Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Analysis: Wrestling with how to talk about race
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Analysis: Wrestling with how to talk about race
By LIZ SIDOTI,Associated Press Writer -
Sunday, September 27
Send
IM Story
Print
WASHINGTON – For a while, it almost seemed as if President Barack Obama had soothed the angst over race in this country simply by taking office. The focus was on big issues facing a new president _ one who just happened to be black.
If only it were so simple. This summer, Obama stepped into the dustup between a black college professor and a white police officer, and the race debate erupted anew. Then vitriolic attacks on Obama over his health care proposals spawned rippling allegations that his critics were motivated by racism.
And now passions over skin color are flaring red-hot again.
Obama's election nearly a year ago _ a monumental stride toward bridging the racial divide _ turned the politics of race on its head.
But it didn't end the matter by any means.
It turns out that Obama was right when he said in his much-watched race speech in March 2008 that there are "complexities of race in this country that we've never really worked through _ a part of our union that we have yet to perfect."
Americans still are figuring out how to hold that conversation as the country navigates uncharted territory under its first nonwhite president.
One conundrum is how to hold Obama accountable for his words and actions _ or even talk about his policies _ without risk of being called racist.
Hillary Rodham Clinton and John McCain both wrestled with that question during the presidential campaign. Both found it tricky to maneuver. Both were frustrated by it. Each handled it differently.
In the Democratic primary, Clinton acted so cautiously that some insiders questioned whether she was afraid to throw a punch.
Come the general election, McCain early on accused Obama of playing the race card, hoping to send a message that he would not brook being called a racist.
Obama had triggered the reaction with a warning that Republicans would try to scare voters by saying he "doesn't look like all those other presidents on the dollar bills."
A year later and now as president, Obama is the one working to tamp down race in the political dialogue.
"Are there people out there who don't like me because of race? I'm sure there are," Obama says matter-of-factly. But he rejects the notion that racism is even partly behind his critics' attacks, as a growing chorus of Democrats have claimed.
Trying to turn down the heat, Obama adds: "We can have a strong disagreement, passionate disagreements about issues without resorting to name-calling."
But the "racist" label is as old as the country itself. And, in a nation founded by slaveholders, people aren't about to stop using it just because a black president is pleading for civility.
Certainly, Obama's election healed some racial wounds. But change takes time, and understanding the ramifications of change takes even longer.
"What we're dealing with is the foundational racial problems that we have had and still have. We're making progress, but we haven't come as far as people would like to believe we have," says Bishop Harry R. Jackson Jr., the senior pastor of Hope Christian Church in Beltsville, Md., and an outspoken conservative who is black. He says society is going through "a learning curve" on how to criticize Obama _ and how to criticize the president's critics.
It's an issue that goes to the very heart of democracy. Free speech, including holding leaders accountable, is at this country's core.
Could the risk of being called a racist end up muzzling healthy debate if people don't dare voice their concerns?
Perhaps for some. But on the whole, criticism hasn't stopped.
Animosity toward the president and his policies has boiled over in recent weeks, most notably with South Carolina Rep. Joe Wilson's "You lie!" retort to the president.
Democrats from Jimmy Carter on down have blamed the increasingly harsh criticism of Obama on racism.
House Republican leader John Boehner countered that "the outrage that we see in America has nothing to do with race."
Reality likely falls somewhere in the middle.
"I hear it as anger, but anger masking fear," says Robin Lakoff, a linguistics professor at the University of California at Berkeley whose books include "The Language War." She says people are afraid of just about everything these days _ the economy, the government, private business included. And she says: "There's this racial element. It isn't exactly racism but otherness."
Obama, for his part, has tried to shift the subject from the powder keg of race. It's been a distraction from his agenda, from his efforts to overhaul the health care system.
"It's important to realize that I was actually black before the election," the president said this week.
It was a gentle joke from the leader of a country still wrestling with the new dynamics that came when the son of a black father from Kenya and a white mother from Kansas took charge of the White House.
___
EDITOR'S NOTE _ Liz Sidoti has covered national politics for The Associated Press since 2003.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
GOP: Dems ignoring public's health care concerns AP - Sunday, September 27
Merkel, Steinmeier in final push for German votes Reuters - Sunday, September 27
General McChrystal submits plea for more Afghanistan troops Reuters - Sunday, September 27
Pope decries Czech communist-era persecution AP - Sunday, September 27
Terror threats prompt flight ban over Oktoberfest AP - Sunday, September 27
News Search
Top Stories
BBVA sells 1 bln dlrs of property to Deutsche Bank
Kasparov beats Karpov in chess legends' rematch
Swine flu vaccines win approval
US durable goods orders slip in August
French banks sue for billions over Lehman collapse
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
New Confucius family tree hits two million
Kasparov beats Karpov in chess legends' rematch
French banks sue for billions over Lehman collapse
Water detected on the Moon
Unilever to buy Sara Lee personal care brands
More Most Viewed »
Ozone hole smaller in 2009 than 2008: WMO
Nanoparticles could pose threat to humans: scientists
Remains of Jesus-era synagogue found in Israel
Implanted tooth helps blind US woman recover sight
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Search
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Saturday, 26 September 2009 Iran must open nuke site, US, world chiefs demand
Kasparov beats Karpov in chess legends' rematch
Nokia caught up in Brazil brand name row
IAEA may inspect new nuclear site: Iran president
| International
|
BBVA sells 1 bln dlrs of property to Deutsche Bank
Bin Laden demands Europe withdraw Afghanistan troops
| International
|
Abbas says Israel freeze of settlements a must
| International
|
Waze turning road warriors into map builders
Swine flu vaccines win approval
Zelaya demands presidency as U.N. condemns Honduras
| International
|
Western leaders warn Iran over nuclear site
US durable goods orders slip in August
Kuwait censors 'terror' blogs
German election race narrows amid security threat
| International
|
Olmert graft trial opens in Jerusalem
French banks sue for billions over Lehman collapse
RIM seen facing increased market-share pressure
Olmert graft trial opens in Jerusalem
| International
|
Text of Obama, Sarkozy, Brown statements on Iran
EU seeks to ensure Microsoft ballot offers choices
Judge agrees to delay Google book case hearing
New Confucius family tree hits two million
Israel's ex-PM goes on trial on corruption charges
Iraq detains 109 in jail break investigation
Nokia caught up in Brazil brand name row
AEG president: Jackson movie should clear co. name
West demands access to Iran's secret nuclear plant
Sarkozy gives Iran December deadline
Twitter snags new investment, backers
| Technology
|
AT&T: net neutrality should apply to Web firms too
| Technology
|
Vanguard readies iPhone app as fund firms go mobile
| Technology
|
Rossellini ponders how to make online video pay
| Technology
|
China indicts 21 people in July ethnic violence
Coroner: 'Fed' written in pen on Ky. Census worker
Fresh bailouts for smaller banks being weighed
5 US troops killed as debate grows over Afghan war
Afghan war commander submits troop request
Second suspect charged in shooting of 4 NJ cops
Ohio AG to probe county auditor in Cleveland
Northern Afghan violence undercuts US supply route
China dismisses punishment for Iran nuke facility
1 in 10 suspect Afghan ballot boxes face recount
House Democrats considering insurance tax
AP NewsAlert
Kazakh media complain after probe shuts press
House passes bill to prevent government shutdown
Teens with own cars have more crashes, study finds
Utah gov backs limits on nonresident gun permits
China charges 21 over Xinjiang unrest: state media
Judge considers possible Elizabeth Smart testimony
Taiwan stops visit by Uighur leader
Indonesians oppose militants' burial plans
Sony's PS3 outsells Wii fivefold in Japan: survey
Emmy-winning actor to lead Hollywood union
Amid weakness at home, Ford, Toyota turn to China
Stability of US dollar key to global recovery: China
EU charges of pork protectionism 'groundless': China
Yen climbs after Japan minister's G20 remarks
First exhibition by Horia Damian in Romania since he left in 1946
Tajik migrants divorce by SMS, causing grief at home
Rossellini ponders how to make online video pay
| Entertainment
|
Bijou Phillips knew Mackenzie had sex with father
Croatia backs down on smoking ban
Mayor bans burqa in Italy spa resort
Sony's PS3 outsells Wii fivefold in Japan: survey
Families to collect Indonesian militants' remains
Warhol gives leaders' wives 15 minutes of provocation
Poverty gap widens in SAfrica: report
Castrati honored in opera star Bartoli's new album
Top British chef apologises to ill diners
Pump down the volume, EU to tell MP3 makers
German leaders appeal for votes as race tightens
Twitter gets new round of funding, new backers
Obama demands Iran come clean on nuclear program
| International
|
Taliban threatens Germany ahead of vote: official
Key sites in Iran's nuclear program
Defamation trial of Estemirova rights group chief opens
Five US soldiers killed in Afghanistan: NATO
Affluent and urban drawn to online social networks: Nielsen
US auto safety group wants to curb gadget use by truckers
Six killed in truck bomb attack in Pakistan
| International
|
Russia won't put missiles in Kaliningrad: Medvedev
| International
|
Google digs deeper into Internet search results
AT&T looks to flip net rules debate on Google
Koreans, split by war for 56 years, meet to say goodbye
| International
|
Twitter gets "significant" new funding
China lays first charges over Xinjiang riots
| International
|
Libya's Gaddafi met Lockerbie bomb victim relatives
| International
|
Vanguard readies iPhone app as fund firms go mobile
German election race narrows amid security threat
| International
|
Google says its voice service should not be regulated
Crime problem weighs on Bangladesh government
| International
|
US auto safety group wants to curb gadget use by truckers
Zelaya demands presidency as U.N. condemns Honduras
| International
|
Attorney: Anti-Iraq officer resigning from Army
Ahmadinejad: Iran is not violating IAEA rules
Oral Roberts inaugurates 3rd university president
Daughter of slain heiress believed dead in NY
Southern California wildfire 85 percent contained
Myanmar's Suu Kyi gives backing to U.S. engagement
AP sources: Guantanamo might not close by January
Twitter gets new round of funding, new backers
| Technology
|
Man convicted in death of father left to rot
Dozen killed in two bomb attacks in NW Pakistan
Anguilla native to be Gitmo jail deputy commander
China lays first charges over Xinjiang riots
Clinton unveils US food security initiative
Koreans, split by war for 56 years, meet to say goodbye
S Koreans head to N Korea for reunions
Indonesia corruption body under attack: activists
S.Korea: North must face "no choice" but to shed nuclear arms
Uighur leader disappointed by Taiwan
US names NKorea human rights envoy
China dismisses punishment for Iran nuke facility
Myanmar's Suu Kyi eases stance on sanctions
Pakistani c.bank buys 40.4 bln rupees of govt paper
Noodle giant plans secondary listing in Taiwan
IMF raises 2010 global growth forecast to 3 pct
Re-born G20 lays out bold financial reforms
New PM tells world Japan committed to recovery
Global economic rebound 'not solid': Chinese president Hu
"Beautiful Life" ends after two episodes
Rome film festival to showcase Clooney, Streep
Jackson lost will to live, confidante says
| Entertainment
|
Seth Rogen gets dream role: 'Simpsons' writer
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Flaming Lips dial down the whimsy on "Embryonic"
Beautiful Life ends after two episodes
| Entertainment
|
Seth Rogan gets dream role: `Simpsons' writer
Families identify Indonesian militants' remains
"Beautiful Life" ends after two episodes
Flaming Lips dial down the whimsy on Embryonic
| Entertainment
|
NY film festival kicks off with Resnais film
NY film festival kicks off with Resnais film
| Entertainment
|
Photos capture America's essence from road, air
Jackson lost will to live, confidante says
Rome film festival to showcase Clooney, Streep
US Navy looks at letting women serve on submarines
Obama accuses Iran of evasion before Geneva talks
No 'perfect' answers in Afghanistan: Obama
Ahmadinejad dismisses anger over new nuclear site
McChrystal troops request shelved pending review
| International
|
U.S. drone crashes into Iraq political party office
| International
|
Typhoon batters northern Philippines
| International
|
Merkel, Steinmeier in final push for German votes
| International
|
Turks pay final respects to Last Ottoman
| International
|
Madagascar government to protest at UN rejection
| International
|
Suicide bombs kill 16, wound about 150 in Pakistan
Koreans separated for more than 50 years reunite
Residents reject referendum on first Taiwan casino
Obama offers Iran `serious, meaningful dialogue'
Ex-wife: DC sniper said 'you have become my enemy'
Pakistan court session on Mumbai attacks delayed
Gadhafi meets with Lockerbie family members in NYC
Analysis: Wrestling with how to talk about race
China tells Myanmar to protect Chinese residents
Where's Palin? Big bucks for speech in Hong Kong
Thousands flee heavy Philippines rain, flooding
'10 dead, missing' as storm hits Philippines
Conan O'Brien hits head during 'Tonight' stunt
CW's 'Beautiful Life' axed after just 2 airings
Myanmar's Suu Kyi eases sanctions stance
Guests on Sunday news shows
Hong Kong publisher to issue banned China book
Tweeting Ugandan gorillas make friends online
| Technology
|
Bombs kill 15 in Pakistan towns: police
Japan sticks to G8 despite shift to G20
Keillor to host 1st 'Prairie Home' since stroke
Renowned Spanish pianist de Larrocha dies at 86
Works of Edward Hopper on display in Netherlands
Malaysian Muslims rock at Black Eyed Peas concert
AP NewsAlert
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights