Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
TiVo win set aside by appeals court; shares drop
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
TiVo win set aside by appeals court; shares drop
Reuters - Saturday, May 15
Send
IM Story
Print
A screen shows Internet services available through an broadband-connected TiVo digital video recorder at the Consumer Electronics Show in Las Vegas, Nevada January 5, 2006. REUTERS/Steve Marcus
Slideshow: Full Photo Coverage: Internet Portals & Search Engines
By Diane Bartz and Franklin Paul
WASHINGTON/NEW YORK - Shares of TiVo fell as much as 42 percent on Friday after an appeals court set aside the company's win in a patent battle over digital video recorders with rivals Dish and EchoStar.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit said the entire court would reconsider its own March 4 decision made by three judges. The larger panel would likely be about 10 judges.
The Federal Circuit had affirmed a contempt finding against EchoStar and Dish in their long-running patent fight with TiVo, which makes digital video recorders.
The original case focused on TiVo's "Time Warp" software, which allowed users to record one television program while watching another.
The ruling further delays resolution of a case seen as critical to TiVo's plans to reap the financial benefits of its software patents.
Dish and EchoStar, its former parent until a spinoff in 2008, had changed their technology during the infringement fight, but TiVo said, and the court had agreed, that the devices still used TiVo technology.
TiVo's shares closed down 41.58 percent at $10.16 on Nasdaq. Dish closed up 4.28 percent at $22.90. EchoStar, whose liability in the case is limited to $5 million, closed down 0.1 percent at $20.45.
Friday's decline removes all of the premium the shares gained after the March 4 ruling: it closed at $10.21 on March 3. At its current price of $10.30, TiVo shares are up only about 2 percent so far this year.
"It is a stumbling block," Hudson Square Research analyst Dan Ernst said. "It does reduce the probability of TiVo receiving ongoing fees. If there is an agreement ever to be had, it is likely pushed out some time. "
TiVo also has lawsuits against AT&T Inc, Verizon Communications Inc and Microsoft Corp.
"We are disappointed that we do not yet have finality in this case despite years of litigation but we remain confident that the Federal Circuit's ruling in our favor will be reaffirmed," TiVo said in a statement.
Jeff Blum, a senior vice president at Dish, said that the company had made major changes in its DVRs.
"We spent a year designing around the patent," he said. "It took a year for us to test it, 8,000 total man hours, 15 engineers. It was in good faith."
Companies often change their products because of accusations of patent infringement, and patent-holders often say the workarounds are inadequate.
"The court will consider how to determine infringement of design-around products," said John Whealan, who teaches patent law at George Washington University Law School.
The two choices are a contempt hearing and a new lawsuit. "There are implications for sanctions and different sets of damages," he said.
The case was originally filed in the U.S. District Court for Eastern Texas. That court imposed contempt sanctions against sister companies Dish and EchoStar for violating a court-ordered permanent injunction to stop making and selling DVRs.
TiVo had sued EchoStar back in 2004, and a jury found that its DVR technology infringed TiVo patents. TiVo had also been awarded $300 million in damages and contempt sanctions as of July 1, 2009.
TiVo was a pioneer in DVRs, but its growth cooled as cable and satellite operators began offering generic DVRs for less than the cost of a TiVo box, and more programing became available on the Internet.
Lazard Capital Markets analyst Barton Crockett called the ruling "surprising" and downgraded the stock to "hold" from "buy", suggesting there was "a meaningful chance" that the full panel would overturn the decision that Dish was in contempt.
"This would put TiVo back to square one with trying to prove that Dish's workaround violates TiVo's patents," he said in a note to clients.
The case is TiVo Inc vs EchoStar Corporation, Case No. 2009-1374, United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
US-TECH Summary Reuters - Saturday, May 15
Ruling could have chilling effect on P2P services Reuters - Saturday, May 15
Google says mistakenly got wireless data Reuters - Saturday, May 15
Beer, betrayal, a lost iPhone in Apple device tale Reuters - Saturday, May 15
TiVo win set aside by appeals court; shares drop Reuters - Saturday, May 15
News Search
Top Stories
Portugal takes more austerity measures
EU's Barroso calls on G20 to agree bank levy
Portugal announces more austerity measures
Boy survivor of Libya air crash 'stable but confused'
Asia steps into Cannes spotlight
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Boy survivor of Libya air crash 'stable but confused'
Scientists stunned as grey whale sighted off Israel
Pope rallies priests as crowds flock to Fatima
Asia steps into Cannes spotlight
Portugal announces more austerity measures
More Most Viewed »
Scientists stunned as grey whale sighted off Israel
Aliens may exist but contact would hurt: Hawking
Lack of sleep linked to early death: study
UN fears 'irreversible' damage to natural environment
Freddie Mac asks for fresh 10.6 billion dollar bailout
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
World Cup 2010
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Saturday, 15 May 2010 Jewish settlers shoot dead Palestinian youth
US-TECH Summary
Bombers attack soccer game in north Iraq, 8 dead
Jewish settlers shoot dead Palestinian youth: police
|
Portugal takes more austerity measures
Google to stop selling smartphone on the Web
Iraq election recount found no signs of fraud
Former UK minister stabbed at his office
|
Russia to sell Syria warplanes, air defence systems
Libya crash boy's family blog becomes a memorial
Iran frees Iraqi soldier in border incident
|
TiVo win set aside by appeals court; shares drop
Five dead in clash with South Sudan rebel general: army
|
Algeria earthquake kills two: report
|
Cuban court throws out jail sentence for dissident
|
Thai troops battle protesters as crisis deepens
Big Afghan offensive must overcome deadly terrain
Clashes in Kyrgyzstan kill 1, injure more than 60
Timeline of events in Thailand's political crisis
Thai troops, protesters clash in capital; 8 killed
China school attacks highlight mental health
Google to stop selling smartphone on the Web
|
Crisis looms in Nepal as political divide sharpens
Protesters say NATO attack killed Afghan civilians
Suspected rebels kill 1 police officer in India
Libya crash boy's family blog becomes a memorial
|
Violence surges in Indian Kashmir after decline
Google proposes remedies in Italy antitrust case
|
Hauppauge soars on TV streaming app for iPad, iPhone
|
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Tokio Hotel guitarist falls ill after taking Viagra
Police uncover plot to kill Indonesia's president
NBC cancels long-running crime show "Law & Order"
Russell Crowe snaps over Irish Robin Hood accent
|
NBC cancels long-running crime show Law & Order
|
Tokio Hotel guitarist falls ill after taking Viagra
|
Five dead in clash with South Sudan rebel general
Russia to sell Syria warplanes, air defence systems
Fighting spreads in Thai capital, 16 dead
|
Ruling could have chilling effect on P2P services
Iran frees Iraqi soldier in border incident
Google says mistakenly got wireless data
Clinton says Lula faces uphill climb in Iran
Beer, betrayal, a lost iPhone in Apple device tale
Chinese man sentenced to death for school stabbing
|
TiVo win set aside by appeals court; shares drop
Nigeria president pledges better security in delta
|
Hauppauge soars on TV streaming app for iPad, iPhone
Middle Eastern Money Transfer System Investigated in Times Square Bomb Case
Chavez orders money changer raids for currency crash
|
Google proposes remedies in Italy antitrust case
U.S. Markets Fall On Friday, But Finish Week Higher
IMF board okays $1.13 billion in aid for Pakistan
|
China Foxconn worker falls to death, seventh this year
|
Study: Hispanic High School Dropouts Lag Behind In Getting GED
Consumer Sentiment Rises Less Than Expected In May
Federal Raid On NY Drug Gangs Nets Dozens
Former Football Star Forbidden From Prom
Fort Lauderdale Police Officer Arrested With Drugs In Patrol Car
J.C. Penney Q1 Profit More Than Doubles
New Album Details Revealed For Kylie Minogue's New Album "Aphrodite"
Mother, Stepdad Of Slain Boy To Be Charged In Utah
Teacher apologizes for recorded beating of student
5 private security guards die in Afghanistan
Australian teen completes round-the-world sail
Beer, betrayal, a lost iPhone in Apple device tale
|
Clashes, blasts for 3rd day in besieged Bangkok
Weather forecast for the Asia-Pacific region
Google says mistakenly got wireless data
|
HK democracy activists make final appeal for votes
New Bangkok street clashes after 16 killed
Big Afghan offensive must overcome deadly terrain
Bangkok battles: 16 dead in clashes, explosions
IMF board okays $1.13 billion in aid for Pakistan
IMF board okays $1.13 billion in aid for Pakistan
Nashville pulls together to weather the storm
Fund-raising sites offer new options to musicians
Hit show "Glee" spreads the joy with stage tour
Rolling Stones revisit their days in Exile
|
Minimalist drama "Here and There" right on target
English actress accuses Polanski of abuse in 1980s
|
Billboard singles reviews: Eminem, Ozzy Osbourne
Wall Street a powerfully told sequel
|
NBC cancels "Heroes," "Mercy" and "Trauma"
Bret Michaels announces May 28 comeback gig
Billboard singles reviews: Eminem, Ozzy Osbourne
|
Gene Simmons says KISS costume prevents "grinding"
Hit show Glee spreads the joy with stage tour
|
"Wall Street" a powerfully told sequel
Minimalist drama Here and There right on target
|
Gene Simmons says KISS costume prevents grinding
|
NBC cancels Heroes, Mercy and Trauma
|
Sudan army says killed 108 Darfur rebels
Sudan army says killed 108 Darfur rebels
|
UK airspace may close due to volcanic ash
|
Sole Libya crash survivor returns home to Netherlands
|
Atlantis Takes Off In Last Of 3 Missions
Gaza rally raises Palestinian reconciliation hopes
|
87-Year-Old Woman Arrested For Selling Crack
UK PM Cameron has talks with Afghan leader Karzai
|
US Chamber Of Commerce Chief Blasts Arizona Law, Urges More H1B1 Visa
Bulgarian National In Mulit-million Dollar Money Laundering Scheme
Iran says conditions right for nuclear fuel deal
|
Greece pledges corruption clean-up of politicians
|
Ship sinking overshadows East Asia meeting
|
AP-GfK Poll flashes mixed signals for parties
At least 30 militants dead in Afghan, NATO raids
Univision forum held on Arizona's immigration law
China court sentences to death school attacker
Suspected militants kidnap 60 in NW Pakistan
Militants kidnap about 60 in Pakistan tribal area
Ship sinking overshadows start of East Asia meeting
Medical worker shot, feared killed in Bangkok clash
Clashes, blasts for 3rd day in besieged Bangkok
Indian state to airlift supplies amid blockade
Ruling could have chilling effect on P2P services
|
2 suspects still at large in Indonesia terror plot
British director Leigh's Another Year at Cannes
|
Fund-raising sites offer new options to musicians
|
Nashville pulls together to weather the storm
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights