Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Canada Afghan dispute could trigger early election
|
Edition:
U.S.
Article
Comments (0)
Save
Email
Print
Reprints
Most Popular
Most Shared
Police barred from penis enlargement
23 Apr 2010
Portuguese 5-yr CDS at record high, spread wider
4:55am EDT
Arizona immigration law protesters urge action
25 Apr 2010
U.S. backs plan to stop leaking Gulf of Mexico oil well
25 Apr 2010
Strong quake in Taiwan, Philippines; no damage reports
12:39am EDT
Potentially deadly fungus spreading in U.S. and Canada
22 Apr 2010
RIM shows new operating system, stock rebounds
4:34pm EDT
Court strikes blow to Wal-Mart in sex bias suit
4:33pm EDT
Google smartphone coming to stores, no Verizon
1:27pm EDT
Pirates rewrite script for Apple's China iPad launch
3:28pm EDT
Police barred from penis enlargement
23 Apr 2010
Potentially deadly fungus spreading in U.S. and Canada
22 Apr 2010
Arizona immigration law protesters urge action
25 Apr 2010
Portuguese 5-yr CDS at record high, spread wider
4:55am EDT
Goldman's "Fabulous" Fab's conflicted love letters
9:52am EDT
Court strikes blow to Wal-Mart in sex bias suit
4:33pm EDT
Britons believe the hills are alive with haggis
23 Apr 2010
U.S. students suffering from Internet addiction: study
23 Apr 2010
George W. Bush to release memoir on November 9
2:18pm EDT
Hertz to buy Dollar Thrifty for $1.2 billion
12:11pm EDT
Canada Afghan dispute could trigger early election
David Ljunggren
OTTAWA
Mon Apr 26, 2010 2:53pm EDT
Related News
SCENARIOS-Impact of Lib Dem surge on British election
1:03pm EDT
Canada's Conservatives hold lead in opinion poll
Fri, Apr 23 2010
REFILE-Canada's Conservatives extend lead in latest poll
Thu, Apr 22 2010
UPDATE 3-Canada's Flaherty says bank tax idea is excessive
Wed, Apr 21 2010
UK Lib Dem surge could hurt Conservatives more
Mon, Apr 19 2010
Former translator Malgarai Ahmadshah speaks to media after testifying at a special committee meeting on the Canadian mission in Afghanistan on Parliament Hill in Ottawa April 14, 2010.
Credit: Reuters/Blair Gable
OTTAWA (Reuters) - Canada's minority Conservative government is locked in a power struggle with opposition members of Parliament over allegations that Canadian soldiers left Afghan detainees open to abuse, and the confrontation might just trigger an early election.
World
Last December, the House of Commons, where the Conservatives have a minority of members, ordered the government to turn over uncensored files on people detained by the military in Afghanistan. The government refused, citing national security.
What happens next depends on House of Commons speaker Peter Milliken, who is due to rule shortly on who has the right to control the documents. If he backs Parliament and the government refuses to obey, the House could vote nonconfidence in the government, and that would trigger an election.
The government could also refer the matter to the Supreme Court of Canada, asking it to judge who has priority, or it could set up a special commission.
Opposition legislators insist Parliament is supreme and say the government's behavior shows too much power is concentrated in the office of Prime Minister Stephen Harper, who they portray as being obsessed with secrecy.
"It is one of the fundamental roles of the House of Commons to hold the government to account ... it is a basic tenet of our democracy," said Jack Harris, a member of the left-leaning New Democrats.
Government officials say Canada's relations with major allies could be seriously harmed if sensitive details leaked out from the documents.
"I would remind the House that our parliamentary privileges are not indefinite nor unlimited," Justice Minister Rob Nicholson told legislators last month, saying governments in other nations with similar political systems had withheld documents on security grounds.
Polls show an election now would most likely produce another minority Conservative government, albeit with fewer seats than the party gained in the October 2008 vote.
This could temper the willingness of main opposition Liberal Party to push the matter too far. If the Liberals back down, however, they could find themselves under attack from critics for being weak.
Constitutional experts say Milliken's ruling could radically change the way Canada is ruled.
"The fundamental foundation of our parliamentary democracy is that the executive has to be accountable to the House of Commons. It cannot be accountable only to itself," University of Ottawa law professor Errol Mendes told the Canadian Broadcasting Corp on Monday.
Milliken also could send the matter to a parliamentary committee and urge legislators from all sides to work it out themselves.
The opposition wants to see the documents because it suspects Ottawa knew that prisoners handed over by Canadian troops to Afghan authorities could be abused.
The government, which has released thousands of pages of often heavily censored material, last month asked retired Supreme Court Justice Frank Iacobucci to look at the documents and decide what can be released.
A spokeswoman for Milliken said he would not issue his ruling on Monday but that he would try to do so this week.
(Reporting by David Ljunggren; editing by Peter Galloway)
World
Add a Comment
*We welcome comments that advance the story directly or with relevant tangential information. We try to block comments that use offensive language or appear to be spam and review comments frequently to ensure they meet our standards. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters.
More from Reuters
Protesters block police in deepening Thai crisis
BANGKOK (Reuters) - Protests and blockades in the provinces on Monday, and a grenade attack against a politician, deepened fears of a civil conflict in Thailand after the prime minister rejected demands by anti-government protesters. | Video
Iraq election turmoil as panel invalidates votes
| Video
Iran's Ahmadinejad: U.N. veto power "satanic"
Sudan elects wanted Bashir as president
Kyrgyzstan mulls Bakiyev extradition request
Obama assures Israel's Barak of U.S. commitment
» More Top News
Reuters Summit:
Reform bill a "strong product"
Gary Gensler, the top futures regulator, says the "American public is tired of bailouts" and expressed support for the Senate's financial reform bill. Full Article
Q&A: Why are swaps in focus?
Bank leader sees reform passing
Live Now: Global Regulation Summit
Global Financial Regulation
Blankfein: No bet against clients
Goldman CEO Lloyd Blankfein denied having a massive short in the housing market and said the firm did not bet against clients in written testimony ahead of his appearance before the Senate. Full Article
Document: Blankfein's testimony
Love letters from "Fabulous" Fab
Goldman, CEO hit with investor lawsuit
Goldman Sachs
© Copyright 2010 Thomson Reuters
Editorial Editions:
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
United States
Reuters
Contact Us
Advertise With Us
Help
Journalism Handbook
Archive
Site Index
Video Index
Analyst Research
Mobile
Newsletters
RSS
Podcasts
Widgets
Your View
Labs
Thomson Reuters
Copyright
Disclaimer
Privacy
Professional Products
Professional Products Support
Financial Products
About Thomson Reuters
Careers
Online Products
Acquisitions Monthly
Buyouts
Venture Capital Journal
International Financing Review
Project Finance International
PEhub.com
PE Week
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
Other News on Tuesday, 27 April 2010 US tells Iraq to 'get show on the road' amid vote row
Supreme Court to decide if kids can buy violent video games
British envoy to Yemen escapes suicide bombing
Sudan elects wanted Bashir as president
US newspaper circulation drops 8.74 percent
Iran's Ahmadinejad: U.N. veto power satanic
|
Iran's Ahmadinejad: U.N. veto power "satanic"
Sudan elects wanted Bashir as president
|
RIM turns Blackberry phones into work line extensions
Study Shows Mortgage Fraud Increased Last Year In U.S.
Wall Street overhaul faces key US Senate test
Five Dutch operators buy into 2.6 GHz band
Caterpillar Swings Q1 Profit, Boosts Outlook
Obama assures Israel's Barak of U.S. commitment
|
Japan phone makers team up to develop new platform
UN orders staff in south Afghan city to stay indoors
Boob-Joke-Turned-Political-Statement Inspires Show Of "Support" On Dupont Circle
Genes influence smoking addiction: study
Las Vegas Betting On Old Parking Meters To Help Homeless
Riders Gather For Bike Blessings
Late Polish president's twin brother to seek top job
|
World's first taxis with easily swapped batteries hit Tokyo
Batman To Tour In Live Stage Show
Kris Allen To Release "The Truth" With Pat Monahan Of Train
Canada Afghan dispute could trigger early election
|
US-TECH Summary
Woody Allen Reveals Film Details
Klausner sues HTC over visual voicemail
Cary Elwes Returns To "Saw" Series For 3D Sequel
Myanmar ministers quit military posts ahead of polls
Joss Stone Designing Limited Edition Footwear For Nine West
Top court to rule on California video game law
UN scales back in dangerous southern Afghanistan
Thai king speaks for 1st time in political crisis
Kyrgyz gov't wants ousted president's extradition
Competition gives TomTom new route to revenue
US asks Nepal's ex-rebels for peaceful protests
Robotic subs race to cap leaking US oil well
Google smartphone coming to stores, no Verizon
|
EU hopes to send poll mission to Myanmar
Protesters block police in deepening Thai crisis
Klausner sues HTC over visual voicemail
|
Yahoo expands offering on Samsung phones
|
Nepal's Maoist leader calls for public protest
Attacks prompt UN warning to 200 Afghan staffers
expands mobile partnership with Samsung
Anne Frank House still stands as a grim reminder
American Airlines delays China service over landing slots
Evangelists claim 'Noah's Ark' discovery on Turkish mountain
Charity slams EU-India trade talks over generic drugs access
Multi-nationals go for 'guanxi' at China's Expo
Justin Bieber concert canceled after crowd crush
Europe trade deal could hit Indian generic drugs
Goody's widower Tweed cleared of rape
Korea's Queen of Cannes Jeon returns as housemaid
|
Singapore filmaker to head Locarno filmfest jury
Film examines Colombian soccer's Faustian bargain
|
Goody's widower Tweed cleared of rape
|
Dr. Oz eases ageing down road to fitness
|
Billy Bragg sings about English identity in play
|
Montreux festival boss promises strong line up
|
Spitzer film recalls glory days, bares enemies
|
Putin woos Ukraine with gas deal, nuclear offer
Thai government vows action as red shirts block train
|
Ex-Panama dictator Noriega arrives in France
|
US Fed expected to hold low interest rates
Chile desert to host world's biggest telescope
Shanghai sets stage for World Expo spectacular
|
Afghan tribunal jails Briton for graft: reports
British envoy to Yemen escapes suicide bombing
Wall Street overhaul bill stalls in US Senate
Sanctions squeeze Iranians in trade hub Dubai
|
American Hindus Ask Bangladesh To Stop Persecution, Call For Recognition In The US
Police Raid Home Of Gizmodo Editor
India government faces possible confidence vote
|
Goldman Sachs CEO Blakfein To Defend Firm In Front Of Finance Panel
Gosselin Kids Cleared For Work On New "Kate Plus 8" Show
Obama 'disappointed' Republicans block finance debate
Karzai's brother pledges support for NATO in Kandahar: FT
Japan PM says finalizing plan to end U.S. base row
|
U.S. Markets Finish Mixed As Financials Weigh
Journalist group demands probes into Iraq deaths
|
Bereaved twin runs for Polish president
Police seize blogger's computers over iPhone prototype
Bailout plan advances as Greece pledges extra cuts
US envoy heads to Japan for base row talks
Iraq election turmoil as panel invalidates votes
Former rivals eBay, Alibaba tie-up on new platform
S.Korean woman in final push for 14 peaks record
Avatar's James Cameron pushes tech careers to young
Police seize blogger's computers over iPhone prototype
|
E-mail faux pas, like ones in Goldman case, common
Protesters disrupt Bangkok elevated trains
Breasts big on Facebook as women take on Iran cleric
Former rivals eBay, Alibaba tie-up on new platform
|
E-mail faux pas, like ones in Goldman case, common
|
Fears of civil conflict deepen in Thailand
Indonesia rounds up 'beach boys' over gigolo film
Thai govt talks tough, protesters beef up defences
US extradites Noriega to France
Hollywood sign safe as Playboy mogul Hefner weighs in
Supreme Court to decide if kids can buy violent video games
US missionary to face trial in Haiti: attorney
South Asian nations to fight climate change
Google loses Verizon, changes Nexus One plans
Obama hits 2010 campaign trail in US heartland
Activists oppose Indian animal testing lab in Malaysia
Gizmodo editor's home raided in iPhone prototype probe
SKorean on her way to reach Annapurna's summit
Top court to rule on California video game law
Obama renews vow of "new beginning" with Muslims
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Shanghai sets stage for World Expo spectacular
Ex-Panama dictator Noriega extradited to France
Third "Ring" thriller coming out in 3D
"Chipmunks" owners sue Fox, seek half of profits
James Patterson's "Maximum Ride" airborne again
Randy Quaid, wife jailed briefly near L.A
Concert raises $4.8M for China quake relief
Trump says "Amazing Race" doesn't deserve Emmys
Police Raid Home Of Gizmodo Editor
Egypt Arrests Israeli Swimmer
Johannesburg's new buses infuriate taxi drivers ahead of WC
Weezer readies new music, "Pinkerton" reissue
Ian McEwan nominated for UK comic fiction award
Robert Downey Jr. back in superhero mode for Iron Man 2
|
Security tightened for Bieber-mania after crowd hysteria
|
Randy Quaid, wife jailed briefly near L.A
|
Third Ring thriller coming out in 3D
|
Chipmunks owners sue Fox, seek half of profits
|
Trump says Amazing Race doesn't deserve Emmys
|
Seoul shares edge lower as techs, autos decline
James Patterson's Maximum Ride airborne again
|
S.Korea buys $1.5 bln to check won -traders
China's Alibaba teams up with US PayPal
S.Korea won down on warning; intervention spotted
China shops for foreign firms, brands
PAKISTAN
S.Korea economy grows faster than expected in Q1
Chinese web portal Sohu reports Q1 profit fall
S.Korea growth quickens, but loose policy seen staying
SKorea's economy grows 1.8 percent in 1st quarter
Israel commanders reprimanded for West.Bank shootings
Chaos in Ukraine parliament as Russia deal ratified
Protests as Ukraine backs Russian base extension
|
BP's soaring profits overshadowed by oil rig tragedy
Nokia unveils new flagship phone model
Sanctions squeeze Iranians in trade hub Dubai
Lib Dems open to Labour coalition after UK election
|
WE TV Premiering New Reality Series About Senior Citizens In Retirement Home
Greek transport on strike as austerity anger grows
|
Most young Chinese use mobiles to get online: survey
British bank Lloyds returns to profit in first quarter
Palm Beach International Film Festival Announces Award Winners
Italian police arrest top mafia fugitive
|
CEO Pleads Guilty in Multi-Million Dollar Ponzi Scheme
Ukraine parliament fight, smoke bomb thrown
Iran opposition urges vote anniversary rally: website
|
Hugh Hefner Saves Hollywood Sign, Donates Final $900,000 Fund
Iraq delays ruling on election candidate ban
|
Russia and Norway strike Arctic sea border deal
|
Ford Sees Boost In 1Q Profits
Flaherty Heads For Showdown With Canadian Banks Selling Insurance On Their Websites
UK police blamed for 1979 protest killing
|
Nokia unveils new flagship phone model
Scientists Say They Have Learned To Stop Pain At Its Source
Study Suggest Brown Rice Could Protect Against High Blood Pressure
Obama Takes Senate Vote In Stride; To Tour Iowa, Missouri, Illinois
Most young Chinese use mobiles to get online: survey
Panel to seek solutions to U.S. budget woes
US senators to grill Goldman execs on meltdown role
Strike against inflation disrupts life in India
Hong Kong gov't won't beef up political reforms
Indian diplomat charged with spying for Pakistan
Karzai's brother says UN should not leave south
Nokia unveils new flagship phone
|
Video search Blinkx launches ad service based on viewers' habits
|
S.Korean first woman to scale world highest peaks
China to close border with Kyrgyzstan, Kazakhstan
Pakistani stocks, rupee flat; o/n rates end lower
China wants telecom companies to inform on clients
Robert Downey Jr. returns to superhero mode for "Iron Man 2"
Softbank net profit surges on robust iPhone sales
Pakistan: US missiles kill 4 insurgents
Top court to rule on California video game law
|
Sharp returns to black, sees TV sales growing
WRAPUP 1-Moody's lifts S.Korea rating to pre Asia crisis level
Mitsubishi returns to profit, announces Peugeot tie-up
Japan minister says Toyota has learned its lesson
EU trade envoy tells China to let yuan rise
China wants telecom companies to inform on clients
Taiwan chipmaker TSMC says profit up 3 percent
Sharp returns to black after big cost cuts
Amy Winehouse in hospital after fall
|
Security tightened in New Zealand for Bieber-mania
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights