Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
UN attempts to defend neutrality in Afghanistan
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
UN attempts to defend neutrality in Afghanistan
By EDITH M. LEDERER,Associated Press Writer -
Thursday, October 8
Send
IM Story
Print
UNITED NATIONS – The United Nations attempted to defend the neutrality of its role in Afghanistan's disputed election Wednesday, with the top U.N. official in the country dismissing claims that he favored President Hamid Karzai as "nonsense."
Kai Eide denied allegations by his former deputy Peter Galbraith that he downplayed widespread fraud in the election and thwarted efforts to do something about it. Galbraith, the top American official at the U.N. mission in Afghanistan, was fired last week by Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon.
Eide's three-page rebuttal to Galbraith's charges, sent to senior U.N. officials, was obtained by the Associated Press. The AP also obtained a U.N. table estimating voter turnout in the Aug. 20 presidential election which reveals major discrepancies with the government's official count, fueling fraud allegations.
In Helmand province in the south, where Taliban fighters remain very active, for example, the U.N. estimated that just 38,000 votes were cast while Afghanistan's Independent Election Commission reported 122,376 votes for the top three candidates, including 112,873 for Karzai. In neighboring Kandahar, the U.N. estimated turnout at below 100,000 voters _ compared to the commission's official count of 242,782 votes, 221,436 of them for Karzai.
Galbraith claimed in a letter to the secretary-general that Eide "denied that significant fraud had taken place, even going to the extreme of ordering U.N. staff not to discuss the matter." He also accused Eide of ordering the staff not to share the U.N.'s voter data, which showed "a minuscule turnout in key southern provinces," because it would be "deeply disturbing to president Karzai."
"This is nonsense," Eide said in his response.
He said he "was reluctant to share the data not because it was displeasing to Karzai but because it was difficult to corroborate." The information was made available to U.N. staff working in the Independent Election Commission, or IEC, he said, and the Electoral Complaints Commission, or ECC, "was informed that if they wished, they could have access to this information." he said.
According to the U.N. spreadsheet, first reported by the Washington Post, there were wide discrepancies between the U.N. and the IEC in the south and east where Karzai won by large majorities.
In eastern Paktika province, the U.N. estimated turnout at 35,000 but the IEC reported 206,886 votes were cast, 193,541 for Karzai. And in neighboring Khost, near the Pakistan border, the commission reported 108,473 votes were cast, over 80,000 more than the U.N. estimate of 25,000 voters.
There have also been fraud allegations against Karzai's main rival, former foreign minister Abdullah Abdullah, but to a lesser extend.
The five-member ECC _ which includes three members appointed by Eide _ is doing recounts and audits of ballots that are suspect because of 100 percent turnout or one candidate with more than 95 percent of votes. The ECC is expected to issue its order to the IEC about how many votes to throw out, and the IEC _ whose members were all appointed by Karzai _ will then announce the final results, probably sometime next week.
In the initial count by the IEC, Karzai received 54.6 percent of the vote. If Karzai does not get 50 percent when the final results are announced, he will face a runoff against Abdullah, who has alleged widespread fraud by the government and backed Galbraith.
Galbraith told the AP that Eide "is operating on the assumption that the IEC is a nonpartisan, objective institution."
"In fact, it is a pro-Karzai body which was complicit on all the fraud that took place," he said.
Eide said in his rebuttal that his fundamental difference with Galbraith was that "I sided with the institutions" _ the IEC and the ECC.
"If one is serious about state-building in Afghanistan, one must allow these nascent institutions to work and to grow," he said. "This means allowing them to make their own mistakes. I was confident that the process had the safeguards it needed."
Three U.N. officials held a news conference at U.N. headquarters Wednesday to back Eide and refute Galbraith's claims.
Edmond Mulet, the assistant secretary-general for peacekeeping, said Galbraith proposed closing 1,500 of the 6,900 polling stations because they were in volatile areas, and annulling the election because of fraud and setting up a transitional government _ actions which were "completely out of bounds" with the U.N. mandate which was to support the Afghan election process, not to monitor it.
Galbraith countered on Wednesday that he never proposed annulling the election and accused the U.N. of "a desperate attempt to obfuscate the issue in this dispute" which was Eide's failure to deal with fraud.
In his letter to Ban, Galbraith said he learned on Sept. 2 that the IEC was about to abandon its published safeguards against fraud and include a large number of Karzai votes "that it knew to be fraudulent." He said he spoke to the chief electoral officer to urge that the IEC stick with the established procedures which provoked a protest from Afghanistan's foreign minister and a threat from its U.N. ambassador to have him expelled from the country.
Eide said it was not his job nor his deputy's "to become bureaucratic warlords."
"I do not believe that Peter was willfully interfering in the electoral process," Eide said. "But his actions opened him up to the charge that he was. That was a political error on his part. It was carelessness of the sort that we cannot easily afford in Afghanistan."
Galbraith told AP on Wednesday that his intervention stopped the IEC from changing the procedure for five days "and then when they realized it meant Karzai would face a runoff, they went ahead and changed the procedure."
"With 100,000 troops in Afghanistan, the international community clearly has an interest in honest Afghan elections, and that clearly means sticking with the published anti-fraud guidelines," he added.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
U.S. cool to Mugabe's overture for better ties Reuters - Thursday, October 8
U.S. Senate health bill costs pegged at $829 billion Reuters - Thursday, October 8
Pacific quakes stir panic but tsunamis tiny Reuters - Thursday, October 8
Honduras talks start, police disperse protesters Reuters - Thursday, October 8
Boxer plans hearing on toxic school drinking water AP - Thursday, October 8
News Search
Top Stories
British bank mulls huge rights issue: report
Tiny device could speed breast cancer detection: study
Tiny moon feeds largest ring around Saturn
Aer Lingus to slash hundreds of jobs, cut pay
Europe hits hole on rough road to economic recovery
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Gold price hits record high on report to ditch dollar
Letterman apologizes to wife over affairs
Tiny moon feeds largest ring around Saturn
'Masters of light' win Nobel Physics Prize
Cracks emerge as IMF, World Bank work for recovery
More Most Viewed »
Oldest hominid skeleton sheds light on human origins
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Thursday, 8 October 2009 Welcome to Hawaii Pacific Teleport
Welcome to Hawaii Pacific Teleport
Russian journalist's unsolved killing remembered
Egypt breaks ties with France's Louvre Museum
Japan's tech titans ready for 3D tussle
Turkey expects to seal deal with Armenia, doubts emerge
Turkey's Gul lobbies hostile France on EU bid
Nobel Peace prize seeks return to activist roots
| International
|
Iran says some countries offer it nuclear fuel
EU moves towards Microsoft truce
Hamas asks to delay reconciliation deal: Hamas source
Russia, Turkmenistan end gas dispute: Kremlin
Egyptian imam seeks $10 million in CIA renditions trial
| International
|
Saudi faces prison over TV sex revelations
Afghan vote subject to complex fraud audit
Ahmadinejad calls Geneva talks a 'step forward'
Somali pirates attack French military flagship
EU warns Czechs about costs of treaty delays
Annan says some Kenyan big men to face ICC
| International
|
French minister under fire for gay sex tourism
| International
|
Obama turning to Hollywood for health reform help
Dell plans first U.S. smartphone with AT&T: report
| Technology
|
Nearly 100 charged in US, Egypt in ID theft scheme
FCC chief lauds opening of wireless networks
| Technology
|
Statue of Helen Keller to be installed in Capitol
Djokovic cruises, Sharapova out at China Open
Orange County water main break creates sinkhole
Online ads: Big Brother or customer service?
| Technology
|
Ex-prep school dean charged with 4th sex assault
China: North Korea nuclear talks could resume
Google, authors asked to submit deal changes by November 9
| Technology
|
Duncan: Chicago education plan not causing deaths
Labor nominee clears divided Senate panel
Khmer Rouge tribunal summons gov't party officials
Vietnam typhoon damage estimate hits $785 mln: UN
Man sentenced to 7 years in frozen chicken scam
Typhoon threatens Japan; troops aid Philippines
Slain Florida couple's daughter appears on `Oprah'
Tajikistan downgrades Russian language
Maldives to hold cabinet meeting underwater
Pakistan expects 'tough resistance' in Waziristan
Biden stumps for NJ's Corzine at union convention
Myanmar's Suu Kyi meets junta minister: official
Foreign rescue teams leave quake-hit Indonesia city
HSBC in advanced talks on buying RBS Asia assets: report
Jaguar reports loan from Indian bank
Honda switches Japan work to British plant
IMF faces headwinds in expanded role
Panasonic, rivals fined for price-fixing
ADB lends $500 mln to revive Indonesian economy
Pakistani stocks rise to year high; rupee firms
Two new movies lift lid on Brazil's dark side
South Korean plane delayed by bird on board
Naomi Watts tops list of actresses to invest in
The Manhattan Transfer -- 40 years and still singing
Artist wraps women's eyes around old heart of Paris
With Obamas, art changes on White House walls
Indonesia mulls declaring villages mass graves
Last-minute Prince decision to stage two Paris concerts Sunday
Aid reaches villagers deep in Indonesia quake zone
Jung's Red Book on display for first time
A list of nominees at Taiwan's Golden Horse Awards
Aid helps quake victims and Indonesia's sick
Kandahar NATO base: hockey, discos and funerals
Post-Saddam film headlines Abu Dhabi festival
Naomi Watts tops list of actresses to invest in
| Entertainment
|
The Manhattan Transfer -- 40 years and still singing
| Entertainment
|
Two new movies lift lid on Brazil's dark side
| Entertainment
|
Obama mulls troop boost request for Afghanistan
British bank mulls huge rights issue: report
US-TECH Summary
Blast outside Indian embassy in Kabul kills 12
| International
|
UN attempts to defend neutrality in Afghanistan
Tiny device could speed breast cancer detection: study
Security Council to raise UN Gaza report next week
Mobile device makers want common earphone plugs
Pacific quakes stir panic but tsunamis tiny
| International
|
Typhoon Melor buffets Japan, disrupts industry
| International
|
U.N. council compromises over Gaza report debate
Pakistan wants U.S. 'trust, drones, market access
| International
|
FCC chief lauds wireless companies
Disappearance of Iranian scientist creates mystery
North Korea not near restoring nuclear plant: South
| International
|
Abbas faces more anger over UN war crimes report
Rights activists see double standard in Twitter arrest
Aer Lingus to slash hundreds of jobs, cut pay
US, Afghan troops seize tonnes of opium, kill 17 Taliban
Time 4 u 2 quit. Text messaging found to help smokers
Honduras talks start, police disperse protesters
| International
|
Dell closing US plant, cutting 900 jobs
Reformist website: Iran protester gets death sentence
| International
|
Google, authors to submit revised book deal Nov 9
Iraqi security forces strain budget, PM says
Taliban say control area after battle with U.S.
| International
|
Iran sees U.S. role in researcher's disappearance
| International
|
Saudi king in Damascus to mend fences with Assad
"Google phones" gaining market momentum
Hamas asks to delay reconciliation deal: Hamas source
YouTube pacts heighten copyright vigilance
Bing search gets vocal on new Samsung mobile phone
Bing search gets vocal on new Samsung mobile phone
Honduran leader offers to leave if Zelaya steps aside
'American Qur'an' blends US life, Quranic verses
Report: Global Muslim population hits 1.57 billion
Court papers: DNA at store matches elusive teen
Pakistan wants U.S. "trust", drones, market access
Pacific islanders flee as quakes prompt tsunami alert
Dell plans first U.S. smartphone with AT&T: source
| Technology
|
One dead as strong typhoon batters Japan
Time 4 u 2 quit. Text messaging found to help smokers
| Technology
|
China's Hu calls on police to protect Tiananmen
U.S. cool to Mugabe's overture for better ties
Rights activists see double standard in Twitter arrest
| Technology
|
Obama to make Asian debut tour next month
FCC chief lauds wireless companies
| Technology
|
U.S. Senate health bill costs pegged at $829 billion
Pakistan says US investment can fight extremism
Boxer plans hearing on toxic school drinking water
Pot legalization gains momentum in California
Small tsunami forms in Pacific, warnings canceled
Powerful 7.8 quake off Vanuatu, tsunami alert
Strong quakes near Vanuatu spark tsunami alert
Army unit's morale improving after 8 deaths
7.3 earthquake hits South Pacific, minutes after 7.8: USGS
Amid the global economic crisis, China rises
Korea Hot Stocks
Japan's current account surplus up 10.4 pct
Seoul shares up 0.4 pct; Tong Yang below IPO price
Fashion photographer Irving Penn dead at 92
| Entertainment
|
Aerosmith guitarist goes solo as band flounders
| Entertainment
|
S.Korea exports recovery seen accelerating -survey
Guy Ritchie says he still loves retarded Madonna
| Entertainment
|
Data adds to S.Korea econ hopes as rate rise looms
Beastie Boys' Yauch hopeful he has beaten cancer
| Entertainment
|
S.Korea T-bonds edge up on U.S. lead; rate vote eyed
Australia Michael Jackson skit sparks racism calls
| Entertainment
|
Barbra Streisand tops U.S. pop chart for ninth time
| Entertainment
|
Seoul shares rise; Tong Yang Life below IPO price
British actress gets An Education in Oscar buzz
| Entertainment
|
Leonard Nimoy gets new sci-fi life on Fringe
| Entertainment
|
CBS orders full seasons of NCIS: LA, Good Wife
| Entertainment
|
Ellen Page to write comedy series for HBO
| Entertainment
|
A well-spoken Jude Law charges through 'Hamlet'
TV news channels explode in Europe but future unsure
Australia Michael Jackson skit sparks racism calls
No charges over Mel Gibson DUI report leaks
Guy Ritchie says he still loves "retarded" Madonna
Leonard Nimoy gets new sci-fi life on "Fringe"
Soprano Sills' estate sells for more than $500K
Fashion photographer Irving Penn dead at 92
British actress gets "An Education" in Oscar buzz
Celebrities to judge videos backing US health care reforms
Poland to sign EU's Lisbon treaty Sunday: ministry
Breakthrough hope for breast cancer treatment
Grim omens as U.S. envoy pursues Mideast relaunch
| International
|
Bank of England keeps interest rate at 0.5%
Car bomb kills 17 near Indian embassy in Kabul
At least 3 dead in Kabul blast: AFP photographer
US Solar Decathlon seeks best sun-powered homes
Italy's Berlusconi vows to stay, tension worrying
| International
|
Saudi Arabia, Syria urge unity government in Lebanon
| International
|
Nobel literature winner Mueller lost for words
| International
|
Turkey eyes talks by Azeri, Armenian leaders
| International
|
Japan new PM seeks to build trust with Beijing, Seoul
| International
|
Ex-cop pleads not guilty to posing as twin for sex
Landslide kills 6 Philippine health workers
Pakistani government defends US aid bill
Highest military court to hear Abu Ghraib appeal
Nadal edges Blake to reach China Open quarters
Red Cross aid appeal for Indonesia quake victims
Scientists race to prevent ash tree's extinction
New quakes, small tsunami panic Pacific islanders
Woman found in Fla. home under 8 feet of trash
Japan court acquits file-sharing software creator
Radio host seeks pardon for executed SC ancestors
Taiwan court orders hearing on Chen detention
'Nazi guard' trial to begin November 30: court
Roadside bomb wounds 10 soldiers in Thai south
AP NewsAlert
US encounters stumbling blocks in training Afghans
Sex crime charges shock Oregon wine country town
Obama to hold private meetings
WRAPUP 2-S.Korea ups lending controls, rate rise bets still on
Pakistani stocks, rupee end weaker on U.S. aid row
Pakistan's forex reserves rise to $14.75 bln
Oil prices rebound as stock markets surge
Taiwan dollar hits 1-yr high on funds, exporters
SKorea, EU to set final text of trade deal
S.Korea, EU to sign free trade deal next week
Australia bank loses tax avoidance case in NZ
Indian firms' earnings weak, better times ahead
Widow asks Toyota to act quickly on floor mats
Nobel literature winner Mueller lost for words
| Entertainment
|
Indonesia police say Sulawesi "blast" not bomb
Indonesia's Golkar party elects new head
Indonesian graft fighter charged with murder
Herta Mueller wins Nobel Literature Prize
Pusan festival opens with Korean political comedy
Aussie TV channel apologises for Jackson sketch
Thai villager beats back waves, but faces new threat
Van Gogh was also a wordsmith, his letters reveal
Nick Nolte's son, Brawley Nolte, arrested
Herta Mueller wins Nobel Literature Prize
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Beastie Boys' Yauch "hopeful" he has beaten cancer
CBS orders full seasons of "NCIS: LA", "Good Wife"
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights