Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Drones kill low-level militants, few civilians: U.S.
|
Edition:
U.S.
Article
Comments (0)
Save
Email
Print
Reprints
Most Popular
Most Shared
U.S. arrests Pakistani-American over failed car bomb
| Video
3:04am EDT
U.S. reveals size of nuclear arsenal
03 May 2010
Man arrested in New York failed car bomb: source
12:46am EDT
Starbucks sued over hot tea alleged to cause burns
03 May 2010
Police barred from penis enlargement
23 Apr 2010
Iran: Punish U.S. for "shameful" nuclear threats
| Video
03 May 2010
UPDATE 1-Man arrested in New York failed car bomb -source
12:43am EDT
FDA still probing Friday's J&J recall
03 May 2010
Progress toward Gulf oil well cap
| Video
03 May 2010
Oil falls to $86 on firm dollar, high U.S. stockpiles
| Video
3:33am EDT
Starbucks sued over hot tea alleged to cause burns
03 May 2010
Google expands venture group, wants more deals
03 May 2010
U.S. reveals size of nuclear arsenal
03 May 2010
Police barred from penis enlargement
23 Apr 2010
FDA still probing Friday's J&J recall
03 May 2010
U.S. firm recalls infant, children's Tylenol
03 May 2010
Iran: Punish U.S. for "shameful" nuclear threats
| Video
03 May 2010
U.S. reviews diabetes, heart risk with prostate drugs
03 May 2010
U.S. arrests Pakistani-American over failed car bomb
| Video
3:04am EDT
Man arrested in New York failed car bomb: source
12:46am EDT
Analysis
UK poll may speed change in U.S. special relationship
Britain's 'special relationship' with the United States, already past its heyday, may become increasingly humdrum if Thursday's parliamentary election delivers a weak, minority government. Full Article
Drones kill low-level militants, few civilians: U.S.
Adam Entous
WASHINGTON
Mon May 3, 2010 8:48pm EDT
Related News
Pakistan Taliban leader alive, threatens U.S. attacks
Mon, May 3 2010
Timeline: Attacks on U.S. targets
Sun, May 2 2010
Suicide bomber in Pakistan's Swat kills 5: officials
Sat, May 1 2010
Pakistan agents believe Taliban's Mehsud is alive
Thu, Apr 29 2010
Risk of mass civilian deaths in Russia jumps: study
Tue, Apr 27 2010
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - U.S. estimates show CIA drone strikes in Pakistan's tribal areas over the last two years have killed more than 500 militants -- a fraction of whom are considered top-tier leaders -- and fewer than 30 civilians, officials said on Monday.
World
The number of so-called combatant and noncombatant casualties in the U.S. government tally is sharply lower than some Pakistani press accounts, which have estimated civilian deaths alone at more than 600.
Disclosing a partial tally of drone strikes since the summer of 2008, when the program was ramped up under then-President George W. Bush, could help the U.S. intelligence community counter protests from Pakistan and human rights groups about the civilian death toll.
But the numbers also show that the vast majority of the 500 killed -- more than 90 percent by some measure -- are lower-level fighters, raising questions about how much the CIA knows about each individual before they are killed, experts said.
Analysts said the truth about civilian casualties was difficult to ascertain because the region is largely inaccessible to outsiders and it is unclear what criteria the CIA uses to pick its targets and to determine who constitutes a combatant.
A U.S. counterterrorism official, who spoke on condition of anonymity, said the estimate was compiled using available intelligence as well as visual images -- presumably from the unmanned aerial drones which can circle overhead for hours after they strike to assess the damage.
There has been little independent verification of casualties in the tribal areas as reporters are generally not allowed to travel there except on occasional trips chaperoned by the Pakistani military.
Tallies by Reuters and other organizations suggest the death toll since mid-2008 was significantly higher than 500. A Reuters count showed nearly 850 people killed in at least 110 strikes since 2008.
DEFINITIONS UNCLEAR
Of those killed by the drones, roughly 14 are considered by experts to be top-tier leaders of al Qaeda, the Taliban or other militant groups, while another two dozen are deemed high-to-mid level leaders.
"Just because they're not big names doesn't mean they don't kill. They do," the U.S. counterterrorism official said. "Their facilities -- where they prepare, rest and ready weapons -- are legitimate targets, too."
The official said the CIA strikes were not "random" and are based on "information and observation, gathered over time."
Officials said U.S. civilian death toll estimates included some people who were traveling with or living with wanted militants, such as the second wife of the Pakistani Taliban's top leader. Both were killed in August by a CIA drone.
Analysts said accurately estimating civilian deaths was difficult, if not impossible, in these circumstances.
"It is unclear how you define who is a militant and who is a militant leader," Daniel Byman, a counterterrorism expert at the Brookings Institution's Saban Center for Middle East Policy, said, referring to those who associate with U.S. targets. "Do you count the driver? There are a lot of areas where people are what you might call 'half pregnant'."
(Reporting by Adam Entous; Editing by Cynthia Osterman)
World
Add a Comment
*We welcome comments that advance the story directly or with relevant tangential information. We try to block comments that use offensive language or appear to be spam and review comments frequently to ensure they meet our standards. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters.
More from Reuters
Iran: Punish U.S. for "shameful" nuclear threats
UNITED NATIONS (Reuters) - Calling nuclear weapons "disgusting and shameful," Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad urged the United Nations on Monday to punish countries like the United States that threaten to use them. | Video
Ireland reopens airspace from 8 a.m. ET
Thai "red shirts" study PM's election offer
| Video
Iran to hold naval exercises in Gulf: State TV
South Korea stops just short of blaming North for sinking
UK leaders make frantic final push for votes
» More Top News
Yuan market in for a bumpy ride
When China finally loosens its grip on the yuan, it will be dealing with something the country has never experienced before: sharp -- but necessary -- currency swings. Full Article
The implications of China reserve move
Q&A: Chinese economic rebalancing
China
Special Report:
Wall Street plows for profit
The heartland is hot for financial firms looking to cash in on growing world food needs. But critics say Wall Street's hayride is a dangerous land grab that risks transferring valuable resources from the poor to the wealthy. Full Article
Farewell to the family farm?
Global Markets
© Copyright 2010 Thomson Reuters
Editorial Editions:
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
United States
Reuters
Contact Us
Advertise With Us
Help
Journalism Handbook
Archive
Site Index
Video Index
Analyst Research
Mobile
Newsletters
RSS
Podcasts
Widgets
Your View
Labs
Thomson Reuters
Copyright
Disclaimer
Privacy
Professional Products
Professional Products Support
Financial Products
About Thomson Reuters
Careers
Online Products
Acquisitions Monthly
Buyouts
Venture Capital Journal
International Financing Review
Project Finance International
PEhub.com
PE Week
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
Other News on Tuesday, 4 May 2010 U.S. envoy arrives for Israeli-Palestinian talks
British leaders in last-ditch push for votes
Iran: Punish U.S. for shameful nuclear threats
|
US-TECH Summary
Basques separatists on trial for Madrid bombing
IBM buys cloud computing software firm Cast Iron
Iranian president blasts US for nuclear threats
Ireland to close airports Tues due to volcanic ash
|
Google buys Canadian 3D desktop software startup
Peeping Tom Suspect Chased By Father, Caught By Police, K-9
Pakistan Taliban leader alive, threatens U.S. attacks
|
IBM buys cloud computing firm Cast Iron Systems
Business jet makers ready to fly through tough year
Woman Arrested In Slaying Of Washington Principal
Europe mobilises to get aid to Greece
'Pope podcasts' pave way for Portugal trip
Man In Wheelchair Struck, Killed By Tractor-Trailer
Apple sells one million iPads in a month
Man hunted over foiled Times Square car bomb
Online Job Ads Rise To Highest Level Since 2008
U.S. chained wounded Canadian teen to door: medic
|
Apple says sold 1 million iPads
US inflation up 2% in March
Republican Tops Poll As Voting Begins In Hawaii Special Election
Turkey reform article rejected in blow to govt
|
iPad Outsells iPhone In Half The Time
Flood Kills Dozen In Tennessee
Plane Turned Around Due To Teens Unruliness
U.S. Consumer Spending, Manufacturing Post Strong Growth
Drones kill low-level militants, few civilians: U.S.
|
Auto Sales At Ford, GM Jump More Than 20 Percent In April
Indian court convicts Pakistani in Mumbai siege
S.Korean climber defends claim to disputed 14-peak record
Thai PM proposes Nov poll in "reconciliation" plan
Thai PM offers reconciliation plan, election date
Video shows Pakistan Taliban boss alive
Thai PM offers November elections to end crisis
Maoist strike shuts down much of Nepal for 2nd day
Connecticut AG probing Craigslist on paid-sex ads
|
Thai PM says ready to hold November elections
Indian court convicts Pakistani for Mumbai siege
1st woman to climb tallest peaks returns safely
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Actress Lynn Redgrave dies in Connecticut at 67
Cuba attracts Russian visitors with sun, nostalgia
Soap opera actress Helen Wagner dies at 91
Fishermen fear for catch, livelihood as mass spill looms
English ousts Russian in ex-Soviet Georgia's schools
Actress Lynn Redgrave dies in Connecticut at 67
|
Soap opera actress Helen Wagner dies at 91
|
Michael Douglas calls son's jail time adequate
|
Domingo's La Scala performance hit by strike
|
Settlers torch West Bank mosque: Palestinians
Labour in tactical voting call at British poll
Jewish settlers blamed for torching West Bank mosque
Ireland reopens airspace from 8 a.m. ET
|
Scheme allows Bangladeshis to 'vote' in UK poll
Connecticut AG probing Craigslist on paid-sex ads
US scores poorly on world motherhood rankings: charity
Europe pressed on slavery reparations
Thai red shirts study PM's election offer
|
Obama, Netanyahu want direct peace talks soon: White House
Electronic medical orders may save lives
United, Continental forge world's biggest airline
Iceland volcanic ash grounds flights across Ireland
Iran to hold naval exercises in Gulf: State TV
|
Obama presses Mideast peace push
South Korea stops just short of blaming North for sinking
|
British actress Lynn Redgrave dies at 67
US automakers report surging sales after troubled times
UK leaders make frantic final push for votes
|
Japan PM urges islanders to accept U.S. base burden
|
Drones kill low-level militants, few civilians: U.S.
|
China to press North's Kim on economy, nuclear talks
|
Jennifer Lopez Headlines 2010 World Music Awards With Award, Performance
MoNique Refuses Oprah Show Interview, Still Angry Over Her Brothers Lies On The Show
Florida Lawmaker Busted Surfing Porn On Senate Floor
World's oldest person, 114, dies in Japan
U.S. Markets Jump On Economic Data
S.Korean climber defends claim to disputed 14-peak record
Iranian President Says U.S. Policies Encourage Nuclear Proliferation
China city's 'shoot to kill' school attacks policy
Nepal strike Day 3: Food, fuel running short
China tainted-milk victims sue in Hong Kong
Australia PM lags in poll after carbon plan halted
NY police tighten net in Times Square car bomb case
Regulators mull antitrust look at Apple: source
|
Tornado, floods kill at least 22 in southern US
Australia gov't polls down after climate law delay
New York bomb suspect arrested at airport: official
China's manufacturing activity slows: HSBC
China to press North's Kim on economy, nuclear talks
Seoul shares inch lower, led by LG Electronics
Taiwan: No change on China policy after Ma comment
India to restrict mining in forests: report
Shanghai Expo opening attendance below expectations
Taiwan urges French firm to pay fine over warship sale
Korea Hot Stocks
PAKISTAN
NY auctions to signal return of good times: art dealers
Seoul shares dip on LG Elec; eyes on Samsung Life IPO
French rogue trader recalls 'banking orgy' in tell-all book
Seoul shares open higher, led by techs, carmakers
Police cameras to flood Manhattan to prevent attacks
NZ wage growth slow in Q1, labour market steadies
Britain's loony leader fights Cameron with insanity
"American Idol" ratings down, but ad sales seen up
Wine seller sues "Hell's Kitchen" star for skipping bill
Music publisher played key role in launching Runaways
Ellen Pompeo launches cancer prevention campaign
Black Eyed Peas break digital sales record
American Idol ratings down, but ad sales seen up
|
Wine seller sues Hell's Kitchen star for skipping bill
|
Meat Loaf explores human condition on Teddy Bear
|
Ellen Pompeo launches cancer prevention campaign
|
Ozzy, Motley Crue, Halford lead Ozzfest bill
|
Black Eyed Peas break digital sales record
|
Iran says plans new war games, photographed U.S. ship
Italian city fines woman for wearing burqa
Cybersecurity summit kicks off with calls to action
Ireland, Britain reopen skies after new ash alert
Palestinian Authority bans work in settlements
|
Airlines must reimburse travellers over volcano chaos: EU
Somali pirates hijack Yemeni cargo ship
|
UBS posts profits rise, warns of market uncertainty
China to press North's Kim on economy, nuclear talks
|
Prosecutors seek death sentence in Mumbai trial
|
Kyrgyzstan orders ousted leader's extradition
|
Israel asks Egypt to rethink pressure on atom pact
|
BP to use domes to capture giant US oil spill
Pakistan says to help U.S. over New York bomb suspect
Three passengers 'taken off New York-Dubai flight'
World's oldest person dies in Japan
Thai protesters agree to work towards end of crisis
Thai protesters welcome PM's compromise
Prosecutors seek death sentence in Mumbai trial
Sri Lanka plans to withdraw wartime restrictions
Taiwan: No change on China policy after Ma comment
Japan PM: Moving US base off Okinawa 'impossible'
Regulators mull antitrust look at Apple: source
|
Philippines recalls faulty voting machine cards
Taiwan to invest in cloud-based computing
U.S. gives Pakistan $656 mln under security fund
Pakistani stocks, o/n rates up; rupee flat
Samsung Life's IPO draws huge response from investors
Taiwan cbank urges capital controls for Asia economies
Japanese oil company to survey Cambodian basin
Renault-Bajaj 'plan $2,500 car for India'
Airbus A380 orders hit headwind: EADS boss
Britain's Turner Prize shortlist revealed
Indonesian volcano spews lava, ash 4,000 feet
Japanese firm signs oil study deal with Cambodia
Singing artist nominated for Britain's Turner Prize
US scores poorly on world motherhood rankings: charity
China's Huawei seeks India meeting over telcom ban
Shazam! Berlin looks at superheroes' Jewish roots
French super-university wants to be among the top 10
Singing artist nominated for Britain's Turner Prize
|
Black Eyed Peas break digital sales record
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights