Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
COMMENTARY: Expect little from Cancun talks
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Australia
China
India
Indonesia
Japan
Malaysia
Philippines
Thailand
Vietnam
COMMENTARY: Expect little from Cancun talks
ANN - Monday, November 29
Send
IM Story
Print
Kuala Lumpur (The Star/ANN) - One year after the Copenhagen conference that ended in chaos, it's Mexico's turn to host this year's big international climate gathering.
Expectations are low this time around. That's probably both good and bad.
The conference last year had been so hyped up beforehand and with so much hopes linked to it that the lack of a binding agreement at the end of it became a near-disaster.
Few expect this year's meeting at the seaside resort of Cancun to produce anything significant in commitments, either to cut Greenhouse Gas emissions or to provide funds to developing countries.
Thus, if Cancun ends as a non-event, it won't be taken as a catastrophe.
On the other hand, this lowering of expectations indicates how low climate change has sunk in just a year in the world's political agenda.
And that is bad indeed, because the climate problem has got even worse.
This year is already rivalling 1998 as the hottest since records were kept.
And there have been so many natural disasters in 2010; some of them like the catastrophic flooding in Pakistan, are linked to climate change.
Other events, especially the spread of the financial crisis to Western Europe and the persistent high unemployment rate in the United States despite economic growth, have taken over the attention of the politicians and public in the developed countries.
Also, the chances of getting a global climate change agreement appear much more dim.
And when a problem seems intractable, political leaders tend to lose interest because like other people they don't like to be associated with failure.
The problems facing the Cancun conference of the UN Climate Change Convention are many and they seem intractable.
The main problem is the inability of the US administration to make any meaningful commitment to cut its country's emissions to an adequate extent because Congress is likely to reject a comprehensive climate bill.
This makes the other developed countries reluctant to firm up their own commitments.
Many of them are still dragging their feet in saying how much they should cut their emissions, individually and as a group, in the Kyoto Protocol's second period that is to start in 2013.
Worse, Russia and Japan have stated that they do not want to continue with the Kyoto Protocol because the US is not a member. Australia, New Zealand and Canada have also been reluctant to commit to Kyoto's second period.
That leaves the European Union, which prefers to shift to a new system, too, but is open to remaining in Kyoto if others do.
Only Norway has said firmly it wants a second Kyoto period.
The death of the Kyoto Protocol, under which the developed countries except the US have legally-binding targets to cut their emissions, is something the developing countries cannot accept.
They want the developed countries to cut their emissions as a group by more than 40% by 2020 (compared to 1990), and for each country to do an adequate cut, under the Kyoto Protocol.
They are in despair because most of the developed countries want to join the US in a voluntary pledging system to replace the legally-binding Kyoto Protocol.
Each country would not have to do what the science says is needed, it would just pledge what it feels it can or should.
Top climate scientists in a new UN Environment Programme report shows how disastrously off-mark such a voluntary system can be.
Instead of cutting their emissions by at least 25% to 40% below 1990 levels in 2020 as required, the developed countries will actually increase their emission by 6% in a bad scenario and will only cut by 16% in the good scenario.
This is based on the pledges that they have made.
The major turn-around in the attitude of most developed counties towards their own emission reduction will be the hardest problem to resolve in Cancun.
The other contentious issue will be the proposed new obligations to be placed on developing countries on the insistence of the developed countries.
These are obligations to cut the growth of their emissions from "business as usual", and to produce reports once in two years on their emissions and on their emission-reduction plans and actions.
The reports will be subjected to international verification or analysis and consultation.
Developing countries are saying they are willing to do more and to give more reports, but they need funds and new technology to do this. Moreover, why should they take on more stringent obligations when the developed countries want to downgrade their own commitments?
The possible bright spot in Cancun could be a decision to create a new climate fund under the Climate Convention.
This would be a very limited gain, as the details of the fund (including its governance and the amounts it will have) are to be worked out later.
After all, it would be easy to set up a fund if there is no clear commitment to put substantial money in it.
But, Cancun may even be deprived of such a small result.
The US has made clear most recently through its special climate envoy Todd Stern, that there cannot be an "early harvest" in Cancun such as setting up a fund.
For the US to agree to that, there must be a Cancun agreement on mitigation, in which developing countries agree to the stringent obligations on reporting and international analysis, and in which developed countries only undertake a system of voluntary pledges.
At Cancun, there will be an appeal to the US to allow the fund to be set up, and not to tie this to conditions that its demands in mitigation will be met.
"Don't take the funds that can get actions going in the developing world as "hostage" or conditional on you getting your way in other areas of the negotiations."
This call will most likely be made many times in the next two weeks in Cancun.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
S.Korea says N.Korea will pay for future provocations AFP - Monday, November 29
Nearly 100 children hurt in China school stampede AFP - 54 minutes ago
Thailand's ruling party braces for ban verdict AFP - Monday, November 29
Cook joins select company in England run feast AFP - 2 hours 40 minutes ago
Australia's Labor loses state poll in blow to PM Reuters - 1 hour 3 minutes ago
News Search
Top Stories
Europe fixes Ireland bailout, future rescue rules
Europe fixes Irish bailout, future rescue rules
Irish bailout fixed at 85 billion, 35 billion for banks
Brazil claims 'D-Day' victory on Rio slums
Experts split on global warming, highland malaria link
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Obama gets 12 stitches after 'elbow in the lip'
Britain's Prince William happy to wait for crown
Black Friday shows slight increase in US sales
Computer meltdown leaves Aussies without cash
International deal struck on Irish bailout
More Most Viewed »
'Naked' airport scanners may be 'dangerous'
EU fines 11 airlines 800 million euros for air cargo cartel
Pilgrims stone 'devil' as Muslims celebrate Eid
World leaders scramble for funds to save the tiger
US, S.Korea plan war games after N.Korean attack
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo!
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Entertainment
Photos
Yahoo! News Network
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Monday, 29 November 2010 Protests and clashes as Egypt holds general election
Spain's ruling Socialists defeated in Catalonia
Hope smells sweet as Gaza exports strawberries
Opposition cries foul in Egyptian election
Irish bailout fixed at 85 billion, 35 billion for banks
Lebanese PM calls in Tehran for Arab-Iran unity
U.S. Refuses WikiLeaks Request For Information About Threatened Individuals
Brazil claims 'D-Day' victory on Rio slums
Moroccans protest against Spanish opposition party
|
Iran offers Hariri help for Lebanese military
Israel to crack down on illegal migrant workers
Gunmen kill 3 Afghans in attack in country's east
Lebanese PM calls in Tehran for Arab-Iran unity
|
Iran obtained missiles from North Korea: leaked US documents
India calls new meeting over parliamentary impasse
India calls new meeting over parliamentary impasse
|
Hundreds pour into Thailand after Myanmar clashes
WikiLeaks documents reveal sensitive U.S. cables
Acer aims to top global PC market in 2011: report
|
Five dead elephants believed poisoned in Indonesia
Spain's ruling Socialists defeated in Catalonia
South Korea vows retaliation against any further attack
|
Wi-Fi lifeline reaches remote Himalayas
Europe fixes Irish bailout, future rescue rules
Protests and fraud charges roil Haiti elections
|
WikiLeaks unleashes a flood of damaging US cables
U.N. climate talks seek to bridge rich-poor divide
|
Fresh Wikileaks Documents Upsets Arab Leaders, Embarrass U.S.
U.S. Issues Statements As WikiLeaks Documents Start Damaging Appearance
Cambodia PM says no one responsible for stampede
|
Saudi king urged U.S. to attack Iran
Two blasts in Iran's capital, one dead: report
|
Violence and accusations as Ivory Coast voting ends
|
Swiss vote to expel convicted foreigners
|
US-TECH Summary
Acer aims to top global PC market in 2011: report
Thai court prepares ruling in PM party funding case
|
Pro-Europe rulers lead Communists in Moldova vote
|
South Korea vows retaliation against any further attack
England moral victors in drawn first Ashes Test
N.Korea's Kim and heir watch musical performance
Thailand's ruling party braces for ban verdict
NZealand announces probe into mine disaster
Rising labour shortage hits China's key delta regions
Legalise same-sex marriage to curb HIV: Chinese experts
Online bargain-hunting spreads beyond Cyber Monday
|
Few smartphone owners are loyal to their brand: survey
|
Fiji Water pulls plug on deal with Pacific nation
Taiwan c.bank: hot money measures effective
Pakistan
Macau tycoon pays 330,000 US dlrs for two truffles
COMMENTARY: Expect little from Cancun talks
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Euro falls to two-month low after Ireland bailout
Dole hit with $200,000 penalty over movie lawsuit
Aussie reveller dives from building, misses pool
"Naked Gun" actor Leslie Nielsen dead at 84
'No punishments' over deadly Cambodian stampede: PM
Hospital train heals Argentina's poor
Naked Gun actor Leslie Nielsen dead at 84
|
Harry Potter still king of the world
|
Dole hit with $200,000 penalty over movie lawsuit
|
Producer brings 3D video-on-demand porn to Europe
|
Taiwan financial markets get brief election lift
'Naked Gun' star Leslie Nielsen, dead at 84
NZ business confidence rises in November
Korea Hot Stocks- Korea Exchange Bank shares tumble
Seoul shares shed 0.3 pct on N.Korea, Europe worry
Court battle looms as hundreds of Picassos turn up: report
Classic comic actor Leslie Nielsen dead at 84: report
Producer brings 3D video-on-demand porn to Europe
"Harry Potter" still king of the world
Euro hits new two-month low on eurozone fears
S.Korea won off highs; N.Korea risk discounted
Iran accuses CIA, Mossad of nuke scientist killing
Shareholders seal BA-Iberia merger
Saudi king urged U.S. to attack Iran: WikiLeaks
|
Euro slumps to two-month low after Irish bailout
Executives in India loans probe to face hearing: sources
|
Israel says Wikileaks vindicates its Iran focus
Euro hits two month low after Ireland bailout
"Burlesque" Debuts At Disappointing 4th Place At The Box Office Weekend
U.N. says Ivory Coast poll was democratic
|
Blast 'kills top Iran nuclear scientist,' Israel blamed
Man Mistakes BB Gun For The Real Thing In Deadly Thanksgiving Day Prank
Election chaos in Haiti as candidates cry foul
Thanksgiving Weekend Yields 6 Percent Rise In Sales
Gaddafi issues warning to EU over African trade
|
Blasts kill Iran nuclear scientist, wound another
Iran blasts kill one nuclear scientist, wounds another
'Naked Gun' star Leslie Nielsen, dead at 84
Walking May Slow Alzheimers Cognitive Decline
Iran accepts date for talks with powers: Ahmadinejad
|
WikiLeaks Rolling Out Quarter Million Documents With 15,652 Classified Secret
Israel consulted Egypt, Fatah on Gaza war: WikiLeaks
NATO says six troops shot dead in east Afghanistan
|
DEA Seizes 20 Tons Of Marijuana, Worth $20 Million
Blasts heard in restive Kyrgyzstan city
|
NATO: 6 service members killed in Afghanistan
Study: Being Too Clean May Be Bad For Your Health
Chavez opens his palace to Venezuelan homeless
|
US deployment to Afghanistan outstrips Soviet war
China AIDS death toll up nearly 20,000 in a year
Indonesia closes airport as volcano rumbles
Cambodia PM says no one responsible for stampede
S.Korea vows N.Korea will pay for future provocations
OR Muslims plea for safety after bomb plot arrest
Pakistan defends nuclear stance revealed by WikiLeaks
FBI: Planes, dogs, psych experts seek 3 Mich. boys
Bigger eruptions in Indonesia 'likely'
NYC teacher caught up in Spanish curse debate
Korean included in top ten Internet languages
Global minimum and maximum temperatures
Pakistan's Zardari barred from pardoning C
Microsoft in talks for new TV service: sources
|
Gartner cuts PC shipment forecasts for 2010, 2011
|
Amazon.com looks to enter new markets: report
|
Supreme court to hear Microsoft appeal on i4i patent
|
Gartner cuts PC shipment forecasts for 2010, 2011
Will Narnia blockbuster sink or sail, pundits ask
|
Amazon.com looks to enter new markets: report
China's Tencent to offer Facebook-like services: report
Few smartphone owners are loyal to their brand: survey
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights