Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Turner's bid for park bison stokes wildlife debate
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Turner's bid for park bison stokes wildlife debate
By MATTHEW BROWN,Associated Press Writer -
Monday, January 18
Send
IM Story
Print
BILLINGS, Mont. – With 88 bison from Yellowstone National Park facing possible slaughter, billionaire Ted Turner has swept in and offered to hold the animals for five years on his sprawling Montana ranch while a new home for them is found.
But Turner, ever the shrewd businessman, won't do it for nothing. The media mogul says he will care for the bison only if he can keep up to 90 percent of their offspring.
And in the Rocky Mountain West _ where wildlife is cherished both for its aesthetic value and as meat on the table _ the plan is stoking a sharp debate over the role of deep-pocketed private entities in conservation.
Hunters, environmentalists and property law experts have all weighed in and most say Turner's plan sets a dangerous precedent for the commercialization of public wildlife. Others describe Turner as a responsible steward of the land with the resources needed to take care of animals that desperately need a home.
Even the urgency of the situation is open to question.
Despite warnings from Montana about possible slaughter, federal officials said earlier this month that the bison could be kept longer if needed at a quarantine compound north of the park. They have already been there for several years to make sure they are disease free.
Dennis Tilton, a rancher from nearby Livingston who worked for a year feeding the animals under government contract, said giving the animals to Turner amounted to "robbing from the public domain." He said the state should put them onto public land to establish new herds.
Since Turner first came to Montana in 1989, his ambitious conservation efforts in the state have been alternately lauded and reviled. He's shielded more than 150,000 acres from development, but in the process put several prized hunting grounds off limits to the public.
Those who want to continue hunting on his Flying D Ranch, in the Spanish Peaks foothills south of Bozeman, today must pony up $14,000 to shoot a trophy elk.
For $4,000, they can harvest a bull bison out of a herd of more than 1,000 of the animals that Turner has been building up for two decades.
His representatives insist the Yellowstone animals are more valuable for their genetics and would be off limits.
Yellowstone's bison, also known as buffalo, represent one the last vestiges of the massive herds that once roamed across North America _ tens of millions of animals that were all but wiped out in the late 19th century.
Turner's representatives say his plan for the 88 park bison would advance a long-standing advocacy for wildlife restoration. It also gains him the animals' unique and valuable genetics.
"We don't understand the antipathy," said Turner Enterprises general manager Russell Miller.
He said Turner is interested in the animals as a way to further his private bison conservation efforts, not for their market value.
"That doesn't mean there won't be a market somewhere way out in the future," he added.
Turner's plan is expected to be acted on by the end of the month by the Montana Department of Fish, Wildlife and Parks. Guernsey State Park in Wyoming has also put in a proposal to the agency for 14 bison.
Montana officials were largely caught off guard by the billionaire's initial bid, which came at the invitation of the state's Democratic governor, Brian Schweitzer.
State and federal pronouncements going back to at least 2005 had called for the quarantined animals to be relocated onto public or tribal lands. Before Turner came along, those pronouncements included an explicit prohibition against commercialization of the animals.
When plans last spring to move them onto a Wyoming Indian reservation fell through _ and the specter of slaughter was raised _ the ban on commercialization was lifted.
Neither Montana nor the U.S. Department of Agriculture, the state's partner in the project, has ever offered to take the animals.
That's due in large part to a broader dispute over whether wild bison belong anywhere in the state outside of Yellowstone. Many ranchers see free-roaming bison as a disease risk and unwanted competition for the grass that feeds their cattle herds.
Meanwhile, conservationists are sinking millions of dollars into restoration efforts for the animal. That includes an attempt by the American Prairie Foundation to buy up vast swaths of land in eastern Montana ranches and create a 3 million acre reserve for bison and other wildlife.
"We don't have a real clear direction of what we want to do with bison," said Montana fish and wildlife director David Risley. "Are they going to be behind a fence forever, or is there a place in Montana where they can be free-roaming?"
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Pope defends Pius against Jewish critics AP - 1 hour 35 minutes ago
Elderly and abandoned, 85 Haitians await death AP - 1 hour 48 minutes ago
Haiti tensions mount amid scramble for last survivors AFP - 2 hours 20 minutes ago
Yanukovich, Tymoshenko qualify for Ukraine run-off: polls AFP - 2 hours 32 minutes ago
Holocaust hangs over pope's visit to Rome synagogue AFP - 2 hours 35 minutes ago
News Search
Top Stories
Pope to visit Rome synagogue amid Jewish anger
Obama's 1st yr marked by diplomacy, but few results
Obama surprises Michelle with birthday dinner
British bank sector hails Obama bank levy as fair
Rescuers battle to reach Haitians still alive in rubble
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Obama surprises Michelle with birthday dinner
Cancer-stricken Dennis Hopper files for divorce
Johnson & Johnson accused of drug kickbacks
Obama's 1st yr marked by diplomacy, but few results
Pope to visit Rome synagogue amid Jewish anger
More Most Viewed »
Beat the blues by going to bed early: study
Huge tomb found at Egypt's Saqqara pyramid
Woman who saved Anne Frank's diary dead at 100
Scientists praise Obama as Doomsday clock reset
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Monday, 18 January 2010 Ex-housekeeper alleges abuse by Israeli PM's wife
US-TECH Summary
Pope to visit Rome synagogue amid Jewish anger
Afghan president to offer Taliban new peace plan
Fearful Haiti quake survivors turn to God for help
|
Karzai to offer Taliban new peace plan
Venezuela's Chavez nationalizes French-owned retailer
|
Saddam official Tareq Aziz hospitalized
Billionaire seen winning tight Chile vote
|
Northern Irish leaders shake hands for first time
|
Angola arrests a third rights activist in Cabinda
|
Quake-hit Haiti's cabinet meets -- in the open-air
|
Turner's bid for park bison stokes wildlife debate
Afghan lawmakers adjourn despite Cabinet standoff
Taliban kidnap two Chinese engineers, four Afghans
Obama to parishioners: Keep faith in hard times
Wall St sets bar higher for IBM in 2010 after rally
|
US supports Afghan plan to reintegrate Taliban
MySQL founder turns to China, Russia to halt Oracle
|
Drug abuse in US prisons is tough to stamp out
182 more ex-child soldiers leave camps in Nepal
4,000 homeless, 1 girl killed in Manila slum fire
No progress in RI immigrant prison release program
Haiti's history created bond with many US blacks
Pakistani officials: Suspected US drone kills 20
Plug being pulled on decades-old navigation system
Police: Minor sidewalk squabble leads to stabbing
Bush, Clinton: Haiti response not about politics
Filipino WWII veterans still waiting for payments
NASA listens for silent Mars lander
Globe nominees mix wild fantasy, harsh reality
Hollywood gets ready for Golden Globes
Avatar hits $1.6 billion worldwide
|
O'Brien, NBC separation may upstage Golden Globes
|
Filmmaker: Movie about balloon dad could clear him
"Avatar" hits $1.6 billion worldwide
O'Brien, NBC separation may upstage Golden Globes
Globe nominees mix wild fantasy, harsh reality
Taliban launches attacks on central Kabul
Ukraine vote heads for tense run-off
U.S. troops to help Haiti's security; aid flows in
|
Sony's PlayStation is 'poison' to children: Chavez
Marines exit Iraq in first wave of US forces out
Why coastal oil spills can pollute for decades: study
Yanukovich, Tymoshenko qualify for Ukraine run-off: polls
MySQL founder turns to China, Russia to halt Oracle
Saab drivers hit the road to support car brand
Suicide bombers, gunmen attack central Kabul
|
Iran state TV cracks open door to opposition
Netanyahu, Merkel to meet on Iran, Palestinian issues
|
Iraq's 'Chemical Ali' sentenced to death
Chinese kidnapped as Karzai mulls Taliban strategy
Chavez says U.S. occupying Haiti in name of aid
|
Iraq's "Chemical Ali" gets 4th death sentence
Al Qaeda: Yemen claims of killing fighters untrue
|
Iran ex-prosecutor denies role in torture deaths
Iraq's 'Chemical Ali' to hang for 1988 gas attack
Kenyan police raid Somali suburb after riots
|
Haiti's voodoo priests object to mass burials
|
Chile shifts right as billionaire wins presidency
|
Fearful Haiti quake survivors turn to God for help
|
Ukraine PM Tymoshenko to face old rival in runoff
|
Sony's PlayStation is 'poison' to children: Chavez
Motorola plans 5-6 smartphones in China this year
|
Can newspaper muckraking carry on in nonprofits?
5 Americans detained in Pakistan allege torture
CAPITAL CULTURE: Obama cites value of volunteerism
China to expand smoking bans in 7 major cities
US Shiites tentatively try to Americanize
Gunbattle reported in Afghan capital
Tips for getting involved in national service
Attorney: Man in JFK breach just used 'wrong door'
Myanmar court hears Suu Kyi appeal of house arrest
5 people found slain in southeast Texas home
Support for Japan PM drops amid cash probe: polls
Shanghai targeted in China phone porn crackdown
More cold to compound misery in China's Xinjiang
Search halted for potential CA boat crash victims
Extreme cold, snow kills 4 in northwest China
4 Miss. college students killed in Ala. motel fire
Police arrest man accused of "time zone" cheating
Earthquake in China kills 7 people
15 sickened on flight from US Virgin Islands to NC
Globe nominees mix wild fantasy, harsh reality
Seoul shares rise 0.6 pct; LG Elec, KEPCO advance
IMF chief: global recovery stronger than expected
S.Korea finmin warns against hasty policy exit
China Eastern surges on 2009 profit expectations
PAKISTAN
Avatar, Hangover take home top Golden Globes
|
Glee sings top TV show tune at Golden Globes
|
Ricky Gervais falls flat at Golden Globes
|
RPT-UPDATE 1-Korea Life Insurance IPO planned for Q1- Hanwha
Golden Globe fashion fights gloom of Haiti, rain
|
Oil price drop, Wall Street hit Asian shares
U.S. Juggles Aid And Military Logistics, Relief Suppliers Complain
Simon Cowell recruiting X Factor judges
|
Taiwan dlr up, market watches govt fund selling, QDII
Obama Attends Church Founded in 1866 By Seven Freed Slaves
Tsunami-generating quake possible off Indonesia: scientists
Seoul shares down on banks; KEPCO, Doosan Heavy rally
Chaotic Conditions In Haiti Still Hamper Distribution Of Disaster Relief Supplies
Peace Activist Cindy Sheehan Concludes Protest In Front Of Cheney's House
S.Korea firms urge govt caution over exit strategy
'Mad Men' wins third drama award in a row
Ricky Gervais falls flat at Golden Globes
Suspected U.S. Missile Attack Kills 12 In Pakistan
Haitian-American Man Behind JFK Security Breach, Police Say
Hillary Clinton Arrives In Haiti, Meets With President Preval And Reassures People
Classy, glitzy, 'Golden Globes' failed as a party
Obama Announces Clinton And Bush Teaming Up To Help Haiti
Cameron's `Avatar' wins best drama honor at Globes
Breaking: JFK Terminal Security Fiasco, Passengers Re-screening Going On
"Glee" sings top TV show tune at Golden Globes
'Avatar' wins top honors at Golden Globes
Avatar scores best film and director at Golden Globes
Leno gets support from staff; O'Brien ratings soar
Actor Todd Lasance to plea to cocaine charge
Militants launch multiple attacks across Kabul
Toyota to double global hybrid output: report
Stars Announced To Perform At Hope For Haiti Event
Turk who shot Pope John Paul released from prison
|
Israeli police arrest 5 in West Bank mosque blaze
Iran says sees signs of progress in nuclear talks
|
Motorola plans 5-6 smartphones in China this year
Meryl Streep, Sandra Bullock Share Best Actress Win At The Critics Choice Awards
Rights groups urge Hamas to allow war crimes probe
UK court scraps curfews on two terrorism suspects
|
Meryl Streep, Sandra Bullock, "Avatar" Win Golden Globes
Qaeda says fighters alive, Yemen vows more strikes
|
Iran tries five people over December unrest
|
Somali pirates free oil tanker after record ransom
|
Saudis say Sept blast killed 3 wanted militants
|
CORRECTED: Gunmen kill five in Iraqi NGO office
|
US-TECH Summary
Motorola plans 5-6 smartphones in China this year
Google probing possible inside help on attack
|
Handset market recovery in focus after weak 2009
|
Turkey blocking 3,700 websites: OSCE
|
ASML Q4 order book seen to signal tech rebound
|
Rapes of elderly women terrify central Texas towns
UK High Court rules for Nokia vs IPCom
|
Obama to celebrate MLK's life and legacy
Leno gets support from staff
Shanghai Expo plans before, after Haiti exhibits
Ex-Minn. senator ousted by Al Franken won't be gov
Cleveland Orchestra musicians strike over contract
China's 1,459-year-old Buddha gets $10.8M facelift
Turkmens to take down golden monument of ex-leader
5 Americans detained in Pakistan allege torture
China to expand smoking bans in 7 major cities
SKorea: Talks with North still on despite threats
Vietnam aims to carve world's biggest jade Buddha
Activist freed on bail after arrest in India
Taiwan artist carves 'world's tiniest tiger'
Taliban militants launch attack on Afghan capital
Conan O'Brien finalizing exit from NBC
|
Pakistani rupee weakens vs dollar; stocks end lower
Google says 'business as usual' in China
S.Korea's rate hike seen premature- OECD
JAL shares hit all-time low of $0.05
China's 2009 web earnings reach 11 billion dollars
The Golden Globes: As It Happened
Japan's recovery still fragile: finance minister
Mazda, Ford deny plans to dismantle China venture
King Cameron redux? `Avatar' aims for Oscar glory
Obama musical thrills audiences in Germany
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Conan O'Brien finalizing exit from NBC
Backstage and on the red carpet at Golden Globes
Simon Cowell recruiting "X Factor" judges
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights