Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Vatican under fire for linking gays to pedophilia
|
Edition:
U.S.
Article
Comments (17)
Slideshow
Save
Email
Print
Reprints
Most Popular
Most Shared
Judge tells Mississippi schools to stop segregating
13 Apr 2010
Texas man pleads guilty to hiding money at UBS
13 Apr 2010
Iran not nuclear weapons capable for "at least a year"-Gates
13 Apr 2010
Quake kills 400, schools cave in
| Video
10:17am EDT
UPDATE 5-Toyota halts Lexus SUV sales after safety warning
13 Apr 2010
Judge tells Mississippi schools to stop segregating
13 Apr 2010
Special Report: Are regulators dropping the ball on biocrops?
13 Apr 2010
Quake kills 400, schools cave in
| Video
10:17am EDT
Diet can sharply cut Alzheimer's risk: study
12 Apr 2010
Burial move shows cracks in Polish unity on crash
8:18am EDT
Vatican under fire for linking gays to pedophilia
Philip Pullella
VATICAN CITY
Wed Apr 14, 2010 11:08am EDT
Related News
Vatican scoffs at idea of arresting pope in Britain
Tue, Apr 13 2010
Priest pedophilia not linked to celibacy: Pope's No.2
Mon, Apr 12 2010
Priest pedophilia not linked to celibacy: Pope's No.2
Mon, Apr 12 2010
Pope willing to meet more abuse victims: Vatican
Fri, Apr 9 2010
Cardinal defends pope, denounces "petty gossip"
Sun, Apr 4 2010
Related Analysis
Homosexuality, not celibacy, linked to pedophilia, says Vatican #2
Vatican scoffs at Dawkins idea of arresting pope while in Britain
Vatican puts abuse rules online to quell critics
Sex abuse scandals shake Church but not faith
<
1 / 2
>
View Full Size
VATICAN CITY (Reuters) - Gay groups and politicians condemned Pope Benedict's number two on Wednesday for calling homosexuality a "pathology" and linking it directly to sexual abuse of children.
World
The comments made by Cardinal Tarcisio Bertone during a visit to Chile, and the controversy they caused, were splashed on mainstream Italian newspapers on Wednesday.
The French foreign ministry and some Catholic blogs that support the pope also condemned the cardinal's remarks.
As the scandal over sexual abuse of children by priests has spread, some in the Catholic Church have called for a review of the Church's rule that prohibits priests from marrying, saying marriage would allow priests to enjoy a healthy sex life.
Bertone, the Vatican secretary of state, who is sometimes called the "deputy pope," told a news conference in Santiago on Monday:
"Many psychologists and psychiatrists have shown that there is no link between celibacy and pedophilia, but many others have shown, I have recently been told, that there is a relationship between homosexuality and pedophilia."
"This pathology is one that touches all categories of people, and priests to a lesser degree in percentage terms," he said. "The behavior of the priests in this case, the negative behavior, is very serious, is scandalous."
Gay rights activists reacted with derision and outrage.
"This is a scientific absurdity. The World Health Organization calls homosexuality a variation of human behavior. It is pedophilia that is a pathology, a crime, not homosexuality," said Franco Grillini, a former parliamentarian who was at the vanguard of Italy's gay rights movement.
"Because they have their own problems with the abuse crisis and don't know how to handle it, they are trying to pass their 'cross' from their shoulders on to ours," Grillini told Reuters.
CATHOLIC BLOG CRITICISES
The French foreign ministry called it an "unacceptable linkage that we condemn."
Some pro-Vatican Catholic blogs said more controversy was the last thing the Vatican needed.
"Pedophilia and homosexuality: Bertone trips up -- again -- on gays," read a post in the Italian-language "Blog of the Friends of Pope Ratzinger."
It said the pope might now have to "clean up the mess made by his right-hand man."
Vatican spokesman Rev. Federico Lombardi issued a statement in which he tried to douse the fire caused by the latest mishap.
He said Church leaders were not trying to make "general affirmations of a specific psychological nature" and offered Church statistics that showed that two-thirds of incidents of abuse of adolescents by priests involved homosexual priests.
A front-page editorial in Rome's left-leaning La Repubblica newspaper titled "The Confusion in the Church" said Bertone's comments would end up causing the Church more "harm to itself, not homosexuals."
Bertone was also criticized by Alessandra Mussolini, a right-wing parliamentarian whose grandfather, wartime Fascist dictator Benito Mussolini, sent gays into internal exile.
"You can't link sexual orientation to pedophilia ... this link risks becoming dangerously misleading for the protection of children," Mussolini said.
ArciLesbica, Italy's main lesbian rights group, accused the Vatican of using "violent and deceptive statements" to divert attention from its abuse scandal and said Italian parents should consider removing their children from Church-run institutions.
The pope did not make any direct reference to the crisis facing the Church during his weekly general audience.
He may address the issue when he visits Malta this weekend. Ten Maltese men who are suing three priests for alleged child abuse have requested a private meeting with the pope.
(Writing by Philip Pullella; additional reporting by Crispian Balmer in Paris and Simon Gardner in Santiago; editing by Tim Pearce)
World
Comments
See All Comments (17) | Post Comment
Apr 14, 2010 9:27am EDT
Homosexuals seem to have lots of friends in high places. Not exactly what you’d expect of a supposedly persecuted minority.
Mega
Report As Abusive
Apr 14, 2010 9:27am EDT
It’s worth noting that in every one of the church sex abuse cases, none of them involved pedophilia in the clinical, pathological sense. ALL pedophiles have certain specific characteristics in common, including that they have no gender preference, and that they are only involved in children under a certain age. All the victims identified so far have been adolescent boys, and all the abusers were, in fact, homosexual.
That may not excuse the priest’s equating homosexuality and pedophilia. But given that the context was the abuse scandal, and given that all of the cases of abuse so far involved homosexuality and not pedophilia, the linkage or lack thereof is probably irrelevant to the discussion.
tizzo
Report As Abusive
Apr 14, 2010 9:44am EDT
The plan to arrest the pope in the UK later this year is factual, and he ought to be arrested and incarcerated just like all the other sexual offenders whether priest or (pardon the pun) lay-man! Equating homosexuality and paedophilia is nothing short of insanity. Most paedophiles are heterosexual, and “tizzo”’s report above echoes exactly my stance. I am outraged at this new slap across our Gay Faces! The world’s gay community is outraged.
GayQuizzy
Report As Abusive
Apr 14, 2010 9:46am EDT
How many alter girls have you ever heard of? So no, it’s not “worth noting.” Priests sexually abusing young boys is obviously a crime of opportunity.
imjustsaying
Report As Abusive
Apr 14, 2010 10:15am EDT
Tags : Dig ; hole ; deeper .
bojimbo26
Report As Abusive
Apr 14, 2010 10:18am EDT
It baffles me that people are so stupid as to conclude that minority groups with socio-political support are somehow NOT being persecuted. What does “having friends in high places” even mean? Following that logic homosexuals would have equal marriage rights in the U.S. since as the first comments states, homosexuals are not persecuted. When will people realize that by calling the grant of equal rights to groups of people who currently don’t have them a grant of “special rights” is clear proof that gays and lesbians are not considered equal! It’s a red herring, and such circular logic and beliefs threaten all members society. As Orwell wrote, “some pigs are created more equal than others.”
soberinps
Report As Abusive
Apr 14, 2010 10:28am EDT
Some of these comments are as appalling as the Cardinal’s statement. The Cardinal is stubbornly misinformed. His attempt to argue that the priesthood has a lower percentage of homosexuals than the general populace, and that homosexuality causes or is linked with pedophilia is a transparent effort to justify the Church’s cover-ups and lack of action. Anyone with the slightest bit of learning, who is acquainted with just one homosexual, understands homosexuals are “born that way” and entirely different from pedophiles who are criminally, mentally ill. The Cardinal’s comments are just bigotry but not surprising-how much has the Church done to protect the human rights of homosexuals over the ages? As a heterosexual former Catholic who attended all male Catholic schools for 12 years, my experience is that the pedophiles were everywhere and no doubt were a higher percentage of priests than the general population. Anyone with half a brain can see that the priesthood, as presently constituted, is a magnet for pedophiles looking for access to children and the ability to control them. I would expect no different excuse though from a bunch of old guys who think that sexual activity is for procreation only, and who oppose contraceptives while doing little in a concrete way to help the world’s starving children. Anyway, one reason I left the Church is because I did not want my children to ever be alone in the company of some of the priests I have met. My children are now thinking adults who have no interest in what the Church is peddling.
John54
Report As Abusive
Apr 14, 2010 10:30am EDT
Once again the gay community becomes the scape goat for the catholic church.
I’d like to know what took the church so long in coming out with a statement like this? It was only a matter of time, and is anybody really surprised by it?
osito3
Report As Abusive
Apr 14, 2010 10:31am EDT
in the situation of the priest scandal, the issue is with priests that fit the definition as homosexual rather than, as stated earlier, the clinical definition of pedophilia. considering people in other areas of society who did not take a vow of celibacy have similar issues at a higher percentage (though not as well publicized), the only way celibacy plays a role is in some individuals inability to control themselves. the people who are claiming it presents a case for priests to marry do not understand the very legitimate theological and practical reasons not to change the church’s stance. i find it interesting that people want the pope to be arrested for a problem which he, in fact, worked to correct (according to the john jay college of criminal justice, abuse cases were dramatically reduced in 1981 when ratzinger took on the issue). don’t just rely on the headlines. the catholic community is outraged at the guilty priests and the poor job of the media to present the full truth of the situation.
anns82
Report As Abusive
See All Comments (17)
Add a Comment
*We welcome comments that advance the story directly or with relevant tangential information. We try to block comments that use offensive language or appear to be spam and review comments frequently to ensure they meet our standards. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters.
More from Reuters
Quake kills 400, schools cave in
BEIJING (Reuters) - A strong earthquake toppled hundreds of homes and some schools in the remote mountainous Tibetan Plateau of southwest China on Wednesday, killing at least 400 people and injuring thousands. | Video
Obama presses Iran, gains nuclear summit pledges
| Video
Red shirts take over "richest part" of Bangkok
U.S. says it is ready to help Kyrgyzstan's new rulers
| Video
Vatican under fire for linking gays to pedophilia
Michelle Obama meets Mexico's first lady in solo visit
» More Top News
China quake kills 400
A strong earthquake toppled homes and some schools in southwest China, leaving hundreds dead, thousands injured and many others trapped. Full Article | Video
Slideshow: Scenes from Yushu
Your View: Send us your pictures
Natural Disasters
Crossing the line on taxes
How aggressive do you get on your annual income tax returns? The collateral damage that follows a questionable filing could steamroll over you. Full Article
Can't pay your taxes? Don't worry
Rules of the tax audit game
Richest Virginians get biggest tax cuts
Small Business
© Copyright 2010 Thomson Reuters
Editorial Editions:
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
United States
Reuters
Contact Us
Advertise With Us
Help
Journalism Handbook
Archive
Site Index
Video Index
Analyst Research
Mobile
Newsletters
RSS
Podcasts
Widgets
Your View
Labs
Thomson Reuters
Copyright
Disclaimer
Privacy
Professional Products
Professional Products Support
Financial Products
About Thomson Reuters
Careers
Online Products
Acquisitions Monthly
Buyouts
Venture Capital Journal
International Financing Review
Project Finance International
PEhub.com
PE Week
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
Other News on Wednesday, 14 April 2010 Sudan elections show up deep divides
Juncker 'reassured' by markets over EU Greek bailout
Facebook rolls out redesigned 'safety center'
Sudan vote errors hit turnout
Poles pay tribute as first couple lie in state
US-TECH Summary
Demjanjuk rejects Nazi camp murder accusations
|
Poles pay tribute as first couple lie in state
US trade deficit widens in February
Brazil rancher convicted in U.S. nun's murder
|
Karadzic war crimes trial witness details horrors
|
Growth, cheap smartphones key in handset market
Afghans demand compensation for German raid
|
Michelle Obama in surprise visit to Haiti
Brazilian rancher jailed for US nun's 2005 murder
China says sanctions 'cannot solve' Iran nuclear issue
Venezuelan website lampoons Latin American leaders
18-year-old Afghan woman slain in campaign of fear
Twitter could act as early warning system for epidemics: experts
In message to North, S.Korea to hold nuclear summit
Twitter unveils ad plan in profit push
Kyrgyz interim leader tells AP US base will stay
Palm approached Huawei for acquisition talks
Apple updates MacBook Pro
|
Pakistani airstrike kills many civilians: official
Pakistan airstrike kills many civilians: witnesses
New York Times leads pack of Webby nominees
|
Apple updates MacBook Pro laptop line
Kyrgyzstan interim leader says US base will stay
Web browser that bypasses big brother a Kazakh hit
|
Pohang, Adelaide, Osaka advance in AFC Champions League
Oracle boosts MySQL investment, targets Microsoft
Hachette says its books among top iPad downloads
List of possible Palm suitors grows, led by Asians
|
2-mile scar on Barrier Reef after ship grounding
Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet in Twitter twist
|
Apple updates MacBook Pro laptop line
World's second-tallest building under construction in Saudi
Spanking children can lead to aggressive behavior: study
Bille August to direct film on 'Out of Africa' author Karen Blixen
German cinema pioneer Schroeter dead at 65: museum
Japanese friend for Thomas The Tank Engine
Indian Sikhs mark 'World Turban Day'
Conan mocks NBC on first stop of comedy tour
Thai protesters hit tourist hub with guns -- of water
Cyprus tourist arrivals rise in March in 15-month first
Conan O'Brien legally prohibited from being funny
|
Christian music star Jennifer Knapp says she is a lesbian
|
New York Times leads pack of Webby nominees
|
Lionel Shriver novel counts cost of healthcare
|
US consumer magazine calls Lexus model a 'safety risk'
Worst over for loss-making Air India: minister
Infosys quarterly profit dips but sees upturn
South Korea to host nuclear summit in 2012 -Obama
China Southern swings back to profit for 2009
ADB says Bangladesh grows by 5.5 percent in 2010
China eases home grown tech purchase rule
China's Hu rebuffs Obama on yuan
Pakistan's anti-Taliban push proves divisive
Greece bailout 'up to 90 billion euros': report
Strong quake kills 300; destroys homes on Tibet plateau
|
Intel net profit up nearly four-fold
Obama voices frustration on stalled Mideast peace
Thai protesters on move to final battleground
|
Mexico Catholic Church seeks child sex abuse pardon
Gates assails Internet group over attack video
Juncker 'reassured' by markets over EU Greek bailout
Corrected: Twitter chases first revenue with ad service
Sudan vote errors hit turnout
Clinton, Taiana Sign Megaports Initiative To Guard Against Nuke Smuggling
"South Park" Re-Skewers Celebs For 200th Episode
Web browser that bypasses big brother a Kazakh hit
Intel Posts Huge Jump In Q1 Earnings, Tops Estimates
Top U.S. envoy in Kyrgyzstan for talks after revolt
|
U.S. Markets Post Modest Gains Ahead Of Earnings
Apple updates MacBook Pro laptops
Iran complains to U.N. over U.S. nuclear threat
|
Union Leader's Planned Resignation Would Shift Balance of Labor's Power
Cargo aircraft crashes in northern Mexico; 5 dead
|
Girl Fashions Prom Dress From Gum Wrappers
Apple updates MacBook Pro
Pilots hailed as heroes for averting Hong Kong air disaster
|
Avon Suspends 4 Executives In Chinese Unit Ethics Probe
President, First Lady To Attend Funeral In Poland
Chavez rallies armed youths to defend socialism
|
Adam Lambert Releases Remix EP, Talks Tour Plans
Obama voices frustration on stalled Mideast peace
|
Recovery Of Bodies Completed At West Virginia Mine
Michelle Obama visits Mexico on first solo outing
Michelle Obama arrives in Mexico
About 300 dead in China quake
Russia calls for swift WTO entry
Pakistan uses scanners to locate truck bombs
Cyclone kills 31 people in eastern India
Hong Kong proposes limited political reform
Millions of women, infant deaths easily avoidable: study
Malaysia's Anwar loses bid to discredit accuser
Cyclone kills 29 people in eastern India
Pakistan delays LNG contract with French company
Venezuelan website lampoons Latin American leaders
|
Opposition bigwig to contest special Malaysia poll
Moody's raises South Korea sovereign rating to A1
Strong quake in western China's Qinghai kills 300
China raises fuel prices as economy steams ahead
Seoul shares extend gains on Moody's upgrade
Thai protesters on move to "final battleground"
CORRECTED
2 drown in river during Hindu festival in India
China raises domestic fuel prices
China's property prices rise in March
Korean Air says sales up but delays profit report
Wal-Mart plans India 'big box' store drive
Hollywood veteran launches dream with "Sex Tax"
Safety issue prompts new Toyota sales suspension
British hero returns to Korea 59 years after battle
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Aiden Turner exits "Dancing With Stars"
Chocolate makers show off Syria's sweeter side
Hollywood veteran launches dream with "Sex Tax"
Aiden Turner exits U.S. dancing show
|
Shrek photo spread too saucy for studios
Shrek photo spread too saucy for studios
|
Booming TV formats go global in risky times
Pop duo MGMT defies critics on Congratulations
|
Scott, James Cann go head-to-head in "Mercy"
Does anybody own Fellini's La Dolce Vita?
|
HBO renews "Treme" after first episode
British Atheists Seek Arrest Of Pope Over Sex Abuse Scandal
Scott, James Cann go head-to-head in Mercy
|
Parents Of Adult Skaters Receive Letters From Police
Irving Penn photos to be auctioned at Christie's
Hollywood veteran launches dream with Sex Tax
|
U.K. Study Proposes Use Of Slop Buckets In Offices To Improve Recycling
Public Image Ltd, returns to U.S. after 18 years
|
Planet Circling "Cold" Star Is Earths Newest Neighbor
Book to reveal unheard Jackie Kennedy interviews
|
HBO renews Treme after first episode
|
Virginia Boy, 12, Arrested For Bringing Gun To School
Irving Penn photos to be auctioned at Christie's
|
"Dirty Dozen" Member Dies
Colorado Sheriff's Deputy Tazes 30 Students; Gets Suspended
Three Senior Citizens Arrested For Attempted Burglary Of Ex-Mob Boss Home
Two Fighter Jets In Near-Collision With Commercial Airliner Over Ohio
British Women Spend Close To Decade Shopping
Holocaust-denying bishop 'to miss German trial'
Apple delays worldwide release of iPad for a month
Greece hit by new debt doubts, string of strikes
Vatican under fire for linking gays to pedophilia
|
UAE Movie Studio Sets Up Shop in Las Vegas
Iraqi Shi'ite blocs inch toward power-sharing deal
|
FDA Phasing Out Asthma, COPD Inhalers Containing CFCs
Justin Bieber, Lady Gaga, Carrie Underwood Headline "Today Show" Summer Concert Series
Palestinians accuse Jewish settlers of mosque attack
|
Police Investigate Chicago Shooting That Left 4 Dead
Poland eyes June 20 vote, post-crash cracks emerge
|
Weight-Loss Surgery May Reduce Pregnancy Risks In Obese Women
Tonight Show Finds Replacement For Band Leader Kevin Eubanks
Florida Democrat Wins First Congressional Election After Healthcare Vote
Protest over Islamic tomb turns violent in Jakarta
|
Britney Spears Releases Unedited Shots From Ad Campaign
Bashir's party asks rivals to join Sudan government
|
Study: Epilepsy And Depression Drugs Linked To Suicide Risk
"South Park" To Premiere 200th Episode
Thai protesters step up anti-government rally
Cyclone kills 85 people in eastern India
Quake in western China kills 400, buries more
Chinese official sentenced to death in mafia trial
Cyclone kills 76 people in eastern India
Apple delays iPad's international launch
|
Shippers: China sending gasoline to Iran
Former China police chief gets death in gang case
Pakistani stocks end up; rupee eases; o/n rates down
Chinese officials: Foreign investors face problems
Dollar falls against euro before US data
Starbucks planning huge expansion in China
Thais rally in Bangkok to oppose Red Shirts
China raises fuel prices as economy steams ahead
Cyclone kills 68 people in eastern India
CSBC seeks shipbuilding order from Taiwan's Evergreen
China defends business environment
China's Agricultural Bank prefers local investor
US base in Japan bans dolphin film: report
News agencies snub Cannes conference over TV dispute
Joss Whedon directing "Avengers" for Marvel
Does anybody own Fellini's "La Dolce Vita"?
"District 9" star in talks for another alien film
Whitney Houston returns to stage, critics divided
Taiwan turns plastic bottles into expo pavilion
Stirrings of less violent protest in Hamas-ruled Gaza
Whitney Houston returns to stage, critics divided
|
Tomb protest turns bloody in Indonesia capital
Indonesia police fire tear gas at protesters
Indonesia detains 30 migrants headed to Australia
News agencies boycott Cannes briefing over access
|
Joss Whedon directing Avengers for Marvel
|
Scrappy fighter Kick-Ass high on Hollywood radar
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights