantom of the Opera" -- where two strings players have been replaced by a synthesizer -- has a more gloomy prognosis in what he calls the "corporate" music landscape.
"You get the feeling that if they had their way, ideally, they would have an entire virtual orchestra," he said.
"They would have all of us replaced with one electronic instrument, then feed that to the public and make more money."
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary Reuters - 2 hours 5 minutes ago
Obama seeks his "mojo" on daytime TV's "The View" Reuters - 2 hours 48 minutes ago
Gal pal of generous Viacom boss says she got nothing Reuters - 2 hours 52 minutes ago
French nuns in music deal get death threat-report Reuters - Friday, July 30
A Minute With: Director Phillip Noyce on "Salt" Reuters - Friday, July 30
News Search
Top Stories
At least 140 dead in DR Congo river disaster
Protestors denounce Arizona immigration law
Arabs agree to Israel-Palestinian talks
Shell defends deep-water oil production, as profits soar
Europe gets new boost as economic confidence surges
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Argentine students crack three-decade-old murder mystery
Earth's climate future may be etched in Greenland bedrock
100 days in, Gulf spill leaves ugly questions unanswered
Daniel Craig to star in Millennium Trilogy
New British lender Metro Bank opens first branch
More Most Viewed »
Parachuting donkey shocks Russian beachgoers
World's first full face transplant man appears on TV
Paris Hilton caught with cannabis in handbag
Argentine students crack three-decade-old murder mystery
Quark by quark, atom smasher closing in on 'God particle'
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo!
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
World Cup 2010
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Friday, 30 July 2010 16 dead, 14 wounded in Baghdad attacks
French minister denies wrongdoing in police L'Oreal grilling
Karzai urges action against militants in Pakistan
YouTube ups video limit to 15 minutes
Spanish bullfighting sector vows to fight Catalan ban
Arabs agree to Israel-Palestinian talks
US-TECH Summary
Shell defends deep-water oil production, as profits soar
2nd US Navy sailor's body recovered in Afghanistan
Russia clamps down on Internet, Google frowns
Europe gets new boost as economic confidence surges
Gunmen and bombs kill at least 12 in Iraq
|
French mother confesses to eight infant murders
Motorola 2nd-qtr results beat Street, shares rise
South Americans try to end Venezuela-Colombia rift
|
Russia 'foils hijacking of plane from Caucasus'
WikiLeaks threatens US security agencies drive
US wants increased police access to email: report
Syria and Saudi say will work to stabilize Lebanon
|
'Welfare robots' to ease burden in greying Japan
Warm words, trade challenges ahead as UK woos India
|
Russian court bans YouTube over extremist videos
U.S. and major powers urged to join cluster munitions pact
|
Online betting firm bwin announces merger with Partygaming
Al Qaeda vows more attacks on Yemen government: tape
|
China jails three Uighur webmasters: report
Motorola 2nd-qtr results beat Street, shares rise
US to press China, UAE, others on Iran sanctions
Floods kill 29 in China's northeast
U.S. wildlife officials trap suspected killer grizzly
Weakened Arizona immigrant rules still draw protests
Monsoon hampers Pakistan black box search
Second U.S. sailor's remains found in Afghanistan
Australia's Corby appeals for clemency from Indonesia
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Japan supertanker probe reveals smashed hull
Obama seeks his "mojo" on daytime TV's "The View"
Shanghai constant source of new mysteries for writer
Gal pal of generous Viacom boss says she got nothing
Four held over China pipeline blast, toll hits 13
Russia clamps down on Internet, Google frowns
|
Sony leads Japan electronics makers back to black
London gears up for two-wheeled revolution
Thailand to end emergency rule in six provinces: PM
U.S. sues Oracle, alleges software contract fraud
|
French nuns in music deal get death threat-report
Fewer Spaniards say they are Catholic: study
Kites fill skies over Gaza as children reach for record
A Minute With: Director Phillip Noyce on "Salt"
Broadway sings blues over synthesizer invasion
Devil may wear Prada, but Virgin Mary dons Louis Vuitton
China's sovereign fund posts 11.7 percent return in 2009
China allows release of critical IMF report
Taiwan Semiconductor reports record net profit
Taiwan's HTC posts 50.5 percent rise in Q2 profit
Softbank net profit dented by tax demand
Nintendo suffers first quarter loss on yen strength
Bangladesh raises garment workers' pay 80 percent
Obama seeks his mojo on daytime TV's The View
|
Why Mel Gibson's lawyers haven't dropped him
|
Gal pal of generous Viacom boss says she got nothing
|
A Minute With: Director Phillip Noyce on Salt
|
French nuns in music deal get death threat-report
|
Russian president's top rights advisor quits
Lebanon hosts rare Arab leader summit
Mexican army kills kingpin in drug war coup
|
Most Pakistanis see US as an enemy: poll
WikiLeaks may have blood on its hands, U.S. says
|
Leaked Afghan war files a 'dangerous' risk: Gates
IMF backs more stimulus to help slow US recovery
3 US troops die in deadliest month of Afghan war
Google says China search block may be tech glitch
Body of 2nd Navy sailor recovered in Afghanistan
Neighbors fail to end Venezuela-Colombia rift
|
US growth expected to slow amid looming stagnation
Arabs agree to Israel-Palestinian talks
US accuses Oracle of software contract fraud
US Fed official warns of 'Japanese-style' stagnation
At least 140 dead in DR Congo river disaster
TeleNav shares sink on revenue worries on Sprint deal
North Korean diplomats seize books on Kim in Myanmar
|
Microsoft talks up tablets, shows off new phones
Hearts and mind hard to reach in Afghan valley
|
Analysts' View: Google says search service blocked in China
Cuban hunger striker Farinas leaves hospital
|
US flank exposed on cyber war front: Hayden
Marbury stays with Chinese basketball team
Bomb explodes in Bangkok, seriously wounding man
|
McAfee profit tops Wall Street target
Pacquiao sister 'wanted' for illegal gambling racket:
Tablet computers 'job one urgency' at Microsoft: Ballmer
Bolivian priest who blessed Morales found with cocaine
|
One hurt in Bangkok grenade blast: police
Microsoft shows off new Windows smartphones
Taiwan faces complex language legacy
Motorola rings up sharply higher net profit
Four killed in U.S. Air Force plane crash in Alaska
Bomb explodes in Bangkok, seriously wounding man
WikiLeaks may have blood on its hands, U.S. says
N.Korea holds more talks with US military
Less oil on surface means less work for fishermen
House rejects bill to aid sick 9/11 responders
Google says China services back up
Ousted USDA employee Sherrod plans to sue blogger
Bangladesh garment workers reject new wage rates
Ariz. files appeal as sheriff launches new sweep
UK author vows to fight Singapore contempt charge
Mark Wahlberg: God most important part of my life
Marc Cohn's new album sets chart record for singer
"Inception" set to fend off three box office rookies
Growing smartphone battle seen hitting vendors' profits
|
Ellen DeGeneres quits "American Idol" as judge
Google says China search block may be tech glitch
|
"Friends" star Matt LeBlanc happy to send himself up
Microsoft talks up tablets, shows off new phones
|
Eminem leads singles chart for second week
TeleNav shares sink on revenue worries on Sprint deal
|
Seoul shares slip weighed by Samsung Elec, banks
McAfee profit tops Wall Street target
|
Samsung Electronics books record Q2 profit on chips boom
US lawmakers urge probe of China Ansteel's deal
S.Korea spotted bying dlrs to check won -dealers
S.Korea to raise domestic electricity, gas fees
Taiwan says to issue rules on private placements
'Nightmare' start for iPhone 4's latest launch
PAKISTAN
Japan's unemployment rises, output falls
S.Korea industrial output grows for 12th straight month
Ellen DeGeneres quits American Idol as judge
|
Disney sells Miramax for over $660 million to Filmyard
|
Inception set to fend off three box office rookies
|
Mark Wahlberg: God most important part of my life
|
Eminem leads singles chart for second week
|
Friends star Matt LeBlanc happy to send himself up
|
Marc Cohn's new album sets chart record for singer
|
Iran ready for immediate nuclear fuel talks
Death toll in Russian forest fires reaches 25
Italy speaker refuses to resign, deepens crisis
|
Forest fires kill 29 in Russia heatwave
Bitter smartphone war seen pinching vendor margins
Syrian and Saudi leaders tackle tension in Lebanon
|
Syrian, Saudi leaders in Lebanon to defuse tension
BA losses hit £122m on strike action, ash cloud
Afghan police fire shots to quell protest after accident
|
UN rights body tells Israel to end Gaza blockade
Calcium supplements linked to heart attacks: study
Berlusconi in crisis after revolt by key ally
Samsung Elec to introduce Android-based tablet in Q3
Mexican army kills kingpin in drug war coup
|
Syrian and Saudi leaders to tackle tension in Lebanon
French police detain Bettencourt finance advisor
Gaza rocket ends quiet year for Ashkelon
French mum 'relieved' after admitting killing babies
WikiLeaks may have blood on its hands, U.S. says
|
Bombs 'kill three foreign troops' in Afghanistan
U.N. rights body tells Israel to end Gaza blockade
|
Gaza rocket hits southern Israel: army
Samsung Elec to introduce Android-based tablet in Q3
China says it opposes EU sanctions against Iran
Wildfires sweeping Russia kill at least 25
|
Exiled Yemen opposition leader killed on return
|
Police open fire at Kashmir protesters, two killed
|
France's Sarkozy cracks down on crime and immigrants
|
China races to recover chemical barrels from river
Mexico kills drug kingpin in raid
S.Lanka, India slam 'unsporting' pitch after draw
Dead whale found pinned to Alaska cruise ship
China naval drill in South China Sea: state media
Wildfire explodes in rural LA County hills
China to crack down on pro-Cantonese protesters
Disney to sell Miramax Films for $660m
Former Australian PM Rudd hospitalised
Economic growth likely slowed in second quarter
'Nightmare' start for iPhone 4's latest launch
London launches cycle hire scheme
Bitter smartphone war seen pinching vendor margins
|
Facebook may postpone IPO to 2012: report
|
Google says China search block may be tech glitch
|
Samsung Elec to introduce Android-based tablet in Q3
|
Honda books record $3.15bn quarterly net profit
Microsoft talks up tablets, shows off new phones
|
TeleNav shares sink on revenue worries on Sprint deal
|
Japanese financial groups post strong Q1 results
Russia clamps down on Internet, Google frowns
|
Japan airline ANA's quarterly loss narrows to $60m
U.S. sues Oracle, alleges software contract fraud
|
Bangladesh garment workers riot over wage row
Amazon offers $139 wireless Kindle for mass appeal
|
McAfee profit tops Wall Street target
|
Hugh Hefner: Rebel with a cause
|
Ellen exit heralds major American Idol makeover
|
Disney to sell Miramax for over $660 million
|
Inception set to fend off three box office rookies
|
Mark Wahlberg: God most important part of my life
|
Obama seeks his mojo on daytime TV's The View
|
Eminem leads singles chart for second week
|
Friends star Matt LeBlanc happy to send himself up
|
Marc Cohn's new album sets chart record for singer
|
Gal pal of generous Viacom boss says she got nothing
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights