Home
U.S.
World
Entertainment
Sports
Business
Health
Science
Technology
Politics
Offbeat
Environment
Travel
News
Articles
Are UN Sanctions Against Iran Kicking In?
Email
Facebook
Digg
Twitter
Buzz Up!
ShareThis
June 29, 2010 9:23 a.m. EST
Topics: politics, foreign aid, economic sanction, United States
The Media Line Staff
United States (TML) - By all objective standards, this week Iran is facing some version of a moment of truth. Responding to the impending imposition of beefed-up United Nations economic sanctions, French oil company Total announced publicly that it was suspending oil shipments to Iran and the Spanish oil giant Repsol withdrew from a contract to develop part of a large Iranian oil field. Even Iran’s neighbor, the United Arab Emirates, announced a series of moves to comply with the strengthened sanctions regime.
But analysts disagree over the import of the sanctions, and the degree to which the new approach will influence the Iranian government.
“These new sanctions will target Iran's financial sector, Iran's ability to trade, Iran’s ability to communicate with the external world and travel, which begins to target the energy sector, and squeeze a number of companies connected to the revolutionary guard,” Dr Emanuele Ottolenghi, a Senior Fellow at the Foundation for the Defense of Democracies and author of Under a Mushroom Cloud - Europe, Iran and the Bomb, told The Media Line. “All of these things combined will have a significant effect.”
“Obviously, it could have been much tougher, but there are some aspects of the resolution which if implemented honestly, conscientiously and resolutely can do a great deal of damage at a time when the Iranian economy is particularly fragile due to the vast incompetence of the current government. And the internal political situation makes the government more vulnerable,” he continued. “If you look at sanctions as a way to slow down and damage the efforts of the regime then these efforts are valuable.”
“Those who think that sanctions will solve the problem are wrong: sanctions are not going to convince President Ahmadinejad or the Supreme Leader Khamenei to reconsider their approach to nuclear power, nor are sanctions going to bring down the regime,” Dr Ottolenghi said. “But if properly implemented, sanctions can achieve two goals: first, to reduce the ability of Iran to procure and acquire sensitive technology abroad which will significantly slow down the Iranian race to nuclear weapons. The second value of the sanctions is that they will immensely raise costs for Iran to engage in all of its illicit activities, wreaking havoc into the system by, for example, by sowing discontent among those within the regime who are in it just for the profit.”
But Dr. Seyed Mohammad Marandi, a professor at the University of Tehran, argued that the sanctions would fail in their stated goals.
“I don’t think that sanctions will have a major effect on Iran, especially since the Iranians had been preparing for the sanctions for quite awhile now,” he told The Media Line. “Iran is trading less and less with Europe and North America; and has been finding alternative partners in Asia, Latin America and Africa.
“Beyond diversifying its trade, Iran has also become more independent, for example in its consumption of oil, with heavy investment in oil refineries,” Dr Marandi said. “So Iran is much more independent than it was a few years ago.”
“There will be a minor effect,” he continued. “For example hospitals will have difficulty importing equipment from Europe. But at the end of the day it’s not going to have a major effect on the Iranian economy, and the irony is that the more sanctions that the west places on Iran, the greater the gap between them and the less leverage Western countries have over Iran.”
Dr Mehrdad Khonsari, a former Iranian diplomat and Senior Research Consultant at the Centre for Arab and Iranian Studies, argued that the sanctions would delay, but not solve, the principal conflict between Iran and the West.
“The sanctions will obviously have some kind of an effect on the Iranian economy by making conditions worse for all Iranians,” he told The Media Line. “But it will not be of sufficient strength or magnitude to force the Iranian government to change its stance or go a different way.”
“Life will become harder, Iran’s flexibility within the international community will be marginalized, but it doesn’t mean that the sanctions will achieve the behavior which they are aimed at achieving,” Dr Khonsari continued. “The oil companies are not pulling out, and those who are buying Iran’s oil are still buying the oil. What they are doing is essentially making sure that there is no new investment or technology and that production levels don’t increase.”
“If the international community were serious about containing Iran’s development towards nuclear weapons, they would recognize reality: we are moving towards a military confrontation, which is exactly what Ahmadinejad wants,” he said. “Sanctions are not working; diplomacy is not working; so what else is left? The choice is very clear.”
Copyright © 2003 - 2010 AHN - All rights reserved.Redistribution, republication. syndication, rewriting or broadcast is prohibited without the prior written consent of AHN.License AHN news for your website, business, digital signage network or publication.
Most Popular Stories
Sandra Bullock's Divorce From Jesse James Final
Angelina Jolie Confirms Daughter Shiloh Wants To Be A Boy
"Melrose Place" Star Amy Locane Charged With DUI Manslaughter
Light Rail Systems Lead To Weight Loss
MMA Fighter Kirkham Killed In South Carolina Bout
Fergie Reportedly Wants To Leave The Black Eyed Peas
Chris Brown Breaks Down, Alicia Keys Wins At 2010 BET Awards
Eva LaRue Marries Beau Joe Cappuccio
Ex-Tennis Star Capriati Treated For Accidental OD Of Prescription Meds
Bagdad Bubba Watson, The Milton Millionaires Cash In On PGA Tour
Recent Posts
Most Popular Comments
Recent Comments
Popular Threads
Home | U.S. | World | Entertainment | Sports | Business | Health | Sci / Tech | Politics | Weird / Offbeat
Follow AHN on Twitter
AHN Social News connects you with friends and the news
Client Login | Submit News | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Contact | Content Services © 2010 AHN All Rights Reserved
Other News on Tuesday, 29 June 2010 Iran freezes nuclear talks for two months
Panama ex-dictator Noriega on trial in France
US-TECH Summary
Obama moves to free spectrum for wireless revolution
Western oil firms stop business with Iran
Era ends, as Byrd, longest-serving US lawmaker, dies
Tycoon trio wins control of France's Le Monde
Iran to 'discipline' West by holding off nuclear talks
BP denies Hayward to resign as oil disaster costs soar
Supreme Court Rules Part Of Sarbanes-Oxley Violated Constitution
Angry House lawmaker cuts aid to Afghanistan
|
Saudi king seeks Obama action on Mideast peace
Football lags other sports on technology
Venus battles Groth to reach quarter finals
Administration Outlines Ambitious Voluntary Broadband Spectrum Plan
EU mobile roaming rates to fall as of July 1
Guinea vote went well despite hitches say observers
|
Apple iPhone 4 Tops 1.7 Million In Sales
Over 12,000 Guineans sms on election issues: US embassy
Personal Spending, Income Rise In May
Apple sold 1.7 million iPhones in three days
Hurricane Watch Raised In Texas, Mexico As Alex Gains Strength
Apple says had sold 1.7 million iPhone 4 on Saturday
"Back To The Future" Trilogy Head To Blu-Ray For 25th Anniversary
Ex-Panamanian dictator Noriega stands trial in Paris
|
"Toy Story 3" Guards Top Spot; "Grown Ups" Take 2nd Place
S.Korean leader wants North apology
Japan war crimes claim sparks France libel case
Li ignores coach to maintain winning feeling
U.S. Senate Republicans rap Obama's high court pick
Japan count on Honda against Paraguay
Five Americans appeal terrorism convictions in Pakistan
India's central bank to weigh interest rate hike: minister
Obama endorses plan to boost wireless broadband
|
Toyota starts production of Europe's first hybrid car
Tata Motors to raise $1 billion in equity and debt
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Motley Crue singer Vince Neil arrested for drunk driving
German police recover stolen Caravaggio painting
India to spend millions restoring classic movies
Saudi Arabia Moves to Regulate Child Marriages
Football's inspiring role at notorious island prison
Dogs join owners in battle against the bulge
French wines' new export strategy: think "Coca-Cola"
Chocolate terracotta warriors to hit Taiwan art show
Stevie Wonder cheers up Glastonbury after football failure
Motley Crue singer Vince Neil arrested for drunk driving
|
U.S. v Ghana tie most-watched soccer game in U.S. history
|
100 foreign troops die in Afghan war in June
US busts 'deep-cover' Russian spy ring
Furious US lawmaker blocks Afghan aid
U.S. missile strike kills 6 militants in northwestern Pakistan
|
Baidu to hire U.S. engineers to work in China
Britain, France, Germany use torture intel: HRW
Rare white elephant caught in Myanmar
Israeli mission complains over Egypt press cartoon
North Korean heir apparent elected to assembly: reports
|
HP cuts contractor use for printer growth
Two held over failed break-in at French imam's home
Oprah tops Forbes celebrity 'power list'
Iran freezes nuclear talks for two months
Chrome unseats Safari as 3rd popular Internet browser
Taiwan and China sign historic trade pact
|
US cracks 'deep-cover' Russia spy mission, arrests 10
US Admits Koreas Are Officially Still At War, Looks Into Norths Actions
Business ideas may be patentable, US Supreme Court says
100 foreign troops die in Afghan war in June
US presses farmers to reduce antibiotics use
Striking workers force closure of Madrid metro
|
"Jimmy Kimmel Live" Features Numerous "Twilight" Guests During "Eclipse" Premiere Week
U.S. Supreme Court Extends Gun Rights To All States, Cities
Brazil ease past Chile, set-up Dutch showdown
Amazon adds video to Kindle e-books on iPad-iPhone
Obama Administration Launches New Space Policy Stressing International Cooperation
Australia PM seeks to end mining row, may call poll
|
Five top U.S. operators pick Samsung Galaxy S phones
Kyrgyz vote wins 90 percent support, Russia wary
|
Era ends as Byrd, longest-serving US lawmaker, dies
Obama endorses plan to boost wireless broadband
Kagan Pledges to be "Modest" as Supreme Court Nomination Hearing Begins
U.S. Markets Finish Slightly Lower As Investors Digest Data, G-20 Comments
Mexico drug hitmen kill state governor candidate
|
Peru inventor 'whitewashes' peaks to slow glacier melt
Israeli inquiry into Gaza flotilla raid opens
|
Tycoon trio wins control of France's Le Monde
Greeks strike on Tuesday, test government pension reform
|
U.S. arrests 10 for allegedly spying for Russia
Tesla stock offering seeks to raise 244 million dollars
Five top U.S. operators pick Samsung Galaxy S phones
US drone strike kills six militants in Pakistan
Senate set to OK Petraeus as U.S. Afghan commander
Baidu to hire U.S. engineers to work in China
|
Motorola and Sprint to sell Windows phone to businesses
China struggles to save 107 buried in landslide
System to assess Afghan forces flawed
Five top U.S. operators pick Samsung Galaxy S phones
|
N.Korean leader's son working as lawmaker: reports
HP cuts contractor use for printer growth
|
Tiger attacks toddler in Indonesian zoo
Sandra Bullock, Jesse James finalize divorce
|
Megan Fox marries in Hawaii: report
|
CSI showrunners renew deals
|
Dr Death admits to fear of death in documentary
|
Women rule Forbes' celebrity power list, Gaga makes debut
|
Radio Disney to air scripted serial
|
Native American actors see new image in Twilight
|
Steve Carell resigning from The Office next year
|
Method Man pleads guilty to tax evasion
|
U.S. top court extends gun rights to states and cities
General McChrystal to retire from U.S. Army-official
Megan Fox marries in Hawaii: report
Australia leadership coup 'not done lightly': MP
Taiwan stocks fall 1 pct; trade deal boost fades
The World's Most Powerful Celebrities
China to stage live-fire military exercises
Longest-serving U.S. lawmaker Byrd dies at 92
Indian Kashmir on the boil again
S.Korea balance of payments hit by market jitters
Minimum and maximum temperatures in Celsius
European firms concerned over China regulations
PAKISTAN
Japan unemployment rises as output slows
Pact to draw China, Taiwan closer than ever
Fiji's neighbours slam media crackdown
North Korean heir apparent elected to assembly
Radio Disney to air scripted serial
NZ household borrowing edges higher in May
Sandra Bullock, Jesse James finalize divorce
S.Korea regains status as world's top shipbuilder
IMF chief says yuan still too low
Steve Carell "resigning" from "The Office" next year
Native American actors see new image in "Twilight"
Method Man pleads guilty to tax evasion
mSpot streams music collections to Android smartphones
Twelve die in Iraq unrest, suicide bombing
No Palestinian state before 2012
Google tweaks China queries, license renewal looms
Russia says U.S. spy charges baseless and improper
|
FIFA chief apologises for World Cup errors
Up to 150 Taliban killed in Afghan battle: report
Protest in Greece as general strike snarls travel
China denies military exercise aimed at U.S.
|
Stephenie Meyer's "Bree Tanner" Sold Over A Million Copies In The U.S.
UN vehicle shot in Afghan capital, driver wounded
Supreme Court Sides With School Against Religious Exclusion
Father Of Missing Oregon Boy Files For Divorce
Iran says nuclear talks to resume with Brazil, Turkey
|
Chicago Cop In Notorious Torture Case Found Guilty Of Perjury
UN vehicle shot in Afghan capital, driver hurt
Witnesses say UN vehicle shot up in Afghan capital
Strikes hit Greece and Spain as ECB deadline looms
|
Are UN Sanctions Against Iran Kicking In?
2 Afghan men convicted for heroin trafficking
No Palestinian state before 2012: Israeli minister
|
Two Florida Police Officers Killed During Traffic Stop
Steve Carell Resigning From "The Office"
U.S. missile strike kills 6 militants in NW Pakistan
Light Rail Systems Lead To Weight Loss
Special Election To Byrd's Senate Seat Will Be In 2012
Japan, Paraguay vie for World Cup quarter-final spot
"Hot Tub Time Machine" Splashes Onto DVD, Blu-ray
China says can guarantee grip on Tibet forever
|
New saliva test 'can detect various cancers'
Philippines' Aquino to probe Arroyo in 'truth commission'
Google switches tack in China before license expires
China denies military exercise aimed at U.S.
Australia's 'Dr Death' guilty of manslaughter
Iraqis seek out private schools to educate children
|
China and Taiwan sign historic trade pact
At least 32 feared dead as Ghana mine collapses
|
Pakistani stocks edge up in dull trade; rupee flat
Japan's Komatsu to hire Chinese managers
Pakistan expects $970 mln foreign inflows to meet IMF target
Foxconn 'to move China Apple production' as costs rise
South Korea c.bankers wanted tightening signal in May
Google alters China course before licence expires
'Prince of Jihad' given five years in Indonesia
China stocks lower on AgBank's low IPO pricing
Oprah tops Forbes celebrity 'power list'
Pakistan c.bank sells 49.50 bln rupees of T-bills
Google tweaks rerouting in fight for China business
|
"CSI" showrunners renew deals
"Dr Death" admits to fear of death in documentary
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights