Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Topping test tables no longer enough for China
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Australia
China
India
Indonesia
Japan
Malaysia
Philippines
Thailand
Vietnam
Topping test tables no longer enough for China
AFP - 1 hour 59 minutes ago
Send
IM Story
Print
Topping test tables no longer enough for China
SHANGHAI (AFP) - – Shanghai students may have topped a recent global survey but educators in China are not rejoicing, saying the country has a long way to go before rote learning and test-taking turn into innovation.
The 500 Shanghai students who participated in the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) study released last month outperformed the rest of the world in reading, science and mathematics.
It was the first time mainland Chinese students had taken part in the Programme for International Student Assessment, or PISA -- a study carried out every three years that benchmarks 470,000 15-year-old pupils in 65 countries.
But while the OECD results sparked alarm overseas as further evidence of China gaining on the rest of the world, Chinese educators are hardly triumphal and say different skills are needed to compete in a global knowledge economy.
"Since China opened up to the world, we found children in foreign countries were relatively more creative and better at solving problems in real life," said Ding Yi, vice-principal at Shanghai's Jing'an Education College Affiliated School.
"We're constantly thinking about this problem," said Ding, whose students took the PISA test.
In the United States and Europe, the findings triggered fears of falling behind China. US Secretary of Education Arne Duncan called it a "wake-up call".
Chester Finn, who served in former US president Ronald Reagans Department of Education, likened China's scores to "Sputnik" -- the Soviet satellite launched in 1957 that startled America into action in the space race.
But Yong Zhao, the University of Oregon's associate dean for global education, drew a simpler conclusion.
"When you spend all your time preparing for tests, and when students are selected based on their test-taking abilities, you get outstanding test scores," Yong wrote on his blog.
The two-hour PISA features a mix of multiple-choice and open-answer questions based on written passages describing real-life situations.
A sample math question asks students which pizza is better value: one that is 30 centimetres in diameter and costs 30 "zeds" or a 40-cm pizza costing 40 "zeds." Students must show their reasoning.
In China, where national achievements are typically trumpeted loudly, the PISA rankings barely made a ripple.
Ding said they showed merely that the country's education reforms and investments to improve schools were bearing fruit.
China has said its spending on education has been rising steadily from a World Bank estimate of 2.9 percent of gross domestic product in 2001 to four percent for 2012.
Ding said that over the past decade, her school's curriculum had evolved to move beyond traditional basic subjects like math, Chinese, and science to classes such as creative writing, building robots and designing web pages.
More emphasis was put on independent research projects as well, she said.
She added that in China, the only tests that truly matter are the fiercely competitive high school and college entrance exams that serve as gateways to the best schools and opportunities.
But even those are being questioned. A study of more than 1,000 top scorers from 1977 to 2008 showed none stood out as successes in academia, business or politics, the state-run China Daily reported after last June's college test.
The paucity of China-reared Nobel prize winners in science despite its huge population of more than 1.3 billion people is also a source of hand-wringing.
"We are really concerned about the situation here and want to see real improvement," said Tao Hongkai, who heads an education research institute at Huazhong Normal University in the central city of Wuhan.
"We won't be complacent about this superficial data."
Schools in Shanghai, China's gleaming commercial hub, also are not considered representative of those in the country as a whole. Vast, poor, inland regions are far less well-funded and struggle to attract good teachers.
By contrast, the Jing'an school features a robotics lab, a new media lab with 40 new Apple computers and a geography room with 3-D maps and a weather station.
These facilities signal a shift away from rote learning, Ding said.
"Not every problem can be solved on a test paper," she said.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Hitmen 'killed Philippine journalist for $3,370' AFP - 1 hour 16 minutes ago
Trial for China hit-and-run suspect as Net rages AFP - 1 hour 27 minutes ago
Topping test tables no longer enough for China AFP - 1 hour 59 minutes ago
Somali pirates could face prosecution in Malaysia AFP - 2 hours 26 minutes ago
China's Li charges into Aus Open semis AFP - 2 hours 53 minutes ago
News Search
Top Stories
Federer into eighth Australian Open semi
Amnesty slams Shell over oil spills in Nigeria
Facebook agrees German privacy-protection deal
World jobless rate stuck at record high: ILO
Oprah meets sister she never knew she had
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Bank of America posts heavy losses
'Inconclusive' Iran nuclear talks enter final day
US expert panel gives nod to Alzheimer's scan
Migraines don't damage brain: study
More than 40 injured in Algeria clashes
More Most Viewed »
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Weekend Edition
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo!
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Entertainment
Photos
Yahoo! News Network
Copyright © 2011 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Tuesday, 25 January 2011 Iran hangs two for involvement in vote unrest
35 killed in Moscow airport suicide bombing
Hezbollah-backed Mikati set to lead Lebanon government
France rallies China, Russia for G20 reform drive
Head of presumed Moscow suicide bomber found: report
Triple attacks on Shiite pilgrims in Iraq kill 12
World needs food system overhaul: report
Afghan president says parliament will open
Peru recognizes Palestinian state
|
At least 31 killed in Moscow airport blast: Interfax
Huawei sues to alter Motorola-Nokia Siemens deal
Irish election likely to be held in late February
|
U.N. defends Ban Ki-moon against rights criticism
|
Syria among worst for rights abuses: HRW report
|
Egypt government warns activists against Tuesday protest
|
Correction: Aniston, Kutcher vie for Hollywood's worst awards
High-tech gear helped S. Korea raid on pirates
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Oprah Winfrey says speechless at news of half-sister
Research firm sees Twitter's ad revenue tripling
|
Aniston, Kutcher vie for Hollywood's worst awards
Intel boosts buyback funds as shares underperform
|
Ed Helms talks "Cedar Rapids" and "Hangover 2"
Foursquare sees no funding needs this year
|
AOL to air podcasts by Kevin Smith, Adam Carolla
Huawei sues Motorola over IP transfer
Latin American chefs test mettle at world contest
Queen Victoria stamps set Hong Kong record
India says inflation fight priority as rate hike looms
Toshiba and GlobalFoundries in chip production talks
|
Indian tribe faces extinction threat: campaigners
Pakistani stocks end down; rupee weakens; o/n rates up
HP to phase out Neoview data warehousing product: sources
|
BBC shrinks online unit to cut costs and refocus
Social networking leads to sex faster: survey
|
Music mood muted despite Lady Gaga, more big albums
Oprah Winfrey says speechless at news of half-sister
|
Christina Aguilera to sing Super Bowl national anthem
|
Ed Helms talks Cedar Rapids and Hangover 2
|
AOL to air podcasts by Kevin Smith, Adam Carolla
|
US-TECH Summary
Foursquare sees no funding needs this year
Nvidia shares extend rally after Barron's article
BBC to slash online budget by a quarter
HP to phase out Neoview data warehousing product: sources
China's online crusaders gain ground
Huawei sues to alter Motorola-Nokia Siemens deal
Groupon CEO says exploring IPO; no decision
Luxury watchmakers fishing for friends on Facebook
Electronic giving increasing for church collections
Iran hangs two activists held in post-vote demos
Medvedev blames security lapse for Moscow blast
|
Afghan security plan 'at risk': US official
Sharp files LCD patent lawsuits against AU in U.S.
Italy's bishops, business sector warn sex scandal harms country
Hezbollah-backed Mikati set to lead Lebanon government
|
Federer into eighth Australian Open semi
Talks under way for body to oversee Tunisia cabinet
|
Palestinians sought symbolic refugee return--leaks
Going digital may not improve U.S. patient care
Amnesty slams Shell over oil spills in Nigeria
Security apps boost Apple as BlackBerry alternative
Leaks show Palestinians giving much ground to Israel
|
Facebook agrees German privacy-protection deal
Discrepancies mar south Sudan independence vote
FAO wants price curbs and warns of food crisis: report
|
Facebook agrees German privacy-protection deal: official
World jobless rate stuck at record high: ILO
Protests as Lebanon tycoon set to be next premier
Oprah meets sister she never knew she had
Discrepancies mar south Sudan independence vote
|
Hezbollah-backed Mikati set to lead Lebanon government
Google and Mozilla take 'Do Not Track' steps
One-clawed dino belonged to T. Rex family
Pink bikers fight Mexican drug war by helping poor
|
Hariri supporters accuse Hezbollah of Lebanon coup
Twitter 2011 ad revenue estimated at $150 million
Huawei sues to alter Motorola-Nokia Siemens deal
Hitmen 'killed Philippine journalist for $3,370'
Trial for China hit-and-run suspect as Net rages
Social networking leads to sex faster: survey
Topping test tables no longer enough for China
Protests as Hariri camp accuses Hezbollah of coup
Toshiba and GlobalFoundries in chip production talks
Somali pirates could face prosecution in Malaysia
Huawei sues to alter Motorola-Nokia Siemens deal
'Sex and the City 2,' 'Twilight' top Oscars spoof awards
Security apps boost Apple as BlackBerry alternative
|
China's Li charges into Aus Open semis
Facebook film tipped as Oscars nods unveiled
US engineer jailed for tech sale to China: report
Groupon CEO says exploring IPO; no decision
|
Kevin Smith goes on "Red State" Twitter rant
Federer into eighth straight Aus Open semi
Australia navy 'sex ring' unacceptable: minister
Going digital may not improve U.S. patient care
|
Clinton says Mexico drug crackdown 'necessary'
Aniston, Kutcher vie for Hollywood's worst awards
Japan suspect in Briton murder 'to release book'
Foursquare sees no funding needs this year
|
Indonesians charged over Australia boat wreck
Russia warns NATO of nuclear deployment
BlackBerry program may help RIM defend its turf
|
Royals' favourite Alpine haunt delivers polo with a twist
A literary melting pot in India's 'pink city'
TI's margins disappoint, envisions spending hike
|
School hijab ban divides Muslim Azerbaijan
Sharp files LCD patent lawsuits against AU in U.S.
|
'Sex and the City 2,' 'Twilight' top Oscars spoof awards
Former MSNBC anchor Olbermann says career not dead
Facebook film tipped as Oscars nods unveiled
China pianist denies White House political snub
Facebook, Twitter oust Myspace for music fans: experts
Japanese pensions costing 10% of GDP
Subway joins growing ad exit from MTV show "Skins"
Seoul shares end up 0.2 pct, lifted by techs, autos
Korea Hot Stocks-Sajodaerim jumps on Russian acquisition hopes
Taiwan stocks up; tourism shrs jump on China travel hopes
Seoul shares open modestly higher, lifted by techs
NZ services sector perks up in December
Former MSNBC anchor Olbermann says career not dead
|
Prada board to mull Hong Kong IPO this week: source
Oprah Winfrey says speechless at news of half-sister
|
Chinese banking giant ICBC opens branch in Spain
Kardashian sisters continue to draw high TV ratings
|
Chaz Bono a regular Joe says film director
|
Japan central bank keeps rates steady
Christina Aguilera to sing Super Bowl national anthem
|
Subway joins growing ad exit from MTV show Skins
|
Kevin Smith goes on Red State Twitter rant
|
Jay Leno to get Harvard Hasty pudding award
|
Comedian Steve Harvey attacked by ex-wife on YouTube
|
Virtual fishing to get reel in Japan
Rwandan war crimes suspect arrives on Dutch soil
British economy suffers shock slump
Siemens profit gains 15%
Microsoft and RIM grow on app developers: survey
Egypt police prepare for Day of Wrath protest
|
Kids who misbehave face trouble as adults: study
Sudan's Bashir pledges support for independent south
|
Female suicide bomber suspected in Moscow blast
Thousands defy violence, mark Muslim rite in Iraq
|
Serbian court to rule on French fan murder
Abbas welcomed home as hero while Qatar denounced
|
West's portrayal of Afghan war deceptive: group
|
Bomb kills 9 civilians in restive Thai south
|
Suicide attack near Pakistan Shi'ite rally kills 13
|
Facebook film tipped as Oscars nods unveiled
Bomb kills 9 civilians in restive Thai south
Four dead in Manila bus bombing; investigation starts
Man falls to death at Indonesia's int'l airport
Indonesian farmers spot mysterious 'crop circle'; aliens suspected
'Glee' spells happiness for bands and brands
Thai "yellow shirts" rally over border row
Corrected
Google's Schmidt expects another 10 years at Google
|
Online paid news service launched for big papers
|
Thailand's 'Yellow Shirts' stage new protest
Jackson doctor to be arraigned for killing star
Ericsson sees strong 2011 as data traffic explodes
|
Southeast Asia facing new 'health crisis'
Farmland seizures spark sharp divide in Venezuela
IMF sees faster growth but recovery 'still at risk'
Parrot-sized dinosaur draws world attention
Morocco, South Africa in another bid contest
Microsoft and RIM grow on app developers: survey
|
Vietnamese shuttler at No. 7
DnB NOR says Korea Line exposure less than $35 mln
Verizon wireless growth beats expectations
|
Phuket attracts record number of tourists in 2010
India hikes rates again to combat inflation
Pakistani stocks end up; rupee firms; o/n rates down
Asian shares mixed as India hikes rates
Bank of Japan raises growth view, holds rates
Volvo unveils new China headquarters
Korea Line seeks receivership as freight rates tumble
Sharp files LCD patent suit against Taiwan's AUO
IMF sees faster global growth, eurozone risk
After 13 years, U.S. removes restrictions on top Indian companies
The Kings Speech, True Grit lead Oscar nominations
Medicare recovers $2.5 billion in fraudulent claims
Air Force command chief pleads guilty to sexual misconduct
Heart disease costs expected to triple by 2030
McDonalds hints of price increase this year
The King's Speech, True Grit lead Oscar field
|
Weight loss and walking key to improving senior mobility
Elton John does not expect invite to royal wedding
|
Kelly Osbourne named the new face of Madonna's Material Girl fashions
U.N. seeks international communitys support for Somalia
Judi Dench, Plan B among South Bank Award winners
|
U.S. Postal Service mulls closure of 2,000 offices
Ericsson sees strong 2011 as data traffic explodes
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights