Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Could London lose 'libel capital of the world' crown?
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Asia Pacific
World
Could London lose 'libel capital of the world' crown?
AFP - 2 hours 57 minutes ago
Send
IM Story
Print
Senior British judges walk from Westminster Abbey to Westminster Hall in central London. The world's rich and powerful have long chosen London to defend their interests in court, but pressure is mounting for an overhaul in the English laws that saw it named "libel capital of the world".
LONDON (AFP) - – The world's rich and powerful have long chosen London to defend their interests in court, but pressure is mounting for an overhaul in the English laws that saw it named "libel capital of the world".
Lawyers, freedom of speech campaigners and even members of the government are questioning whether legislation designed to protect people's reputations is now being used to silence criticism, especially by scientists.
"What concerns me is that the current arrangements are being used by big corporations to restrict fair comment, not always by journalists but also by academics," says Justice Secretary Jack Straw.
English libel laws are widely viewed as some of the toughest in the world, a fact blamed for a stream of foreign claimants who come here to sue for defamation, prompting the press to dub London the world's "libel capital".
Concern about this so-called "libel tourism" and the law more generally have grown as it emerged that scientists are also being targeted.
Cardiologist Peter Wilmshurst is facing legal action here from US firm NMT Medical about comments he made on some of their research two years ago.
Meanwhile science writer Simon Singh is being sued by the British Chiropractic Association for a 2008 newspaper article in which he questioned the use of spinal manipulation in various childhood conditions.
NMT Medical and the BCA both argue they are not stifling debate but are fighting libellous remarks.
Their cases, which have yet to be resolved, have been taken up by campaigners as an issue of freedom of speech.
The British Medical Journal has warned that suing scientists for raising concerns could harm patient care.
"People whose scientific claims are questioned are turning to the law to attempt to silence their critics rather than engaging in open scientific debate," it said in an editorial.
It added: "Weak science sheltered from criticism by officious laws means bad medicine."
Leading barrister Lord Gordon Barrie has also argued: "Scientists, other scholars, medical experts are becoming increasingly wary of challenging dubious claims... because of the chilling effect of the various aspects of libel law."
A defining feature of English libel law is that while claimants must only prove the comments made about them were defamatory, the defendant must show they were either true, 'fair comment' on an issue or in the public interest.
"The defendant carries the burden of proof," said a report published last month by two freedom of speech charities, Index on Censorship and English PEN, which have demanded widescale changes.
"The English approach to libel therefore suggests that the reputation of the claimant is more important than the free speech of the defendant."
Campaigners argue that foreign claimants eager to benefit from this tough approach are suing in English courts, which accept their cases simply because the offending item could be viewed or purchased online in Britain.
This has caused concern in the United States, where a bill passed the House of Representatives in June that would make English libel rulings invalid there.
"Libel tourism threatens the principles of free speech because foreign courts often don't place as difficult a burden on plaintiffs in libel cases," the US bill's co-author, Congressman Steve Cohen, said at the time.
The legislation was sparked by proceedings brought in London against US academic Rachel Ehrenfeld by Saudi businessman Khalid bin Mafouz over allegations in her book, "Funding Evil".
Neither party lived in London but the English court accepted jurisdiction because 23 copies of the book were brought in Britain over the Internet.
However, Paul Tweed, an Irish libel lawyer who has acted for US singers Britney Spears and Jennifer Lopez, denied either that change was required or that "libel tourism" was a problem.
He said most claimants sued here not because it was easy but because they had a reputation to defend here or had been libelled by a British publication.
In the Wilmshurst case, NMT Medical said it sued in England because the comments related to its research here involving British patients and doctors.
And Tweed said English libel laws provided a useful check on the media.
"The broadsheets (newspapers) in Britain are in my view among the most credible in the world simply because of our libel laws," he told AFP.
He added: "Most of my clients, their priority is to get an apology and a retraction as opposed to damages, but they need the leverage of the damages to get the former."
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary Reuters - Saturday, December 5
"Anvil" rocks film documentary awards Reuters - Saturday, December 5
Tom Brokaw unhurt in NY highway wreck that kills 1 AP - Saturday, December 5
Singer Blige feels "Stronger" with each challenge Reuters - Saturday, December 5
NYC Rock & Roll Hall of Fame annex to close Reuters - Saturday, December 5
News Search
Top Stories
OPEC should maintain output: Arab oil ministers
US jobs picture improves, unemployment dips to 10 percent
Polanski to move to Swiss chalet under house arrest
White House accused of 'stonewalling' gatecrash probe
Bernanke admits mistakes, urges Fed independence
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Woods in marriage therapy after admitting 'sins'
Bernanke admits mistakes, urges Fed independence
White House accused of 'stonewalling' gatecrash probe
Sperm genes could explain why women live longer
Polanski to move to Swiss chalet under house arrest
More Most Viewed »
Global stocks mixed amid Dubai debt crisis
Tiny magnetic discs could kill cancer cells: study
Alcohol helps cut heart disease risk for men: study
Mankind using Earth's resources at alarming rate
Dubai blackout over debt plans to hit Gulf markets
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Saturday, 5 December 2009 US allies offer 7,000 troops for Afghan surge
Turncoat Mafia hitman alleges Berlusconi mob links
Reuters launches website overhaul
Iranian group: health care blocked at Iraq camp
US-TECH Summary
UN 'to probe alleged climate change cover-up'
Iraqis defy bomb threat to attend movie nights
Kate Beckinsale Gets Glam And Vamp In New Vodka Campaign Shots
"Friends" Named The Decade's Most Watched Show On TV
Plagiarism Suit Against "Breaking Dawn" Author Stephenie Meyer Dismissed
There's something in the air: augmented reality
George Clooney's "Up In The Air" Wins NBR Best Film
Egypt Nile ferries collide, 80 believed missing
|
Sudanese who deny Darfur crimes may be charged: ICC
|
Iraqi counterterror chief falls to his prey
Jay-Z And Alicia Keys Spend Another Week At #1 With "Empire State Of Mind"
Two Rwandan peacekeepers killed in Darfur: U.N.
|
CIA can expand using drones in Pakistan: report
Ronnie Wood Arrested On Suspicion Of Assaulting Girlfriend
Israeli stalling blocks Shalit deal: Hamas
Roman Polanski To Move To House Arrest After Posting $4.5 Million Bail
Beyonce, Taylor Swift Lead Grammy Nods List
There's something in the air: augmented reality
|
Senior Kashmir separatist wounded: Indian police
France offers to sell artillery, tanks to India
Canada PM speaks out on rights in China
Gunmen wound Kashmir separatist who favored talks
US, Russia uphold 'spirit' of expiring nuclear pact
3 injured in false fire alarm at Indonesia airport
Italian jurors consider verdicts in sex murder trial
Campaign manager for ex-Conn. rep accused of theft
US Marines launch large offensive
Woman Tackled, Trampled By Deer Stampede
Suicide attackers kill 35 at Pakistan mosque
Polanski takes refuge in Swiss chalet
US Marines launch large offensive in Afghanistan
Police search for man linked to 4 Wis. slayings
AP NewsAlert
Michael Jackson Tops Most Searched Term On Internet
Va. Tech report details new fumbles in shooting
Myanmar court agrees to hear Suu Kyi's appeal
Federal Agents Step Up Manhunt For Thanksgiving Day Murderer
Homeowner Association Threatens WWII Vet With Legal Action Over Flagpole
Moderates seek greater health care cost controls
Gibbs: Obama encouraged by new employment report
Washington Presses Iran About Former FBI Agent Missing Since 2007
Burglary Suspect: 'I Didn't Know They Were Dead'
NY terminals evacuated when wired box found on jet
Jurors Hear Confession Tape In Wimberly Trial; Defense Says Tape Proves Insanity Plea
South Carolina Impeachment Panel Dismisses 28 Of 37 Ethics Charges Against Gov. Sanford
Senate Official: Tiger Has The Answers
Third Person Charged With Assisting Clemmons In Eluding Police
NYC Rock & Roll Hall of Fame annex to close
|
Sony, Disney executives top Hollywood power list
|
Edgar Allen Poe book from 1827 sells for $662,500
|
Pakistan stocks end down after attack; rupee eases
Friendlier Obama tune on Cuba brings musical detente
|
'Tis the season for nightmarish traffic in Lebanon
Roman Polanski released to house arrest in Swiss chalet
Russian classic inspires Indian star to pen script
Strike keeps French museums shut, Louvre reopens
Twisted Sister guitarist recovers from surgery
Film star Richard Todd dies at 90
Rock and Roll Hall of Fame annex in NYC closing
Secret of Stradivarius violin varnish picked apart
Fla. judge wants footage in 'Girls Gone Wild' suit
Chinese Premier Scolds Canadian Prime Minister For Taking Too Long To Visit Beijing
Woman Tackled, Trampled By Deer Stampede
English Teen Has 'Super' Long Name
Two Rwandan peacekeepers killed in Darfur ambush
Firework blaze in Russian club kills at least 101
|
OPEC should maintain output: Arab oil ministers
102 dead in Russian restaurant fire
NATO allies offer 7,000 extra troops for Afghan war
|
Dozens of militants attack Pakistan army checkpoint
|
Egypt Nile ferries collide, 80 believed missing
Apple acquires music service Lala
, Microsoft ink Web search agreement
76 dead in Russian cafe blast: report
US lauds wealth of Afghanistan troop pledges
Hospitalized Thai King makes rare public appearance
|
Turncoat Mafia hitman alleges Berlusconi mob links
US jobs picture improves, unemployment dips to 10 percent
Ecosia search engine fights climate change
Twelve die in drug war shootouts in Mexico
|
Iran rejects IAEA transparency demand on atom sites
Microsoft search engine Bing suffers brief outage
Iraqi counterterror chief falls to his prey
Taiwan's China-friendly party on test in local poll
|
Colombia says Venezuela destroys bridge, holds soldier
|
Philippines imposes martial law in massacre province
|
Sony, Disney executives top Hollywood power list
Apple mute on Lala plans
|
George Washington letter sells for record $3.2M
Obama boosts climate talks with change of plans
Thai king leaves hospital for birthday celebrations
Congress Gets Push To Resist Pressure To Weaken Investor Protection Reforms
Transcript shows man claiming to be spy helped FBI
China swine flu death toll reaches 200
Lawyer: Blagojevich will testify at his own trial
4 US teens held for attempted murder in Japan: police
Man who left water for immigrants faces prison
Indonesia police probe deadly karaoke club fire
US military deaths in Afghanistan region at 852
Hospitalised Thai King makes rare public appearance
Kremlin agrees with US to maintain expiring pact
Japan chooses new envoy to Taiwan: lawmaker
Another arrest in Washington police shooting case
Rice an unlikely global warming culprit
Ind. parents grieve slain son, as teen son charged
Philippines imposes martial law in massacre province
North Korea talks seen unlikely to end arms stalemate
Dozens of militants attack Pakistan army checkpoint
GM, Chinese partner join forces in India
OECD urges India to loosen foreign investment curbs
Rolling Stone magazine to launch restaurant, lounge
Spielberg drops 'Harvey' remake
Rich nations must show sensitivity on climate: World Bank
Japan plans huge stimulus package next week
Malaysia's exports rise 1.6% in October: ministry
Vietnam donors up aid pledge by 33 percent: government
Fans kept guessing about Jackson 4 reunion
|
Anvil rocks film documentary awards
|
Invictus achieves its goal without digging deep
|
Could London lose 'libel capital of the world' crown?
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Kylie Minogue to release New York live set
|
"Anvil" rocks film documentary awards
Elvis Costello enjoys TV role as carnival barker
|
20 killed in Indonesian amusement center fire
Police quiz suspects in fatal Indonesian bar fire
Tom Brokaw unhurt in NY highway wreck that kills 1
Singer Blige feels "Stronger" with each challenge
Singer Blige feels Stronger with each challenge
|
NYC Rock & Roll Hall of Fame annex to close
Kylie Minogue to release New York live set
Washington letter, Poe book set auction records
New Caribbean art showcased during Art Basel fair
Elvis Costello enjoys TV role as "carnival barker"
Google buys online collaboration startup
Saudi investors shrug off Dubai debt crisis
Guinea on edge after attack on junta leader
|
About a dozen missing after Egypt ferries collide
|
Iran says needs 20 nuclear sites: report
|
Anti-China opposition gains ground in Taiwan local election
|
Turkish commanders in court to testify in plot probe
|
Nothing will fill hole in our lives, say Kerchers
|
Accidental blast kills 3 in NW Pakistan
1 more body found after Bangladesh boat capsizes
Obama: efforts aimed at economy's long-term health
The nation's weather
Lawmakers get little reaction to Obama's war plan
Protests in Kashmir over separatist shooting
Little resistance in new US-Afghan offensive
Asian nations confident despite tough World Cup draw
Indonesian police arrest alleged kangaroo smuggler
LA Episcopal diocese may elect first gay bishop
Japan fans expect tough fight after World Cup draw
1 killed, 2 injured in Texas refinery accident
Ex-UN weapons inspector condemns Blair, Bush on Iraq
AP NewsAlert
Maldives gets 92.5 million dollar bailout from IMF
Indian court deals blow to Anil Ambani gas project
NKorea orders soldiers to shoot defectors: report
Pakistani c.bank buys 147.8 bln rupees of govt paper
Beware the great 'greenwashing' con, experts warn
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights