Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
US storm as Mohammed cartoons edited out of book
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Asia Pacific
World
Search
Search:
US storm as Mohammed cartoons edited out of book
AFP - Monday, August 31
NEW YORK (AFP) - - Editors of a new US book on the controversy over cartoons caricaturing Muslims and the Prophet Mohammed have triggered a storm by deciding not to reprint the 12 sketches for fear of new violence.
ADVERTISEMENT
"The Cartoons That Shook the World," due out in November by Yale University Press, examines the reaction of the Muslim world to the 2005 publication of the cartoons by the Danish newspaper Jyllands-Posten.
Author Jytte Klausen, a Danish-born professor of politics at Brandeis University in Waltham, Massachusetts, reluctantly agreed to cut the cartoons from the book.
"I am sad personally because I feel it is a loss to the book to be published without the illustrations. It is also sad that we have a circumstance where an academic press feels compelled to go ahead and remove these illustrations," Klausen told AFP in a telephone interview.
Other images of Mohammed were also removed, including a 19th century Gustave Dore print illustrating a passage from Dante Alighieri's Divine Comedy of Mohammed in hell.
Director of Yale Press John Donatich made the decision after consulting with a "couple dozen" diplomats, intelligence and academic experts.
"I didn't feel this was a censorship issue," Donatich told AFP. "It had become a security issue," he said, adding he was concerned for the safety of Yale Press employees.
"I felt that the cartoons and the illustrations we are talking about here, they're not new information. It was gratuitous to publish them again if they were this troublesome. People were certain they would cause violence," he said.
The Mohammed cartoons originally appeared in Danish newspapers in September 2005, sparking protests across the Muslim world. Five people died in Pakistan in protests in February 2006.
But Klausen disputes the grounds for cutting out the cartoons.
"Security experts were asked to provide advice without having the manuscript, without having the context in which these illustrations were going to be reprinted," she said.
"I think it's very serious to suppress illustrations when not a single Muslim has protested the book and there were some Muslim reviewers."
In mid-August, the prestigious Yale University revealed that among the experts it had consulted were former US deputy secretary of state John Negroponte, and author and journalist Fareed Zakaria.
And in a written statement explaining Yale's to pull the cartoons, UN under secretary general Ibrahim Gambari is quoted saying: "You can count on violence if any illustration of the prophet is published. It will cause riots I predict from Indonesia to Nigeria."
Yale said the violence surrounding the cartoons continued pointing to a car bombing outside the Danish embassy in Islamabad, Pakistan in June 2008 which killed eight people.
"The next day Al-Qaeda claimed responsibility for the bombing, calling it revenge for the 'insulting drawings,'" it said in its statement.
But Klausen countered: "I think it is ludicrous to think that an academic book written for undergraduate students as a case study of an international relations conflict could set off civil war in Nigeria."
The actions by Yale have triggered a storm of protest in the literary world.
Vanity Fair columnist Christopher Hitchens said in the online magazine Slate it was "perhaps the worst episode in the steady surrender to religious extremism -- particularly Muslim religious extremism -- that is spreading across our culture."
And Islam scholar Reza Aslan, author of "No god but God: The Origins, Evolution and Future of Islam," pulled his jacket blurb praising the book in a failed attempt to get Yale to change its mind.
Aslan said Yale's experts misunderstand the original controversy.
"It wasn't just the cartoons, it was a deliberate attempt by the newspaper in Denmark to provoke the Muslim minority in Denmark, to give them a sort of citizenship test. The cartoons were seen by two polarized camps as an argument as to whether, A, Europe is Islamophobic or, B, whether Muslims have any place in Europe," he said.
"The reason the anger erupted was because of the racism embedded in the cartoons, their deliberate provocation of the Muslim community and the way the cartoons were manipulated to say that Europe is racist. That's where the mistake lies here, to think that the cartoons in and of themselves have the power to create this global crisis," he said.
But Zakaria said he was "certain that the publication of the book would provoke violence."
"I think it is a very difficult call whenever you are contemplating any kind of restraint on freedom of expression but I think that the judgment call that Yale made is exactly the right one," he said.
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Sign in to recommend this article »
0 users recommend
Related Articles: Entertainment & Lifestyle
UK police to review Rolling Stones guitarist deathAP - 1 hour 25 minutes ago
Future of daytime TV a hot topic at Daytime EmmysAP - 1 hour 34 minutes ago
Rolling Stones guitarist's death to be re-examinedReuters - Tuesday, September 1
Arab TV looks to Ramadan to offset lossesAFP - Monday, August 31
Highlights of Hollywood's fall, holiday scheduleAP - Monday, August 31
Enlarge Photo
People are seen in Paris, during a demonstration of Muslims to vent their anger over satirical images of the Prophet Mohammed, in 2006. Editors of a new US book on the controversy over cartoons caricaturing Muslims and the Prophet Mohammed have triggered a storm by deciding not to reprint the 12 sketches for fear of new violence.
Most Popular – Entertainment
Viewed
Obama ends frenetic vacation
Kidnapped US girl walks into police station 18 years on
Michael Jackson's death homicide: coroner
Microsoft apologizes for photo gaffe
Tick saliva could hold cancer cure: Brazilian scientists
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Monday, 31 August 2009 Iraq al Qaeda militant says Syria trained him
Merkel party suffers setback in state votes: exit polls
Setbacks loom for Merkel's party in election warm-up
Former Israeli prime minister Olmert indicted
Iran's president defends Cabinet amid skepticism
Merkel loses ground to left in German states
| International
|
Iraq: suspected bomber recently released by US
Iraq al Qaeda militant says Syria trained him
| International
|
Former Israeli PM Olmert indicted for corruption
| International
|
Dalai Lama arrives in Taiwan after China's protest
| International
|
Pakistan reality TV contestant drowns in challenge
Myanmar says 26 forces, 8 rebels killed at border
Cheney says he and Bush disagreed at times
Former first daughter Jenna Bush joins `Today'
Indian scientists hail aborted lunar mission
Police search neighbors' back yard in kidnap case
Hurricane Jimena off Mexico upgraded to Category 4: NHC
Blast kills 15 police recruits in Pakistan's Swat
Calif. wildfire heads north, threatens thousands
Contact lost, India terminates first moon mission
Despite pedigree, Hatoyama had long wait in wings
Blackwater tapped foreigners on secret CIA program
Cheney says politics behind CIA probe at Justice
Dalai Lama says Taiwan visit is 'non-political'
Hatoyama not likely to change US-Japan alliance
Police: 1 killed in small plane crash in Pa.
Democrats: Honor Kennedy through civil debate
Death toll rises to 19 in Indonesian ship sinking
Boat sinks in Indonesia, '19 dead, 20 missing'
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Horror, violence lure movie fans
| Entertainment
|
Cranberries reunite for tour after seven years
Bush daughter Jenna Hager becomes 'Today' reporter
Cranberries reunite for tour after seven years
| Entertainment
|
Horror, violence lure movie fans
Anti-Taliban ops claim high toll in Afghanistan
Merkel challenger refuses to be ruled out
Japan Democrats take power, tough challenges loom
| International
|
Britain urges more reform of finance sector
American commander: US on the road out of Iraq
Obama ends frenetic vacation
Dalai Lama tells Taiwan he's dedicated to democracy
| International
|
British immigration centres hold 470 children: report
Suspected Taliban torch NATO supplies in SW Pakistan
| International
|
Democrats, Republicans rejoin fight after Kennedy farewell
Iraq: suspected bomber recently released by US
Captured Ukrainian crew plead for help
Myanmar refugees begin warily returning from China
| International
|
Former Israeli PM Olmert indicted for corruption
Gabon awaits poll outcome, Bongo's son confident
| International
|
Merkel party suffers setback in election warm-up
Colombia says president has swine flu
| International
|
Thai politics a drag on economic recovery: Fitch
| International
|
Russia says kills al Qaeda agent in North Caucasus
| International
|
World Bank in talks with Cambodia over evictions
| International
|
LG Display in deal for China LCD plant
Great expectations for Japan's victorious Democrats
Dalai Lama tells Taiwan he's dedicated to democracy
Calls for fast action in Japan after historic vote
Myanmar says 34 killed as border fighting ends
Hatoyama not likely to change US-Japan alliance
Blast kills 16 Pakistan cadets; NATO trucks bombed
Firefighters battle blaze near small Utah town
Protest accuses Dalai Lama of 'politics' in Taiwan
LG Display in deal for China LCD plant
| Technology
|
Report: US makes $4 billion from bailout banks
Analysis: Democrats tasked with delivering change
Pakistan: Border blast sets NATO fuel trucks afire
US parties rejoin fight after Kennedy farewell
Japan suffer 59-year world championship low
3 Texas boaters missing for a week rescued at sea
`The Bold and the Beautiful' wins drama series
Police: 8th person dead in Ga. mobile home attack
Calif. fire to reach mountain's TV transmitters
Police: NM boy faces murder charge in dad's death
US military deaths in Iraq war at 4,337
Schumer proposal aims to avert crashes over Hudson
Highlights of Hollywood's fall, holiday schedule
Vampires, werewolves, liars lead fall film cast
CORRECTED-UPDATE 1-LG Display in deal for China LCD plant
Taiwan dollar firms on exporters, foreign funds
China Southern Airlines says 1H profit down 97 pct
Seoul shares down; Hyundai Mobis falls, techs rise
Arab TV looks to Ramadan to offset losses
India hungry for foreign oil despite home finds
Japan industrial production up 1.9 percent in July
`The Bold and the Beautiful' wins drama series
Winners at 36th annual Daytime Emmy Awards
Japan's factory output rises 1.9 pct in July
Rachel Ray, Tyra Banks win talk show Emmys
| Entertainment
|
Korea Hot Stocks
Emmy Awards struggle to stay relevant to viewers
S.Korea says needs global cooperation on exit plan
S.Korea T-bond futures rise, key economy data eyed
Actress puts the 'Mad Men' in their place
Pakistan reality TV contestant drowns in challenge
Actress puts the Mad Men in their place
| Entertainment
|
WW2 singer Vera Lynn returns to British album charts
3-D flick 'Final Destination' tops North American box office
Star Trek veteran boldly saved movie franchise
| Entertainment
|
Madonna tours Jewish holy sites in Jerusalem
No talks without full settlement freeze
US-TECH Summary
Madonna makes late-night visit to Western Wall
Ahmadinejad cabinet faces growing opposition
AMD ships lower power server chip
LG Display in deal for China LCD plant
Afghan vote fraud claims soar
Afghan officials on democracy's front line
Ridge: Talk of terror-alert politics exaggerated
LA-area blaze size doubles, threatens 12,000 homes
Sniffer dogs search home in US abduction case
The Nation's Weather
Experts: Abductees such as Jaycee stay out of fear
Convicted killer on trial in Texas triple homicide
Raging California wildfires leave two dead
Vogo Fund to buy S.Korea card firm stake for $156 mln
India's economic growth accelerates to 6.1 percent
Pakistani stocks end 1.5 pct higher; rupee firms
Japan industrial production up 1.9 percent in July
SKorea industrial output faster-than-expected rise
Japan's post-election market euphoria short-lived
India's economy grows at 6.1 pct Apr-June quarter
Japan stocks slip on worries about yen, policies
Seoul shares fall; Hyundai Mobis, shipbuilders down =2
US storm as Mohammed cartoons edited out of book
Highlights of Hollywood's fall, holiday schedule
Vampires, werewolves, liars lead fall film cast
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights