Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
War of Words: Israel attacks Palestinian rhetoric
|
Edition:
U.S.
Article
Comments (1)
Save
Email
Print
Reprints
Most Popular
Most Shared
UPDATE 1-New U.S. senator helps Democrats advance jobs bill
22 Feb 2010
Jay Leno sets high-profile "Tonight Show" guests
22 Feb 2010
Bad news for record lottery "winner"
16 Feb 2010
Arizona dog is world's tallest
22 Feb 2010
Russian ice dancers stage folk dancing cover-up
22 Feb 2010
UPDATE 1-New U.S. senator helps Democrats advance jobs bill
22 Feb 2010
Arizona dog is world's tallest
22 Feb 2010
How to decline Facebook friends without offence
22 Feb 2010
Nearly 20 percent of U.S. workers underemployed
8:21am EST
High blood pressure in U.S. a "neglected disease"
3:22am EST
War of Words: Israel attacks Palestinian rhetoric
Erika Solomon
RAMALLAH, West Bank
Tue Feb 23, 2010 10:35am EST
Related News
Abbas considers options on peace talks restart
Fri, Feb 19 2010
Vice President Biden to visit Mideast in March
Mon, Feb 15 2010
Abbas seeks U.S. answers before talking to Israel
Mon, Feb 15 2010
Palestinian killer had personal problems: Israel
Thu, Feb 11 2010
Israeli air strike kills Gaza militant, wounds two
Thu, Feb 11 2010
A Palestinian man smokes a cigarette beside Israeli soldiers after minor clashes with Palestinian stone-throwers in the West Bank city of Hebron, February 23, 2010.
Credit: Reuters/Ammar Awad
RAMALLAH, West Bank (Reuters) - Concerned that its image abroad is suffering, Israel is going on the offensive to show that Palestinians, not Israelis, are responsible for perpetuating the region's cycle of violence.
World
With the peace process at a standstill since its war in Gaza a year ago, Israel is trying to paint the Palestinian Authority as the source of incitement to violence -- a violation of Palestinian obligations under peace agreements.
Citing usage of the word "martyr" to honor dead Palestinian militants and speeches recalling the "noble heritage" of armed struggle, Israel's incitement accusations put the onus on Palestinian leadership for failure to return to negotiations.
In January, Israel's Center for Near East Research stepped up the anti-incitement campaign with the launch of a monthly "Incitement Report." Aimed at Western legislators, it chronicles language its writers say encourages violence.
Israel's Ministry for Public Diplomacy is also inviting ordinary citizens to get involved, with a program to teach volunteers how to present a positive image of Israel abroad. Palestinian incitement is included as a talking point.
Palestinian officials insist their speeches do not incite violence. Their political rhetoric, however, pays homage to a past of violent resistance to Israeli occupation.
Fatah, the dominant force behind the Palestinian Authority, calls its legislative body the "Revolutionary Council." Its charter still does not recognize Israel, even as its leaders promote a two-state solution and peace with the Jewish state.
Palestinians say rhetoric from their side about guns or bloodshed is nothing compared with the physical subjugation and humiliation they suffer at the hands of Israeli occupation troops manning West Bank checkpoints and armed patrols.
Real incitement isn't just words, they say, it is actions.
"The Israelis keep taking Palestinian land to build settlements, their settlers provoke Palestinians by cutting their trees or taking their homes in Jerusalem. It goes on and on," says Ghassan Khatib, Palestinian Authority spokesman.
"Israeli behavior is the most effective incitement to the Palestinian public," he said.
SERMONS
The incitement debate stems from the Roadmap to peace, a 2003 Middle East peace plan whose first phase required Palestinian authorities to end violence, and Israel to help normalize Palestinian life and freeze settlement activity. Each side is called on to end incitement against the other.
Palestinians insist they are meeting their obligations but can only do so much to muzzle individuals.
A few weeks ago, a Palestinian official missed his appointment to give a sermon on non-violence at a small mosque in the West Bank village of Burin, on the frontline of skirmishes between Jewish settlers and Palestinians.
While he was held by Israeli troops at a checkpoint, a replacement speaker stepped up to the minbar (dais) and delivered a blood-curdling call on Muslims to kill Jews.
The PA, which has gagged the cleric, said such incidents can be hard to stop in places like Burin, where a neighboring mosque had just been attacked and Israel settlers were suspected. The Koran was burned and Hebrew graffiti scrawled on the walls, vandalism denounced by Israeli ministers and rabbis.
Palestinians say some Israeli examples of "incitement" are unrelated to violence.
In a speech last week, Israel's Deputy Foreign Minister Danny Ayalon named Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas and Prime Minister Salam Fayyad as sources of incitement because they go "from capital to capital to defame Israel...to vilify Israel."
"We need to have common definitions as to what incitement is and what it is not," said Khatib, who suggested creating a joint observation committee.
But others say no consensus is possible.
Media analyst Nebal Thawabteh of Birzeit University in the West Bank recalls a joint incitement study by Israeli and Palestinian organizations a few years ago.
"They had completely different criteria. You can't even discuss the issue because there are no guidelines. It all depends on political views," she said.
(Editing by Douglas Hamilton and Jon Boyle)
World
Comments
See All Comments (1) | Post Comment
Feb 23, 2010 10:20am EST
I try to give Israel the benefit of the doubt but this isn’t looking very good. So “defaming” (i.e. criticising) Israel amount to incitement now? If this is what most Israeli officials believe it shows how out of touch they are. Instead of focusing on its image Israel should be worried about its actions.
["The Israelis keep taking Palestinian land to build settlements, their settlers provoke Palestinians by cutting their trees or taking their homes in Jerusalem. It goes on and on," says Ghassan Khatib, Palestinian Authority spokesman.
"Israeli behavior is the most effective incitement to the Palestinian public," he said.]
This is a perfectly reasonable and logical sentiment. Israel, show that you are truly serious about peace and maybe your image will improve.
KOSMOS
Report As Abusive
See All Comments (1)
Add a Comment
More from Reuters
Home prices unexpectedly dip
NEW YORK (Reuters) - Home prices unexpectedly slipped in December but the annual rate of decline slowed, reinforcing the housing market's rocky road to recovery, Standard & Poor's/Case-Shiller indexes showed on Tuesday.
Toyota vows quality shake-up, faces criminal probe
| Video
New senator helps Democrats advance jobs bill
U.S. Afghan death toll hits 1,000
| Video
Target quarterly profit tops estimates
Consumer confidence falls to 10-month low in Feb
» More Top News
Special Report:
"Hell to pay" for the dollar?
Nearly 40 years after President Nixon took the U.S. off the gold standard, the greenback still dominates world trade. Some say that's about to change. Full Article
Tightening underway, Fed a passenger
Is change coming for China's yuan?
Currencies
Vancouver 2010:
Track tweaked after more spills
Changes are being made to Whistler's controversial sliding track after Latvian and Croatian four-man sleds roll over. Full Article
Medals for a few, defeat for most
Drug-testers: stalkers or herders?
Slideshow: The best of Day 10
2010 winter olympics
© Copyright 2010 Thomson Reuters
Editorial Editions:
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
United States
Reuters
Contact Us
Advertise With Us
Help
Journalism Handbook
Archive
Site Index
Video Index
Analyst Research
Mobile
Newsletters
RSS
Podcasts
Widgets
Your View
Labs
Thomson Reuters
Copyright
Disclaimer
Privacy
Professional Products
Professional Products Support
Financial Products
About Thomson Reuters
Careers
Online Products
Acquisitions Monthly
Buyouts.com
Buyouts Europe:
Buyouts Conferences:
Venture Capital Journal
EVCJ
International Financing Review
International Securitisation Report
Project Finance International
PEhub.com
PE Week
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
Other News on Tuesday, 23 February 2010 Monarch, PM meet over future of Dutch govt
French petrol pumps run dry in refinery strike
Swiss scanners to help blind in the kitchen
Exhibitor numbers decline at world's biggest hi-tech fair
EU slams killing of Hamas official, misuse of passports
NATO air strike, Afghan suicide attack kill 41
Chinese consultant wrote code used in Google attack: FT
Obama Urges Governors To Spur Lagging Education Standards
Unhappy with Israel, EU condemns Dubai killing
U.S. ITC to investigate Apple complaint versus Nokia
Bank Of America Brings Two Former Merrill Execs On Board
Modern Etiquette:How to decline Facebook friends without offence
EPA Sets $475 Million Rehab Plan For Great Lakes
From Today, New Credit Card Protection Rules Go Into Effect
Ukraine's Tymoshenko rules out deal with Yanukovich
|
Niger junta to assume powers, will name PM, government
|
Mariah Carey Duets With Mary J. Blige, Akon For Upcoming Remix Album
Judge Approves Bank Of America, SEC Settlement
Trina Lines Up Lady Gaga, Flo Rida, And Diddy For New Album
Algeria says al Qaeda guards Sahara drug smugglers
|
U.S. ITC to investigate Apple complaint versus Nokia
Researchers: Teen Sleep Problems Tied To Lack Of Morning Light
Israeli heritage plan draws Palestinian protests
|
Fans Can Relive "Jersey Shore" Moments At Tropicana Casino In Atlantic City
Indonesian to stand trial over hotel bombings
Obama presents make-or-break health reform plan
Nepal pro-monarchy party seeks to restore king
Blast kills 8 in Pakistan's Swat Valley
Dalai Lama says 'no problem' ending his position
Wal-Mart agrees to buy movie service Vudu: report
|
23 suspects to stand trial in China for CCTV fire
NATO strikes that killed many Afghan civilians
Afghan police say Tora Bora commander killed
Afghan police: 15 killed in suicide bombing
Afghan Cabinet: NATO airstrike kills 27 civilians
Guard recalls brush with Indonesian suicide bomber
US Federal jury subpoena, documents add to Toyota woes
Taiwan fines HK clothes firms for alleged tax evasion
Japan Airlines to raise fuel surcharge
Malaysia Airlines returns to profit in fourth quarter
Videogames meet film noir under a Heavy Rain
Taiwan to give $200 mln to local film industry
Cantor to launch futures exchange for film buffs
|
Videogames meet film noir under a Heavy Rain
Dark side of sculptor Henry Moore on show in London
|
S.Africa to beef up World Cup condom supply
New Yorker editor pens new Obama biography
|
China police punished for lavish banquets
Elegance and glamour on the London catwalks
World's top restaurant to become foundation
Top restaurant elBulli to become non-profit foundation
Iran's nuclear plans draw sharp response from US
NATO airstrike kills 27 civilians in Afghanistan
|
US-TECH Summary
French, British strike action clouds Europe's skies
Supreme Court Asked To Review Tobacco Industry's Criminal Conviction
NATO chief defends Afghan mission after civilian deaths
Microsoft, Amazon sign patent deal
Iran picks sites for 10 uranium enrichment plants
U.S. Markets Snap Winning Streak, Finish Slightly Lower
Terror Suspect Zazi Enters Guilty Pleas To 3 Charges
Former US VP Cheney hospitalized with chest pains
Miami Herald drops reader contribution program
Second Season of "Sonny With A Chance" Premieres In March
Turkey detains top military brass in conspiracy probe
Germany's Lufthansa and pilots resume talks, ending strike
Iran picks sites for 10 uranium enrichment plants
|
Wal-Mart buys online movie company Vudu
Swiss man freed in Libya as another heads to jail
"Nurse Jackie: Season One" Hits DVD On February 23
Microsoft helps languages talk tech
At least seven dead in blast in Afghanistan's Helmand
|
Garth Brooks Gives Fans Another Set, Announces More Concert Dates In Las Vegas
Twitter users creating 50 million 'tweets' a day
Yemen arrests 80 separatists over southern unrest
|
French petrol pumps run dry in refinery strike
Wal-Mart agrees to buy movie service Vudu: report
Quake aftershock of 4.7 magnitude hits Haiti
|
The mounting cost of Spain's new illegal underclass
|
South Africa says intercepted North Korea arms shipment
|
Iran arrests Sunni rebel leader Rigi
|
Afghan admits NYC bomb plot, al Qaeda training
Al-Qaeda suspect pleads guilty to New York bomb plot
Former US VP Cheney hospitalized with chest pains
Obama offers plan to revive healthcare push
Iran nuclear plans further evidence it rejects engagement: US
Microsoft, Amazon sign patent deal
|
China studies long-term impact of tainted milk
Thousands give last rites to dead whale in Vietnam
NATO commander takes apology direct to Afghans
US, S.Korea seek to revive N.Korea nuke talks
Weather forecast for the Asia-Pacific region
Senior N.Korea official arrives in China: Yonhap
Indonesia mulls new capital as Jakarta sinks
Dalai Lama says feels love for China
Indonesian stands trial over hotel bombings
NZ, Fiji officials may hold informal discussions
Seoul shares edge up on defensives; techs fall
Toyota global sales up 15.3 pct on-year in January
China Unicom denies bid for Nigerian phone company
Capital gains tax of 10 pct soon on Pakistan stocks
PAKISTAN
Jay Leno sets high-profile Tonight Show guests
|
Toyota must do 'much better' on safety: president
Tenor Domingo to undergo preventive surgery
|
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
NZ inflation expectations steady
Kevin James to co-star in Ron Howard film
|
TMZ sued over leaked Debbie Rowe interview
China Southern trade suspended, awaits cash boost
Disney takes long view in Alice theater dispute
|
Snowboarding dudes ageing disgracefully
Avatar passes $200 million mark at Imax
|
Taiwan dollar firms on inflows; awaits Fed
'Real men' don't watch figure skating
Odeon bans 'Alice in Wonderland' in Britain, Ireland, Italy
The Hurt Locker sweeps Avatar aside at BAFTAs
|
Disney takes long view in "Alice" theater dispute
Jay Leno sets high-profile "Tonight Show" guests
TMZ sued over leaked Debbie Rowe interview
|
Kevin James to co-star in Ron Howard film
Tenor Domingo to undergo "preventive surgery"
English aristocrats punk up at Paul Smith's London show
Argentina to win support in Falklands dispute
Iran nabs Sunni militant from flight 'in blow to US'
Harsh winter freezes German business confidence
Senior Yemen al Qaeda leader threatens U.S. attacks: site
|
Cricketer Lee 'to quit Tests' after Flintoff chat
Handset market rebounding in 2010: report
More British, Irish passports used in Dubai killing
|
Eight die in Afghan bombing as US loses 1,000th soldier
French strike adds to European air travel woes
Iran says any fuel swap must be on its territory
|
Amazon and Microsoft ink patent deal
N.Ireland car bomb will not derail peace: politicians
Iran captures top Sunni militant
U.S. Navy rescues Tanzanian ship, nabs 8 pirates
|
Britain's Brown hits back as bullying row escalates
War of Words: Israel attacks Palestinian rhetoric
|
Iran arrests Sunni rebel leader Rigi
Afghan bike bombing kills seven: official
Sudan to offer Darfur rebels government posts: documents
|
US General apologises over Afghan civilian deaths
Egypt police arrest Cairo synagogue bomb suspect
|
Iraqi politician raises eyebrows with Saudi trip
|
Toll of US dead in Afghan war hits 1,000: website
US, SKorea envoys visit China amid NKorea hopes
Her Facebook status changed to single? Ur dumped
|
Federal Panel Urges More Action To Control Hypertension
Indonesian police arrest four in anti-terror raid
China says Google hacking claims groundless
|
"The Real Housewives Of O.C." To Air Special 2-Part Reunion Episode In March
Philippine police: Gov't agencies face gun charges
Intel plans $2 billion fund to invest in U.S. companies: report
|
Handset market rebounding in 2010: report
|
China urges US to 'undo damage done' by Dalai meet
Doctors' Group Wants More Effort To Prevent Childhood Choking Accidents
Group slams Thai deadline for registering migrants
Alexa Ray Joel To Front Prell Shampoo Ads 25 Years After Mom Christie Brinkley Did
How to decline Facebook friends without offence
|
Five dead, dozens buried in Indonesia landslide
Former Vice President Suffers Chest Pains, Hospitalized
"Women In Trouble" Debuts On DVD
Police say 60 buried in Indonesian landslide
People Now Permitted To Pack Pistols In National Parks
China launches strict new Internet controls
Rare Comic Book Featuring Superman Sold For $1 Million
Indonesian ranger escapes Komodo dragon attack
Report: More People Dying Of Infections Acquired At Hospitals
California Family Of Four Mysteriously Disappears
Even Oscar-winners 'insecure' and 'anxious', says Cotillard
Maruti Suzuki recalling 100,000 India-made cars
Pakistani stocks end lower; rupee firms; o/n rates down
Morgan Stanley nears selling stake in Chinese bank
Japan finance minister pushes BoJ over deflation
Pakistani Finance Minister Tarin says resigning
Japan officials want Toyota to restore confidence
Indian parliament in uproar over food prices
Landslide in Indonesia kills four, buries 40
Ellen is hit with Idol fans, Garcia early favorite
|
Japan automakers boost global output in January
Ellen is hit with "Idol" fans, Garcia early favorite
Abbey Road studios win preservation order
|
Indonesian on trial over Jakarta hotel bombings
'Prince of Jihad' on trial over Indonesia bombings
No splitting hairs with Shebab fashion police
Militant on trial over funding Jakarta bombings
Universal signs new deal with Lloyd Webber
Even Oscar-winners 'insecure' and 'anxious', says Cotillard
Universal signs new deal with Lloyd Webber
|
Zimbabwe's white farmers struggle to build city lives
TNY ship exhibit recalls glamor of Transatlantic crossings
Comeback Whitney hits a flat note Down Under
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights