Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Broadband link to U.S. jobs exaggerated: experts
| Technology
|
My Profile
Top News
Reuters top ten news stories delivered to your inbox each day.
Subscribe
You are here:
Home
>
News
>
Technology
>
Article
Home
Business & Finance
News
U.S.
Politics
International
Technology
Internet
Entertainment
Sports
Lifestyle
Oddly Enough
Environment
Health
Science
Special Coverage
Video
Pictures
Your View
The Great Debate
Blogs
Weather
Reader Feedback
Do More With Reuters
RSS
Widgets
Mobile
Podcasts
Newsletters
Your View
Make Reuters My Homepage
Partner Services
CareerBuilder
Affiliate Network
Professional Products
Support (Customer Zone)
Reuters Media
Financial Products
About Thomson Reuters
Broadband link to U.S. jobs exaggerated: experts
Fri Jan 30, 2009 4:21pm EST
Email | Print |
Share
| Reprints | Single Page
[-]
Text
[+]
By Kim Dixon
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - A co-author of a widely cited forecast that nearly 300,000 U.S. jobs would be created for every percentage point rise in high-speed Internet use said on Friday these and similar estimates are "a gross overestimate."
"There is a great deal of overstatement in most of these studies," said Robert Crandall, a Brookings Institution economist and co-author of the frequently-cited paper with that estimate.
U.S. lawmakers are proposing grants between $6 billion to $9 billion and tax credits to encourage investment in high- speed Internet, as part of an economic stimulus plan winding its way through Congress costing up to $900 billion.
The 300,000 jobs estimate has been used in newspapers and cited by other publications advocating investment in high-speed Internet, or broadband.
The Brookings Institution study, published in July 2007, is not particularly relevant now because of differing employment and related migration trends at the time of the study, Crandall said.
Attempting to extrapolate it nationwide at this time is a "gross overstatement," he said.
Most the data on jobs and broadband is not relevant because it doesn't apply to underserved, mostly rural and high cost areas targeted in the stimulus package, said Shane Greenstein, a professor at Northwestern University's Kellogg School of Management.
"The experience of Manhattan in 2005 has no relationship to the experience in West Texas," Greenstein said.
Chris King, an investment analyst at Stifel Nicolaus said the proposals targeting unserved rural areas are not enough to propel rural providers to invest in any event, largely because they do not address ongoing operating costs.
"We believe the current plans are unlikely to stimulate private sector investment in unserved areas," King said.
King, concurring with several Wall Street analysts, said tax credits for ultra-fast Internet speeds for underserved areas would likely only benefit Verizon Communications Inc and perhaps some cable companies.
To see the Brookings study, go to: www3.brookings.edu/~/media/Files/rc/papers/2007/06labor_crandall/06labor_crandall.pdf
(Editing by Andre Grenon)
© Thomson Reuters 2009 All rights reserved
Share:
Del.icio.us
Digg
Mixx
My Web
Facebook
LinkedIn
Next Article:
Hitachi warns of $7.8 billion loss, to restructure
Also on Reuters
Slideshow
Slideshow: Flying through life -- from birth into adulthood
Full Coverage: The Year in Review 2008
Blog: So many ways to say goodbye...to your job
More Technology News
Ex-Fannie Mae programmer says not guilty of virus
Hitachi warns of $7.8 billion loss, to restructure
Dell plots smartphone foray, eyes Apple: report
Businesses risk $1 trillion losses from data theft: study
RIM's Storm costlier to make than iPhone: report
More Technology News...
Editor's Choice
Slideshow
A selection of our best photos from the past 24 hours. Slideshow
Most Popular on Reuters
Articles
Video
Republicans in high-stakes challenge to Obama | Video
Recession rocks Hollywood's showbiz papers
Naked couple surprises diners in stroll
North Korea, trying to jolt Obama, warns South | Video
Cost of shoring up U.S. banks may be in trillions
Cuomo eyes return of $4 billion in early Merrill bonuses: report
Snow study shows California faces historic drought
Fidel Castro demands Obama return Guantanamo base
GDP sees biggest drop in 27 years | Video
Turkish PM returns to hero's welcome after Gaza row | Video
Most Popular Articles RSS Feed
Video
Hero's welcome for Erdogan
Peres, Erdogan clash
Blagojevich removed from office
Monkey with a mission
Stimulus bill revives "Buy American"
Potty-trained parrot
Is Rush running the GOP?
Obama seeks deal with Republicans
Dog cloning cheaper but still bites
North Korea cuts ties with South
Most Popular Videos RSS Feed
pictures
Slideshow
Tech watch
A recent sampling of our best pictures from the world of science and technology. Slideshow
Reuters Deals
The global destination for corporate leaders, deal-makers and innovators
Knowledge to Act
Reuters.com:
Help and Contact Us |
Advertise With Us |
Mobile |
Newsletters |
RSS |
Interactive TV |
Labs |
Reuters in Second Life |
Archive |
Site Index |
Video Index
Thomson Reuters Corporate:
Copyright |
Disclaimer |
Privacy |
Professional Products |
Professional Products Support |
About Thomson Reuters |
Careers
International Editions:
Africa |
Arabic |
Argentina |
Brazil |
Canada |
China |
France |
Germany |
India |
Italy |
Japan |
Latin America |
Mexico |
Russia |
Spain |
United Kingdom |
United States
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
Other News on Saturday, 31 January 2009 Iraq encouraged by US reassurances, minister says
Iraq in lockdown on eve of provincial vote
U.S. envoy warns of setbacks ahead in Mideast talks
| International
|
Obama retools campaign machine
Iraq on high alert after election candidates shot dead
Amanda Bynes Sued Over Multi-Car Pile Up Accident
Spotlight on vote-buying on eve of Iraqi ballot
| International
|
Apple gadget ecosystem plants new roots
Merkel and Brown call for global economy rules
Facts about Saturday's Iraqi election
Exxon notches 45.22 billion dlrs record profit
Turkish PM defends Gaza outburst
Zimbabwe opposition will join government
Hamas wants new leadership for Palestinians
Congo children branded as witches, abducted: U.N.
| International
|
Georgia's Saakashvili names fifth PM in five years
| International
|
Priests' comments on Jews, Muslims embarrass Pope
| International
|
North Korea warns South on rising tensions
UN special envoy Ibrahim Gambari to visit Myanmar
Sri Lanka rejects ceasefire with Tamil rebels
Two auto workers die in clash with Venezuela police
Indonesia to repatriate Myanmar 'economic migrants'
Oil wavers on economic data from Commerce
Thousands Still Without Power In Parts Of Kentucky
Broke Pennsylvania Town Asks Police, Employees To Continue Working
PA State Survey Finds 1 Million People Without Health Insurance, Many Of Them Employed
Update: White House Launches Task Force Headed By Biden To Strengthen Middle Class
Economy Shrinks The Most In 3 Decades; White House Calls For 'Aggressive' Stimulus
Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin To Dine With President Obama During Annual Banquet
Report: Republican Senator Being Considered By Obama As Commerce Secretary
India's Tata Motors losses $54 million in quarter
India's Tata Motors reports Q3 net loss of 53 mln dlrs
Rapper DMX sentenced to 90 days in jail
| Entertainment
|
Taylor Swift launches first headline tour
| Entertainment
|
Miss America hopes to see Super Bowl champ crowned
Bacon exhibition to open at Madrid's Prado
Franco-Mexican mini matador aims high
Rome University offers master's in teaching the Holocaust
Golden age of archaeology in China
Yes we can: Schools, streets renamed for Barack Obama
Thought things were bad? US survivalists await worse
New photo exhibit pictures black America in racially riven US
ABC's 'General Hospital' getting a makeover
Bollywood's 'Victory' in Colombo
Broke Pennsylvania Town Asks Police, Employees To Continue Despite Lack Of Paychecks
Smokers In California City Face $100 Fine For Smoking In Apartment, Condo
Monster.com Hacked For Third Time
President Obama, Formal Rival Gov. Palin To Dine Together At Annual Banquet
Iraqis vote as violence begins to fade
| International
|
Islamist looks set to be new Somali president
| International
|
Hamas needs to be part of peace process: Blair
| International
|
Security Council reform talks to start in February
| International
|
Ex-Fannie Mae programmer says not guilty of virus
| Technology
|
Broadband link to U.S. jobs exaggerated: experts
| Technology
|
Paul McCartney to headline Calif.'s Coachella
| Entertainment
|
Rapper DMX sentenced to 90 days in jail
| Entertainment
|
Italian writer raises case against Button
| Entertainment
|
Broadway bids to woo audiences amid recession
| Entertainment
|
De Niro's restaurants to pay $2.5 million in tip case
| Entertainment
|
Killing of Iraqi candidates highlights dangers
British protests against foreign energy workers spread
Iraq on high alert for election day violence
Brazil will not bow to Italy to extradite Battisti: Lula
U.S. envoy warns of setbacks ahead in Mideast talks
Major political forces in Iraqi elections
Cyprus searches suspected Hamas-arms ship
Obama addresses global trade imbalances with Hu
Obama places call to China's president
US-TECH Summary
Ex-Fannie Mae programmer says not guilty of virus
Data theft from firms topped a trillion dollars in 2008: study
US economy down 3.8 pct, not as bad as feared
Broadband link to U.S. jobs exaggerated: experts
NYC Mayor Bloomberg Announces Major Budget Cuts
Michael Steele Becomes First African-American Republican Chairman
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Italian writer raises case against "Button"
Q&A: `Virtuosos' talk about film awards season
De Niro's restaurants to pay $2.5 million in tip case
Paul McCartney to headline Calif.'s Coachella
Tempers flare in New York horse war
UN confirms special envoy's visit to Myanmar
Bollywood promoter sentenced in bank fraud scam
Strick named director of Nasher Sculpture Center
Liberal Groups Take To Airwaves To Strike Back At Rush Limbaugh
Wall Street Dips On Concerns Of 'Bad Bank' Delay
Yushchenko warns against 'social catastrophe'
S.Korea downplays N.Korea's vow to drop peace pact
Iraqis vote behind barbed wire, testing security
| International
|
Iraqis vote behind barbed wire as violence fades
Islamist leader wins Somali presidency
| International
|
U.N. envoy arrives in Myanmar, reform hopes slim
| International
|
Sputtering Wall Street awaits Obama stimulus
U.S. senator says missile shield could boost U.S.-Russia ties
Obama urged not to backburner climate change
US military deaths in Iraq war at 4,236
US military deaths in Afghanistan region at 573
U.S. judge says will likely rule for Micron
| Technology
|
Oxfam says new U.S. strategy needed in Afghanistan
Blackwater's Iraq deal not to be renewed
U.S. eyeing plan for fifth brigade in Afghanistan
Tour Bus Accident Near Hoover Dam Kills 7 Chinese
U.S. State Department Not Renewing Blackwater Contract For Iraq
FDA To Ban Painkiller Linked To Suicides
Florida House Speaker Temporarily Quits Amid Illegal Dealings Probe
Jan 30 Highlights Of Low Points In U.S. Economy
Free online game lets players be Hudson River hero pilots
After Idol, Doolittle Coming Back to spotlight
| Entertainment
|
Classical fans build vacations around music
| Entertainment
|
Classical fans build vacations around music
Japan PM set to announce huge aid package: reports
Prosecutor: Polanski defense motion is 'frivolous'
US economy slumps as world crisis tightens grip
SMU's museum opens exhibit of Etruscan artifacts
New Airbus joint-venture with China announced
Spears gets restraining order on Lutfi, Ghalib
After "Idol", Doolittle "Coming Back" to spotlight
India: 5 newborns killed in hospital fire
China's Hu urges Obama to resist protectionism
Endangered Sumatran tigers kill Indonesian farmers
UN urges safety of civilians as Sri Lanka presses for victory
Six dead after tour bus crashes in Arizona: police
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights