Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Isolde alone cannot save this production
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Asia Pacific
World
Search
Search:
Isolde alone cannot save this production
By GEORGE JAHN,Associated Press Writer AP - Saturday, August 29
BAYREUTH, Germany - Tristan and Isolde, Wagner once wrote, was meant to be a "monument to that most beautiful of dreams" _ love.
ADVERTISEMENT
But in Christoph Marthaler's production, this opera of sensual and psychological longing unto the death of the two lovers is more a memorial to boredom _ over four hours of it.
As seen Friday in this revival performance rounding out this year's Bayreuth Festival, little moves except the music.
This opera is admittedly challenging to stage. It is organically static, with what "action" there is taking place on a ship's desk, a garden and under a linden tree, in Wagner's original.
What's more, the stage is dominated by only two characters, the star-crossed Tristan and Isolde, with the four other principals making only brief appearances.
Wagner obviously meant to give his music center stage. The orchestral complement to this opera is arguably the finest he has ever written _ and the libretto reflects it, with the instruments often left to complete the main characters' half-uttered unfinished phrases of ardor with wave after wave of crashing emotion breaking on breathtaking musical sensitivity.
But in Marthaler's production it's not a question of little staging, and little action. It's as if he has given up and decided to put on a concert performance of the work.
Instead of a the deck of a rolling sailing ship making its way to Cornwall with Isolde, the betrothed of King Marke, we have a cruise ship's lounge in deadly brown. Isolde is dressed variously in a shapeless knit dress and a yellow two-piece job complemented by Tristan's buttondown blue blazer and flannels.
Not quite the dashing warrior Wagner envisaged. And it only gets worse.
Meant to be minimalist to transport the audience into the heart and soul of the opera, this production is skeletal in terms of acting.
The singers move so slowly that one is tempted to look for a snail's wet track. And the two lovers hardly touch. In their supposedly passionate night garden scene _ inside the ship's lounge revamped to look like a school gym _ Isolde opens the buttons of her jacket to reveal a prim blouse.
Tristan is obviously turned on.
He loosens his tie.
And so it goes. When the lovers expire, finally united forever in their "Liebestod" death scene, it's a release _ and not only for them.
In terms of voices, Friday's performance should have been called "Isolde and Tristan." Irene Theorin was in full register, transcending octaves without effort. She more than kept pace both with the orchestra and Robert Dean Smith, whose voice was pleasant but who, as Tristan, lacked the breadth needed to keep pace with his co-star.
Robert Holl was persuasive as King Marke, who absolves both his trusted Tristan and Isolde, his wife, of all guilt as he recognizes the inevitability of their love. Also good: Jukka Rasilainien as Kurwenal, Tristan's comrade in arms, Michelle Breedt as Isolde's maid, Brangane, and Ralf Lukas as the treacherous Melot.
Bayreuth veteran Peter Schneider coaxed a fine performance of an orchestra tasked with the challenges of sketching love eternal through finely shaded musical moods that vary from the most subtle foreshadowings and tender shudders to the veritable tidal waves of strings reflecting anger or ardor at their highest pitch.
But even the music could not save this production.
"Sleep without awakening," to paraphrase Wagner himself.
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Sign in to recommend this article »
0 users recommend
Related Articles: Entertainment & Lifestyle
Spanish album an unexpected "Plan" for FurtadoReuters - Saturday, August 29
Noel Gallagher quits British rock group OasisAFP - Saturday, August 29
Clapton, Hornsby to perform on new Leno showAP - Saturday, August 29
Noel Gallagher quits OasisReuters - Saturday, August 29
Last chapter arrives for 'Reading Rainbow' on PBSAP - Saturday, August 29
Most Popular – Entertainment
Viewed
Kidnapped US girl walks into police station 18 years on
Boeing delays 787 Dreamliner first delivery to late 2010
Microsoft apologizes for photo gaffe
AIG extends improbable rally as bears squeezed
Appetite spells three wolves' doom in Switzerland
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Saturday, 29 August 2009 Iceland to pay back Icesave cash
Chip maker Intel raises revenue forecast
Iran slows nuclear work but pressed on bomb suspicions
| International
|
Iraqis mourn death of key Shi'ite party leader
Tick saliva could hold cancer cure: Brazilian scientists
Big Blue dreams of a big green battery
Dutch court blocks girl's solo global sailing bid
Nixon enlisted secret service to spy on Ted Kennedy
Iran president wants opposition leaders punished
U.S. unveils new rules on border searches of laptops
Eulogies for Iraqi Shiite leader reflect worries
Scots divided over release of Lockerbie bomber
| International
|
South America tries to ease rift over U.S. military
| International
|
IAEA extends probe of alleged secret Syria atom site
| International
|
Flixster's Movies aims to connect film fans
| Technology
|
Opposition looks to reshape Japanese economy
Flat incomes raise doubts about economic recovery
NKorea to free SKorean fishermen as tensions ease
Obama's aging czar sees issue as unifying force
Ohio soldier made 2 calls to mom telling of abuse
Fla. governor taps ex-aide to replace US senator
Australia debates whether Aboriginal policy racist
Kennedy memorial speakers include family, friends
Dozens hurt by ammonia leak at Calif. meat plant
South American leaders attack US bases plan
Malaysia Muslims protest proposed Hindu temple
August deadliest month for US in Afghanistan
Myanmar fighting forces up to 30,000 to flee to China
California governor declares wildfire emergency
Officials close public viewing for Sen. Kennedy
China urges Myanmar to end conflict in border area
US service member killed in Afghanistan
Coroner: Slain pastor had gashes to neck, chest
India sentences Muslim militant to life in prison
AP NewsAlert
AIG's Taiwan unit gets three low bids-sources
Apple seals deal to bring iPhones coming to China
China Shenhua says 1H profit up 14 pct
iPhones coming to China after Apple, Unicom deal
China shares drop on worries liquidity might fall
PetroChina says 1H profit down 7.2 percent
Mary Mary still going strong 9 years later
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Court throws out FCC cable ownership limit
Jackson death a homicide, criminal charge possible
| Entertainment
|
Charges against Japanese artist dropped in NYC
Label has high hopes for Whitney Houston comeback
| Entertainment
|
Chesney, Swift, Sugarland to appear on ABC special
Idol champ Kris Allen sets release date for album
| Entertainment
|
Gypsy trio criticizes booing of Madonna
Big screen evolves to compete with small
Flixster's Movies aims to connect film fans
| Entertainment
|
Fay Weldon paints bleak picture of future in novel
| Entertainment
|
Dutch court blocks girl's solo global sailing bid
Iran has slowed uranium output: UN agency
Iran slows nuclear pace but bomb suspicions grow
| International
|
Internet Age re-inventing music business: Bandwidth
Michael Jackson's death homicide: coroner
Iran slows nuclear work but pressed on bomb suspicions
Argentina to adopt Japanese standard for HDTV
Taiwan president has no plans to meet Dalai Lama
| International
|
IAEA extends probe of alleged secret Syria atom site
Candidates woo voters on eve of Japan election
| International
|
US envoy in 'testy' election meeting with Karzai
Eulogies for Iraqi Shiite leader reflect worries
Fresh Myanmar fighting erupts, one dead in China
| International
|
Suicide bomber kills four in northern Iraq
| International
|
Ahmadinejad says Iran opposition leaders should be punished
South American rift persists over US-Colombia deal
| International
|
Australian navy intercepts suspected asylum seekers
| International
|
Candidates make final pitch on eve of Japan election
5 dead, 18 missing after ferry sinks in Indonesia
SKorea ready to receive fishermen from NKorea: police
Central Beijing shut off for National Day rehearsals
Foster parents arrested in disappearance of boy
NZealander tells of mid-Pacific sailing nightmare
AP NewsAlert
China Unicom in 3-year deal for Apple's iPhone
| Technology
|
Alleged leader of Phillipine kidnapping extradited
Mexico: anti-Mexican discrimination in US growing
Cricket: Hussey's century helps Australia shake off Ashes agony
Pakistani court: Lift curbs on nuclear scientist
Questions arise over how kidnapper went undetected
DJ AM, who battled drug habit, found dead in NYC
Congressman: Gadhafi won't stay in Englewood, NJ
Boy goes missing in rough NC surf caused by Danny
Utahns can now practice DUI jail call
China comes to Canary Wharf company's rescue
China to scrap higher tariffs on auto parts imports: US
DJ AM found dead in New York apartment
| Entertainment
|
Noel Gallagher quits Oasis
| Entertainment
|
Spanish album an unexpected Plan for Furtado
| Entertainment
|
DJ AM, who battled drug habit, found dead in NYC
Noel Gallagher quits British rock group Oasis
Clapton, Hornsby to perform on new Leno show
Noel Gallagher quits Oasis
Last chapter arrives for 'Reading Rainbow' on PBS
Kelly Preston: 'Too soon' to talk about losing son
`Always Sunny' live tour adds second Philly show
Jackson death ruled homicide, focus on doctor
Mexico expects 15,000 dancers for 'Thriller' dance
Isolde alone cannot save this production
Second black box of crashed Yemenia jet retrieved
US shuttle Discovery lifts off
Karzai extends Afghan vote lead; run-off indicated
| International
|
Wall Street confidence rising but Sept peril looms
Bombs in northern Iraq kill at least 15
Pakistan holds Mumbai conspirators' trial in secrecy
| International
|
Lockerbie bomber says backs call for inquiry
| International
|
12 killed, over 40 wounded in northern Iraq attacks
North Korea returns South fishermen after a month
| International
|
Lawyer says Iraqi shoe thrower to be released
Iranian FM Mottaki in Baghdad
Iran says report confirms atomic work peaceful
| International
|
Afghan vote fraud claims gather momentum
Peacekeeping civilians kidnapped in Darfur
| International
|
Obama: No turf wars, red tape in Katrina recovery
India loses communication with lunar satellite
Pakistan court delays case against Mumbai suspects
Lockerbie bomber backs inquiry into attack
3 killed, 17 wounded in restive southern Thailand
Space shuttle blasts off, finally flying on try 3
Pakistan holds Mumbai conspirators' trial in secrecy
1 killed, 17 wounded in restive southern Thailand
SC GOP reps to discuss impeaching philandering gov
Michael Jackson's death homicide: coroner
Taiwan stresses no politics in Dalai Lama visit
North Korea frees 4 South Korean fishermen
Funeral Mass for fallen senator begins in Boston
Philippine Muslim extradited to US for kidnap
US has alternative to Europe missile sites: report
Wounded CBS journalist at hospital in Afghanistan
Pakistan sets 10 bln rupees target for Islamic bond
Pakistani c.bank buys 22 bln rupees of govt paper
Opposition looks to reshape Japanese economy
Jackson death ruled homicide, focus on doctor
| Entertainment
|
Free download Bollywood tribute to Michael Jackson
Spanish album an unexpected "Plan" for Furtado
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights