Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Sondheim tribute would be better without songs
|
Edition:
U.S.
Article
Save
Email
Print
Reprints
Most Popular
Most Shared
UPDATE 2-'South Park' airs 'censored' episode after threat
22 Apr 2010
Potentially deadly fungus spreading in U.S. and Canada
22 Apr 2010
North Korea torpedoed South's navy ship: report
22 Apr 2010
Corrected: Global stocks rise on economic data, euro up
| Video
11:11am EDT
New home sales jump 26.9 percent in March
10:23am EDT
Exclusive: WellPoint routinely targets breast cancer patients
22 Apr 2010
Wall Street gives much to lawmakers in reform debate
8:13am EDT
Oil spill not growing, search for 11 continues
| Video
10:33am EDT
Greece presses aid button, markets still wary
| Video
11:14am EDT
UPDATE 1-Citi offers to buy back $1.1 billion in notes
8:33am EDT
Exclusive: WellPoint routinely targets breast cancer patients
22 Apr 2010
Potentially deadly fungus spreading in U.S. and Canada
22 Apr 2010
North Korea torpedoed South's navy ship: report
22 Apr 2010
Biggest study on cellphone health effects launched
22 Apr 2010
Legalizing pot may kill buzz in California enclave
22 Apr 2010
Privacy chiefs keep watch over Facebook
| Video
22 Apr 2010
WellPoint routinely targets breast cancer patients
22 Apr 2010
New home sales jump 26.9 percent in March
10:23am EDT
Greece presses aid button, markets still wary
| Video
11:14am EDT
TEXT-Greek PM statement on activating EU/IMF aid
7:53am EDT
Pictures
Celebrity sightings
When the stars are out so are the cameras. Slideshow
"Sondheim" tribute would be better without songs
Frank Scheck
Fri Apr 23, 2010 7:43am EDT
Related News
Green Day's American Idiot a tough sell on Broadway
Thu, Apr 22 2010
Green Day's American Idiot a tough sell on Broadway
Tue, Apr 20 2010
Kelsey Grammer shines in "La Cage Aux Folles"
Mon, Apr 19 2010
Brits flock to the West End for entertainment
Sun, Apr 18 2010
Brits flock to the West End for entertainment
Sun, Apr 18 2010
NEW YORK (Hollywood Reporter) - A person can't turn a corner in New York these days without stumbling onto yet another 80th birthday celebration for Stephen Sondheim.
Entertainment
The yearlong canonization of Broadway's most eminent living composer -- which has included endless tribute concerts and revivals of such works as "A Little Night Music" and "Anyone Can Whistle" -- continues at Studio 54 with "Sondheim on Sondheim," an intriguing but misconceived hodgepodge of musical revue and video documentary.
This is the sort of Broadway show that seems designed to include pledge breaks. Conceived and directed by longtime Sondheim collaborator James Lapine ("Sunday in the Park With George," "Into the Woods," "Passion"), the production features an eight-person cast -- including such well-known performers as Barbara Cook, Vanessa Williams and Tom Wopat -- showcased to less than positive effect. Their renditions of dozens of Sondheim compositions, well-known and obscure, are interwoven with video footage in which the composer discusses the artistic genesis of many of the songs being performed.
The awkward result is unlikely to attract significant audiences outside of the Roundabout's subscription base, though it will prove of undeniable interest to Sondheim fanatics, and they are legion.
The best parts of the show are the interview segments, in which the erudite and witty composer provides an entertaining running commentary ranging from breezy showbiz anecdotes -- the one about Ethel Merman's run-in with Loretta Young is priceless -- to explications of his creative process to self-revealing autobiography. Anyone interested in the famously private songwriter will relish the opportunity to see footage of him puttering around his home, not to mention the close-ups of the bric-a-brac littering his office.
Unfortunately, these informative segments are too often interrupted by the live performers on hand, who provide wildly uneven renditions of songs that usually fare much better. For instance, "Comedy Tonight," performed by the ensemble, is seriously unfunny, and "Something's Coming" has the blandness of Muzak.
Wopat doesn't begin to plumb the interpretive depths necessary for such powerful numbers as "Epiphany" from "Sweeney Todd" or "Finishing the Hat" from "Sunday." The 82-year-old Cook looks quite awkward while singing romantic duets with her much younger co-stars and even worse when forced to participate in strained comedy bits. Her voice seems weak at times, no doubt because of the rigors of an eight-performance workweek. She does acquit herself beautifully when she's in her natural element, delivering gorgeously sung solo renditions of such songs as "In Buddy's Eyes" and "Send in the Clowns."
Williams generally is saddled with the more obscure material (some of it, like a number cut from "Gypsy," for a reason), though she does knock it out of the park with "Losing My Mind" and is devastatingly sexy when stripping down to flimsy lingerie for "Ah, But Underneath" (written for the London production of "Follies.")
The starring trio is augmented by five supporting performers, ranging from Broadway pros Leslie Kritzer, Norm Lewis and Euan Morton to relative unknowns Erin Mackey and Matthew Scott. They each have their moments, most notably Lewis with a powerful "Being Alive," but generally don't make a strong enough impression.
Too rarely do the interview segments serve to enrich the onstage performances. When it does happen -- as when Sondheim discusses his deeply painful relationship with his unloving mother as a prelude to "Children Will Listen" or when he describes the evolution of the song "Being Alive" before we hear its early and finished versions -- it only makes one all too aware of how much aesthetically powerful the show might have been.
The video projections are expertly handled, even if there is a tendency toward too many Monty Python-style visual effects, and Beowulf Boritt's modular set, which keeps breaking up into different pieces, is arresting. (Not so for Susan Hilferty's costumes, which often look like she picked them up at the Gap on the way to the theater). Although the true fans will relish the opportunity to hear Sondheim expound at length, not to mention the plethora of rarely performed obscurities in the program, most audiences will find "Sondheim" more tutorial than entertainment.
Entertainment
More from Reuters
Usher's "good and bad" fight it out on new album
LONDON (Reuters) - The eligible bachelor is back in singer Usher's new album "Raymond v. Raymond," which he sees an expression of his struggle to balance life in the fast lane with his commitments as a family man and father.
Polanski loses bid to be sentenced in absentia
Kitty Kelley's Oprah dissection a brave opus
Simon Cowell ups fortune by $69 million in past year
"Avatar" sets first-day Blu-ray sales record
Woody Allen details movie with Carla Bruni
» More Top News
Greece asks for $60.5 billion aid
Greek request to trigger billions in emergency loans could be the largest state bailout ever attempted. Full Article | Video
Most Greeks think aid will hurt country
EU problems: Ash cloud, Greek debt
Global Markets
Apple over Microsoft by a TKO
Apple's shares are now 80 times what they were in 1997 while Microsoft's have barely doubled. A Silicon Valley insider explains why. Commentary
Microsoft profit rises, shares fall
Apple lauded after blowout quarter
Technology
© Copyright 2010 Thomson Reuters
Editorial Editions:
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
United States
Reuters
Contact Us
Advertise With Us
Help
Journalism Handbook
Archive
Site Index
Video Index
Analyst Research
Mobile
Newsletters
RSS
Podcasts
Widgets
Your View
Labs
Thomson Reuters
Copyright
Disclaimer
Privacy
Professional Products
Professional Products Support
Financial Products
About Thomson Reuters
Careers
Online Products
Acquisitions Monthly
Buyouts
Venture Capital Journal
International Financing Review
Project Finance International
PEhub.com
PE Week
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
Other News on Friday, 23 April 2010 Armenia halts ratification of Turkey peace deal
Greece takes a battering on EU deficit revision
Iran tests speed boats in "major" Gulf war games
CenturyTel in 10.6-billion-dollar purchase of Qwest
Greece hit by widening deficit, ratings downgrade
New York Times posts profit, says ready to take on WSJ
U.S. sees sanctions by May; Iran lobbies against West
|
Obama says financial reforms will end taxpayer bailouts
US-TECH Summary
At least 45 wounded in Bangkok blasts: hospital
Military gains seen sapping Iraq al Qaeda strength
|
Naomi Campbell Rages Off ABC News Set, Strikes Camera After "Blood Diamond" Questions
Biggest study on cellphone health effects launched
U.S. signals its nuclear arms stay in Europe for now
|
Gabourey Sidibe Shows Off Funny Side In "SNL" Promos
Missing Ohio Woman Found Safe In Miami With Mysterious Man
Armenia halts ratification of Turkey peace deal
|
Michelle Answers Raise Eyebrows, Laughter During Take Your Child To Work Day Event
Four Decades Later, Healthy And Green Earth Day Brings Cash For Appliances
NATO agrees to launch Bosnia membership plan
|
Burning Oil Rig Sinks In Gulf Of Mexico
IMF chief tries to shore up fraying G20 unity
|
Obama Gets Cutter As Assistant for Special Projects
Greek workers strike, warn of social explosion
|
U.S. Existing Home Sales Rise 6.8 Percent In March
Homeless May Be Protected From Hate Crimes Under Florida Law
Passengers Battered When Carnival Cruise Ship Tips
Obama makes defining pitch for finance reform
Pollution risk as US oil rig sinks after blast
Three dead, 70 wounded in Bangkok grenade attacks
Iran's Quds force in Venezuela, Latin America: Pentagon
Explosions kill 1, wound dozens in Bangkok
China will agree to new UN sanctions against Iran: Biden
Targeted killings put Pakistan's Swat back on edge
Grenade blasts kill 1, wound 75 in Bangkok
Briton's arrest in Kyrgyzstan raises concerns
Burqa bans infringe women's rights, say Indonesian clerics
Japan's most popular politician bolts conservative party
Indonesian workers riot over 'stupid' slur
Big expectations for RIM at BlackBerry trade show
|
Automakers showcase new models at Beijing show
Japan's debt threatens its credit rating, says Fitch
Budapest book fest honours Israel
Fitch warns Japan credit rating at risk from debt
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Korea keen on Kazakh uranium, grain
London crowds say farewell to punk pioneer McLaren
China tycoon goes on trial for graft
NCAA signs $10.8 billion basketball tourney TV deal
India in danger of urban 'chaos': report
Playboy porn breaks into Disney channel
In Haiti, schools lure back students with a free daily meal
Michelin covers three more Japanese cities
Thousands take to Swiss Alps in gruelling Glacier race
Lisa Kudrow forges diverse post Friends career
|
Irish author Banville loves being Black
|
NCAA signs $10.8 billion basketball tourney TV deal
|
Israel PM seeks new plan as U.S. envoy visits
UK's election race tightens after second TV debate
Thai police confront red shirts after grenade attack
|
Microsoft profit soars with Windows 7 sales
No sign Scuds moved to Lebanon
Under-fire Ukraine president defends Russia deal
Israel PM seeks new plan as U.S. envoy visits
|
U.S. sees sanctions by May; Iran lobbies against West
Microsoft to invest in small black-owned firms in SAfrica
Stars shine spotlight on the planet for Earth Day
US newspapers draw record traffic in first quarter: NAA
Minister says rockets not fired from Jordan
G20 plots post-crisis path; Greece dampens hopes
|
Amazon net profit up but shares slide
Car bomb explodes outside Northern Ireland police station
|
South Korea won't retaliate alone for ship sinking
|
Guatemala hands over key file in army genocide case
|
No sign Scuds moved to Lebanon: U.S. officials
|
Venezuela raids cocaine labs on Colombia border
|
Ariz. lawmakers: Candidates must prove citizenship
NKorea says it will seize 5 SKorean assets
US, African Union pledge greater engagement
US, China to resume human rights dialogue
Alleged US victim aims to open Vatican abuse files
N.Korea seizes S.Korean assets at mountain resort
'Major oil spill' as rig sinks off US coast
China says naval exercise near Japan not a threat
China to OK new UN sanctions against Iran: Biden
South Korea won't retaliate alone for ship sinking
Thai police tell Reds to retreat after grenade attacks
Sri Lanka president to appoint new cabinet
Obama, Dalai Lama world's most popular leaders: poll
Remaining wreck of S.Korean warship lifted from seabed
Suspected militants kill 4 'US spies' in Pakistan
Redbox gets deals with Fox, Universal movie studios
Wipro quarterly profit up 21 pct, attrition rises
Chinese auto maker Chery says signs Messi
Kia Motors says Q1 profit quadruples, sales rise
PAKISTAN
NZ credit card billings rise in March
S.Korea's Kia Motors earnings quadrupled in Q1
S.Korea hopes to bridge divide over yuan
Honda doubles operating profit: report
Brazilian state bans Toyota Corolla sales on safety concerns
Susan Boyle success helps Cowell amass a fortune
Polanski loses bid to be sentenced in absentia
Fox to air delayed lingerie ad with busty models
"Dragon" set to overshadow J.Lo at box office
Woody Allen details movie with Carla Bruni
Four-day adventure gets Irish film to NY's Tribeca
Redbox gets deals with Fox, Universal movie studios
Rapper B.o.B leads chart, Glee crew ubiquitous
Nixed "Idol" Tim Urban gives secret to his smile
Polanski loses bid to be sentenced in absentia
|
Woody Allen details movie with Carla Bruni
|
Dragon set to overshadow J.Lo at box office
|
Fox to air delayed lingerie ad with busty models
|
Four-day adventure gets Irish film to NY's Tribeca
|
Rapper B.o.B leads chart, Glee crew ubiquitous
|
Greece pleads for debt aid
Bombs kill 56 in Baghdad after al Qaeda deaths
EU wants united airspace after ash cloud
|
McAfee: rogue anti-virus slipped quality controls
Greece asks for activation of EU-IMF debt rescue
At least 32 killed in Baghdad attacks
Greece to seek EU-IMF debt bailout: govt source
Zimbabwe's Mugabe backs Iran's nuclear programme
Bombs kill 64 in Iraq after al Qaeda deaths
|
Tori Spelling Starring In Planned ABC Talk Show
ABC, Fox Deny Refusal To Air Lane Bryant Plus-Size Lingerie Ad
'Major oil spill' as rig sinks off US coast
NATO irons out plan for Afghan civil, military handover
50 Cent Announces The Invitation U.S. Tour
Belgian bishop resigns over abuse of boy
|
Iran agrees belatedly to better monitoring
SEC Staffers Engorge Hard Drives In Flaccid Economy
Two UC Davis Students Charged In Hamster Tortures
Archie Comes Out With First Openly Gay Character
UK parties clash over recovery after GDP data
|
Monsters Inc Opening Sequel In 2012
Poll: Most Americans Confused About Health Care Bill
U.S. charges 11 Somalis with piracy in ship attacks
|
Tiger Woods Mistress No. 1 Pitching Reality Show Idea
Napping Could Boost Memory, Especially If You Dream
NATO agrees Afghan plan, but says no rush to exit
|
India police clash with Kashmir protest, 7 injured
Sri Lanka reduces Cabinet to 37 from more than 100
A day to honor poets? Quoth the raven 'Evermore'
US envoy in Israel talks amid spat between allies
Northern League says Berlusconi government doomed
|
Kyrgyzstan's ousted president vows not to return
Sex abuse victim lawsuit against pope 'without merit'
Thai protesters want Parliament dissolved in month
Iraq closes secret prison, arrests 3 officers
|
Suspect nabbed over killing of US consular worker
22 Indonesians die after drinking poisonous liquor
South Korea won't retaliate alone for ship sinking
|
Clinton urges North Korea to avoid provocative actions
NATO says 2 US soldiers killed in Afghan firefight
China warns of anthrax, rabies in quake zone
Thai protesters welcome promise of fresh elections
Pakistani stocks down; rupee weakens; o/n rates flat
Pakistani banks to close on Saturdays to save power
Euro rises as Greece requests debt help
Euro at a year low as Greek debt weighs heavy
India approves $3.4 bln bank recapitalisation plan
India's Wipro reports profit rise
"Sondheim" tribute would be better without songs
China's Changan confirms Peugeot tie-up talks: report
Kitty Kelley's Oprah dissection a brave opus
Chinese auto maker Chery signs Messi
Singapore's 'void decks' reflect racial rainbow
Gandhi's sex life laid bare in new book
Usher's good and bad fight it out on new album
|
Kitty Kelley's Oprah dissection a brave opus
|
Simon Cowell ups fortune by $69 million in past year
|
Avatar sets first-day Blu-ray sales record
|
Sondheim tribute would be better without songs
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights