Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Germany must pay Afghan victims of NATO raid: Lawyer
|
Edition:
U.S.
Article
Save
Email
Print
Reprints
Most Popular
Most Shared
UPDATE 1-Drug data mining ban unlikely in Senate health bill
14 Dec 2009
Fewer Americans worried by climate change: survey
15 Dec 2009
Boeing Dreamliner touches down after first flight
| Video
15 Dec 2009
For tsunami's Baby 81, fame brought misfortune
| Video
6:08am EST
YouTube looks at subscriptions, more ad dollars
15 Dec 2009
Fewer Americans worried by climate change: survey
15 Dec 2009
UPDATE 1-Drug data mining ban unlikely in Senate health bill
14 Dec 2009
WITNESS: Failed state? Try Pakistan's M2 motorway
15 Dec 2009
Branson offers Lotus F1 boss a stewardess challenge
15 Dec 2009
French minister tells Muslims to speak properly
15 Dec 2009
Germany must pay Afghan victims of NATO raid: Lawyer
Golnar Motevalli
KABUL
Wed Dec 16, 2009 9:44am EST
KABUL (Reuters) - The victims of a German-ordered NATO raid in northern Afghanistan that killed scores of civilians must be compensated for the rest of their lives by the German government, their lawyer said on Wednesday.
World
On September 4, a U.S. fighter jet called in by German troops struck two fuel trucks that NATO said at the time had been hijacked by Taliban insurgents.
Germany's defense minister at the time has since stepped down because of the incident, which the Afghan government said killed 99 people including 30 civilians. Independent rights groups estimate between 60 and 70 civilians were killed.
Karim Popal, an Afghan-born German lawyer from Bremen who has taken on the case of 165 Afghans in Kunduz and who lost relatives in the airstrike, said what they needed was not money, but a guarantee from the German government that it would build the homes, schools and clinics they need to continue their lives.
"In Kunduz, a large number of young people have lost fathers and whole families. There are a large number of widows now. It is the responsibility of the German government to help them," Popal told Reuters.
German courts, according to Popal, are prepared to work with him and his team in order to avoid the case going to trial, but the government's latest offer of compensation was inadequate.
"They suggested 3 million euros ($4.36 million), but we have not accepted this because this is not just a matter of money, but about the livelihoods of these people and the rest of their lives."
Popal said a team of six lawyers, including two women, went to Kunduz for a month and a half after the air strike to carry out research, interview residents and victims and gather information about those who lost relatives.
"We have come to the conclusion, after the work that we did, that 137 were killed who were not Taliban," Popal said. According to his findings, 56 children were among those killed and the number of Taliban insurgents killed could have been as few as five or six.
"But even if they killed 10 Taliban or more, that does not justify killing 137 people."
Popal said he was looking into similar cases in Afghanistan where civilians had been killed in NATO-led air strikes but would not disclose which incidents he was looking to work on.
The air strike sparked outrage in Afghanistan and was publicly condemned by Afghan President Hamid Karzai, and turned many Germans against the war.
In Berlin a parliamentary investigation into the raid will begin to shed light on what Merkel's government knew about the killings and whether it deliberately suppressed details of the attack before she had to face a federal election on September 27.
Popal said he wanted Germany to take an active role in developing the district of Char Dara, where the air strike took place, by building schools, clinics and houses and helping women who were widowed to live independent lives so that they could look after their families properly.
"For these women houses must be built. She has to be able to live the life of the man that has been killed, to be able to make a living," Popal said.
(Reporting by Golnar Motevalli; Editing by Bill Tarrant)
World
More from Reuters
Housing starts, consumer prices up in November
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - New home construction rose less than expected last month, while consumer prices increased marginally, suggesting little urgency for the Federal Reserve to raise interest rates sooner as the economy steadily recovers. | Video
Fine for Credit Suisse raises Iran alarm
Stocks seen notching up more gains in 2010
Global stock market rally has further to run
Stocks set to open up after data
| Video
Iran tests missile, warns opposition leaders
| Video
» More Top News
No great expectations
Investors are getting antsy about when the Fed will tighten its purse strings, now that the economy appears to be coming back to life. Full Article
Bernanke: Banks stable, lending weak
Time magazine's Person of the Year
ECONOMY
Iran tests upgraded missile
Hardline rulers send uncompromising signals to foes at home and abroad, testing a missile that could reach Israel and warning of legal action against opposition leaders. Full Article | Video
U.S. missile agency readies Iran plans
Factbox: Iran's missiles, recent tests
Iran
© Copyright 2009 Thomson Reuters
Editorial Editions:
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
United States
Reuters
Contact Us
Advertise With Us
Help
Journalism Handbook
Archive
Site Index
Video Index
Analyst Research
Mobile
Newsletters
RSS
Podcasts
Widgets
Your View
Labs
Thomson Reuters
Copyright
Disclaimer
Privacy
Professional Products
Professional Products Support
Financial Products
About Thomson Reuters
Careers
Online Products
Acquisitions Monthly
Buyouts.com
Buyouts Europe:
Buyouts Conferences:
Venture Capital Journal
ECVJ
International Financing Review
International Securitisation Report
Project Finance International
PEhub.com
PE Week
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
Other News on Wednesday, 16 December 2009 Hamas blames Israel for breakdown in Schalit talks
Berlusconi to curb his public duties after attack
YouTube looks at subscriptions, more ad dollars
Wall Street Journal launches Japanese website
Latin Americans, EU strike historic deal on banana trade
Contractor arrest may ruffle Obama's Cuba overture
|
Microsoft suspends Juku amid plagiarism charges
Minister seeks closure of anti-Berlusconi websites
Red Cross sees Taliban captives in Afghanistan
Bullock, Streep, Damon Score Double Nods At The Golden Globes
US industrial production regains vigor, up 0.8%
S.Korea's LG aims to sell 400,000 3D TVs next year
Jay-Z's 40/40 Club Sued For Beating Patron
Germany's largest-ever class action suit kicks off
Sun Micro wins intellectual property cases
Grammy Nominee Buju Banton Arrested On Drug Charges
Leona Lewis' Attacker Detained Under The Mental Health Act
NATO to seek Russian kit, trainers for Afghanistan
|
Mexico's Calderon seeks broad electoral reform
|
"CSI: Miami" Star Jonathan Togo Arrested For Domestic Violence
Courtney Love Loses Custody Of Daughter Frances Bean Cobain
French minister tells Muslims to speak properly
|
S.Korea's LG aims to sell 400,000 3D TVs next year
"30 Rock" Actor Grizz Chapman Needs Kidney Transplant
Kid Rock And Dave Grohl Sue Small Town Bar Over Copyright Infringement
Taylor Swift Donates $250K To Public Schools On Her 20th Birthday
Arlington, Va., educators cancel Taliban debate
Jury: Naveed Haq guilty in Jewish center shooting
Snow storm stalls search for missing Ore. climbers
Blast kills 33 near lawmaker's home in Pakistan
Mass. 2nd-grader sent home for crucifix drawing
Suicide blast kills 33 in crowded Pakistani market
Google investing for growth in display ads
|
3 RI cops shot in drug raid released from hospital
YouTube looks at subscriptions, more ad dollars
|
China official's royal audience stirs ire in Japan
Schools, roads close as heavy rain drenches South
Comcast rolls out Web TV service nationally
|
Gotta love it! NYC holds condom contest
Blast kills 20 near minister's home in Pakistan
Gitmo detainees not free in US after prison
Japan to halt new missile defence spending: media
Spymaster sees Israel as world cyberwar leader
|
'Goodfellas' mobster blames alcohol for arrest
Philippines wins marathon double at SE.Asian Games
Lieberman indicates support for health bill
Myanmar allows Suu Kyi to meet ailing party elders
Suicide bombing blast near former VP home in Kabul
China says Uighur asylum seekers are criminals
Pakistan market bombing kills 27: official
Chinese firms slam UN wind farm rulings
'Up In the Air', 'Avatar' head Golden Globes contenders
Golden Globe nominations announced
Golden Globe animated film nominations announced
Quirky Glee hits high note at Golden Globes
|
Cameron and Weaver on 'Aliens,' and 'Avatar'
Quirky "Glee" hits high note at Golden Globes
Lindsay Lohan's father arrested in NY
Lil Wayne heads to NY jail in February
Binge drinking soars among German youth, data show
'Up In the Air', 'Avatar' head Golden Globes contenders
Spanish catering industry protests planned smoking ban
Madrid's Prado woos art lovers despite crisis
'Goodfellas' mobster blames alcohol for arrest
CORRECTED: "Nanny Returns" to New York's now troubled elite
U.S. House passes Iran gasoline sanctions bill
NATO chief in first Russia visit to rebuild trust
For tsunami's Baby 81, fame brought misfortune
|
Iranian elections top Twitter topic for 2009
Britain urgently seeks changes after Livni arrest warrant
Boeing's Dreamliner in maiden flight
BA launches legal action to stop Christmas strike
YouTube leads Google charge in display ad market
WITNESS: Failed state? Try Pakistan's M2 motorway
|
Earliest proven case of leprosy found in Israel
Iran students hold rival rallies, bazaar closes
Twitter gets more business friendly
Baby among five killed in Iraq attacks
Boeing's 787 Dreamliner takes off on maiden flight
Cocaine and rebels haunt Peru's remote jungle
|
Miami Herald asking online readers for contributions
Israel responsible for delay in freeing Shalit: Hamas chief
Border stability to top China-Myanmar talks
|
OMG! Text messaging up sharply in US since 2003: study
Iran ex-rebels defy police orders to quit Iraq camp
US-TECH Summary
Hundreds evacuated after quake rocks central Italy
|
Borders jumps into digital books fray
USGS turns to Twitter for earthquake reports
Italy to beef up security after Berlusconi assault
|
Spymaster sees Israel as world cyberwar leader
Mobile sales to fall 0.7 percent this year: Gartner
Car hits horse-drawn Va. holiday hayride; 12 hurt
Pittsburgh City Council set to vote on tuition tax
FBI squad to assist NYC terror trial prosecutors
Vietnam asks China to return seized fishing boats
Report: NKorea presses for lifting of UN sanctions
Borders jumps into digital books fray
|
US House approves Iran energy sector sanctions bill
Weather forecast for the Asia-Pacific region
Attorney: Missing Utah mom's husband met with cops
Police kill separatist rebel leader in Papua
80-year-old sailor rescued in Gulf of Mexico
Smog sinks Hong Kong's famous skyline
Border stability to top China-Myanmar talks
Envoy delivered Obama letter to NKorea leader: report
Man pleads not guilty to 1981 Calif. triple murder
One woman's fight against pollution in China
Google phone with T-Mobile contract in Jan: source
|
New Zealand teen flashes driver, gets hit by car
Asia leaves its mark on 2009 in sports
Pakistani rupee trades at record low of 84.55
Even top Hollywood directors feel like outsiders
WRAPUP 1-S.Korea signals exit strategy, mortgage squeeze
US presses for Asia-Pacific trade deal
FACTBOX-South Korea to tighten banking rules
China: foreign direct investment up 32 pct in Nov
Taiwan dlr eases on stocks ahead of US Fed meeting
Seoul shares turn lower; techs, shipbuilders weigh
S.Korea bonds fall on U.S. lead, strong shares
Golden Globe nominations boost underdogs
|
S.Korea won down; fin ministry to report 2010 focus
Even top Hollywood directors feel like outsiders
|
"Avatar" starts long march toward profitability
Seoul shares open flat;tech exporters lend support
ABBA, Stooges to join Rock and Roll Hall of Fame
|
Feast or famine for Golden Globe nominees
Avatar starts long march toward profitability
|
Even top Hollywood directors feel like outsiders
Metallica, Slayer to tour together
|
Washington city votes to legalize gay marriage
Feast or famine for Golden Globe nominees
|
Smog sinks Hong Kong's famous skyline
Mundane Morgans wastes talented cast
|
Europeans dominate Golden Globe foreign film group
|
Michael Jackson estate administrators seek payment
Fitness guru Jack LaLanne undergoes surgery in LA
Scorsese, Polanski thrillers join Berlin lineup
|
True Blood finds its sexy werewolf
|
CORRECTED: Europeans dominate Golden Globe foreign film group
'Dance' finale expects a well-behaved Lambert
Scorsese, Polanski thrillers join Berlin lineup
Abbas says peace deal possible in 6 months
Architect of Russia's shock therapy reform dead
US university coding future of news
Century-old butter found in Scott's Antarctic hut
Iran tests long-range missile, raises ire of West
Iran tests missile, warns opposition leaders
|
Bing app for iPhones hits App Store
PLO keeps Abbas as Palestinian president
Fed set to keep extra support for fragile US economy
Pakistani Supreme Court reconsiders amnesty ruling
|
Afghan surge troops won't target drug crops
|
Kuwait's prime minister survives key vote
Nigerian government sued over president's absence
|
Iran test-fires missile, drawing Western censure
Cyprus seeks Interpol help to find stolen corpse
|
Iran says U.S. fuel sanctions move will fail
Muslim revival brings polygamy, camels to Chechnya
|
Man arrested outside Berlusconi hospital room
|
I shot Guinea leader soldier tells French radio
|
Germany must pay Afghan victims of NATO raid: Lawyer
|
Obama to host new safety chairwoman, NASA chief
Protest erupts in Indian parliament over inflation
Filipino dictator's son open to presidency
Federal Trade Commission sues chip giant Intel
|
Microsoft browser pledge ends EU dispute
|
Study: Sexually active girls at risk of infection
AP source: Obama writes letter to NKorean leader
China's anti-porn drive to run until May
|
Lava flow from Philippine volcano continues: govt
SC legislators consider formal rebuke of governor
Japan PM under fire over delay in US base row
Indonesia police say Papuan rebel commander killed
'You lie!' on Yale list of year's memorable quotes
US calls Japan base delay decision unfortunate
Custody dispute may have led to shooting deaths
Indonesia to separate child inmates from teens
House rushes to finish its work for year
N.Korea's Kim raps foreign hairstyles: report
Myanmar opposition leader meets party elders
Mo. farmers with best land face 2011 tax rise
SPIN METER: No real consensus on bank overhaul
Documents in probe of wayward plane to be released
Banks to get more time on new global rules: report
Thai auto sales growth highest in years: industry
China's Chery dismisses foreign car purchase plans
China defends home grown tech purchase rule
India's Bharti to buy Bangladesh mobile operator
S.Korea bond futures dive on rate hike, Fed fears
Japan enters high-speed train sales race
Swiss won't decide on Polanski extradition until 2010
|
'Glee' cast joyful over Globe nods
Layered cake breathes life back into tiny US island
Metallica, Slayer to tour together
Seychelles getting 'sinking feeling'
Once an underdog, Reitman now an Oscar favorite
Golden Globe nominations boost underdogs
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights