Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Federal judge strikes down Calif. gay marriage ban
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Federal judge strikes down Calif. gay marriage ban
By LISA LEFF and PAUL ELIAS,Associated Press Writers -
Thursday, August 5
Send
IM Story
Print
SAN FRANCISCO – A federal judge overturned California's gay marriage ban Wednesday with an unequivocal ruling that could eventually force the U.S. Supreme Court to confront the question of whether same-sex couples have a constitutional right to wed.
Chief U.S. District Judge Vaughn Walker's strongly worded opinion in the landmark case _ the first in a federal court to examine if states can lawfully limit marriage to a man and a woman _ touched off a celebration outside the courthouse. Later in the day, a jubilant crowd marched through the city that has long been a haven for gays.
As word of the verdict spread, about 300 people assembled in a West Hollywood park waving rainbow gay pride flags. In New York City, a crowd of about 150 gathered outside a lower Manhattan courthouse. They carried signs saying "Our Love Wins" as organizers read portions of the 136-page decision aloud.
Ruling in a lawsuit filed by two couples who claimed the ban violated their civil rights, Walker methodically dismantled every argument advanced by sponsors of the voter-approved measure, known as Proposition 8, before declaring it unconstitutional.
"Proposition 8 singles out gays and lesbians and legitimates their unequal treatment," he wrote. "Proposition 8 perpetuates the stereotype that gays and lesbians are incapable of forming long-term loving relationships and that gays and lesbians are not good parents."
Standing in front of eight American flags at a news conference, the two couples behind the case beamed and choked up as they related their feelings of validation.
"Our courts are supposed to protect our Constitutional rights," lead plaintiff Kris Perry said as Sandy Stier, her partner of 10 years, stood at her side. "Today, they did."
"We are not here to change the world. Equality is something our country has always been about," said co-plaintiff Jeff Zarrillo, who is seeking the right to marry his partner of nine years, Paul Katami. "Today's decision brings Paul and I and so many others like us closer to that equality, too."
Voters passed Proposition 8 as a state constitutional amendment in November 2008, five months after the California Supreme Court legalized same-sex unions and an estimated 18,000 same-sex couples already had tied the knot. Despite Wednesday's ruling, it remains uncertain when gay weddings will be allowed to resume in the state.
Protect Marriage, the coalition of religious and conservative groups that sponsored the ban, said it would appeal Walker's ruling to the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
"In America, we should uphold and respect the right of people to make policy changes through the democratic process, especially changes that do nothing more than uphold the definition of marriage that has existed since the founding of this country and beyond," said Jim Campbell, a lawyer on the defense team.
Walker, meanwhile, said he would consider while Protect Marriage pursues its appeal suspending an order requiring the state to cease enforcing Proposition 8. He ordered both sides to submit written arguments by Friday on the issue.
The appeal would go first to the 9th Circuit, then to the U.S. Supreme Court, if the high court justices agree to review it.
Currently, same-sex couples can legally wed only in Massachusetts, Iowa, Connecticut, Vermont, New Hampshire and Washington, D.C.
Before deciding the case, Walker heard 13 days of testimony and arguments. Former U.S. Solicitor General Theodore Olson teamed with David Boies to argue for the plaintiffs, bringing together two litigators best known as adversaries who respectively represented George W. Bush and Al Gore in the disputed 2000 election.
Reveling in their joint victory Wednesday, Boies said their unusual alliance would be valuable if the Proposition 8 case, known as Perry v. Schwarzenegger, reaches the Supreme Court.
"Ted and I have a deal: He is going to get the five justices that were for him in Bush v. Gore, and I'm going to get the four justices that were with me in Bush v. Gore," Boies joked.
Defense lawyers argued at trial that the ban was necessary to safeguard the traditional understanding of marriage and to encourage responsible childbearing. But they called just two witnesses, claiming they did not need to present expert testimony because the U.S. Supreme Court had never specifically recognized a right to gay marriage.
"To prevail in the end, our opponents have a very difficult task of convincing the U.S. Supreme Court to abandon precedent and invent a new constitutional right," Andy Pugno, a lawyer for Protect Marriage said Wednesday.
The judge, however, dismissed the notion that gay Americans were seeking a new right as opposed to one already guaranteed them as U.S. citizens under the Constitution's due process and equal protection clauses.
Preventing gays from marrying does nothing to strengthen heterosexual unions or serve any purpose that justifies the ban's discriminatory effect, he said.
"Same-sex couples are identical to opposite-sex couples in the characteristics relevant to the ability to form successful marital unions," the Walker wrote. "Like opposite-sex couples, same-sex couples have happy, satisfying relationships and form deep emotional bonds and strong commitments to their partners."
"Indeed, the evidence shows Proposition 8 does nothing more than enshrine in the California Constitution the notion that opposite-sex couples are superior to same-sex couples," the judge wrote.
Describing the defense case as "a rather limited factual presentation," he also said its proponents offered little evidence that they were motivated by anything other than animus toward gays _ beginning with their campaign to pass the ban, which included claims of wanting to protect children from learning about same-sex marriage in school.
"Proposition 8 played on the fear that exposure to homosexuality would turn children into homosexuals and that parents should dread having children who are not heterosexual," Walker wrote.
The ruling puts Walker, a Republican appointed by President George H.W. Bush, at the forefront of the gay marriage debate and marks the second verdict in a federal gay marriage case to come down in less than a month.
In July, a District Court judge in Massachusetts decided the state's legally married gay and lesbian couples had been wrongly denied the federal financial benefits of marriage because of a law preventing the U.S. government from recognizing same-sex unions.
___
Associated Press Writers Juliana Barbassa in San Francisco, Raquel Dillon in West Hollywood, Jennifer Peltz in New York City contributed to this report.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Naomi Campbell arrives at war crimes court: official AFP - 21 minutes ago
New Kenya constitution poised for referendum victory AFP - 38 minutes ago
'Yes' vote edges towards victory in Kenya referendum AFP - 2 hours 7 minutes ago
Suicide attack kills seven Afghan police AFP - 30 minutes ago
Barclays bank says net profits soar 29 percent AFP - 36 minutes ago
News Search
Top Stories
Barclays bank says net profits soar 29 percent
ECB mulls alternatives to rate-cut to spur growth
Phelps swims to two titles as Peirsol falls
US economy adds private jobs but at lackluster pace
Hope for Gulf as BP plugs well, most of the oil gone
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Elite US cyber team courts hackers to fight terrorists
Israel cuts down trees that caused Lebanon clashes
US obesity growing 'faster than anyone imagined'
Spanish resort city readies to host Michelle Obama, daughter
BP partner refusing to pay 1.2-billion-dollar oil spill bill
More Most Viewed »
Parachuting donkey shocks Russian beachgoers
Argentine students crack three-decade-old murder mystery
World's first full face transplant man appears on TV
Paris Hilton caught with cannabis in handbag
Calcium supplements linked to heart attacks: study
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo!
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
World Cup 2010
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Thursday, 5 August 2010 U.N. supports Israeli claim on Lebanon clash
Medvedev sacks officers over Russia fire failures
Petraeus issues new rules to avoid civilian casualties
Intel to end tactics against competition: FTC
Italy rejects no-confidence motion against junior minister
US-TECH Summary
BP partner refusing to pay 1.2-billion-dollar oil spill bill
Iran's Ahmadinejad unhurt after blast near motorcade
Chechen rebel chief revokes resignation: video
LinkedIn makes first acquisition
Piano 'played by Mozart' discovered in Germany: report
UAE decision to ban BlackBerry services 'final'
Israel warns Lebanon but also seeks calm along border
Time Warner profits top forecasts
US economy adds private jobs but at lackluster pace
Yes voters take early lead in Kenya referendum
|
More than 50,000 altar servers gather at Vatican
40 US billionaires pledge half wealth to charity
Mexico drug cartels use gory videos to spread fear
|
Siemens to cut 2,000 IT jobs in Germany
Cuba lawmakers to hear Fidel Castro nuclear fears
|
Google's Android takes lead in US consumer smartphones
Russia moves radioactive material from nuclear site
U.N. council calls on Iraq to form government soon
|
UAE decision to ban BlackBerry services 'final'
Criminals, spies swamp cyber world: experts
Fires rage in Russia, death toll rises to 48
|
Japan's DoCoMo ties up with publisher to launch e-books
Point and peek iPhone app for Aussie househunters
Six wounded in mosque attack in violent Karachi
Devastating Pakistan floods sweep Punjab
Death toll from Pakistan political unrest reaches 70
New Zealand makes Champions Trophy history
Messi stars as Barca beat K-League All Stars
Google's Android leads U.S. smartphones
|
Microsoft and Salesforce settle patent tiff
|
Nearly 1,700 dead, missing in China floods
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
LinkedIn makes first acquisition
|
Asian ministers fret over millennium goals
Wyclef Jean set to announce Haitian presidency run
Pakistan president attacked over Europe trip after floods
Swiss film fest with Asian touch to show banned zombie movie
Airil leads Selangor Masters golf after first round
India Tata Group starts quest for Ratan Tata successor
China taps celebs to star in image-boosting commercials
Record China sales boost Daimler
Rice paddy art puts Japan village on the map
Salman Rushdie headlines Brazilian book festival
India says overly aggressive rate hikes could hurt recovery
Media giant Time Warner's profits top forecasts
Japan's automakers recover but challenges remain
China to step up crackdown on hot money inflows
Yen emerges from shadow of action stars Chan, Li
Huang denies making formal bid for Liverpool
Taiwan cabinet opposes court ruling on AU plant
Kanye West paints his way back onto MTV
|
Avenged Sevenfold earns first No. 1 on album chart
|
Wyclef Jean set to announce Haitian presidency run
|
Suicide attack kills six Afghan police
Suicide bomber kills 7 Afghan police in north
Petraeus clarifies rules on Afghan air strikes
|
Mideast BlackBerry ban hits Hollywood and media
Hollywood glad kids willing to pay for content
China defends dealings with Iran after US pressure
IBM and Aetna tie up to offer clinical support service
U.N. council calls on Iraq to form government soon
Microsoft and Salesforce end patent duel
Google phones unseat BlackBerry as US best seller
Suicide bomber kills six police in Afghan north
|
Google Android gains pace, social Web a focus: CEO
Verizon and Google reach Internet traffic deal: sources
ECB mulls alternatives to rate-cut to spur growth
Too few users catch Google's 'Wave'
Phelps swims to two titles as Peirsol falls
Ex-PM Rudd charges into Australia poll race
Factbox: BlackBerry security explained
S.Korea kicks off military drill despite threats
Hope for Gulf as BP plugs well, most of the oil gone
Magnitude 5.7 quake hits near Concepcion, Chile
|
Petraeus clarifies rules on Afghan air strikes
China protesters cut off and swallow fingertips
40 US billionaires pledge half wealth to charity
Pakistan's Sindh province braces for floods
|
Giuliani daughter arrested at NYC cosmetics store
Military shakeup could derail Thai peace moves
Obama turns 49 with Mrs. Obama, kids out of town
Hong Kong Octopus chief resigns after data sale
Federal judge strikes down Calif. gay marriage ban
Japan child porn cases surge to record high
UN chief in Japan calls for end to nuclear arms
Group sues to stop mosque near NYC's ground zero
Pacific meeting focuses on Fiji, climate change
UN rushes envoy to mounting Pakistan flood crisis
10 missing after Indonesian ships collide
Google's Android leads U.S. smartphones
|
Google Android gains pace, social Web a focus: CEO
|
Indonesia posts 6.2 pct growth in second quarter
Mideast BlackBerry ban hits Hollywood and media
|
January Jones "sucks it up" for Emmy
Chinese import prompts S.Korea car safety fears
Island paradises for sale or rent
Verizon and Google reach Internet traffic deal: sources
|
Seoul shares end down; banks sink on foreign selling
Hollywood glad kids willing to pay for content
|
China bank adviser urges more flexible yuan
Piracy forces Taylor Swift to rush out new single
British drink to good health at beer festival
S.Korea says China trade talks likely next year
"Expendables" revels in excess
IBM and Aetna tie up to offer clinical support service
|
PAKISTAN
Philippines suffering from migrant brain drain
Web porn saga "Middle Men" boasts colorful cast
S.Korea says facing risks despite recovery
Prosecutors claim doctors over-medicated Anna Nicole
New Zealand Post 2010 profit to fall on one-offs
Restraining order for accused DiCaprio bottle attacker
NZ unemployment rises, chances of rate pause grow
Michael Jackson's last home up for sale
Prosecutors claim doctors over-medicated Anna Nicole
|
Lady Gaga to Green Day, Lollapalooza boasts motley cast
|
Restraining order for accused DiCaprio bottle attacker
|
Piracy forces Taylor Swift to rush out new single
|
January Jones sucks it up for Emmy
|
Web porn saga Middle Men boasts colorful cast
|
Expendables revels in excess
|
Michael Jackson's last home up for sale
|
Corrected
Putin bans Russia grain exports due to drought
Saudis brace for BlackBerry ban, new models in UAE
Karzai orders probe into Afghan civilian deaths reports
|
Suicide attack kills seven Afghan police
Greece still faces problems despite progress: EU-IMF
Iran sees regional alliance to counter NATO
|
Barclays bank first-half profits soar 29%
Kyrgyz troops break up crowd, see coup attempt
|
Suicide bomber kills 7 Afghan police in north
Leaks undermine Afghan support for NATO: UK
|
NATO helicopter goes down in southern Afghanistan
Kenya 'yes' camp declares referendum victory
Zimbabwe sparks accident scare with airport drill
Iran stoning case lawyer in Turkey, seeking asylum
|
Naomi Campbell arrives at war crimes court
Russia in losing battle against spreading wildfires
Kenya votes Yes to new constitution
|
Supermodel Campbell tells court of dirty pebbles
|
Special Report: In Rwanda Inc., an election exposes repression
|
On Facebook, wife learns of husband's 2nd wedding
911 call on Conn. shooting shows racial disparity
NM gov meets with lawman Pat Garrett's descendants
Will Smith teaches son how not to kiss on-screen
Suspected suicide bomber injures 14 in Philippines
Green turtles return to Malaysia but future bleak
S.Korean military in war against foul language
Pakistani stocks, o/n rates end down; rupee weakens
Lebanon to assess security concerns over BlackBerry
|
Sri Lanka tea export earnings to hit record high
Singer Lily Allen reveals pregnancy
India's Reliance eye stake in US shale gas field
Cambodia selecting securities firms for new bourse
Seoul to invite 100 world CEOs to G20 summit
Supermodel Campbell tells court of "dirty pebbles"
Seoul shares end down; banks sink on foreign selling
Indonesia court upholds ban on 'Balibo' film
Will Smith teaches son how not to kiss on-screen
Supermodel Campbell tells court of dirty pebbles
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights