Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Health negotiators look at malpractice changes
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Search
Search:
Health negotiators look at malpractice changes
By RICARDO ALONSOZALDIVAR and ERICA WERNER,Associated Press Writers AP - Saturday, September 12
WASHINGTON - Following President Barack Obama's offer of compromise on an issue that has long divided Washington, congressional health care negotiators are considering proposals to foster alternatives to medical malpractice lawsuits.
ADVERTISEMENT
The possibility that malpractice changes could be part of health care legislation that suddenly seems to have better chances of passing has sent doctors and trial lawyers scrambling.
Senators on the Finance Committee are looking at the possibility of special courts in which a judge with medical expertise would hear malpractice cases, says Sen. Kent Conrad, D-N.D. The theory is that medical judges wouldn't be as easily swayed by emotion as are lay juries. Other possibilities include the option of arbitration, as well as some liability protection for doctors who follow "best practice" clinical standards in treating their patients.
Many economists are skeptical that malpractice insurance premiums paid by doctors _ or even the practice of defensive medicine to avoid litigation _ are major reasons for soaring health care costs. But the issue looms large politically because many conservatives in both parties are convinced that doctors routinely order up tests their patients don't need because they're afraid of getting sued.
Obama's overture in his Wednesday night speech could give him a way to peel off some Republican votes, as well as shore up support from moderates in his own party. The president said that while he doesn't see malpractice changes as a "silver bullet," he's talked to enough doctors to suspect that fear of litigation contributes to unnecessary costs. He's directing the Health and Human Services Department to provide funding for pilot programs to test some alternatives to litigation.
"The door is open now to discussion of any kind of legitimate alternative," said Rep. Bart Gordon, D-Tenn., a longtime supporter of malpractice curbs. Two ideas that Gordon has promoted will be part of the administration's pilot programs.
Doctors' groups, which lost the battle for national limits on jury awards for pain and suffering, now see a possibility for other ways to reduce malpractice lawsuits.
"I think there's been significant movement," said Dr. James Rohack, president of the American Medical Association. "The physician community has said it's a problem. The Republicans have said it's a problem. And now you have a Democratic president who says it's time to deal with this."
Trial lawyers say no further action is needed from lawmakers.
"It shouldn't be part of the health reform debate in Congress because the president is already doing something today," said Linda Lipsen, the top lobbyist for the American Association for Justice, which represents lawyers. "I think it should close the door because the president has taken control over the issue."
Administration officials said Obama's order will encourage states to experiment with programs that reduce litigation and promote patient safety. Preventable medical errors are estimated to cause 44,000 to 98,000 deaths a year. HHS officials pointed to two types of programs in particular.
One kind, known as "early disclosure" or "Sorry Works," encourages doctors and hospitals to own up to their mistakes, apologize to patients and their families, and offer restitution as well as a pledge of corrective action to prevent other patients from being harmed by the same mistake.
The second type of program requires would-be malpractice plaintiffs to go before an expert before they proceed to court. The expert _ it can also be a panel _ acts like a grand jury to weed out frivolous cases. Gordon said that since his state of Tennessee adopted such a requirement last year, the number of malpractice cases filed has dropped by 69 percent. And malpractice insurance premiums are expected to decline by 2.5 percent this year.
Lipsen said trial lawyers are concerned that rules for these alternatives to malpractice litigation are written so that people aren't coerced into giving up their right to their day in court.
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Sign in to recommend this article »
0 users recommend
Related Articles: World
UK police probe spy agency MI6 on torture claimAP - 2 hours 12 minutes ago
Iran leader warns opposition of "harsh response"Reuters - 2 hours 34 minutes ago
UN climate chief sees 'significant' Copenhagen dealAFP - 2 hours 36 minutes ago
Health care issues: Controlling medical costsAP - 2 hours 41 minutes ago
Afghan vote delay may help Taliban, US warnsAFP - 2 hours 50 minutes ago
Most Popular – World
Viewed
Britain apologises to WWII code-breaker hero
Greenspan says further financial crisis 'inevitable'
Refurbished Hubble reveals cosmic wonder
Storms delay Discovery landing: NASA
Giant statues reveal red hat secrets: study
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Friday, 11 September 2009 Iraqi shoe thrower might drop TV, turn to activism
Sarkozy pushes ahead with unpopular carbon tax
US Copyright Office concerned by Google book settlement
Russia says Iran proposals something to work with
| International
|
US new jobless claims fall to 550,000
Kurds demand security after bomb kills 19 in Iraq
EU 'not prepared' to lift Zimbabwe sanctions
Google to share scanned books with rivals
200 missing in Sierra Leone boat tragedy
Venezuela's Chavez draws closer to Moscow
| International
|
Iran will not talk about nuclear work with powers
Japan to send first cargo spacecraft to ISS
Hariri gives up bid to form Lebanon unity government
22 killed in Iraq suicide truck bomb attack
Medvedev targets Russia's weaknesses, pledges change
| International
|
Afghan commission orders first ballots invalidated
Mexico hijacker is singing, gunslinging evangelical
| International
|
Motorola unveils Google phone, carrier deals
| Technology
|
China protests Dalai Lama, Uighur speeches
Stampede kills 5 students at New Delhi school
China tainted milk parents warned against meeting
Key U.S. lawmaker seeks changes to broadband rules
| Technology
|
AP NewsAlert
Vietnam, US launch health panel on Agent Orange
Report: Japan executes mentally ill prisoners
The first tailors? Researchers find ancient fiber
Coast Guard to harness tide for electric power
Australian PM: War crimes probe creates challenges
Yale student disappears days before wedding
Wash. mayor loses primary race on coin flip
China military village grooms prize parade troops
Afghanistan: Doubt grows over another distant war
Home sought for bison languishing in quarantine
White House cautiously optimistic on stimulus jobs
Ohio cheetah is fastest land mammal, at 36 mph
Mild El Nino continues, strengthening expected
Beatles set to dominate UK charts once again
| Entertainment
|
CORRECTED: Future, past useless at my age, says actor Sharif
Chinese govt to help finish Revel's AC casino
Chinese gov't to finance rest of Revel's AC casino
Group says Myanmar hid billions in gas revenues
European firms want 'level playing field' in China
Japan's Suntory in talks to buy Orangina
Ex-Morgan Stanley banker guilty of insider trading
Pope invites world artists to Sistine chapel
NY's Met museum reattributes painting to Velazquez
City of Berlin wins top Spanish award
Akin brings comedy to Venice with `Soul Kitchen'
Clean-up at The Met uncovers 'real' Velazquez
Top cable programs for Aug. 31-Sept. 6
Fatih Akin cooks up 'Soul Kitchen' for Venice filmfest
Cash-strapped US art owners hit the pawnshop
Megan Fox, U2 on `Saturday Night Live' opener
Bachelors in Nigerian city flee as 'hunter' goes on prowl
US dampens hopes Iran offer will revive nuke talks
Twitter expands rules to allow advertising
Iran offers talks, but not on its nuclear program
| International
|
Storms delay Discovery landing: NASA
Layoff fears as GM picks Canadian buyer for Opel
NY Times defends mission of kidnapped reporter
Polo's Rugby launches iPhone app for custom shirts
US trade gap widens on record leap in imports
Iran offers talks, but not on its nuclear program
Needle attacks and rumors spread in China's Xinjiang
| International
|
Key U.S. lawmaker seeks changes to broadband rules
Israelis want peace but won't be suckers
Ally of Iran's Mousavi detained: reformist website
| International
|
Motorola unveils Android-powered smartphone, the Cliq
22 killed in Iraq suicide truck bomb attack
Japan new PM may pick cabinet next week
| International
|
Google to share scanned books with rivals
Switzerland bans civil servants from using Facebook
Violence, accidents are killing world's youth: study
| International
|
Blogs are Cuba's free speech outlet: media rights group
Pakistani forces arrest Taliban spokesman in Swat
| International
|
Panasonic offers changes in Sanyo takeover: EU
US-TECH Summary
Yemeni tribes kidnap Russian doctor: official
| International
|
Motorola unveils Android-powered smartphone, the Cliq
US military deaths in Afghanistan region at 746
US military deaths in Iraq war at 4,343
Obama picks GOP Senate aide for CFTC commission
North Korea makes new concession to South Korea
Obama honors 2009 Stanley Cup champion Penguins
Zoo tiger kills one in Vietnam: official
Nine held over new Xinjiang attacks: state media
UN urges Sri Lanka to free its staff
ACORN fires 2 after hidden-camera footage aired
Needle attacks and rumours spread in China's Xinjiang
Motorola unveils Google phone to muted response
| Technology
|
Ex-managers: security firm cut corners at embassy
Japan launches rocket carrying transport vehicle
Twitter expands rules to allow advertising
| Technology
|
Bad weather forces space shuttle to skip landing
Chinese legislator warns against protectionism
US-China extend dialogue to cover counterterrorism
Wallaby win buoys All Blacks for crunch Test
Obama seeks new momentum on healthcare effort
Fraud group voids ballots from Afghan election
Suit claims Milwaukee police coerced witnesses
Perry: Ranger teams to go to Texas-Mexico border
Korea Hot Stocks
Taiwan dlr hits 3-mth high on foreign fund inflows
Japan revised 2Q growth weaker than initial data
Seoul shares hit 14-mth high; banks fuel gains
Japan revises down 2Q economic growth
Markets bump up end-2009 S.Korea rate outlook
Disney says no plans to bring back Jackson 3D film
S.Korean T-bonds extend dive on rate hike concern
Japan revises down 2Q GDP to 2.3 percent growth
DeGeneres: She'll be honest but kind on `Idol'
China to maintain stimulus push: Wen
Porn, fireworks, diamonds made with child labor: US
DeGeneres' Idol gig splits fans but brings buzz
| Entertainment
|
Venice film festival gives voice to Iranian opposition
Judge: Seinfeld book doesn't violate trademark
Seinfelds beat plagiarism, defamation claims in NY
La Toya Jackson says Michael was 'God-like'
Oprah talk show to get second airing on radio
| Entertainment
|
Jackson tribute to kick off MTV Music Video Awards
Gwen Stefani rocks the '80s at NY Fashion Week
Toronto film festival raises curtain on Creation
| Entertainment
|
Almost 40 million people in America live in poverty
Record labels sue over use of songs on Ellen show
| Entertainment
|
Paris Hilton's wisdom immortalized in book of quotes
| Entertainment
|
Seinfelds beat plagiarism, defamation claims in NY
| Entertainment
|
Disney says no plans to bring back Jackson 3D film
| Entertainment
|
Afghan vote delay may help Taliban, US warns
Britain apologises to WWII code-breaker hero
Iran leader issues stern warning to opposition
| International
|
Prisoners riot at Iraq's Abu Ghraib
| International
|
Iran to 'confront' opposition groups: Khamenei
Washington sceptical over Iran nuclear talks offer
Iran's supreme leader warns opposition in sermon
Controversy deepens over Afghan hostage rescue
Russia's Putin says not yet decided on 2012 election
| International
|
Prisoners start fire, riot at Iraq's Abu Ghraib
Rockets hit Israel from Lebanon, no casualties
| International
|
Taliban could benefit from Afghan vote delay: US
China opposes Dalai Lama trip to disputed India state
| International
|
Britain says has major concerns about Afghan vote
| International
|
Nearly 10,000 Sri Lanka war refugees go home
| International
|
Riots rock Uganda capital for second day, 3 killed
| International
|
Motorola unveils Cliq, the Android-powered smartphone
Taiwan ex-president gets life for corruption
China says swine flu spreading inland
Studies: 1 dose of swine flu vaccine works
Career milestones of former Taiwanese president
Harvard's endowment drops sharply amid recession
Obama observing moment of silence for 9/11 victims
Survey: Dioxin levels high in Vietnam near US base
Students burn midnight oil at Boston college
US troops in Afghanistan run to remember 9/11
NATO: 2 service members killed in Afghanistan
The Nation's weather
Health negotiators look at malpractice changes
Taiwan's ex-president jailed for life over graft
2 Malaysia air force pilots killed in runway crash
Japan sends first cargo spacecraft to ISS
Census '10 puts states, groups in campaign mode
Timeline for the 2010 census
State-by-state breakdown of census response rates
Paris Hilton's wisdom immortalized in book of quotes
Oprah talk show to get second airing on radio
Japan's economic growth revised down
China banks lend $1bln to S.Africa's Standard Bank
Pakistani stocks end higher; rupee weakens
Foreign porn makers slam SKorea over discrimation
Japan stocks fall on weak dollar
Seoul shares gain 0.4 pct led by banks, retailers =2
Iranian street protests hit big screen in Venice
TABLE-Foreign trading in Taiwan stocks
Egypt Ramadan TV serials look to stir patriotism
Jet Airways in talks to end 'sick leave' strike
End of a textile era as Jacquard loom closes
China new loans rebound in August: central bank
Bacall, Corman, Willis to get honorary Oscars
Paris Hilton's wisdom immortalized in book of quotes
Organizers cancel Jackson Vienna tribute concert
| Entertainment
|
Oprah talk show to get second airing on radio
U.S. comedy, Israeli war movie lead race in Venice
| Entertainment
|
Dunne eulogized in NY as great dad, friend, gossip
Iranian street protests hit big screen in Venice
| Entertainment
|
Record labels sue over use of songs on "Ellen" show
Terrified Tom Ford launches debut film in Venice
| Entertainment
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights