Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Old style ballot box facing electronic poll threat
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Australia
China
India
Indonesia
Japan
Malaysia
Philippines
Thailand
Vietnam
Old style ballot box facing electronic poll threat
AFP - 2 hours 41 minutes ago
Send
IM Story
Print
Old style ballot box facing electronic poll threat
HONG KONG (AFP) - – They held elections within days of each other: The Philippines, a lively democracy where politicians get shot dead in the street and Britain, the rock solid 'mother of all parliaments'.
But the Asian state's quick-fire digital vote made the European nation look more like a grandmother as its citizens stuck to the old style of dropping bits of paper in battered old boxes.
It was hoped electoral automation in the Philippines would cut rampant cheating, where ballot boxes went missing or were stuffed with fake votes and local officials sometimes simply fiddled the results themselves.
There was also the logistical nightmare of collecting votes from a country made up of over 7,000 islands, some of them tiny.
The May 10 poll, which was overseen by the government authority Comelec, had some minor glitches but Comelec commissioner Gregorio Larrazabal said: "Definitely it was a success.
"Everybody knows that it worked. There were some kinks that need to be ironed out but it was generally successful," he told AFP.
"Ask the people on the streets, ask the citizens' organisations who monitored the elections, the teachers who conducted the elections, they say the same thing."
In Britain, there were angry scenes outside a handful of polling stations which had closed before thousands of people had voted on May 6, leading some commentators to describe it as a "third world" ballot.
"Its largely a legacy of the Victorian era," said Jenny Watson, the chairman of the Electoral Commission which sets the standards for running elections for Britain's 45-million voters.
"Its not sensible to have a system that was designed when five million people were eligible to vote," she told the BBC.
In the Philippines, Venezuelan company Smartmatic won the contract to run the electronic election. Voters still had to go to a booth and mark a piece of paper, but it was fed into a machine for counting, not a ballot box.
The results were then sent electronically to election headquarters in Manila, with 30 copies printed out and sent to stakeholders as a back up.
"Electronic voting can bring credibility to a country with a bad history of fraud, and whose officials are not considered legitimate," Cesar Flores, the company's president for Asia-Pacific, told AFP
"Electronic voting will be the norm in 20 years from now, and only a few countries will remain counting votes manually. It is not a question of 'if', but 'when'.
"As long as the system is auditable, and recounts are available, the benefits significantly outnumber the possible risks."
But it is exactly these risks that make the world's electoral authorities nervous.
Ingo Boltz, an Austrian electronic election expert, urges caution in adopting automated voting. The human element in traditional elections, he says, can often be its greatest asset.
"With a traditional ballot box, every layperson can, without the use of expert knowledge or tools, follow and verify every step of the election process," he told AFP.
"As long as an observer is physically present, the process is completely transparent to the naked eye. The price of automated voting is the delegation of these tasks to a handful of information technology experts.
"And most IT security experts agree it is basically impossible to guarantee that an eVote system does exactly what its programmer says it does. We are obliged to trust that programmers are incorruptible."
As ever more people bank and shop online, will the world soon vote remotely online?
Most election experts think not. The biggest problems of fully remote systems are secrecy and "cyber-terrorism".
Secret ballots could be compromised, for example, if the patriarch of a large family wanted them all to vote in a particular way -- he could be in the room to make sure they did exactly that.
Computers could be infected with a virus that would manipulate the vote without the voter ever knowing, or used to launch a denial-of-service attack in which infected computers bombard the system until it overloads and shuts down.
The Open Voting Consortium (OVC), a US advocacy group dedicated to delivering trustworthy elections, was set up after the debacle of the 2000 US presidential elections because, the founders said, "nobody could figure out how Florida's voters had voted".
The election was left in disarray partly due to errors in the state's punchcard system that brought infamy to "chads" -- fragments left when holes are made in paper.
The election was so tight, and the vote so close in Florida, that these voting machine errors became crucial. An OVC electronic voting machine should be available soon.
But one of OVC's founders, Alan Dechert, says mass uptake of fully electronic elections is not on the horizon.
"We are a very long way from having a system good enough to be widely trusted for this type of purely electronic voting," he told AFP. "I don't see this type of system taking hold in the US over the next 100 years."
Electronic voting machines are currently used in India and Brazil and have been tested at some level in many other countries, including Britain.
But in India there is growing concern after Dutch and US scientists proved that the Indian system can be manipulated, and results altered. Holland, Germany and Ireland have all abandoned using electronic voting machines.
Silvana Puizana, an electoral expert who has worked on very different election challenges from Afghanistan and Albania to Suriname and Australia, is also cautious.
"Think of the evils bestowed on so many people by bad governments and governments who will stop at nothing to stay in power," Puizana told AFP.
"The most effective fraud is done by changing results after the count is done -- how much easier is that going to be to do undetected when there is no paper trail to trip you up?
"And you, as the corrupt government, control everything anyway. Don't like the result? Just change it, and no one will ever be able to prove you did it!
"I've seen too much fraud and corruption done with impunity to wish to make it even easier for them to do it in the future -- with a virtual promise of being undetectable."
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Japan PM faces deadlock after poll rout AFP - 16 minutes ago
China to get first 100 million-population province Reuters - 27 minutes ago
India launches five satellites into orbit AFP - 36 minutes ago
Australian PM may call election within days Reuters - 48 minutes ago
S.Korea says location of war games undecided AFP - 57 minutes ago
News Search
Top Stories
Fiesta in Spain, agony in Netherlands after World Cup final
European banks mull 20-bln-euro private bailout fund
Football: Casillas true hero as Iniesta steals headlines
Spain win seals perfect eight for 'psychic' octopus
Spain, Holland go to extra-time in World Cup final
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
European probe Rosetta flies by asteroid: ESA
Bahamas police capture 'Barefoot Bandit'
Spain win seals perfect eight for 'psychic' octopus
Football: Casillas true hero as Iniesta steals headlines
Remote Easter Island braces for total solar eclipse
More Most Viewed »
Reclusive top mathematician turns down prize, again
Germany's 'Octopus oracle' keeps perfect record
Aussie men shoot each other in buttocks 'to see if it hurts'
Amputee cat gets bionic legs
Fans gather for Michael Jackson death anniversary
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
World Cup 2010
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Monday, 12 July 2010 Darfur violence kills 221 in June
Government inspectors ease scandal over French minister
20 kilos of 20 pct enriched uranium ready: Iran
All children of Russian spies repatriated
Iran halts woman's stoning 'for now'
Senior Palestinian calls Jerusalem a time bomb
|
"Irrational" Iran can't get nuclear arms
Guatemala nabs cocaine-stuffed submarine in Pacific
|
Iraqi court seeks arrest of Iranian exiles
Sarkozy's party loses by-election amid scandal
|
Attacks kill 11 Afghan police, official in north
Darfur violence kills 221 in June: peacekeepers
|
Japan ruling party reels after vote
Japan ruling party handed big defeat over tax plan
Japan ruling party loses on tax talk: exit polls
China confirms it renewed Google operating license
Total solar eclipse arcs its way across Pacific
Soldiers take over where Afghan gov't fears to go
Soccer City erupts in light for World Cup closer
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
"Despicable Me" leads North American box office
Despicable Me leads North American box office
|
Angelina Jolie defends daughter Shiloh's style
|
Iran spares woman from stoning for now
Russians risk jail in 'forbidden art' trial
Removal of Taliban leaders from terror list sought
Uganda bombings kill 64 as World Cup fans targeted
|
Russian spy's call to father triggered arrests
The World's Most Expensive Bicycles
NATO soldier, 11 police killed in Afghan attacks
Fiesta in Spain, agony in Netherlands after World Cup final
Karzai to ask U.N. to trim Taliban blacklist: report
|
Nine Technologies To Ease Pain Of Getting Old
Senior Palestinian calls Jerusalem a "time bomb"
Brother angered by death of British fugitive
Israel failed in ship interception planning: reports
|
Celebrities: Macs Vs. PCs
Spain win seals perfect eight for 'psychic' octopus
6.2 magnitude earthquake strikes Chile
|
US-TECH Summary
Attacks kill 11 Afghan police, official in north
Government inspectors ease scandal over French minister
Electronic voting no threat yet to the old style ballot box
Three Northern Irish police shot in overnight riots
|
European banks mull 20-bln-euro private bailout fund
Football: Casillas true hero as Iniesta steals headlines
Afghan government seeking bigger slice of aid pie
|
Japan faces policy gridlock as ruling party reels
|
Betancourt accuses Colombia of failing to protect her
|
Australian PM may call election within days: media
|
Spain, Holland go to extra-time in World Cup final
China to start draining dam that threatens city
|
Bahamas police capture 'Barefoot Bandit'
S.Korea says location of war games undecided
Bahamas police capture 'Barefoot Bandit'
Myanmar troops seize vulnerable boys for tough army life
New Zealand PM sees pacts boosting Vietnam trade
Japan PM faces deadlock after poll rout
Australia PM drops election hint, leads in polls
Lawsuit against Apple, AT&T can remain as class action: report
|
Old style ballot box facing electronic poll threat
Celebrities: Macs Vs. PCs
Beijing steps up English-language drive
India's industrial output jumps 11.5 percent
Running with Pamplona's bulls, 'a high that lasts all year'
"Eclipse" still has bite at foreign box office
Australian PM may call election within days
Taiwan's CPC to set up oil shipping venture
Mel Gibson ouster more about money than morals
Anti-whaling protester: 'ugly war' will cost lives
Asia must brace for possible economic shocks: IMF
Louisiana prays for oil to finally get capped
Seoul shares rise on airlines, battery makers
Lopez faces 40 million lawsuit over Cyprus cancellation
Taiwan's Evergreen buys 10 vessels from CSBC
South Korea c.bank sells 91-day MSBs at 2.37 pct
'Despicable Me' tops ticket sales at Americas box office
Korea Hot Stocks
Renault's S.Korea unit to recall 59,000 vehicles
Yen falls after Japan ruling party suffers setback
PetroChina open to closer ties with BP
Eclipse still has bite at foreign box office
|
The filmmaker who became a legal spy
|
Mel Gibson ouster more about money than morals
|
Spain says awaiting 11 freed Cuban dissidents
Facebook installs 'panic button' for children
North Korea and U.N. officers to meet over ship sinking
|
Riots in N.Ireland see 27 officers hurt
Facebook launches child safety application
Three jailed 20 years in foiled UK airliner bomb plot
|
Polanski free after Swiss reject extradition
Afghanistan frees more suspected Taliban
|
ICC issues arrest warrant for genocide against Bashir
|
S.Africa urged to build on World Cup success
Fidel Castro to appear on Cuban television and radio
|
Champions Spain back home, Blatter praises .SAfrica
Strong Russian remarks on Iran please Washington
|
Stargazers in awe as total eclipse arcs across Pacific
Bahamas police capture 'Barefoot Bandit'
Canadian Guantanamo inmate turns down US plea deal
Timor parliament rejects Australian refugee plan
Tiger countries meet in Indonesia to map rescue
North Korea to meet U.N. officers over ship sinking
Microsoft CEO touts new Windows tablets vs iPad
|
Facebook launches child safety application
|
China to get first 100 million-population province
Roman Polanski freed as Swiss deny extradition
India launches five satellites into orbit
Pakistani rupee at record low; stocks flat
Experts fined in Russian art trial
Honda's China sales down 2.7 percent in June
Court fines organisers of Moscow exhibition
Jennifer Lopez faces $40 mln lawsuit over gig cancellation
S&P warns policy gridlock could hit Japan rating
Russia court finds 'Forbidden Art' organisers guilty
S.Korea rate rise vote was not unanimous
Taiwan Formosa to determine naphtha unit downtime by next week
S.Korea to invest $2 bln in carbon capture to 2019
China tycoon bids to be Prada's biggest shareholder
Pakistan June inflation up 12.69 pct yr/yr
Seoul shares rise on airlines, battery makers
Roman Polanski freed as Swiss deny extradition
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights