Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Special report: Tracking Iran's nuclear money trail to Turkey
|
Edition:
U.S.
Article
Comments (0)
Slideshow
Email
Print
Reprints
Read
Analysis: Swedish government seeks way to exclude far-right
19 Sep 2010
BP says oil spill compensation payout rate soars
| Video
9:50am EDT
China media warn Japan over escalating sea row
8:36am EDT
Australia, U.S. warn citizens as India probes shooting
5:05am EDT
BP to conduct test to show if Gulf well dead
18 Sep 2010
Shared
Editor's choice
17 Sep 2010
Best of the week
17 Sep 2010
Editor's choice
8:05am EDT
Facebook denies plans to build its own phone
19 Sep 2010
Analysis: Swedish rout highlights European socialist crisis
9:33am EDT
Watched
Soros: Gold "not safe"
Wed, Sep 15 2010
The week ahead
Fri, Sep 17 2010
BP oil well sealed.
Sun, Sep 19 2010
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. NASDAQ delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
Editor's choice
Our top images from the past 24 hours. Slideshow
Special report: Tracking Iran's nuclear money trail to Turkey
Tweet This
Share on LinkedIn
Share on Facebook
Factbox
FACTBOX-Reaction to Basel III bank capital rules
Mon, Sep 13 2010
Related News
UPDATE 1-Turkey's PM tells businessmen to boost Iran trade
Thu, Sep 16 2010
Turkey's PM tells businessmen to boost Iran trade
Thu, Sep 16 2010
Sanctions deter some Turkish banks from Iran trade
Tue, Sep 14 2010
Basel eases capital fears, top banks in spotlight
Mon, Sep 13 2010
Analysis & Opinion
African agricultural finance under the spotlight
Related Topics
World »
Turkey »
1 / 4
A general view of the entrance to the European-Iranian Trade Bank AG (EIH Bank) in the northern German town of Hamburg, September 8, 2010.
Credit: Reuters/Christian Charisius
By Louis Charbonneau
UNITED NATIONS |
Mon Sep 20, 2010 10:39am EDT
UNITED NATIONS (Reuters) -- Turkey and other U.S. allies have been allowing Iranian banks with suspected links to Tehran's nuclear program to do business within their borders, frustrating Western countries trying to put a financial squeeze on the Islamic Republic, Reuters has learned.
An examination of classified reports and interviews with Western diplomats, government and intelligence officials underscore that Turkey and others have resisted international pressure to make it harder for Iran to finance its uranium enrichment program.
"Turkey's blossoming financial-economic relationship with Iran provides Iran with a gateway to the entire European financial system," according to an intelligence report on Turkey and Iran provided to Reuters by a diplomat. "The fact that Turkey is allowing itself to be used as a conduit for Iranian activity via Turkish banks and the Turkish lira is making it possible for Iranian funds in Turkish guise to make their way into Europe."
Turkey, a NATO member that looks to join the European Union, has enjoyed growing economic and financial relations with neighboring Iran. Trade between the two nations reached $10 billion in 2008 and could triple in five years, Turkish Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan told a group of businessmen he met together with Iran's First Vice President Mohammad Reza Rahimi last week.
Much of that trade is legitimate, but if Turkey becomes a virtual safe haven for Iranian banking activities, it will be easier for Tehran to dodge sanctions, according to diplomats.
Ankara's move closer to its eastern neighbor, which is a major energy supplier to Turkey, comes at a time of growing international isolation for Tehran. Iran has been stepping up its uranium enrichment program, which the West fears is aimed at building a nuclear bomb and Tehran says is purely peaceful.
Even so, persuading Turkey to overlook its own economic interests and restrict the activities of the more than a dozen Iranian banks the United States and EU have sanctioned won't be easy. Ankara is obligated to implement just the U.N. measures, and only Turkish banks with business in the United States could face U.S. penalties for dealing with Iranian companies blacklisted by Washington.
BLACKLISTED
Earlier this year the United States, Britain and others pushed the U.N. to blacklist Iran's central bank, the Export Development Bank of Iran, Bank Mellat and other Iranian financial institutions. But they met with fierce resistance from China, which has close business ties with and imports much of its crude oil from Iran.
Those banks, U.S. and EU officials argued, have turned to Europe, the Middle East, Asia and Africa to finance Iran's illicit procurement activities for its nuclear and missile programs, sometimes covering up the fact that they were working on behalf of other blacklisted Iranian banks.
In the end, the U.N. Security Council only added one bank -- a subsidiary of Mellat called First East Export Bank -- to its blacklist. Although Mellat itself avoided any sanctions, resolution 1929 noted that over the last seven years it has "facilitated hundreds of millions of dollars in transactions for Iranian nuclear, missile and defense entities."
The U.S. and EU, for their part, slapped Mellat, Iran's second largest bank, with sanctions on their own. But the bank continues to operate branches in three Turkish cities -- Istanbul, Ankara and Izmir -- without any visible interference from the Turkish government.
This has irked the United States and EU, which have grown frustrated with what they see as Turkey's conciliatory approach to Iran -- and simultaneous cooling of relations with Tehran's arch enemy Israel, a longtime Turkish ally.
Turkey and fellow rotating Security Council member Brazil became the first two nations to vote against a U.N. sanctions resolution on Iran in June. In the past, the few dissenting members have abstained.
The two nations attributed their move to the dismissive response by the U.S. and EU to a Turkish-Brazilian plan to revive a stalled nuclear-fuel-swap deal with Iran. They had hoped the proposal would help resolve the standoff with Iran, eliminating the need for new sanctions -- a view Washington, London and Paris did not share.
Turkey has said it does not want any atomic weapons in the region -- which could apply to Israel as well as Tehran. But it is also worried that a more confrontational approach to Iran's nuclear program could lead to another war in the Middle East.
Turkey's finance and economy ministries as well as individual banks refused to comment for this story. But Turkish officials sometimes complain privately that the nation gets beaten up by Western media because of Ankara's criticism of Israel's stance toward the Palestinians as well as its position on Iran's nuclear program. Western officials say they are only trying to encourage Ankara, a candidate for European Union entry, to assume a more cautious approach toward Iran.
Apart from First East Export Bank, the only Iranian bank blacklisted by the four U.N. Security Council sanctions resolutions passed during the past four years is Bank Sepah. But U.N. warnings about two other banks, Bank Melli and Bank Saderat, have also led to their de facto blacklisting, while the United States and EU have identified many more Iranian banks to be shunned.
The U.S. Treasury Department alone has blacklisted 17 Iranian banks to date, making it illegal for any bank that does business in the United States to have contact with those institutions. Individuals and firms sanctioned by the Security Council face global travel bans and asset freezes.
HIGH-LEVEL VISIT
A senior official at the U.S. Treasury Department told Reuters that Deputy Assistant Secretary for Terrorist Financing and Financial Crimes Daniel Glaser recently went to Turkey to brief local officials on the tough new U.S. sanctions, adopted in the wake of the latest U.N. measures on Iran.
"They (Turkey) are a matter of concern," the Treasury official said on condition of anonymity. "They are not a unique concern, but they are a matter of concern. We will go everywhere, but there is a reason why we also went to Turkey."
He added that other Treasury officials have visited Bahrain, United Arab Emirates, Lebanon, Brazil, Ecuador and other countries to get the message out.
The Export Development Bank of Iran and Eximbank of Turkey, Western diplomats said, agreed earlier this year to cooperate on trade in the two nations' local currencies. Bank Mellat, they said, now operates a Turkish lira bank account at its Istanbul branch.
Turkey's Erdogan and Iran's Rahimi oversaw a meeting last week which brought together over 100 businessmen, including Turkish investors eager to put their money into Iran's mostly government-owned textile, machinery and automotive industries. At the meeting, some Turkish businessmen were enthusiastic about the idea of closer economic ties to Iran, while others backed away.
"This is a big opportunity for Turkey," said Mehmet Koca, member of the executive board of the Turkey-Iran business group. "Finance and trade that was carried out by Dubai and the United Arab Emirates before the sanctions can be taken over by Turkey," said Koca, who is also the general manager of Turkish fertilizer company Gubretas.
For this reason, Western diplomats fear, Turkey could become a gaping hole in the international sanctions regime. "Turkey is seen by Iran as a convenient arena for activity aimed at bypassing international sanctions to enable Iranian financial activity in Europe and the rest of the world," the intelligence report said.
Some Turkish banks have curtailed business with Iran. Younes Hormozi, chairman of Bank Mellat's Turkish unit, told Reuters that Bank Mellat Turkey had dealt with a higher number of transactions since some Turkish banks halted activities with Iran. He said several Turkish banks with close ties to the EU and United States have halted financial trade with Iran due to U.N. sanctions.
Hormozi confirmed that an American delegation visiting Turkey had warned banks about taking sides, prompting some to pull out of Iranian transactions. He said there had been no pressure placed on banks from the Turkish government and the banks had acted independently to cut trade with Iran.
SOUTH KOREA AND OTHERS
Until recently, envoys and intelligence officials say, there were similar problems in another country that has historically been a close ally of the United States -- South Korea.
In Seoul, where for months the U.S. Treasury Department had been pressing authorities to shut down the operations of Bank Mellat, the Finance Ministry recently announced that it was blacklisting Mellat and 101 other companies and 24 individuals for aiding Iran's nuclear program.
But South Korean authorities simultaneously asked the Central Bank of Iran to set up a South Korean won-denominated account. Seoul's finance ministry said last week Iran's central bank had agreed to open won accounts at two South Korean state-owned banks to avert disruption in bilateral trade from the sanctions.
Western diplomats said they would keep an eye on South Korea, which was slow to act against Bank Mellat and continues to trade heavily with Tehran. South Korea was Iran's sixth biggest trading partner in 2009.
Turkey and South Korea are not alone. "Many (financial) institutions continue to do business with the Islamic Republic, essentially undermining the overall sanctions effort," Avi Jorisch, a U.S. financial intelligence expert and head of the Red Cell Intelligence Group consultancy told a recent U.S. congressional committee hearing.
There are also concerns about at least one EU bank. The intelligence report on Turkey and Iran obtained by Reuters said that Austria's Oberbank maintains a euro account at the Turkish state-owned bank Halk Bankasi, possibly "to help its Iranian customers trade and transfer funds via the Turkish bank to a European third party."
In a statement to Reuters, Oberbank insisted that it was not violating the U.N. or EU sanctions and was only engaging in Iran-related transactions with "customers it has known for many years." It noted that such transactions are carefully screened, and any that raise suspicions must be vetted by the bank's compliance officer.
It acknowledged that Oberbank has a euro account at Halk Bankasi to make life easier for its Turkish clients but said that account had been in existence for many years.
"Oberbank has worked with Halk Bankasi and many other Turkish banks on customer transactions for decades without problems," Oberbank said. Halk declined to comment.
Security Council member Austria, unlike Turkey, voted for the new U.N. sanctions against Iran in June.
Germany is among the EU countries that have recently cracked down on Iranian banking activities on their territory. Earlier this month the United States slapped sanctions on European-Iranian Trade Bank (EIH) in Hamburg, which the U.S. Treasury Department said had facilitated millions of dollars in transactions for Iranian missile companies and other blacklisted firms, sometimes in cooperation with Bank Mellat.
Although the EU has not officially sanctioned EIH yet, a spokesman for Germany's Finance Ministry made clear that restrictive measures were being applied to all Iranian banks in the EU's largest economy: "Subsidiaries or branches of Iranian banks are not conducting any business activity in Germany."
CENTRAL BANK
The United States, Britain and some other European countries have also considered the possibility of sanctioning the Central Bank of Iran (CBI), which one Western diplomat described as the "kingpin" of Iran's efforts to conceal banned transactions outside Iran.
But the idea lacked sufficient support on the Security Council for inclusion in the latest round of sanctions. China and Russia, which have close economic ties with Tehran and fought to dilute all four U.N. sanctions resolutions before adoption, rejected it.
The United States and EU have also decided not to blacklist the CBI, which could make it difficult for Iran to engage in any foreign trade, though they persuaded other Security Council members to urge U.N. member states to be vigilant regarding all transactions linked to the CBI.
The CBI has been helping sanctioned Iranian banks cover their tracks by arranging for alternate institutions to carry out transactions on their behalf, U.S. and EU officials say. The CBI then settles accounts back in Tehran, away from the prying eyes of Western authorities.
Western officials say that Dubai also remains a key financial center for Iran. Dubai was Iran's fifth biggest trading partner in 2009.
Authorities in Dubai say that they have been cracking down on Iranian activities and are complying with the U.N. sanctions, but Western diplomats voiced skepticism. "I haven't seen anything to indicate that Dubai has changed in any fundamental way," a Western envoy said.
Even though Iran has pressed ahead with its nuclear program, and is enriching uranium to levels much closer to those needed for weapons than ever before, Western officials insist that the international sanctions have slowed down Tehran's progress on its atomic program.
"The four U.N. sanctions resolutions have had an impact," a senior Western diplomat told Reuters. "It's not easy to quantify, but we estimate that the sanctions have delayed Iran's nuclear program by 18 months to two years."
They add that the setback would be more severe if all countries implemented the sanctions as aggressively as they could. (Additional reporting by Andrew Quinn and Arshad Mohammed in Washington, Sylvia Westall in Vienna, Dave Graham in Berlin, Jack Kim in Seoul and Ibon Villelabeitia, Evrim Ergin and other reporters in Istanbul; Editing by Jim Impoco and Claudia Parsons)
World
Turkey
Add a Comment
*We welcome comments that advance the story directly or with relevant tangential information. We try to block comments that use offensive language or appear to be spam and review comments frequently to ensure they meet our standards. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters.
© Copyright 2010 Thomson Reuters
Editorial Editions:
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
United States
Reuters
Contact Us
Advertise With Us
Help
Journalism Handbook
Archive
Site Index
Video Index
Reader Feedback
Mobile
Newsletters
RSS
Podcasts
Widgets
Your View
Analyst Research
Thomson Reuters
Copyright
Disclaimer
Privacy
Professional Products
Professional Products Support
Financial Products
About Thomson Reuters
Careers
Online Products
Acquisitions Monthly
Buyouts
Venture Capital Journal
International Financing Review
Project Finance International
PEhub.com
PE Week
FindLaw
Reuters on Facebook
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
Other News on Monday, 20 September 2010 Egypt's spy chief meets Hamas leader in Saudi
Dutch police arrest terror suspect at airport: prosecutors
Iran denies detaining seven US troops
Ahmadinejad calls on U.S. to release 8 Iranians
|
Germany's HRE bank defends millions in bonus payments
Four die as woman opens fire in German town
|
Boxer Hatton denies cocaine problem
ETA says ready to go further for peace
United, Continental Airlines Stockholders Approve Merger
Florida Couple Plead Guilty To Forcing Foreigners Into Cheap Labor
Virginia Governor Refuses To Call Off Woman's Execution
Police Fear Group Suicide Plot In LA Area
Nigeria security adviser quits to challenge Jonathan
|
Iran Denies Arresting U.S. Troops
Dutch arrest terrorism suspect at Schiphol
|
Electronic Payment Solution Processes $6 Billion
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Ben Affleck steals box office crown with "Town"
Yemen Outlaws Motorcycles
England cricketer appears naked in gay magazine
Germany's beer fest deploys stench-eating bacteria
UK police leader says: 'decriminalise cannabis'
S.African maize may feed Chinese chickens
China's Sinochem asks government to back Potash bid
Global brands face growing labour militancy in Asia
Ben Affleck steals box office crown with Town
|
King's Speech wins top Toronto film fest prize
|
Twin Baghdad car bombs kill 29
US hiker feels 'one-third free' as friends stay in Iran jail
Sweden coalition lose majority as far-right surge
China media warn Japan over escalating sea row
|
US-TECH Summary
Four killed in Germany shootings: police
BP's broken well in Gulf of Mexico is 'dead'
American released from Iran prison says she's no spy
|
Ahmadinejad calls on U.S. to release 8 Iranians
Apple's latest iPhone to go on sale in China on Saturday
Australia warns of C.Games terror attack 'risk'
Oracle unveils new hardware for managing cloud computing
'Serious concern' over fraud at Afghan elections
Swedish center-right wins vote, losses majority
|
American Detained In Iran Arrives Home
Pakistan cricket chief says England threw game
Toyota Settles Runaway Lexus Accident Claims With Relatives Of Dead Victims
Cancer: New gene clues point to women's 'silent killers'
Dutch arrest British terrorism suspect at Schiphol
|
"Modern Family" Releasing Complete 1st Season Blu-Ray, DVD
Facebook denies plans to build its own phone
Missing Cult Members Found Praying In Park
'Hacktivity 2010' tackles computer security in Hungary
EU acts to extend digital switchover to remote and elderly
Strong German opposition to Google Street View: report
Moral search engines squeeze out sin on Internet
Ghost of communal riots haunts India mosque verdict
|
Tajikistan blames Islamist militants for ambush
|
After pummelling Taiwan, storm Fanapi hits China
Hurricane Igor passes Bermuda with no direct hit
Rich donors urge rethink of aid at U.N. poverty meet
|
Lockerbie bomber 'can get out of bed, walk'
13 dead in India train crash: officials
Pope, ending his trip, recalls Nazi terror in WW2
|
Top Mideast officials fly to US as peace talks crisis looms
Q+A
Woman opens fire in German town, four killed
|
Seven held in China over new tainted milk find: report
Indonesian anti-terror squad kills three suspects
Randy Quaid arrested for squatting in old home
Police probe Delhi shooting amid fear for C.Games
Italian press blasts "Eat Pray Love" as kitsch
Powerful typhoon heads for China after lashing Taiwan
'The King's Speech' wins Toronto film fest award
Australia warns 'high risk of terrorism' at C.Games
Affleck heist film tops US box office
Malaysia buys China bonds in boost for renminbi: report
Australia's Wiggles still on song after 20 years
Oracle unveils new hardware for managing cloud computing
|
Protesters urge Madrid to adopt debate on bullfighting ban
Typhoon injures 107, shuts plants in Taiwan; China next
Facebook denies plans to build its own phone
|
"King's Speech" wins top Toronto film fest prize
Seoul shares rangebound in light pre-holiday trade
Apple's latest iPhone to go on sale in China on Saturday
|
S.Korean bonds edge up in thin pre-holiday trade
Seoul shares open lower;caution before holiday
RPT-PREVIEW-Taiwan August export orders seen up 20.2 pct y/y
NZ services sector growth picks up in August
Indian group weighs MGM bid: report
China a beacon for foreign clean tech firms
Indonesian companies cash in on boom times
China central bank adviser says no to yuan pressure: report
Randy Quaid arrested for squatting in old home
|
Lindsay Lohan tweets that she failed drug test
|
YouTube and Guggenheim showcase video artists
|
Italian press blasts Eat Pray Love as kitsch
|
Special report
Competition watchdog fines French banks 384 mln euros
Karzai believes too early to judge Afghan election
|
Dell to invest $100 billion in China by 2020
Iran hits at U.N. nuclear watchdog, defies West
Iran hits at U.N. nuclear watchdog, defies West
|
New film to chronicle the birth of Facebook
BP oil spill costs hit $9.5 bln
UK forces hand over Afghan district to US
IMF-EU delay Greek bank tests: report
Bill Clinton philanthropy meeting eyes Haiti, Pakistan
|
Pastor Terry Jones Billed $180K For Security Surrounding Protest
Israel angered over Russian plan to sell Syria missiles
Special report: Tracking Iran's nuclear money trail to Turkey
|
Fraud claims cast shadow over Afghan poll
Senate Candidate Dabbled In Occult
Mladic arrest vital for war crimes courts: prosecutor
|
Missing Georgia Boy May Be In Danger
Iran presses US as freed American returns
IBM To Buy Netezza For $1.7 Billion
U.N. chief urges donors not to divert aid from poor
|
Abercrombie Up Against Hawaii Lt. Gov. In November Governor Race
Ireland needs to rethink budget plan: central bank government
|
Afghan vote observers: Fraud must be investigated
Canadian Aborigine Leaders Want U.S. To Stop "Dirty Oil" Flow
Many Cases Of Childhood Obesity Could Be Caused By Viruses
Kids With H1N1 Had More Seizures Than Those With Seasonal Flu
British troops leave volatile Afghan district
India snubbed by Kashmir separatists
UK hands over violent Afghan district to U.S. troops
|
Japan calls for calm as China boat row escalates
Homes Destroyed After Guardmen's Training Sparks Fire
"The Town" Finishes First Place, "Easy A" Debuts Strong At Second
Ousted Malaysian sultan mounts legal challenge
New TV thriller "Event" a test of viewer patience
Australia and U.S. warn citizens as India probes shooting
Lady Gaga, Katy Perry lead MTV Europe nominations
China media warn Japan over escalating sea row
"Monsters" sets standard for guerrilla filmmaking
World powers to tackle climate amid skepticism
Anwar loses bid to strike out sodomy charges
YouTube and Guggenheim showcase video artists
Thai army says grenades missing
India seeks upgrades for BlackBerry monitoring: sources
|
Muslim rebels clash with Phillipine troops
Verizon names new COO, likely CEO successor
|
BUY OR SELL-S.Korean retailers: How long can they outperform?
Ghost of communal riots haunts India mosque verdict
Special Report: Welcome to Nokia, Mr Elop
|
Cambodian PM to urge Obama to cancel "dirty" debt
Vietnam's mooncakes 'grease wheels of commerce'
IBM to buy analytics firm Netezza for $1.7 billion
|
Seoul shares end slightly up in pre-holiday trade
Q+A-How China trade will help Taiwan retool its economy
Germany debating privacy with Google and peers
|
PAKISTAN
NZ consumer confidence flat in Sept
New TV thriller Event a test of viewer patience
|
Fashion world bids farewell to Alexander McQueen
|
Lady Gaga, Katy Perry lead MTV Europe nominations
|
King's Speech wins top Toronto film fest prize
|
India seeks upgrades for BlackBerry monitoring: sources
Monsters sets standard for guerrilla filmmaking
|
Germany debating privacy with Google and peers
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights