Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Why Hollywood should be nervous about court pick
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Asia Pacific
World
Why Hollywood should be nervous about court pick
Reuters - Tuesday, May 11
Send
IM Story
Print
By Eriq Gardner
LOS ANGELES - Hollywood may have some reason to be nervous about President Obama's nomination of Elena Kagan to be the next U.S. Supreme Court justice.
Not a whole lot is known about Kagan's judicial philosophy, which in some ways, makes her the perfect pick to win confirmation by the Senate. Her record on issues the industry cares about, though, isn't entirely opaque.
Hollywood's biggest worry about Kagan might be her philosophy on intellectual property matters. As dean of Harvard Law School from 2003 to 2009, she was instrumental in beefing up the school's Berkman Center for Internet & Society by recruiting Lawrence Lessig and others who take a strongly liberal position on "fair use" in copyright disputes.
Most notably, during those years, Professor Charles Nesson at the Berkman Center represented accused file-sharer Joel Tenenbaum in the defense of a lawsuit by the Recording Industry Association of America, the trade group representing the major U.S. record labels. Professor Nesson led his cyberlaw class in alleging that "the RIAA is abusing law and the civil process" with excessive damage claims in piracy cases. It was Kagan herself who wrote a personal letter to the U.S. District Court to help certify the students.
Paradoxically, the Obama administration later weighed in on the side of the RIAA in the case. But that was before Kagan was fully confirmed as U.S. Solicitor General. At the time, Professor Nesson expressed some doubts about whether Kagan would back the government's amicus brief and also called her "enlightened" on these issues.
Kagan got her biggest opportunity to showcase her feelings on IP when the U.S. Supreme Court asked her, as U.S. Solicitor General, to weigh in on the big Cablevision case.
Hollywood was upset when Cablevision announced its intention to allow subscribers to store TV programs on the cable operator's computer servers instead of a hard-top box. The introduction of remote-storage DVR kicked off furious litigation, and the 2nd Circuit overturned a lower court ruling by saying that the technology wouldn't violate copyright holder's rights. The studios appealed to the Supreme Court.
In Kagan's brief to the high court, she argued the justices shouldn't take the case and trumpeted fair use. She went against broadcasters there and even criticized Cablevision for limiting the scope of its arguments.
Of course, this isn't quite enough evidence to predict what kind of U.S. Supreme Court justice she will be. At Harvard, she was famous for ingratiating herself to professors of all political stripes, so who knows if Nesson has a good read on her? Working in the Obama administration, she also surrounded herself with entertainment industry advocates, including as her assistant, Ginger Anders, who worked on an amicus brief in the Cablevision case for a coalition that included the RIAA.
And finally, Hollywood's got at least one reason to cheer. Her history in academia suggests she'll be an extreme supporter of free speech under the First Amendment.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Beware phony 3-D as Hollywood cashes in AFP - 12 minutes ago
Outlaws and terrorists line up for Cannes film frenzy AFP - 1 hour 13 minutes ago
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary Reuters - 2 hours 14 minutes ago
Salary dispute holds up "Twilight 5" announcement Reuters - 2 hours 14 minutes ago
Why Hollywood should be nervous about court pick Reuters - Tuesday, May 11
News Search
Top Stories
US judge dismisses Polanski 'lie' claims
US regulators move to stop repeat of market free-fall
BP hopes 'top hat' will succeed where dome failed
Jazz singer, actress Lena Horne dead at 92
Europe boosts markets with 'shock and awe' deal
More Top Stories »
Related Full Coverage
Hollywood NewsGet the latest Hollywood news
All Full Coverage »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
BP dealt setback in oil containment bid
EU agrees bumper eurozone aid deal: diplomat
Jazz singer, actress Lena Horne dead at 92
World stocks, euro soar on major EU bailout
Europe boosts markets with 'shock and awe' deal
More Most Viewed »
Aliens may exist but contact would hurt: Hawking
Lack of sleep linked to early death: study
Freddie Mac asks for fresh 10.6 billion dollar bailout
French driving veil row escalates
Airlines want compensation as Europe's skies reopen
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
World Cup 2010
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Tuesday, 11 May 2010 Karzai arrives to US red carpet after rocky ties
British PM falls on sword, seeking post-poll deal
Twitter bug causes users to lose followers
91 killed in Iraq's bloodiest day this year
British PM announces stepping down as Labour leader
China says software piracy declines -- to 19 billion dollars
Europe boosts markets with 'shock and awe' deal
Attacks kill over 100 in Iraq, al Qaeda blamed
US-TECH Summary
Maroon 5 Announce 2010 Tour Dates, New Album Details
EU's Ashton says U.N. plan for Iran sanctions likely soon
Google's Android takes No 2 spot from iPhone
Military Signal Jams, Controls Garage Doors
Yemen says will not turn over militant cleric to US
|
Israel primed for war on Iran
Dish Network Q1 Profit Slips Despite Customer Rebound
Gas Prices Increase; Could Decrease Shortly
Pakistan to come under more U.S. pressure
|
Former Sunday School Teacher Faces Life With Guilty Plea
U.S. Assistant Secretary Heads To Indonesia, Japan
First Birds Rescued From Gulf Spill To Be Released; BP Tries Second Dome
U.S. Envoy Meets Myanmar Opposition Leader, Party Members
Cuban Refugees Picked Up, Sent Back
Lady Gaga Extends Monster Ball Tour Through 2011
BP mulls risky 'junk shot' to stem US oil slick
Afghanistan readies program to reintegrate Taliban
Karzai, Obama set for "frank" talks on Afghan war
Pakistan under pressure after NY car bomb
Thai protesters refuse to leave, push new demands
Aquino leads Philippine race on promise of change
Google's Android takes No 2 spot from iPhone
|
Philippine polls deliver decisive win for Aquino
Thai protesters OK poll date but set new demands
Pakistan to come under more U.S. pressure
Chinese AIDS activist flees to US after harassment
Aquino III leads in Philippines' presidential race
Jackson, Brown among Apollo's Walk of Fame in NY
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Jackson, Brown among Apollo's Walk of Fame in NY
Opera impresario flits from country house to prison
Spanish radio show livens the airwaves with death
China premier backs plan for ailing eurozone
Britain's Loach bids for Cannes gold with Iraq film
Morocco festival rejects ban appeal against Elton John
Taiwan artist sees the world in a grain of sand
"Idol" creator Fuller marks iTunes milestone
On the set in Serbia with a bloody Ralph Fiennes
|
Barbara Walters to undergo heart surgery
Katy Perry tops Maxim Hot 100 list
|
Iconic Yves Klein work a spring auction highlight
Hobbled Robin Hood director skipping Cannes
|
Jackson, Brown among Apollo's Walk of Fame in NY
|
Barbara Walters to undergo heart surgery
|
Spanish radio show livens the airwaves with death
|
Opera impresario flits from country house to prison
|
US mends fences with Karzai visit
Ukraine protesters challenge pro-Russia shift
Face-to-face time makes us happier than Facebook
Iraq on alert after attacks kill over 100
Siberia mine blast toll hits 43, Putin to visit
Russian mine death toll rises to 43
|
US regulators move to stop repeat of market free-fall
Beijing to allow news websites to list: report
4 French troops injured in Afghan attack: military
French parliament to take anti-burqa stand
No deal in sight as Thai protesters refuse to quit
|
BP hopes 'top hat' will succeed where dome failed
Medvedev seeks to revive ties on landmark Syria visit
Philippine election gives Aquino a strong platform
|
Twitter bug zaps followers
Tests rule out cancer in Spanish king: hospital
Jazz singer, actress Lena Horne dead at 92
Sunday School Teacher Who Killed Child Pleads Guilty To Murder
UK's two big parties court Lib Dems, Brown to quit
|
Obama in multi-media push for Supreme Court nominee
Warner Bros. Furthers Efforts To Upgrade From DVD To Blu-ray
U.S. missiles kill at least 14 in Pakistan
|
Android phones overtake iPhones: NPD
Greek cabinet agrees radical pension reform
"The View" Focuses On Affordable Clothing During Budget Week
Haitian police break up violent protest at palace
|
U.S. Markets Jump On European Loan Package
Android phones overtake iPhones: NPD
U.S. links Cheonan probe to stance toward N.Korea
|
Police, allies kill 18 insurgents in S Afghanistan
Obama reshapes Supreme Court with legal 'trailblazer'
Malaysia's Anwar aims to undermine sodomy claims
Missile barrage kills 14 in Pakistan tribal area
S.Korean climber returns home after 14-peak record
Aquino opens up commanding lead in Philippine vote
Beijing to allow news websites to list: report
|
S.Korean millionaire finds perfect son-in-law
Cable worries about Web video as fee disputes grow
|
Malaysia's Anwar: Sodomy trial tainted with lies
Face-to-face time makes us happier than Facebook
|
Floods kill 70 in southern China
U.S. missiles kill at least 14 in Pakistan
Why Hollywood should be nervous about court pick
"Bling Ring" actress jailed over Orlando Bloom break-in
'Iron Man 2' shows mettle at North American box office
Celebrity burglar reality star jailed for six months
Toyota roars back into the black
New York's Apollo Theater unveils Walk of Fame
Japan to cap new govt borrowing: finance minister
Toyota reports $1.2 bln profit for latest quarter
Seoul shares slip 0.4 pct as Europe worry lingers
China's consumer prices, bank lending rise in April
Outlaws and terrorists line up for Cannes film frenzy
Samsung outlines $20.6 billion investment plan
Radiation death exposes India's lax waste disposal
Toyota Prius tops Japan's April auto sales
China inflation rises as housing, food costs jump
Salary dispute holds up "Twilight 5" announcement
Samsung cash to target green energy, health
China's human rights lawyers face uphill struggle
PAKISTAN
Why Hollywood should be nervous about court pick
S.Africa tourism looks for long-term gains from WC
LA judge rejects defense bid in Polanski case
|
France's Pompidou Centre opens regional art hub
Why Hollywood should be nervous about court pick
|
Salary dispute holds up Twilight 5 announcement
|
LA judge rejects defense bid in Polanski case
"Bling Ring" actress jailed over Orlando Bloom break-in
Cable worries about Web video as fee disputes grow
|
Bling Ring actress jailed over Orlando Bloom break-in
|
Medvedev urges more US action in 'very bad' Mideast
Over $50 bln lost to software piracy: report
Israel sees no discord with U.S. on nuclear issue
Putin mourns Siberia mine tragedy as hope fades
No end in sight as Thai protesters refuse to leave
|
Toyota returns to profit despite recall crisis
Greece to ask EU, IMF for first tranche of debt aid
Iran says it warned off U.S. plane near manoeuvres
US judge dismisses Polanski 'lie' claims
Invasive Lizard Species Found In Florida National Forest
Russia says may build nuclear power plant in Syria
|
Breakfast At Tiffanys Authors House Sells For $18M
Iran says it warned off U.S. plane near maneuvers
|
Pep Boys Agree To $5 Million Settlement In Clean Air Act Case
Four Plead Not Guilty To Craigslist Murder
DCCC Pulls Out Of Special Election In Hawaii District Of Obama's Birth
Iran seeks nuclear talks with EU's Ashton
|
Bran May Reduce Risk Of Death From Diabetes
Shaqs All-Star Comedy Jam Premieres On Demand
Sin within the Church threat to Catholicism: pope
|
Eating Nuts May Lower Bad Cholesterol
Afghan girls hit again by suspected gas attack
|
Drug Developed To Kill Non-Hodgkin Lymphoma Cells
Former ABN AMRO Forfeits $500 Million In Financial Conspiracy Case
US mends fences with Karzai visit
Medvedev urges more US action in Mideast peace efforts
Thai protesters vow to rally until deputy PM charged
Greenhouse gas emissions rise in India
Bomb kills 2 US service members in Afghanistan
Indonesian ex-top detective arrested in bribe case
Vietnam court upholds dissidents' jail sentences
Toyota roars back into black despite recalls
Vietnam court upholds jail for two dissidents
Ranbaxy says US sales drive $210m quarter profit
Protests to stay til Thai leaders report to police
Pakistani o/n rates flat; rupee firms; stocks down
Toshiba to spend big on chips, nuclear power
Toyota quarterly profit $1.2 bln as sales recover
Beware phony 3-D as Hollywood cashes in
US transport chief rides 300-mph Japanese maglev
Asian markets fall back as euro fears persist
Samsung outlines $20.6 billion investment plan
Hitachi trims annual loss, sees return to profit
China inflation rises as housing, food costs jump
Indonesian to make film on Obama's Jakarta childhood
Anna Nicole items up for auction, Dannielynn benefits
Indonesia's ex-top detective questioned on bribery
FIFA marketing rules spark frustration in S.Africa
Beware phony 3-D as Hollywood cashes in
Anna Nicole items up for auction, Dannielynn benefits
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights