Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Bluefin tuna showdown pits economy vs. ecology
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Top Stories
Most Popular
Photos
Full Coverage
Sitemap
Bluefin tuna showdown pits economy vs. ecology
AFP - 1 hour 29 minutes ago
Send
IM Story
Print
PARIS (AFP) - – Dozens of nations gathered in Paris to decide catch quotas for Atlantic bluefin tuna, a highly-prized luxury food consumed raw in Japan as sashimi or sushi.
The 10-day meeting of the International Commission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas (ICCAT), starting Wednesday, will seek an elusive compromise between boosting stocks of the dwindling species and salvaging a multi-billion dollar industry spread around the Mediterranean rim.
Conservationists argue that no real compromise is possible.
"Bluefin tuna fishing does not have a future unless ICCAT shuts down purse-seine fishing and farming," said Maria-Jose Cornax, an expert with advocacy group Oceana.
Purse-seine fishing in the Mediterranean, is when bluefin are trapped during spawning season in floating drawstring nets that can capture thousands of fish at once, and then hauled to coastal "farms" where they are fattened for market.
Oceana, along with NGOs Greenpeace, WWF and Pew Environment Group, called on Tuesday for a ban on this kind of fishing.
They also want a reduction in 2011 of the allowable annual catch from 13,500 tonnes -- the 2010 limit -- to a maximum of 6,000 tonnes.
"That is a realistic scenario," ICCAT Chairman Fabio Hazin of Brazil said when asked to comment.
"One of the things that is being discussed [within ICCAT] is the possible suspension of purse-seine fishing and the caging activities," he said at a roundtable discussion.
Driven by wholesale prices in Japan that can top 100,000 dollars per specimen, industrial-scale fishing in the Mediterranean and eastern Atlantic has depleted stocks by 85 percent in recent decades, scientists say.
The Japanese consume 80 percent of the Atlantic bluefin catch, with Americans appetites accounting for nine percent.
ICCAT member states have disagreed sharply going into the meeting whether next year's quotas should remain at 13,500, as in 2010, or be cut in half or even suspended.
France's fisheries minister, Bruno Le Maire, said his country favoured maintaining the 13,500 level, a position backed by Spain and Italy.
Britain and Germany, along with EU Fisheries Commissioner Maria Damanaki, have come out in favour of a sharp reduction.
The European Union was supposed to forge a common position going into the meeting, but has so far failed to do so.
Some conservation groups argue that only a complete suspension will allow the species to recover.
ICCAT's scientific committee said last month that extending the 2010 catch limit for each of the next three years would give bluefin in the eastern Atlantic and Mediterranean a 63-percent chance of attaining so-called "maximum sustainable yield" by 2022.
"The commissioners should be precautionary and not go for the higher range of possibility," Hazin said, adding this was "only my personal view."
Before the introduction of purse-seine fishing and tuna ranching in the 1990s, bluefin were caught using more traditional methods.
Critics also say ICCAT is riddled with fraud, a claim bolstered by recent investigative reports and France's admission in 2007 that its catch for that year was more than double the authorized limit.
"There is so much illegal fishing going on that the only responsible thing to do is to suspend the fishery, get it sorted out, and then open it slowly so the species can recover," said Sue Lieberman, policy director for the US-based Pew Environment Group.
Industry representatives, backed by their governments, say the organisation has cracked down on renegade fishing in the last three years by adding independent on-board inspectors and an improved ship-to-market tracking system.
"I hope, I believe, that the dark ages of ICCAT are in the past. The time of not respecting science in ICCAT is over," Hazin said.
At the same time, the chairman acknowledged that the system was still far from perfect.
The so-called Bluefin tuna Catch Document Scheme "is not working the way it should," he said.
Half of the entries in the database were missing crucial data such as vessel or species names and tonnage, according to an recent investigative report.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
News Search
Top Stories
Swiss pharmaceutical giant Roche to shed 4,800 jobs
Bluefin tuna showdown pits economy vs. ecology
High-caffeine energy drinks linked to alcohol abuse
FDA panel recommends first lupus drug in 50 years
EU in talks with IMF as Irish bailout looms
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Prince William to marry Kate Middleton next year
Pilgrims stone 'devil' as Muslims celebrate Eid
US truck dealer triggers buying spree with free AK-47s
Oil will run out 100 years before new fuels developed: study
'Baby black hole' offers insight into cosmic enigma
More Most Viewed »
Alcohol more harmful than heroin, crack cocaine: study
Toddler survives seven-floor fall in France
EU fines 11 airlines 800 million euros for air cargo cartel
'Naked' airport scanners may be 'dangerous'
Be fit, have fewer colds: study
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo!
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Entertainment
Photos
Yahoo! News Network
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Wednesday, 17 November 2010 Iran security agents strike French diplomats: ministry
Prince William seals engagement with Diana's ring
Vatican to broadcast pope images in HD
Iran starts biggest air defense war games
|
U.S. sees Iran rift, says strike would unite country
France warns of deadly diabetes drug
EasyJet profits surge 70%, plans first dividend
Cuban dissident blogger gets Danish think-tank freedom award
US-TECH Summary
Disneys A Christmas Carol Hits DVD And Blu-Ray In 3D
GM hikes the price of landmark stock offering
Afghan president marks holiday with plea for peace
Beatles For Sale: The Beatles Music Finally Available On iTunes
Steve Forbes gives up CEO reins at Forbes Media
Boeing keeps 787s grounded as fire probe continues
Mayim Bialik Blossoms From Guest Star To Regular On "The Big Bang Theory"
Best U.S. option in Yemen? Help it fight al Qaeda: Gates
|
China video-sharing site Youku files for IPO in US
Former Alabama Trooper Pleads Guilty To 1965 Civil Rights Era Shooting
Pilgrims stone 'devil' as Muslims celebrate Eid
Afghan Hero Dog Euthanized By Accident
'Baby black hole' offers insight into cosmic enigma
Beatles, iTunes come together
Murkowski Leads Alaska Senate Count; Miller Pins Hopes On Overseas Ballots
Wal-Mart quarterly profit soars, beats expectations
Consumer Reports Poll Uncovers How Americans Spend Holiday Season
Colombia to extradite accused Venezuelan drug lord
|
Barnes & Noble says shipments of NookColor start
Lindsay Lohan's Brother To Star As Heroin User In New Film
Poll result triggers violence in Guinea
|
Emphatic Park wins Olympic re-match but China rule
Thailand extradites alleged arms dealer Bout to US
Official: Alleged arms dealer Bout en route to US
India government mired in giant graft scandal
China boosts ties with Chile amid push into Latin America
Eight held over Shanghai blaze that left 53 dead
Reuters journalist may have been killed by Thai troops
Gayle hits 333 as Windies dominate Sri Lanka
China jails coal mine chiefs over deadly gas blast
Beatles' hits come to Apple's iTunes store
|
U.S. sees huge cyber threat in the future
|
French cuisine named 'intangible' world heritage
Beatles, iTunes come together
Paris Louvre asks public for help to buy painting
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Microsoft's Gates, Ballmer defend stock sales
|
China's Xi arrives in S.Africa to seek more trade
Beatles' hits come to Apple's iTunes store
Steve Forbes gives up CEO reins at Forbes Media
|
Top Indian microfinancier condemns 'rogues' in industry
French wine reaps 304,375 dollar auction record
Scandal-hit Indian outsourcer sees stocks plunge on earnings
Apple says Beatles songs now on iTunes
S.Korea says politics driving US objections to trade pact
Final Harry Potter movie will be "like a war film"
Microsoft says sells 1 million Kinect devices
|
China central bank chief warns on fund flows, inflation
Chinese plane maker boasts 100 orders at air show
Beatles' hits come to Apple's iTunes store
|
Dolly Parton theme park wins top industry award
|
NATO hails Kandahar progress but attacks continue
Prince William seals engagement with Diana's ring
Thailand extradites Russian arms suspect to U.S.
|
Iran starts "biggest" air defence war games
China telecom briefly hijacked U.S. Web traffic: panel
Sarkozy goes prime time to sell agenda to French
Bluefin tuna showdown pits economy vs. ecology
Video game industry sales fall 4 percent in October: NPD
Landmine kills 14 in Cambodia
|
High-caffeine energy drinks linked to alcohol abuse
Britain compensates former Guantanamo detainees
Online holiday sales growth seen doubling
FDA panel recommends first lupus drug in 50 years
Iran starts biggest air defense war games
|
EU in talks with IMF as Irish bailout looms
Colombia to extradite accused Venezuelan drug lord
|
Intel Capital unveils $77 million in start-up stakes
US faces 'huge' cyber threat in the future: Gates
U.N. panel cuts gay reference from violence measure
|
After tussle, Google Voice application comes to iPhone
Telco payment venture targets Visa and MasterCard
Spoilers trying to sabotage Haiti elections: U.N.
|
Karzai remains US partner: Gates
Rights prize a reward for years of suffering: Cuba blogger
France's Sarkozy very worried about Mali hostages
|
Asiad bikini girls distract volleyball players
S.Korea snubs North on cross-border tour talks
Suspected Russian arms trafficker arrives in US
Old anti-tank mine kills 14 in Cambodia: police
Philippines ditches much-maligned tourism campaign
Top Taiwan prosecutor targeted by Chinese hackers
Sniffer dog attacks Philippine shopper
TV producer wanted for Mexico death held in LA
Paul McCartney to play Apollo Theater for Sirius XM
Shanghai blaze prompts China fire-safety push
HP hopes to reassure Street, Dell's margins key
|
Amazon.com launches movie studio
India, RIM move closer to deal on corporate email: report
|
Landmine kills 14 in Cambodia
Adam Lambert to release acoustic EP in December
Oracle should get $40.6 million at most, says SAP expert
|
Russian arms suspect arrives in NY from Thailand
Beatles climb iTunes charts after catalog debuts
China telecom briefly hijacked U.S. Web traffic: panel
|
"Glee" contest gets own reality TV show
China premier announces inflation clamp-down
Rare pink diamond sells for world record 46 million dollars
Prince Charles calls for action in TV environment film
Online holiday sales growth seen doubling
|
High-caffeine energy drinks linked to alcohol abuse: study
Video game industry sales fall 4 percent in October: NPD
|
Seoul shares end flat amid caution; LG Elec gains
Intel Capital unveils $77 million in start-up stakes
|
CPC Corp reports small fire at Taiwan distillery
South Korea bids for Lithuania nuclear project
New Zealand economy stalls in Q3
Korea Hot Stocks-LG Elec gains, Hyundai E&C, Merchant tumble
S.Korea bonds rangebound after rally on rate hike
S.Korea spotted buying dlrs to keep won weak-dealers
Seoul shares open down on Europe, China worry
Report: Ford to reduce Mazda stake to 3 percent
TV producer wanted for Mexico death held in LA
|
Beatles climb iTunes charts after catalog debuts
|
App-centric iPhone model is overrated: RIM CEO
Paul McCartney to play Apollo Theater for Sirius XM
|
Amazon.com launches movie studio
|
India, RIM move closer to deal on corporate email: report
Glee contest gets own reality TV show
|
Adam Lambert to release acoustic EP in December
|
HP hopes to reassure Street, Dell's margins key
Prince Charles calls for action in TV environment film
|
After tussle, Google Voice application comes to iPhone
Oracle should get $40.6 million at most, says SAP expert
Terror attack 'planned this month in Germany'
NATO to endorse Afghan strategy despite Karzai row
|
Israel approves Lebanon border village pullout
China Telecom denies hijacking U.S. Web traffic
Germany raises security alert after attack warnings
|
Iraq president refuses to sign Aziz death order
GM stock offering to be largest in US history
Taiwan taekwondo fighter disqualified over 'sensor' socks
EU/IMF mission to Ireland to begin Thursday: minister
Israel pullback alarms Lebanon border town
|
Iraq's Talabani says will not sign Aziz death order
Swiss pharmaceutical giant Roche to shed 4,800 jobs
"Don't hold your breath" for Facebook IPO: Zuckerberg
U.S. Reluctant For Another War, Offers Training, War Equipment To Yemen
Morocco to investigate W.Sahara raid if Spain requests
Israel to quit half of Lebanon border town
EU to focus more on east neighbors in 2011: Poland
|
Found Guilty Of Ethics Lapses, Rangel To Receive Sanction Wednesday
Madagascar top military vows to crush any coup attempt
|
Facebook swats bug that disabled accounts
Sarkozy goes prime time to sell agenda to French
U.S. Welcomes Argentina Moves To Settle Paris Club Debt
Afghan transition may go beyond 2014: NATO
Statins May Be Over-Prescribed
Iran military stages mock warplane interception
|
NATO: Combat role in Afghanistan could pass 2014
UNESCO Adds 3 Indian Performing Art Forms To Heritage List
Afghan handover could run past 2015 in areas: NATO
|
Senator Doesnt See START Treaty Approval This Year
Report: Premature Birth Rates Falling, But Still Too High
Greeks march to mark student revolt anniversary
|
Honored US soldier fought in deadly Afghan valley
Bristol Palin Stars In New Abstinence PSA With The Situation
Four Loco Makers Removing Caffeine From Products
Russia to urge Iran to discuss nuclear programme
|
Gates Sees Rift Between Ayatollah, Ahmadinejad After U.N. Sanctions
Egypt blogger released after 4 years in jail
|
Justice eludes Cambodian acid attack victims
Evacuations after Delhi building collapse
US to focus on 2014 Afghan withdrawal at NATO meet
China vows to tame inflation, price controls in reserve
Tremlett takes four as England dominate Australia A
Its gelivable! The whole world's speaking Chinese
Bonham Carter to get lifetime prize at indie awards
Windies in control of rain-hit Sri Lanka Test
Ukraine police learn English for Euro 2012
South Korean military boat sinks, 3 dead
Japan to send envoy to Nobel peace award ceremony
Amazon.com launches movie studio
|
Inflation hits China's 2010 character poll voting
Innovations move amusement parks into digital age
|
Lesbian family film Kids elbows into Oscar race
|
Angelina Jolie cuts Bosnia filming on permit woes
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights