Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
New U.S. commander pushes faltering Afghan war effort
|
Edition:
U.S.
Article
Comments (3)
Save
Email
Print
Reprints
Most Popular
Most Shared
UPDATE 1-Obama pushes immigration reform, seeks broad support
01 Jul 2010
Analysis: Google's private data grab means big legal trouble
01 Jul 2010
Google to buy travel software co ITA for $700 million
8:55am EDT
Singer murdered after denying he was dead
29 Jun 2010
Weak private hiring shows tepid recovery
11:19am EDT
Special Report: Should BP nuke its leaking well?
11:22am EDT
"Last Airbender" another failure for Shyamalan
30 Jun 2010
Wall Street edges lower on payrolls and technicals
| Video
11:36am EDT
WRAPUP 7-Oil invades more wetlands as surf pounds Gulf coast
01 Jul 2010
Total sees tougher rules as storm spreads Gulf slick
| Video
11:26am EDT
UPDATE 1-Obama pushes immigration reform, seeks broad support
01 Jul 2010
Special Report: Should BP nuke its leaking well?
11:22am EDT
Google to buy travel software co ITA for $700 million
8:55am EDT
Consumers sue Apple over iPhone antenna problems
01 Jul 2010
Scrap dollar as sole reserve currency: U.N. report
29 Jun 2010
Weak private hiring shows tepid recovery
11:19am EDT
Singer murdered after denying he was dead
29 Jun 2010
Gene pattern predicts who will live the longest
01 Jul 2010
Fructose intake may increase blood pressure risk
01 Jul 2010
Too much fructose could raise your blood pressure
01 Jul 2010
New U.S. commander pushes faltering Afghan war effort
Digg This
Tweet This
Share on LinkedIn
Share on Facebook
Related Topics
World »
U.S. General David Petraeus, newly appointed U.S. and NATO forces commander in Afghanistan, answers questions during a joint news conference with NATO Secretary General Anders Fogh Rasmussen (unseen) at the Alliance headquarters in Brussels July 1, 2010.
Credit: Reuters/Thierry Roge
By David Fox
KABUL |
Fri Jul 2, 2010 11:44am EDT
KABUL (Reuters) - The United States' top field commander arrived in Afghanistan on Friday to take charge of the faltering war, pledging to tackle the nine-year-old Taliban insurgency with a strategy he successfully pioneered in Iraq.
General David Petraeus landed a day after his appointment was confirmed by the U.S. Senate and just hours after the U.S. House of Representatives approved $33 billion in funding for a troop surge he hopes will turn the tide of the war.
An amendment demanding an exit timetable from Afghanistan failed, but got 162 votes -- the biggest anti-war vote in the House on Afghanistan to date.
Petraeus's appointment could be a last throw of the dice for Washington to end an increasingly costly conflict that is draining Western budgets as they emerge from one of the worst global recessions in history.
A formal change-of-command ceremony will be held on Sunday.
The surge will bring to 150,000 the number of foreign troops in Afghanistan just as the new strategy takes root. It entails tackling the Taliban in their strongholds while relying on the government to simultaneously improve local governance and development.
The Taliban showed on Friday just how capable they are of operating outside their traditional strongholds by launching a daring commando-style raid on the office of an American company that provides logistical support for U.S. government aid in relatively peaceful Kunduz, in the north.
A Briton, German, Filipino and two Afghans were killed in the pre-dawn attack, provincial officials said, as well as the six insurgents who mounted the raid.
Also on Friday, the NATO-led International Security Assistance Force (ISAF) that Petraeus now commands said two service members had died after separate insurgent attacks in the south and east.
TURN THE TIDE
Petraeus, who wrote the U.S. army's field guide on waging a counter-insurgency, used the tactics to help turn the tide of the Iraq war and the strategy was introduced to Afghanistan earlier this year by former commander General Stanley McChrystal.
McChrystal was sacked last week after he and some aides disparaged senior administration officials in a magazine profile.
While Petraeus has pledged to continue with the same strategy, he told NATO chiefs in Brussels on Thursday that some operational tactics would be reviewed -- including air strikes on suspected Taliban hideouts.
The issue came to a head last year after a series of air attacks killed scores of civilians -- including 140 in one incident -- but McChrystal's arrival was credited with vastly reducing collateral damage.
Petraeus said on Thursday that any tactics that raised the possibility of more soldiers being killed needed to be reviewed.
More than 1,800 foreign troops have died in Afghanistan since the Taliban were overthrown in 2001 -- including more than 100 last month, the bloodiest since the war began.
"I have a moral imperative as a commander ... to bring all force that is available when our troopers -- and, by the way, our Afghan partners -- are in a tough position," he told NATO chiefs.
The last two weeks have thrown an especially harsh light on the war effort, with new reports of corruption in President Hamid Karzai's government and the change in command of foreign forces.
Doubts have also been raised over the commitment of the government to push governance and development alongside the military drive, and also the ability of Afghan forces to take over responsibility for security.
At the same time, Karzai has been wooing the Taliban with a series of modest peace overtures, all have which have been rejected by the hardline Islamist movement, which insists all foreign forces must leave before they will end the insurgency.
(Additional reporting by Susan Cornwell in Washington; Editing by Nick Macfie)
World
Comments
See All Comments (3) | Post Comment
Jul 02, 2010 10:28am EDT
The counterinsurgency manual, if followed, won’t work in this situation primarily for three basic reasons:
(1) The military did not implement its entire COIN strategy as outlined in the Army field manual because the CIA implemented their own tactics as the first force in-country to direct operations against the Taliban and al Qaeda. Even when the military took over from the CIA, there wasn’t enough time to implement actions as defined in the counterinsurgency bible.
(2) With no Afghanistan infrastructure at the start of the war, there has been no foundation for us to build on. The Afghanistan political and security apparatus in place now is weak at best and ripe for collapse through force and corruption (and drawdown of U.S./allied forces).
(3) The military is ill-equipped to handle most aspects of infrastructure development because it is not their mission.
There is no U.S. group that fully trains in rebuilding (or in this case, building) a country’s infrastructure. Simply installing someone and making them accountable in an Afghanistan (or Somalia) environment doesn’t work – too many conflicting forces; a federal and local government that is rag-tag at best with no respect or support from the outlying communities; too few solid levels of any type of public works or services to rely on; U.S. and allied forces spread too thin and with a tactical mission that isn’t prioritized to provide local/regional security for infrastructure; emergency services that are 19th century; and an insurgent base which is heavily supported by other regional states (read Pakistan) – a composition for failure.
A good dictate would be to follow the Powell (Weinberger) Doctrine and stick to it.
A subsequent dictate would be to “hit and run” in the type of chaotic environment such as Somalia and Afghanistan and stick to it.
A third option, if necessary, would be to create some form of Unified Command (StructCom is a good start for a name) comprised of the Defense Department, State Department, and other U.S. Departments AND a new group of entities solely related to national and local level infrastructure and services in a pre- or post-war environment (public works, power, gas, police, fire, ambulance, schools, transportation, water, stores/supplies, government, etc). The new group can be pulled from expertise from U.S. federal, state and local infrastructure groups and other disaster-relief organizations. It needs to be developed properly and with wisdom AND no politics – drawing from lessons learned in Haiti, Somalia, Afghanistan, Iraq and from the many disaster-relief efforts in which we have participated.
To fund a new infrastructure-related Unified Command, we could start by dumping the Department of Homeland Security which is a huge waste of red tape and layered bureaucracy for capabilities that already exist.
After our departure from Afghanistan, the country will either go three ways – a weak democracy that will need years of support to build into a viable nation; a stronghold dictatorship; or an Islamic-extremist shell of a country returning to pre-war status.
Let’s hope for the best and get it right if we have to do this again.
finneganG
Report As Abusive
Jul 02, 2010 11:26am EDT
Nothing will ever work until Washington, DC quits “micro-managing” everything. The “softies” making all the money & spending all of the citizens money as rapidly as they can need to leave war to those who KNOW how to run it.
Dhuebdhue
Report As Abusive
Jul 02, 2010 11:28am EDT
Beware the Orwellian mindwarp of the forever Af/Pak War. Don’t be fooled.
Irwinrsteffy
Report As Abusive
See All Comments (3)
Add a Comment
*We welcome comments that advance the story directly or with relevant tangential information. We try to block comments that use offensive language or appear to be spam and review comments frequently to ensure they meet our standards. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters.
© Copyright 2010 Thomson Reuters
Editorial Editions:
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
United States
Reuters
Contact Us
Advertise With Us
Help
Journalism Handbook
Archive
Site Index
Video Index
Reader Feedback
Analyst Research
Mobile
Newsletters
RSS
Podcasts
Widgets
Your View
Labs
Thomson Reuters
Copyright
Disclaimer
Privacy
Professional Products
Professional Products Support
Financial Products
About Thomson Reuters
Careers
Online Products
Acquisitions Monthly
Buyouts
Venture Capital Journal
International Financing Review
Project Finance International
PEhub.com
PE Week
FindLaw
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
Other News on Friday, 2 July 2010 Netanyahu says Israel ready to deal for Shalit release
Who's right
Iran tells UN it is 'more determined' on nuclear drive
US-TECH Summary
Russia spy scandal '11th man' vanishes in Cyprus
India's Reliance Communications to acquire Digicable
Secret tapes scandal halts L'Oreal fraud trial
At least 35 dead in suicide bombings in Pakistan
|
Amazon again cuts Kindle price as iPad raises heat
ECB auctions soothe bank fears ahead of key stress tests
NATO says district Afghan Taliban chief arrested
As world first, Finland makes broadband service basic right
Greek unions set anti-austerity strike for July 8
|
Amazon cuts price of large-screen Kindle
Woman Dies After Portable Toilet Crashes Through Car Windshield
Serena sees off challenge to reach Wimbledon final
iPhone 4 Antenna Complaints Lead To Lawsuit For Apple
Microsoft killing its 'Kin' social network phone
Adam Brody, Marley Shelton Added To "Scream 4" Cast
Lady Gaga leads race to get 10 million on Facebook
Sex.com domain name on sale
Ford, GM Sales Come In Shy Of Estimates
Toyota warns of engine defect in 270,000 cars
Katy Perry Beats Out Eminem, Rihanna For Fourth Week At #1 On Billboard Hot 100
Drug hitmen kill Mexican official ahead of vote
|
U.S. Pending Homes Sales Tumble In May
U.N. starts distributing flotilla aid in Gaza Strip
|
Gunmen kill senior Yemen intelligence officer
|
Venezuela fights illegal gold camps deep in jungle
|
Cyprus issues warrant for Russian spy suspect
Japanese footballers return home
SKorea president discusses economic, trade ties in Mexico
Appeal against Taiwan ex-president's sentence reduction
Uighur leader appeals to world year after unrest
Consumers sue Apple over iPhone antenna problems
|
China says it welcomes visit by US defence secretary
Meryl Streep eyeing Margaret Thatcher biopic: report
Tens of thousands march for democracy in Hong Kong
India central bank warns on global double-dip recession
U.S. government slowly adopting Web-based computing
|
Myanmar democracy activists row over hat symbol
Taiwan president says China has political aims with pact
Strike shuts down Japanese electronics factory in China
China's Xinhua launches English news channel
India's exports surge 35% in May
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Etisalat seeks PakTel deal discount
Meryl Streep in talks to play Margaret Thatcher
Google strengthens benefits for gay or lesbian workers
Meryl Streep eyeing Margaret Thatcher biopic: report
"Eclipse" enjoys record Wednesday at box offices
Denmark music festival commemorates fatal crush
Orange fever grips Netherlands prior to Brazil clash
Catalonian parliament rejects burqa ban
Saatchi gives modern art collection to Britain
Brain freezer in Russia claims secret of eternal life
Eclipse enjoys record Wednesday at box offices
|
A Minute With: Dev Patel from Slumdog to Airbender
|
Rapper Drake postpones European leg of tour
|
3 dead as Taliban attack US aid group in Afghanistan
Russia spy suspect confessed: US prosecutor
US aid office under attack in Afghanistan
S.Korean jailed for killing mother over gaming addiction
Obama signs toughest-ever US sanctions on Iran
US videogame sales slip in May: NPD
Obama says new U.S. sanctions on Iran toughest ever
USAID compound attacked in Afghanistan; 4 killed
U.S. video game sales down 5 percent in May
New Mel Gibson Recording Reveals Racist, Misogynistic Comments
USAID compound attacked in Afghanistan; 2 killed
Katy Perry Beats Out Eminem, Rihanna For Fourth Week At #1 On Billboard Hot 100
US recovery faces litmus test
Afghan governor: Suicide attackers strike Kunduz
Eminem Debuts At #1 With "Recovery" On Billboard Albums Chart
Newsmax out of Newsweek bidding, deadline for bids expires
Drug hitmen kill Mexican official ahead of vote
|
Turkey and Israel hold talks on mending fences
Turkey and Israel hold talks on mending fences
|
From boy to man: Cuba's Elian gives thanks 10 years later
Abbas voices frustration over Israel peace talks
Disney buys iPhone game maker Tapulous
Afghan Hindus and Sikhs grapple with uncertain future
|
Google buying travel software firm for 700 million dollars
U.S. House approves money for Afghan surge
Hillary Clinton arrives in Ukraine
BP boss takes spill questions in open Internet event
U.S. House approves money for Afghan troop surge
Hillary Clinton's Ukraine trip to balance tilt to Moscow
One suspect released, 9 held in Russian spy case
IBM endorses Firefox as in-house Web browser
Microsoft banishes battery bungling
Source: Chelsea Clinton to marry in upstate NY
Disney buys iPhone game maker Tapulous
|
Australia backs down in tax row with miners
Dell agrees to buy software company Scalent
|
Jennifer Lopez To Join Taio Cruz For Remix, Music Video
Australian priest jailed for 'sadistic' child abuse
Suicide bombers kill 42 in Pakistan shrine attack
Casket Of First Michigan Governor Lost And Found
Widespread Support For Immigration Reform Initiative Of President Obama
Obama Readies For Immigration Reform, Calls For Bipartisan Support
U.S. video game sales down 5 percent in May
Hit Malaysian TV talent show stars Muslim scholars
Police explain reasons for reopening Gore case
California Assembly Approves $20 Million Settlement For Kidnap Victim And Daughters
Miami Authorities Make Arrests In Hotel Shooting of Russian Tourist
Prosecutors: US network ready to aid spy ring
Philippines leader sets example, gets stuck in traffic
Mortgage Rates Fall To New Record Low
Russian Spy Ring Appears in Court as Evidence Mounts Against Them
40,000 cameras keep watch on China's Urumqi
South Korean coach quits over cyber attacks
Global Weather-Celsius
Bollywood's Aamir Khan bites back with satire
Tibetans adapted to altitude in under 3,000 years: study
'Private armies' hold Philippine politics at gunpoint
Art show examines India's World Cup absence
Reading sessions help Haiti children through quake trauma
Ecstasy a growing rave in Lebanon drug market
Toshiba to make batteries for electric vehicles
Women's Lilith tour drops 10 dates amid poor sales
Seoul shares dip on econ worries, foreign selling
Andrew Garfield is new 'Spider-Man': studio
UK-raised theater actor nabs "Spider-Man" role
S.Korea econ planners revive early rate rise view
Macau gaming revenue down due to World Cup
Rail route to Peru's Machu Picchu reopens
Bank of China to issue 60 billion yuan in new shares
Katy Perry and Eminem lead U.S. singles chart
PAKISTAN
JAL asks creditors for further debt waiver
PREVIEW-Taiwan June CPI seen up 0.89 pct y/y
Toyota to recall 270,000 cars over engine fault
Eclipse enjoys record Wednesday at box offices
|
Mourners bid farewell to popular SKorean actor
Samsung Heavy wins $1.7 billion shipbuilding deals
Mel Gibson uses racial slur: report
|
UK-raised theater actor nabs Spider-Man role
|
Women's Lilith tour drops 10 dates amid poor sales
|
Katy Perry and Eminem lead U.S. singles chart
|
Kelsey Grammer and third wife divorcing
|
Book about North Korean wins UK non-fiction award
|
Jordan nuclear deal held up by U.S. curbs
Reclusive top mathematician turns down prize, again
Undersea cable set to boost West Africa broadband
Gaza gets chocolate but no cement as embargo eases
New U.S. commander pushes faltering Afghan war effort
|
Google to buy travel software co ITA for $700 million
German car sales plunge in June, exports climb
Turkish jets bomb Kurdish rebel targets in Iraq
Japanese not keen to go four-eyed for 3D TV: survey
Pakistan under pressure to act after Lahore violence
|
Fence-mending on agenda for Obama-Netanyahu talks
Hawaii's Landmark Shark Fin Ban Takes Effect
Turk airstrike hits Kurd rebel targets in Iraq
France to look at possible U.S. sub link to sinking
|
Iran frees Nobel winner Ebadi's aide: website
Trent Reznor To Score Facebook Movie
Bill To Tighten Cruise Ship Security Awaits Obama
USAID compound attacked in Afghanistan; 4 killed
Fence-mending on agenda for Obama-Netanyahu talks
|
Budget-less, Schwarzenegger Orders Minimum Wage For State Workers
Chelsea Clinton To Wed In New York This Month
Kurd conflict comes back to haunt Turkey before polls
|
Sony Names Andrew Garfield As The Next "Spider-Man"
California Assembly Passes BPA Ban In Baby Bottles
Wildfires Force Nevada Residents From Homes
Consumption Of Added Sugar Could Lead To High Blood Pressure
Testosterone Levels May Be Linked To Heart Attack Risk
NATO's door still open for Ukraine: Clinton
Australia strikes compromise tax deal with miners
|
Israel settlers pressure PM on construction halt
Blast kills one, hurts 10 in flashpoint Kosovo town
|
Taliban attack U.S. aid company, five killed
|
Group to show car that can be driven by the blind
Surveys predict close presidential run-off in Poland
|
Fear lingers in Tibet two years after riots
|
Pakistan under pressure to act after Lahore violence
Alleged war criminal wins Australia extradition fight
Malaysia exports jump 21.9 percent in May
Militants ambush Thai security forces in south
Bank of China to raise $8.9 bln in rights issue
Silk Road city razed to remake west in China's image
Pakistani stocks end lower in dull trade on new tax
Japan's hot dog champ hungry for July 4 victory
Apple says iPhones overstate signal strength
|
GM auto sales in China slow in June
At Sun Valley, brighter moods may not mean big deals
|
China revises 2009 growth up to 9.1%
Obama announces broadband grants to spur jobs
|
Nokia aims to be the best with Symbian, MeeGo-Vanjoki
|
Seoul shares dip on econ worries, foreign selling
Google to buy travel software co ITA for $700 million
|
Disney buys iPhone game maker Tapulous
|
Japanese not keen to go four-eyed for 3D TV: survey
|
Undersea cable set to boost West Africa broadband
|
Larry King's replacement should have attitude
Writer Beryl Bainbridge dies aged 75
Phil Collins brings Motown heatwave to Montreux
|
Writer Beryl Bainbridge dies aged 75
|
Larry King's replacement should have attitude
|
Iron Maiden explores Final Frontier on new album
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights