Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Can anything derail Glee from Emmy glory?
|
Edition:
U.S.
Article
Comments (0)
Save
Email
Print
Reprints
Most Popular
Most Shared
UPDATE 1-Obama attacks Bush policies in Bush's home state
09 Aug 2010
Nikkei slips, weighed by China stock fall on data
12:22am EDT
Obama attacks Bush policies in Bush's home state
09 Aug 2010
Pentagon to shut military command, cut jobs
09 Aug 2010
Economists cut forecasts and see more Fed action
1:22am EDT
Unstable lake threatens mudslide-ravaged China town
| Video
3:35am EDT
Cancer cells slurp up fructose, US study finds
02 Aug 2010
Verizon, Google propose Web traffic rules
09 Aug 2010
Dollar rises as stocks slip on caution before Fed
2:58am EDT
HP's Hurd latest CEO to get lucrative exit payout
09 Aug 2010
UPDATE 1-Obama attacks Bush policies in Bush's home state
09 Aug 2010
Russian drought fires
09 Aug 2010
Cancer cells slurp up fructose, US study finds
02 Aug 2010
Steward bolts from JFK plane via emergency chute
09 Aug 2010
Editor's Choice
09 Aug 2010
TEXT-Oracle CEO Ellison's comments on exit of HP's Hurd
09 Aug 2010
Verizon, Google propose Web traffic rules
09 Aug 2010
Obama attacks Bush policies in Bush's home state
09 Aug 2010
Freddie Mac says needs $1.8 billion from taxpayers
09 Aug 2010
Man dies in final of sauna championships
09 Aug 2010
Can anything derail "Glee" from Emmy glory?
Digg This
Tweet This
Share on LinkedIn
Share on Facebook
Related News
TV's female characters more complicated than ever
Sun, Aug 8 2010
Reality, nonfiction Emmy races produce odd rivals
Sun, Aug 8 2010
HBO to end 'Entourage' next summer
Sun, Aug 8 2010
Emmy's actor race a (mostly) level playing field
Wed, Aug 4 2010
How much is an Emmy worth?
Mon, Aug 2 2010
Related Topics
Fashion »
Entertainment »
Television »
Media »
By Carita Rizzo
Tue Aug 10, 2010 1:46am EDT
LOS ANGELES (Hollywood Reporter) - It's a sign of just how much the genre has shifted recently that the front-runner in the best comedy series Emmy Awards category -- for the first time in more than a decade -- is an hourlong comed-drama.
Overlooked are such classic three-camera, laugh-track vehicles as "Two and a Half Men," "How I Met Your Mother" and "The Big Bang Theory," none of which made it into the final six nominees this year, despite the growing popularity of the latter in particular.
Instead, Fox's "Glee" will compete with two premium-cable shows (HBO's "Curb Your Enthusiasm" and Showtime's "Nurse Jackie"), NBC's "The Office" and "30 Rock" as well as ABC's "Modern Family."
Can any of them knock "Glee" from its front-runner perch when winners are announced on August 29?
Voters' ages might be a deciding factor. While the Academy of Television Arts and Sciences doesn't publicize the age and gender breakdown of its 15,000 members, they are widely believed to be older than the younger demographic toward which "Glee" skews.
"The perception has been that, if you're over 40, you don't like to have fun watching TV," one insider says. And "Glee" is nothing if not fun.
But chairman John Shaffner says the assumption that the TV Academy largely comprises people age 50 and older is wrong.
"The reality is that voting members are professionals in all adult age groups," he says. (A study that The Hollywood Reporter conducted last year revealed that the parallel motion picture Academy has an average membership age of 57.7 years.)
Still, age will be just one factor in this race. Even more important, says TV academy member and writer-producer Marc Guggenheim (ABC's "Brothers and Sisters"), is a show's buzz factor.
"(A series' overall) commercial success is driving awards, more than anything else," he argues.
There's a reason for this: Emmy voters might receive nominated programs in the form of DVDs, but they are inevitably influenced by the shows they like to watch on a regular basis. They're also influenced by the families with which they watch them; meaning older voters may be influenced by their kids.
If Guggenheim is right, this favors "Glee," which consistently led the ratings last season with an average of 11.1 million viewers. It also overwhelmed its Emmy competition among adults 18-49, a demographic coveted by advertisers.
ABC's dark-horse candidate "Modern Family," averaged 9.6 million viewers. While respected -- especially for its five supporting nominees -- "Family" hasn't yet gained the massive traction of its Fox competitor.
After six seasons, NBC's "The Office" still retains a strong following, averaging almost 8.9 million viewers. But the show has already won once, during its heyday in 2006, and has been overshadowed in recent years by reigning three-time champ "30 Rock." Despite "Rock's" self-perpetuated joke that no one actually watches the show, the show averaged 6.7 million viewers.
Cable's offerings -- the seven-season-old "Curb" and "Nurse Jackie," fresh off its second season -- lack official demographics as they are on pay cable networks that don't cater to advertisers; but last season they averaged 5.7 million and 3.6 million viewers, respectively.
Still, if commercial success is as important as Guggenheim believes, being on cable will hurt these series.
"They just don't have the same level of exposure as network shows," says analyst Larry Gerbrandt of Media Valuation Partners. "When you're less accessible, it's a handicap."
By contrast, what might help these shows is how different they are from the kind of sitcom that has mostly been excluded this year.
The absence of "Two and a Half Men," "How I Met Your Mother" and "Big Bang Theory" (all on CBS) has created a singular void: Not one of this year's nominated comedies has a traditional laugh-track, multicamera format.
This might indicate that Emmy voters are looking for something less conventional.
But will "Glee" just seem too unconventional -- at least for those determined to reward an actual comedy? Will it be seen as too much of a dramedy to get the comedy vote, which would make it the first one-hour show to take home the trophy since Fox's "Ally McBeal" in 1999? Back then, insiders were surprised when that series was even entered as a comedy.
"'Glee' feels much like 'Ally' did," Guggenheim says. "(But) there's no real litmus test anymore. If you combine drama with comedy, the comedy is more funny and the drama more dramatic. The counterpoint brings out the essence in both tones."
Adds one of "Glee's" directors, Paris Barclay (he's nominated for the "Wheels" episode): "I was raised on comedies like 'Andy Griffith.' There wasn't this broad expectation of laughter in every scene. In some ways, we are reinventing our childhoods through these contemporary comedies. All around, the characters feel more like real people."
As for the "Glee" writers themselves -- Ryan Murphy, Ian Brennan and Brad Falchuck -- they say they've never questioned their show's genre.
"Not every comedy is designed to be 'joke, set-up, joke, set-up, joke,'" Brennan says. "People's tastes are broader now. It's actually a credit to the academy and to viewers that ('Glee' is in this race) -- even though we are probably a little more than just a 'comedy.'"
Fashion
Entertainment
Television
Media
Add a Comment
*We welcome comments that advance the story directly or with relevant tangential information. We try to block comments that use offensive language or appear to be spam and review comments frequently to ensure they meet our standards. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters.
© Copyright 2010 Thomson Reuters
Editorial Editions:
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
United States
Reuters
Contact Us
Advertise With Us
Help
Journalism Handbook
Archive
Site Index
Video Index
Reader Feedback
Mobile
Newsletters
RSS
Podcasts
Widgets
Your View
Analyst Research
Thomson Reuters
Copyright
Disclaimer
Privacy
Professional Products
Professional Products Support
Financial Products
About Thomson Reuters
Careers
Online Products
Acquisitions Monthly
Buyouts
Venture Capital Journal
International Financing Review
Project Finance International
PEhub.com
PE Week
FindLaw
Reuters on Facebook
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
Other News on Tuesday, 10 August 2010 Omar Khadr's confession allowed in Guantanamo trial
|
Putin cuts Russia harvest forecast
Google-Verizon nix 'net neutrality' for wireless
Moscow deaths double in Russia's 'worst ever' heat
Iranian journalist Akbar Ganji named 'press freedom hero'
BP pays three billion dollars into oil spill fund
Israel-Palestinian direct talks may restart: Abbas
|
US-TECH Summary
Verizon and Google propose Web traffic rules
Naomi Campbell said Taylor gave her a diamond: Farrow
|
Saudi telecoms test fix to avert BlackBerry ban
Rwanda votes, Kagame aims to consolidate growth
|
Skype files to sell shares at up to 100 million dollars
German authorities shut 9/11 plotters' mosque
German ministers told to avoid BlackBerrys, iPhones
Russia, NORAD shadow jet in Pacific hijack drill
Saudis hold breath on BlackBerry ban
Oman says no plans to ban BlackBerry services
Death toll rises to 165 in Indian Himalayan floods
Death toll in China mudslides jumps to 337
Verizon and Google propose Web traffic rules
|
UN memorial ceremony held for Hiroshima, Nagasaki victims
'Almost nil oil spill' now from stricken ship off Mumbai
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
North Korea fires artillery into sea as tensions rise
Vampires reign at Teen Choice awards
Cambodian PM warns of 'bloodshed' over Thai border
One dead, 12 missing in Philippine ship sinking
Saudi telecoms test fix to avert BlackBerry ban
|
Naomi Campbell said Taylor gave her a diamond: Farrow
Venice festival adds Skolimowski film to contest
French island adopts Scottish-style tartan
Transgender woman fights for right to marry in Hong Kong
Spectacle cancelled after pro-Israel video sparks anger
China quake film sets domestic box office record
Strauss' "Elektra' batters ear-drums at Salzburg Festival
Clint Eastwood pleads for axed UK film lobby group
Vampires reign at Teen Choice awards
|
Rod Stewart, Penny Lancaster expecting second child
|
Accused Jennifer Aniston stalker gets stay away order
|
Clint Eastwood pleads for axed UK film lobby group
|
FBI probes medic murders in Afghanistan
Big protest against cross to late Polish president
Unstable lake threatens mudslide-ravaged China town
|
Gulf activists brace as BlackBerry secrecy targeted
UN: Afghan citizens killed, injured rising sharply
Former Mexico president supports legalizing drugs
|
Extreme weather fuels debate over global warming
Verizon, Google propose Web traffic rules
Traffic police re-arm amid fresh Baghdad attacks
Pakistani president returns home to flood crisis
|
Visitors attack Taiwan 'haunted house' actors
Hezbollah says Israel staked out Hariri's routes
|
Fed expected to downgrade US growth outlook
Iran denies cracks appearing in ties with Syria
Seven Baha'is get 20-year terms in Iran
Japan PM reaches out to South Korea with apology
|
BP makes first deposit into Gulf disaster fund
Paraguay leader seen coping with advanced cancer
|
Prisoner in Afghanistan kills two US Marines
Rwanda's Kagame poised for landslide election win
|
Israeli PM says Turkey ignored flotilla warnings
WHO emergency committee reviews pandemic status
|
Outrage over aid workers' murders in Afghanistan
Charity plans to stay in Afghan despite murders
More than 70 rescued in Indonesia ferry sinking
Bomb kills NATO soldier in Afghan south
Major earthquake frightens Vanuatu
S.Korea says to "act resolutely" against N.Korea
Actor Michael Douglas to speak at Hong Kong forum
Bangladesh bans beating in schools
Charlie Sheen's wife feared for life during assault
Accuser of ex-HP CEO Hurd steps forward
|
Global Weather-Celsius
China orders milk powder probe over baby breasts
Gulf activists brace as BlackBerry secrecy targeted
|
"Jersey Shore" cast never planned on stopping work
US pilots fly Pakistan flood aid to win hearts
"Avatar" sequels could shoot back-to-back
Pakistani president returns home to flood crisis
China's trade surplus balloons
Hopes fade for China mudslide survivors
Taiwan stocks post worst fall in 6 wks; TSMC gains
Vietnam, US display military ties amid China tension
Taiwan says on track for record export value in 2010
Japan issues fresh apology for colonial rule of Korea
Seoul shares slip; N.Korea, China data weigh
Ailing studio MGM facing bankruptcy next month
Judge unsticks "Bruno" Velcro lawsuit
Bank of Japan keeps interest rate steady
Actor Michael Douglas to speak at Hong Kong forum
China mining giants to align rare earth prices
Can anything derail "Glee" from Emmy glory?
Witherspoon moving from June Carter to Peggy Lee
News Corp sells stakes in Chinese TV channels
Levi Johnston to run for mayor in reality pitch
Frankfurt stock market bids for China listings
Cop comedy rules at US and Canadian cinemas
Charlie Sheen's wife feared for life during assault
|
China's property prices continue to slow in July
Portia de Rossi aims to change name to DeGeneres
Witherspoon moving from June Carter to Peggy Lee
|
Seoul shares slip; N.Korea, China data weigh
Can anything derail Glee from Emmy glory?
|
Charlie Sheen's wife feared for life during assault
Ailing studio MGM facing bankruptcy next month
|
Judge unsticks Bruno Velcro lawsuit
|
Portia de Rossi aims to change name to DeGeneres
|
Jersey Shore cast never planned on stopping work
|
Levi Johnston to run for mayor in reality pitch
|
Avatar sequels could shoot back-to-back
|
Eminem And Rihanna Spend Third Week At #1 On Billboard Hot 100
Train Gets "Unplugged" On VH1 In September
2010 New York Comedy Festival Announces Lineup
Justin Bieber, President Bill Clinton To Receive World Leadership Awards
Eminem And Rihanna Top Billboard Hot 100 For Another Week With "Love The Way You Lie"
Eminem Beats Out Debuts From Rick Ross, Sheryl Crow On Billboard Albums Chart
Lindsay Lohan To Head To California Rehab
Update: 19 Reported Dead At Germanys Love Parade Music Festival
Eminem's "Recovery" Spends Fourth Straight Week At #1 On Billboard Albums Chart
Karan Keen On Making Fim With Aamir-SRK
North Korean Artillery Barrage Follows U.S. Naval Drill
Saudis Use High Tech to Track Absconding Foreign Workers
Turkish Airlines Tells Staff to Shed Weight
Controversial 'Hooters' Comes Calling To India
Woman Discovers Her Husband Has Second Wife
Malfunction Strands Passengers On State Fair Ride
Iraq oil hub Basra hoping to see its share of wealth
GDF Suez takes over British power company
McAfee says malware threat at a new high
Signs of movement in Middle East peace talks
Saudi regulator says BlackBerry Messenger to continue
U.N. report says Afghan civilian toll up 31 percent
|
Campbell's ex-agent lied to court: Taylor lawyer
Hundreds of Muslims attend anti-terror summer camp
Afghan civilian casualties up 31 percent: UN
Saudis extend BlackBerry ban reprieve: agency
Russia battles to defend nuclear sites from fires
Saudi watchdog backtracks on BlackBerry ban
Israel weighed all options in Gaza boat raid: defense minister
|
Israel threatens to pull out of UN's Gaza probe
Rights groups urge WikiLeaks to remove Afghan names
Canadian Guantanamo inmate's trial bad precedent: U.N
|
Historic heat to hit Russian growth, fires rage
|
UN: Afghan civilian deaths rise sharply
Signs of movement in Middle East peace talks
|
Paraguay's Lugo vows to beat cancer and govern: aide
|
UN: Afghan citizens killed, injured rising sharply
Polish cross wars rage four months after crash
|
Colombia's Santos, Chavez seek to end dispute
|
Thai PM demands Cambodians leave border area
Unstable lake threatens mudslide-ravaged China town
Malaysian political death probe finds new 'suicide note'
UN to launch appeal for Pakistan flood disaster
China zoos in 'barbaric' animal abuse: report
BlackBerry gets reprieve as Saudi praises progress
|
18 miners trapped in flooded shaft in China
Google under probe in South Korea over data collection
Netflix and Epix strike programming deal
|
Google under probe in S.Korea over data collection
Google under probe in South Korea over data collection
|
Florida sues major LCD makers for price fixing
|
AFP, Xinhua sign three key agreements
McAfee says malware threat at a new high
|
S.Korea probes Google over private data collection
Pakistan floods to hit economic growth
PREVIEW-Pakistan's July CPI seen up 12.34 percent
S.Korean firm hits oil reserves in northern Iraq
S.Korea Hyundai Steel raises Sept export prices
Captain Underpants' creator returns with more poopypants
|
Google lets uneasy Germans opt out of 'Street View'
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights