Reuters top ten news stories delivered to your inbox each day.
You are here:
Business & Finance
The Great Debate
Do More With Reuters
Make Reuters My Homepage
Support (Customer Zone)
About Thomson Reuters
Rights activists see double standard in Twitter arrest
Wed Oct 7, 2009 9:11pm EDT
Email | Print |
| Reprints | Single Page
By Michelle Nichols
NEW YORK (Reuters) - The arrest of a New Yorker for using Twitter to alert protesters to police movements at a meeting of world leaders in Pittsburgh last month would be deemed a human rights violation if it happened in Iran or China, rights activists charge.
Pittsburgh police arrested Elliot Madison, 41, on September 24 as hundreds of people -- some throwing rocks and breaking shop windows -- protested on the first day of a summit of the Group of 20 rich and developing nations.
The protesters, with a broadly anti-capitalist agenda, were kept well away from the convention site where the leaders held their two-day meeting. Police sporadically used pepper gas to disperse them.
The criminal complaint against Madison said he broke the law by using Twitter to direct unlawful protesters and other people involved in criminal acts to avoid arrest and to inform them of police movements and actions. Twitter allows subscribers to publish 140-character text messages.
Madison, who was released on bail, is charged with hindering apprehension or prosecution, criminal use of communication facility and, possessing instruments of crime -- defined as telecommunications equipment.
"The same conduct (of authorities) in Iran or China during recent demonstrations would be called human right violations whereas here it's called necessary crime control," Vic Walczak, legal director of the American Civil Liberties Union of Pennsylvania, told Reuters. "It's a real double standard."
Twitter was used by protesters in Iran amid the protests and government clampdown that followed the country's disputed June elections. At one point, the U.S. State Department even urged Twitter to delay a planned upgrade that would have temporarily cut service to Iran.
China has blocked access to online sites such as Twitter several times, including in May ahead of the 20th anniversary of the Tiananmen Square crackdown and again in July following ethnic unrest in the northwestern region of Xinjiang.
Pittsburgh police, asked about what was illegal about Madison's actions, noted the charge that Madison was hindering apprehension or prosecution by law enforcement.
"All law enforcement agencies must keep abreast of constant developments in technology, both for determining how technology can help police better serve the public and for uncovering ways in which technology can be used to commit crime," spokeswoman Myra Taylor said. "The criminal complaint alleges that Mr Madison used legal devices to perform illegal acts."
Laura DeNardis, executive director of Yale Law School's Information Society Project, said Madison's arrest could be used "by repressive countries who may be looking to crack down on technologies."
"They might cite this as a justification for thwarting free speech in even more direct ways and for cracking down in cases like we saw in the Iranian election protests," said DeNardis. "To me this seems like a double standard."
Madison was arrested in a Pittsburgh motel, but authorities raided his home in the New York City borough of Queens on Thursday and his lawyer Martin Stolar went to Brooklyn Federal Court on Friday to ask for the return of property taken.
"It's an outrageous use of criminal law to punish dissent, to punish speech, which tends to support dissent, and it is the most unique application of the criminal law to the use of Twitter that I have ever seen," said Stolar.
"Essentially we have Elliot accused of taking publicly available information and giving it to another person in the public and then being charged with a crime for doing so," he said. "I'm missing something here." Continued...
View article on single page
FCC chief lauds wireless companies
Also On Reuters
Blog: Amazon's Kindle going places, but rivals fast behind
Online ads: Big Brother or customer service?
Blog: Content, convergence and creativity
More Technology News
Dell plans first U.S. smartphone with AT&T: source
Time 4 u 2 quit. Text messaging found to help smokers
FCC chief lauds wireless companies
Amazon.com takes Kindle global
Dell brings baseball, fashion designs to PCs
More Technology News...
A selection of our best photos from the past 24 hours. Slideshow
Most Popular on Reuters
8.1 magnitude earthquake strikes northwest of Vanuatu
Barbra Streisand tops U.S. pop chart for ninth time
Pakistan wants US 'trust,' drones, market access
Pakistan wants U.S. "'trust", drones, market access | Video
Amazon up on Kindle price cut, overseas launch
Afghan Taliban say they pose no threat to the West
Italian scientist reproduces Shroud of Turin
Guy Ritchie says he still loves "retarded" Madonna
Alcoa sees aluminum demand picking up in second half
Senate health bill costs pegged at $829 billion
Most Popular Articles RSS Feed
Ribosome riddle delivers Nobel prize
Japan's next-gen green cars
Qureshi: Pakistan wants drones
Olympics give Rio shot at rebirth
Sister says remember Politkovskaya
Farmers plow coal to stop warming
CCTV captures Indonesia quake terror
Turkish protesters rock IMF meeting
Talk of the Town
Human lung stolen in Peru
Most Popular Videos RSS Feed
Help and Contact Us |
Advertise With Us |
Journalism Handbook |
Site Index |
Thomson Reuters Corporate:
Professional Products |
Professional Products Support |
About Thomson Reuters |
Latin America |
United Kingdom |
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.