Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Ten years on, Israel wrestles with Lebanon pullout
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Asia Pacific
World
Ten years on, Israel wrestles with Lebanon pullout
AFP - Friday, May 21
Send
IM Story
Print
The Iranian flag fluttters over an electricity pole in the village of Marun Al-Ras in southern Lebanon, near the border with Israel. In the decade since Israeli troops ended their 22-year occupation of south Lebanon, Israel and Hezbollah have fought a bloody war.
JERUSALEM (AFP) - – Ten years after withdrawing all its troops from south Lebanon, Israel is still wrestling with the results of the unilateral move which cost the Jewish state dearly in terms of deterrence.
In the decade since Israeli troops ended their 22-year occupation of south Lebanon on May 24, 2000, Israel and Hezbollah have fought a bloody war, and the Shiite militia has transformed itself into a well-equipped military force.
Tensions remain high, with Israel accusing Hezbollah of stockpiling sophisticated weapons -- including Scud missiles -- in preparation for a new conflict.
Leaving Lebanon was supposed to bring an end to what many considered to be Israel's Vietnam, an unwinnable guerrilla war with an escalating number of casualties.
Pulling out was supposed to strip further Hezbollah attacks of legitimacy and encourage the group to turn its energies to internal political affairs.
The consensus in Israel was -- and still is -- that it was the right move, despite the devastating war of 2006.
But the way in which the withdrawal was carried out severely weakened the perception of Israel's military superiority.
"The image the withdrawal created, of Israel being forced to retreat under pressure, unable to hold out for an extended period of time, had almost immediate consequences," wrote former defence minister Moshe Arens in an editorial in the Haaretz daily this week.
"Whatever deterrent capability Israel possessed was lost to the winds and had to be restored at considerable cost."
The image of Hezbollah "forcing out" Israel's military machine is widely regarded as the inspiration for the second Palestinian intifada, or uprising, which erupted months later.
Worse still was Israel's failure to respond decisively to further Hezbollah provocations in the wake of the withdrawal.
"The pullout and the action following the pullout led to quite a significant deterioration in Israel's deterrent status and contributed to the events since -- the intifada and the 2006 war," said Jonathan Spyer, senior researcher at the centre for Global Research in International Affairs in Herzliya.
"Israel has paid quite a heavy price."
For six years, there was an illusion of quiet along the northern border -- until July 2006, when Hezbollah militants captured two Israeli soldiers, prompting a massive Israeli retaliation.
In the ensuing 34-day conflict more than 1,200 Lebanese were killed, mostly civilians, and 160 Israelis were killed, mostly soldiers.
"The 2006 war was an inevitable by-product of the failure to re-establish deterrence," said Spyer. "(Sheikh Hassan) Nasrallah has admitted that had he known the extent of the Israeli response, he would not have got involved, meaning we didn't have deterrence," he said, referring to Hezbollah's leader.
The process largely repeated itself in the Gaza Strip, where Israel unilaterally withdrew its soldiers and settlers in 2005 before coming under a near-daily barrage of rockets fired by Palestinian militants.
In December 2008 Israel launched a devastating 22-day war on the territory, now ruled by the Islamist Hamas movement, aimed largely at restoring deterrence.
"There was a very large-scale rocket problem coming out of Gaza. There is not any more," Spyer said.
"If you're going to have a unilateral withdrawal, it is imperative to have deterrence because you cannot decide what happens on the other side after you leave," he added.
Since 2006, Hezbollah has regrouped and built up an impressive arsenal of 40,000 rockets -- three times the number it had in July 2006, Israeli intelligence officials say.
And yet those upgraded capabilities could actually make war less likely in the near future, analysts believe.
"It's not only that Hezbollah is deterred by Israel, but Israel is deterred by Hezbollah," said Shlomo Brom, senior research associate at the Institute for National Security Studies.
"Everyone understands that the next round of violence will be much worse," he said. "No one has an appetite for that."
Osama Safa, head of the Lebanese Centre for Policy Studies, agrees. He said the 2006 war between Hezbollah and Israel established a new "balance of terror" in the region.
"The new equation today is: we can all start a new war but it would be very difficult to stop it," he said.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Lindsay Lohan dodges arrest warrant AFP - 2 hours 23 minutes ago
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary Reuters - 2 hours 35 minutes ago
Filmmakers planning Comic-Con documentary Reuters - 2 hours 37 minutes ago
"Scream 4" lures "Twilight" and "Heroes" vets Reuters - 2 hours 58 minutes ago
Latest "Shrek" sequel eyes $100 million opening Reuters - Friday, May 21
News Search
Top Stories
US Senate passes historic Wall Street overhaul
BA suffers record annual loss
Europe finance heads mull tighter fiscal monitoring
US team creates first 'synthetic life'
France's Sarkozy denies rift with Germany over debt crisis
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Blood diamond prosecutors seek to subpoena Naomi Campbell
Dow index suffers biggest drop in more than a year
Judge issues arrest warrant for Lindsay Lohan
Lindsay Lohan misses LA court hearing after Cannes theft
US team creates first 'synthetic life'
More Most Viewed »
Scientists stunned as grey whale sighted off Israel
Lack of sleep linked to early death: study
UN fears 'irreversible' damage to natural environment
Earth may be too hot for humans by 2300: study
Ocean fish could disappear in 40 years: UN
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
World Cup 2010
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Friday, 21 May 2010 Maliki attends Iraq leaders' lunch, Allawi abroad
Paris museum burglar grabs 120-million-dollar art haul
France sees majority backing for Iran sanctions
German '4G' phone auction raises over 4.3 billion euros
Google unveils platform to bring Web to TV set
Darfur rebels and army clash, peace hopes fade
US-TECH Summary
US team creates first 'synthetic life'
ETA suspect held in France 'is group's top leader'
Google, Sony, Intel join on Web television project
Blood diamond prosecutors seek to subpoena Naomi Campbell
Iran may cancel atom swap deal if sanctions passed
|
German minister stresses privacy rights with Google chief
France's Sarkozy denies rift with Germany over debt crisis
Turkish planes bomb targets in Northern Iraq: Turkish media
|
Judge issues arrest warrant for Lindsay Lohan
Paris police ban mass "Facebook aperitif" party
Sri Lanka's detained ex-army chief denies war crimes
|
Libya plane crash black boxes flown to France
|
India telecom firms pay heavy price for 3G prize
Microsoft chief sees software future in the Internet 'cloud'
Spain unions to battle pay cuts for civil servants
|
Mitsubishi rolls out new electric car in Hong Kong
U.S. fails to describe wireless industry as competitive
German '4G' phone auction raises over 4.3 billion euros
Google unveils Internet television platform
Muslim concerns trigger Pakistani Web bans
US-TECH Summary
NKorea warns of war if punished for ship sinking
Wreckage of airliner seen on Afghan mountainside
Fix broken, inefficient US immigration system: Mexican leader
Veteran Myanmar opposition politician dies at 87
Annual US-China talks to focus on Iran, currency
Oil hits shore as BP scoops up 5,000 barrels a day
Indonesian film portrays Obama's early years
Ramos-Horta says East Timor finds peace at last
Thailand mops up, but fears of long-term strife
Google premieres Web television gamble
|
Afghan militants holds talks in Maldives
Paris police ban mass Facebook aperitif party
|
US lawmakers blast Toyota over defect probe
India's Jet Airways sees 11 percent profit rise
Cairn Energy to increase Indian oil project output
Toyota to 'voluntarily' repair over 22,000 compact cars
Asian nations must coordinate stimulus exit plans: ADB
China says 3,000 officials punished for construction graft
Celebrated Indonesian singer Gesang dies at 92
Lily Allen scoops top prizes at Ivor Novello Awards
Taiwan activists protest against China trade pact
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Taiwan economy sees biggest growth in over 30 years
Rap mogul Suge Knight arrested in Los Angeles
Prosecutors seek Naomi Campbell testimony in Taylor trial
Lohan faces arrest after missing court date
Oil threatens French-speaking Cajuns, native Choctaw
Moscow mayor bans gay pride march: organiser
Second detained Iranian director on hunger strike
Lost fans abroad get quick finale broadcasts
|
Lohan faces arrest after missing court date
|
Sex and the City sequel takes on Middle East
|
Rap mogul Suge Knight arrested in Los Angeles
|
Prosecutors seek Naomi Campbell testimony in Taylor trial
|
Epic French film treats Carlos the Jackal at Cannes
|
Iran may cancel atom swap deal if sanctions passed
Europe finance heads mull tighter fiscal monitoring
South Korea vows caution over ship as North sees war
|
Paris museum burglar grabs 120-million-dollar art haul
Google bringing Web to TV set
Early Thai election possible: finance minister
|
US Senate passes historic Wall Street overhaul
Dell profit surges on revived business spending
Taliban attack Afghan police base camp: officials
|
Android update turns Google phones into Wi-Fi hot spots
Looney Tunes Back In Action With New 3D Short, Television Series
Dow index suffers biggest drop in more than a year
Suspected Taliban blow up U.S. spies in Pakistan
|
Google will 'fight' for AdMob: Schmidt
Dell Q1 Earnings Jump On Growing PC Sales
US cartoonist disavows 'Draw Mohammed' Facebook page
Three Britons killed in Pakistan over family feud
|
BP Ordered To Switch To Less Toxic Dispersant, Admits More Oil Leaking
Annoyed by cellphones? Scientists explain why
U.S. Markets Continue Slide As European Debt Worries Remain
After Facebook, Pakistan shuts down YouTube
Mexican President's Speech To Congress On Drugs, Immigration Gets Mixed Response
New Chinese fighter jet expected by 2018: U.S. intelligence
|
Swedish Internet provider to take filesharing case to supreme court
Wall Street Reform Bill Passes First Senate Hurdle
US-TECH Summary
Malawi gay couple sentenced to 14 years in jail
|
MTV Picks Up "Teen Wolf" Series
Older Adults Who Don't Follow Medication Instructions Fall More
Google, Sony, Intel join on Web television project
Bomb blast in southern Afghan city kills civilian
Sri Lanka's detained ex-army chief denies war crimes
|
Animals Die In Fire At Berkeley Shelter
Rights group offers evidence of Sri Lanka war crimes
Democrat Chief Kaine Takes Stock, Announces All Out Effort For Midterm Elections
Spain unions to battle pay cuts for civil servants
|
2 Ark. police killed during traffic stop on I-40
SKorea calls for cautious response to ship sinking
Canada's 'Prince of Pot' extradited to US
Taiwan writer held at World Expo over t-shirt: report
US top spy quits after intelligence failures
Early Thai election possible
Louisiana marshes hit by Gulf oil slick
Suspected Taliban blow up "U.S. spies" in Pakistan
Clinton starts Asia tour as N.Korea tensions rise
US top spy quits 'with deep regret'
Another Foxconn worker dies in China; 8th in 2010
Obama's intelligence czar to resign: US official
South Korea vows caution over ship as North sees war
Thailand picks up the pieces after deadly conflict
Google premieres Web television gamble
|
Toyota recalls Lexus cars in Japan, US to follow
Excessive rise of yen undesirable: Japan FM
Japan's economy 'starting to recover moderately': BoJ
PAKISTAN
Japan central bank keeps interest rates unchanged
S.Korea sees limited market impact from tension with North
Indonesians fear for 'Reformasi'
Lindsay Lohan dodges arrest warrant
Indonesian film portrays Obama's early years
PetroChina shares fall after investment plan announced
Filmmakers planning Comic-Con documentary
NZ consumer confidence perks up in May
US, EU irked by stalled Japan Post privatisation
"Scream 4" lures "Twilight" and "Heroes" vets
Toyota teams up with Tesla to make electric cars
Ten years on, Israel wrestles with Lebanon pullout
Latest "Shrek" sequel eyes $100 million opening
Usher replaces Eminem atop singles chart
"Glee," Rolling Stones eye top of albums chart
Mike Leigh and monks vie for top Cannes film prize
Arrest warrant lifted for Lindsay Lohan
|
Simon Cowell speaks of depression, admits mistakes
|
Latest Shrek sequel eyes $100 million opening
|
Buzz in short supply at Cannes
|
Filmmakers planning Comic-Con documentary
|
Glee, Rolling Stones eye top of albums chart
|
Scream 4 lures Twilight and Heroes vets
|
Lost fans abroad get quick finale broadcasts
|
Usher replaces Eminem atop singles chart
|
Iran sanctions won't stop missiles
Euro rescue package clears German parliament
British Airways reports record annual loss of £531m
Police hunt Paris art thief after $120 mln heist
Wreckage of Afghan plane, bodies found: minister
Bosnian police in major organized crime crackdown
|
Sony, Samsung meeting seen focusing on LCD panels
Israeli army kills 2 armed Palestinians from Gaza
|
Police break Vietnam immigrant trafficking ring
|
South Sudan swears in first elected president
|
Spain court convicts 3 ETA members of airport bomb
|
Iran sanctions won't stop missiles: Russian senator
|
Sony, Samsung meeting seen focusing on LCD panels
Colombia presidential race tight days before poll
|
PM calls for reconciliation to heal Thai divide
No survivors found at Afghan airline crash site
AP INVESTIGATION: Texas man faked way into Army
Wall St plunge triggers Asian turmoil
Clinton starts Asia tour as N.Korea tensions rise
Clinton: NKorea must face consequences for attack
Group presents new evidence on abuses in Sri Lanka
US to work closely with new Philippine leader
103 arrested in Indonesian election protest
Taiwan zoo expects no panda cubs before 2011
Sony, Samsung meeting seen focusing on LCD panels
|
Pepsi to invest $2.5 billion in China
Another Foxconn worker dies in China; 9th in 2010
Pakistan stocks, o/n rates down; rupee weakens
Up in smoke: Indonesian child-teen smokers rising
France-Algeria war film sparks Cannes protests
Abbott buys unit of Piramal Healthcare for $3.7B
US says preparing to ease high-tech export controls
Jackson fans to spend night among his possessions
Rising yen casts shadow over Japan recovery
Cannes stars turn out for glitzy AIDS charity bash
Rock 'n' roll nostalgia is sure seller at Cannes
US presses Beijing on clean-energy market access
Cuban drag queens take to the stage
Japan central bank keeps interest rate unchanged
Clinton: US condemns N.Korea sinking of South's ship
U2 frontman Bono undergoes surgery
|
Algerian independence film stirs protest at Cannes
|
Jackson fans to spend night among his possessions
|
Cannes stars turn out for glitzy AIDS charity bash
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights