Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
China jails Rio Tinto staff for 7-14 years
|
Edition:
U.S.
Article
Comments (6)
Slideshow
Video
Save
Email
Print
Reprints
Most Popular
Most Shared
Obama rallies troops on first Afghan trip
| Video
28 Mar 2010
Bombers kill at least 38 in Moscow subway
| Video
11:31am EDT
Junk food addiction may be clue to obesity: study
28 Mar 2010
Obama did not snub Israeli PM: Axelrod
28 Mar 2010
Sex virus blamed for rise in head and neck cancers
26 Mar 2010
Junk food addiction may be clue to obesity: study
28 Mar 2010
Bombers kill at least 38 in Moscow subway
| Video
11:31am EDT
Sex virus blamed for rise in head and neck cancers
26 Mar 2010
U.S. lobbies a hurdle in Mexico drug war: Calderon
28 Mar 2010
Obama rallies troops on first Afghan trip
| Video
28 Mar 2010
China jails Rio Tinto staff for 7-14 years
Lucy Hornby and Rujun Shen
SHANGHAI
Mon Mar 29, 2010 8:06am EDT
Factbox
Factbox: China-Australia ties span business, people
4:40am EDT
Related News
Instant View: China convicts four Rio Tinto executives
4:40am EDT
Timeline: Ethnic Chinese punished for stealing secrets, spying
5:50am EDT
Related Video
Four Rio staff jailed for bribery
7:24am EDT
<
1 / 4
>
View Full Size
SHANGHAI (Reuters) - A Chinese court jailed four Rio Tinto staff for seven to 14 years on Monday for taking bribes and stealing commercial secrets, a sentence Australia said was harsh.
World
Rio Tinto said it would fire the four to distance itself from what it called "deplorable behavior" in a case that dates back to the middle of last year. It said Chinese prosecutors had unearthed "clear" proof of backhanders.
Internal investigation had shown that all wrongdoing was outside company systems, it added.
Canberra acknowledged there was convincing evidence of corruption, adding that ties with Beijing would not be hurt by the verdict in a trial which has been closely tied up with politics and diplomacy.
But Australian Foreign Minister Stephen Smith said he still had "serious unanswered questions" about the most controversial part of the trial, covering the stealing of commercial secrets, which was held behind closed doors.
Rio said it could not comment on these charges.
In China, the verdict could strengthen the hand of China's largest, state-owned steel mills and sharply curtail Chinese iron ore purchases from volatile spot markets.
The Shanghai Intermediate People's Court sentenced China-born Stern Hu, who headed Rio Tinto's iron ore operations in China, to 10 years in jail, with parts of a seven-year bribery term and a five-year secrets sentence running concurrently.
Three other executives, all Chinese nationals, were jailed for seven to 14 years on bribery and secrets charges.
Smith said China had missed a chance to clarify its secretive and often confusing rules about what constitutes a secret, but added that a relationship which has been strained in the past year was not at risk.
"On any measure this is a very tough sentence. It is a tough sentence by Australian standards. As far as Chinese sentencing practice is concerned, it is within the ambit or within the range," he told a news conference in Canberra.
"I don't believe the decision that has been made or has occurred will have any substantial or indeed any adverse implications for Australia's bilateral relationship with China."
RIO SHARES UNAFFECTED
The four men, dressed casually in sports jackets, stood for the verdicts, which came nine months after they were first detained at the height of fraught iron ore negotiations.
The court said the defendants helped obtain information from confidential strategy meetings of the China Iron and Steel Association (CISA), which represented the Chinese steel industry in negotiations with the world's three top iron ore suppliers, Rio, BHP Billiton and Vale.
Rio shares were barely affected by the sentencing.
"There's no implication that Rio Tinto was involved directly in what transpired," said Tim Schroeders, portfolio manager at Pengana Capital.
"This will probably allow one lingering doubt to be resolved and people to focus on the fundamentals of the company."
The company's chief executive, Tom Albanese, said the miner would focus on improving ties with China now the trial was over.
"I am determined that the unacceptable conduct of these four employees will not prevent Rio Tinto from continuing to build its important relationship with China. This is a high priority for me personally," he said.
Rio declined to comment on the commercial secrets charges that were at the heart of most foreign investor concern about the case, saying the firm had not been able to consider the evidence.
"This was an opportunity for China to bring some clarity to the notion or question of commercial secrets," Smith said, referring to a decision to close the portion of the trial dealing with commercial secrets to Australian diplomats.
"As China emerges into the global economy, the international business community needs to understand with certainty what the rules are in China," he added.
Leaked testimony of money handed over in cardboard boxes and plastic bags highlighted Chinese steel mills' desperation to secure relatively low-cost and stable iron ore supplies from Rio Tinto, the world's second-largest miner.
The court said the infringement of commercial secrets caused a great loss to the Chinese industry, putting it in a disadvantageous position in iron ore prices talks.
According to the court, last year over 20 Chinese steelmakers paid extra advances of 1.02 billion yuan for their iron ore imports because of the crimes committed by the four.
It named Tan Yixin, once tipped as future head of Shougang Steel in Beijing, and Wang Hongjiu, shipping manager for Laiwu Steel in Shandong, as the source of some of the leaks.
The court also sentenced those two men on Monday, but did not announce their sentences or when the trial had taken place. Both were detained shortly after the Rio executives, in July.
Foreign reporters were barred from the Rio Tinto executives' trial, held last week at the No. 1 Intermediate People's Court in Shanghai, but allowed in for the verdicts.
($1=6.826 yuan) (Additional reporting by Chen Aizhu in Beijing and Fang Yan in Shanghai; Editing by Nick Macfie)
World
Comments
See All Comments (6) | Post Comment
Mar 29, 2010 3:47am EDT
They should obviously appeal the case. This case shows the world that the Chinese government is a corrupt, criminal organization that is using this case as a way to get back at Rio Tinto for harsh negotiations, which in a civilized world means business a usual. The chinese government wants foreign companies to kowtow to them, and when they don’t they attack. Just look at google.
blahhhhhh
Report As Abusive
Mar 29, 2010 6:56am EDT
Boy, that should horrify anybody doing business in China. This kind of thing is going to happen more often as so many businesses are setting up operations in China
Story_Burn
Report As Abusive
Mar 29, 2010 8:38am EDT
Boy, if that isn’t the pot calling the kettle black!
minipaws
Report As Abusive
Mar 29, 2010 9:08am EDT
I wonder if the Chinese government cracks down on corruption of their own officials as severely as they crack down on foreign crooks.
Benny_Acosta
Report As Abusive
Mar 29, 2010 9:15am EDT
Is it about time for Rio Tinto to apologize to the Chinese? It was accusing Chinese government all kinds of wrong doings towards its employees.
Were Goolge’s employees doing the same things in China?
commomsense
Report As Abusive
Mar 29, 2010 10:17am EDT
If China is going to start jailing people for giving and taking bribes, then every Chinese government official and most chinese businessmen should be thrown in jail as well. Because that is how business is done in China!!! This case demonstrates the HUGE double standard in China. In order to get anything done, a bribe is expected by government officials, but now these same officials are turning around and jailing foreign company employees that give the bribes.
THE ONLY REASON FOREIGN COMPANIES ARE GIVING BRIBES IS BECAUSE THE CHINESE SYSTEM RELIES UPON BRIBES!!! YOU CAN’T DO BUSINESS IN CHINA WITHOUT BRIBING GOVERNMENT OFFICIALS!!!
I think it’s time to thrown the CCP officials in jail!!! See how full the prisons are then!!!
Voice-of-Reason
Report As Abusive
See All Comments (6)
Add a Comment
More from Reuters
Blasts rock Moscow subway stations
Suicide bombers detonated explosives on two packed Moscow subway trains during morning rush hour, in what officials say is the worst attack in the Russian capital for six years. Video | Full Article
Medvedev vows to root out "terrorists"
Factbox: Moscow subway a Stalinist prestige project
Your View: Send us your photos from the scene
Russia
Special Report:
High-rollers and a Vegas giant
A murder-for-hire case masterminded by the head of one of China's triad organized crime groups sheds light on their ties to Macau's booming gambling industry and raises troubling questions about one of the world's largest gaming companies. Full Article
China
Top 100 hospitals in the country
Do you live near a top hospital? Our interactive graphic maps out the best 100 on Thomson Reuters' annual list. Full Coverage | Full Article
Healthcare
© Copyright 2010 Thomson Reuters
Editorial Editions:
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
United States
Reuters
Contact Us
Advertise With Us
Help
Journalism Handbook
Archive
Site Index
Video Index
Analyst Research
Mobile
Newsletters
RSS
Podcasts
Widgets
Your View
Labs
Thomson Reuters
Copyright
Disclaimer
Privacy
Professional Products
Professional Products Support
Financial Products
About Thomson Reuters
Careers
Online Products
Acquisitions Monthly
Buyouts
Venture Capital Journal
International Financing Review
Project Finance International
PEhub.com
PE Week
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
Other News on Monday, 29 March 2010 Obama lands in Afghanistan for surprise visit
No end in sight to BA strike as row becomes political
Israel blames Palestinians for blocking US peace efforts
Colombian rebels free soldier to Red Cross
|
Bomb explodes in Athens, one killed: police
|
Rescuers search Morocco lake for Abu Dhabi sheikh
|
N. Ireland priest on leave over child safety concern
|
Chanting Haitian voodoo celebrants honor quake dead
|
French government sticks by civil service cutbacks
|
Somali pirates claim to have hijacked Spanish ship
|
Darfur rebels say shot down Sudan helicopters
|
US, WTO Urge EU To Speak With One Voice At G20 Summit
Crane Crashes Into Building In Lower Manhatten
New iPad orders won't ship until April 12
|
China's Geely seals Volvo Cars takeover
China making anime push as Japan hits slump
In surprise visit to war zone, Obama prods Afghans
Thailand's televised protest talks end without resolution
Angry families visit site of sunken SKorean ship
Samoa take Hong Kong Sevens title
Flood in new China coal mine traps 123 miners
Missing China rights lawyer alive, say close friends
Pakistani army kills 22 Taliban near Afghan border
123 trapped in flooded China coal mine
Vote ends power struggle in Malaysia Chinese party
Afghan government reports 6 civilian deaths
Irish museum gives leprechauns their due, to be sure
Dragon knocks Alice off top box office perch
|
Pullman risks Christian anger with Jesus novel
|
Phillies Fan Charged With Attempted Sex Trade
"Dragon" knocks "Alice" off top box office perch
Hacker Sentenced To 20 Years For Data Theft
Irish museum gives leprechauns their due, to be sure
Shanghai's Bund reborn ahead of World Expo
Obama presses Karzai in surprise Afghan visit
Dozens dead in twin blasts on Moscow metro: officials
Suicide bombers kill at least 37 in Moscow metro
|
Music video games primed for new dance revolution
Netanyahu rejects Obama "disaster" headline
Merkel's visit spotlights Turkey's contentious EU bid
Latest iPad orders won't ship until April 12
North Korea warns South to stop tours at border
|
Turnout down in electoral test for Italy's Berlusconi
Thousands march against bullfighting in Spanish capital
Armed gang escapes after storming Swiss casino
Thai PM's talks with red shirts to resume
|
Junkies and junk-food addicts share craving mechanism
UNAIDS calls for lifting of HIV travel bans
Searchers: remains of Errol Flynn's son found
US Navy joins search for missing SKorean sailors
2 foreigners sent to NZ prison for hunting lizards
Opposition deciding whether to run in Myanmar poll
PAKISTAN
China Construction Bank 2009 profit up 15 percent
China Sinopec's 2009 profit more than doubled
Music video games primed for new dance revolution
|
Two Japanese architects win Pritzker prize
Japan minister sounding out US on base row
Alyssa Milano series gets start date
|
'80s stars Hall & Oates back in spotlight
"Wonderland" No. 1 destination at overseas theaters
Alyssa Milano series gets start date
Post-divorce Usher returns with new attitude
|
'Train Your Dragon' slays box office competition
Pullman risks Christian anger with Jesus novel
Fox picks up sketch-comedy pilot from Jamie Foxx
|
US concerned by Australian Internet filter plan
NKorea accuses South of psychological warfare
China's deadliest reported mining disasters
Thai PM, protesters meet again after live TV talks
Bombs in Iraq holy city kill five, wound 64
Suicide bombers kill 38 on Moscow metro
Turkey gets Clinton pledge on genocide resolution
Japan considers end to cellphone 'SIM lock'
Israel limits access to Al-Aqsa as Passover starts
GlobalPost charts online future amid newspaper woes
China jails Rio Tinto staff for 7-14 years
|
IMF foresees rapid US growth
Obama presses Karzai in surprise Afghan visit
Special report: High-rollers, triads and a Las Vegas giant
|
Israel to allow clothes, shoes into blockaded Gaza
|
Toyota global sales up 13% in February
Israel to focus on key Iran nuclear targets in any strike
|
Suu Kyi's party says won't stand in Myanmar polls
|
Train Makes Stop At #1 On iTunes With "Hey, Soul Sister"
Pilot, Passenger Survive Miami Beach Helicopter Crash
Study: Junk Food Habit Like Drug Addiction
Italy government seen winning 4 regions, rivals 6, 3 tied
|
Study Suggests Very Few Can Safely Drive, Talk On Phone
Turkey makes case against sanctions on Iran
|
Scientists stumped as bee population declines further
Angelina Jolie Being Considered To Play Sleeping Beauty Villainess
Bombs in Iraq holy city kill five, wound 64
|
White House Releases Largest Set Of Visitor Logs To Date
Passenger Of Florida Cruise Ship Charged With False Bomb Threat
Miley Cyrus Says Her Last Record Coming Out In June
Conan OBrien Turns Down Tony Hosting Gig Offer
Florida Man Dies After Accidentally Cutting His Leg With A Chainsaw
Race on to rescue 153 trapped Chinese coal miners
iPad to hit stores Saturday as consumer test begins
|
A virtual farm turns new ground for game developers
|
Philippines clears clan head of rebellion charges
Philippine massacre suspects cleared of rebellion charges
Suu Kyi's party to boycott Myanmar elections
14 injured in NATO helicopter crash in Afghanistan
Pakistan stocks end lower; rupee, overnight rates ease
Toyota global sales up 13% in February
China to grow 12% in first quarter: state media
China slaps Rio employees with up to 14 years jail
Japan auto production surges in February
RPT-IMF to approve Pakistan tranche in April-official
Divers reach SKorean ship, find no sign of life
Alyssa Milano series gets start date
No rebel charges against Philippines massacre clan
Thai PM rebuffs demands for dissolving parliament
Indonesian park official: 2 rare elephants killed
Aussie striker Aloisi moves to Melbourne Heart
Indonesian village hunts for 7-meter killer python
SKorean actor commits suicide 2 years after sister
Sci-fi epic 'Avatar', McKellen dominate Empire awards
In UAE, foreigners bring money and social challenges
Wonderland No. 1 destination at overseas theaters
|
Shoes shine: Dr. Martens celebrate 50th birthday
'80s stars Hall & Oates back in spotlight
|
Fox picks up sketch-comedy pilot from Jamie Foxx
Post-divorce Usher returns with new attitude
China making anime push as Japan hits slump
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights