Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Israel plays wargame assuming Iran has nuclear bomb
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Israel plays wargame assuming Iran has nuclear bomb
Reuters - Tuesday, May 18
Send
IM Story
Print
By Dan Williams
HERZLIYA, Israel - A nuclear-armed Iran would blunt Israel's military autonomy, a wargame involving former Israeli generals and diplomats has concluded, though some players predicted Tehran would also exercise restraint.
Sunday's event at a campus north of Tel Aviv followed other high-profile Iran simulations in Israel and the United States in recent months. But it broke new ground by assuming the existence of what both countries have pledged to prevent: an Iranian bomb.
"Iranian deterrence proved dizzyingly effective," Eitan Ben-Eliahu, a retired air force commander who played the Israeli defence minister, said in his summary of the 20-team meeting.
Though the wargame saw Iran declaring itself a nuclear power in 2011, the ensuing confrontations were by proxy, in Lebanon.
In one, emboldened Hezbollah guerrillas fired missiles at the Defence Ministry in Tel Aviv. That was followed by U.S. and Israeli intelligence findings that Iran had slipped radioactive materials to its Lebanese cohort, to assemble a crude device.
Neither move drew Israeli attacks, though Ben-Eliahu said his delegation had received discreet encouragement from Arab rivals of Iran to "go all the way" in retaliating.
Instead, Israel conferred with the United States, which publicly supported its ally's "right to self-defence" and mobilised military reinforcements for the region while quietly insisting the Israelis stand down to give crisis talks a chance.
"As far as the United States was concerned, Israel was trigger-happy. It sought to use the Hezbollah attack as justification for what the United States was told would be an all-out war," said Dan Kurtzer, a former U.S. ambassador to Tel Aviv who played President Barack Obama.
Kurtzer voiced satisfaction with his team's response to the "dirty bomb," which entailed cajoling U.N. Security Council powers into mounting an armed intervention against Hezbollah.
"Countries like China and Russia have their own terrorists, and don't want to see them getting nuclear weapons," he said.
"In certain circumstances, agile U.S. diplomacy can actually work in this region, and it ends up not only leaving Israel in check but it also ends up leading a willing international coalition."
STRATEGIC BALANCE
Those playing Iran and Hezbollah went as far as to question the very premise that Tehran would let the Lebanese guerrillas goad Israel into a potentially catastrophic fight, or give them nuclear know-how that would worry even sympathisers like Syria.
Aharon Zeevi-Farkash, a retired Israeli intelligence chief acting as Iranian Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei, insisted Iran would regard its bomb as a means of "self-defence and strategic balance" -- an allusion to Israel's own, assumed atomic arsenal.
Such assessments are seldom voiced by Israel's rightist government, which describes a nuclear-armed Iran as a mortal danger. Where Israeli officials would once make veiled threats to strike Iran, now they often try to warn the West against accommodating their foe, which denies seeking atomic weapons.
In what appeared to signal government discomfort with the wargame, a senior Israeli defence official who had been due to attend withdrew at short notice. A Foreign Ministry spokesman said a written summary would be studied at government-level.
That left Tzipi Livni, the centrist head of Israel's opposition, as the most prominent observer of the IDC event.
"As leader of the free world, the United States has the responsibility of leading more effective sanctions that can turn around, absolutely, this shift from a process of stopping to a process of acceptance," she said.
While the simulation found no immediate international drive to tackle Iran, Kurtzer attributed this to passive factors such as U.S. war-fatigue and complained of a failure to address ramifications such as a nuclear arms race among Arab powers.
Some of the participants -- including those playing Israel, the Palestinians and Syria -- saw an opportunity for renewed Middle East peacemaking that might head off Iran's ascendancy.
"This was tactical, but of course tactics can often serve real strategic interests, both for us and for the Americans," said Zalman Shoval, a former Israeli ambassador to Washington who acted as Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
Somali president vows to appoint new PM AFP - 2 hours 5 minutes ago
Plane crashes in Afghanistan with 43 on board AFP - 23 minutes ago
UK-World Summary Reuters - 30 minutes ago
Somali president to appoint new PM Reuters - 34 minutes ago
Turkish mine explosion 'leaves 32 trapped' AFP - 44 minutes ago
News Search
Top Stories
Greece PM says 'not begging' ahead of EU loan
Euro, shares and oil caught in debt storm worries
GM returns to profit in 2010 first quarter
Astronauts begin first space walk from Atlantis
Prudential eyes record takeover of Asian insurer
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Boy survivor of Libya air crash 'stable but confused'
Portugal takes more austerity measures
Asia steps into Cannes spotlight
Pope rallies priests as crowds flock to Fatima
Euro hits four-year dollar low, stocks mixed
More Most Viewed »
Scientists stunned as grey whale sighted off Israel
Lack of sleep linked to early death: study
UN fears 'irreversible' damage to natural environment
Earth may be too hot for humans by 2300: study
Freddie Mac asks for fresh 10.6 billion dollar bailout
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
World Cup 2010
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Monday, 17 May 2010 Turkish PM to Tehran in bid to seal nuclear swap
Sudan arrests Islamist opposition leader
Israeli left flies flag to urge end to occupation
Iran, Turkey and Brazil agree on fuel swap deal: minister
|
BP Successful In Inserting Tube Into Damaged Riser
Three Chinese oil workers abducted in Yemen
|
United Airlines Flight Crew Locks Blind Woman On Empty Plane
Sudan arrests Islamist opposition leader
|
Israel bars academic Chomsky entry to West Bank
|
Suicide bomber strikes Afghan border police
Fear in Bangkok as bullets fly close to home
Maldives: Accepting Guantanamo detainees honorable
Thailand toughens stand against spiralling protests
Thai govt rejects plea for talks, pushes crackdown
Malaysia opposition beats gov't in Borneo ballot
Pakistani military kills 58 suspected militants
Bus plunges off bridge killing 11 in Bangladesh
NATO soldier killed in Afghan insurgent attack
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Robin Hood hits bull's-eye at worldwide box office
Tavernier brings "16th century thriller" to Cannes
Robin Hood hits bull's-eye at worldwide box office
|
Iran, Brazil, Turkey sign nuclear swap deal
US-TECH Summary
Final Thai crackdown feared as guests evacuate
|
Ultra-Orthodox Jews lose grave battle in Israel
Free games lure new players including women, elderly
Volcanic ash grounds hundreds of European flights
|
LG Display banks on e-reader growth
China's Web "firewall" should be WTO issue: EU's Kroes
Iraq recount fails to overturn Allawi election win
|
Apple's iPhone replaces Blackberry for some bankers
Iran, Brazil, Turkey sign nuclear swap deal
|
"I do" goes high-tech with Japan robot priest
Israeli coalition wobbly on peace terms: minister
|
LG Display banks on e-reader growth
Ultra-Orthodox Jews lose grave battle in Israel
|
Kyrgyzstan Communist leader to be held 2 months
Cuba cedes to farmers right to purchase supplies
|
Wounded rogue Thai general dies as chaos continues
India test fires nuclear-capable missile
Indonesian president says terror threat remains
Reports: Hatoyama, Clinton to discuss US base
578 addicts escape from rehab center in Vietnam
Rogue "red shirt" military adviser dies
Weather forecast for the Asia-Pacific region
Red Shirt military strategist dies of wounds
Apple's iPhone replaces Blackberry for some bankers
|
China's Web firewall should be WTO issue: EU's Kroes
|
LG Display banks on e-reader growth
|
I do goes high-tech with Japan robot priest
|
Seoul shares down; Europe fears fan foreign selling
Japan's Astellas to buy US drug maker OSI for $4B
"Dark Stranger" a serviceable Woody Allen comedy
Qatar, Shell, China's CNPC in gas agreement
Free games lure new players including women, elderly
|
Heavy metal veteran Ronnie James Dio dies, aged 67
PAKISTAN
Underground Cuban rappers live on the edge
Euro debt fears hit S.Korea banks, tech shares
S.Korea president upbeat on economy as c.bank eyed
US, Europe look to China for clean energy sales
Japan machinery orders rise 5.4 percent in March
Seoul shares off; Europe fears fan foreign selling
Japan machinery orders rise in March
Heavy metal veteran Ronnie James Dio dies, aged 67
|
Underground Cuban rappers live on the edge
|
Two 20,000 Leagues films in the works
|
Christopher Walken to sow Wild Oats
|
Dark Stranger a serviceable Woody Allen comedy
|
Plane crashes in Afghanistan with 43 on board
Russian president in Ukraine to tighten relations
Microsoft settles with VirnetX, to pay $200 million
France to deport Iranian assassin after woman freed
Volcanic ash grounds 1,000 European flights
|
Astronauts begin first space walk from Atlantis
Prudential eyes record takeover of Asian insurer
Iran agrees controversial nuclear fuel swap deal
Airplane with 43 on board crashes in Afghanistan
|
Euro hits four-year dollar low, stocks mixed
Iran agrees to send low enriched uranium to Turkey
Four dead, many evacuated as floods sweep central Europe
|
UK coalition to announce 2010 cuts next week: Osborne
|
Israel plays wargame assuming Iran has nuclear bomb
Pakistan's President Zardari faces legal challenge
|
Maoist bus attack kills about 35 in India, government
says
|
NATO emphasizes defense spending despite crisis
|
Evacuations start amid fears of Pakistan lake burst
|
Ultimatum passes as battles rage on in Bangkok
India scrapyard radioactive but no risk, govt says
BP mulls options as tube captures 'some' oil
Report: Rebels blow up bus in India, killing 40
Philippine chopper crash kills governor, 4 others
Afghan passenger plane crashes with 44 on board
Report: Lightning kills 5 in Bangladesh
Top U.S. carriers plot faster gadgets, services
|
Indian company trains small army to meet 3D surge
|
Thousands of Thai protesters defy deadline to leave
Pakistani stocks near 2-mth low; rupee weakens
Nestle eyes resuming ties with Indonesia palm oil firm
Euro plunges to four-year low as debt fears weigh
Governor dies in Philippine helicopter crash
Microsoft settles with VirnetX, to pay $200 million
|
Samsung to triple capital, R&D spending this year
AU sees LCD shortage, eyes China deals
|
China stands firm on currency ahead of talks with US
Taiwan new regulator to stay course on AIG deal
Korean Air turns 1Q net profit amid stronger won
Shanghai court rejects ex-Rio Tinto execs' appeals
Japan's Astellas to buy US drug co. OSI for $4 bln
Sharp banking on 3-D for mobile devices, TVs
Euro, shares and oil slump over Europe debt fears
Godard blames Greeks for Cannes no-show
Indonesian filmmaker documents Obama's childhood
Bjork, Italian composer Morricone win music prize
Cannes film festival hits halfway short on buzz
Scorsese eyes 2011 bow for George Harrison film
Two "20,000 Leagues" films in the works
Christopher Walken to sow "Wild Oats"
Javier Bardem moves Cannes crowd in Biutiful
|
Robin Hood hits bull's-eye at worldwide box office
|
Indian company trains small army to meet 3D surge
|
Cannes film festival hits halfway short on buzz
|
Scorsese eyes 2011 bow for George Harrison film
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights