Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Israel wasn't ready for flotilla resistance: general
|
Edition:
U.S.
Article
Comments (10)
Save
Email
Print
Reprints
Most Popular
Most Shared
Scientists find new superbug spreading from India
10:07am EDT
Colorado Democrat Bennet escapes anti-incumbent mood
8:30am EDT
U.N. warns of second wave of Pakistani flood deaths
| Video
10:56am EDT
Nasdaq falls 3 percent
| Video
11:36am EDT
Attractive women overlooked for certain jobs?
09 Aug 2010
Florida AG proposes law against illegal immigrants
11:11am EDT
UPDATE 1-Colorado Democrat escapes U.S. anti-incumbent mood
12:39am EDT
Cancer cells slurp up fructose, US study finds
02 Aug 2010
Hollywood disdainful of Levi Johnston TV venture
4:07am EDT
Analysis: Drought to crimp not cripple Russia recovery
10 Aug 2010
Scientists find new superbug spreading from India
10:07am EDT
Cancer cells slurp up fructose, US study finds
02 Aug 2010
Florida AG proposes law against illegal immigrants
11:11am EDT
Attractive women overlooked for certain jobs?
09 Aug 2010
Quick brain scan could screen for autism
10 Aug 2010
Yen soars to 15-year high
10:11am EDT
Strange and unusual
29 Jul 2010
Setback for BlackBerry in India
| Video
8:24am EDT
Russia fires cause "brown cloud," may hit Arctic
10 Aug 2010
U.N. warns of second wave of Pakistani flood deaths
| Video
10:56am EDT
Israel wasn't ready for flotilla resistance: general
Digg This
Tweet This
Share on LinkedIn
Share on Facebook
Related News
U.N. panel on Gaza flotilla incident begins work
Tue, Aug 10 2010
Libya to fund Gaza homes after Israel approves aid
Tue, Aug 10 2010
Israel weighed all options in Gaza boat raid: defense minister
Tue, Aug 10 2010
Israel solely responsible for convoy deaths: Turkey
Tue, Aug 10 2010
Israeli PM says Turkey ignored flotilla warnings
Mon, Aug 9 2010
Related Topics
World »
Israel's army chief Lieutenant-General Gabi Ashkenazi (front) sits before testifying at a state-appointed inquiry into the Israeli naval raid on a Gaza aid flotilla, in Jerusalem, August 11, 2010.
Credit: Reuters/Gali Tibbon/Pool
By Ari Rabinovitch
JERUSALEM |
Wed Aug 11, 2010 9:04am EDT
JERUSALEM (Reuters) - Israeli troops were not ready for the violent resistance they met when they boarded a Gaza-bound aid ship and killed nine pro-Palestinian activists, the country's top military officer said on Wednesday.
Speaking to an inquiry, Israeli Defense Forces Chief of Staff General Gabi Ashkenazi gave the most detailed explanation so far of what went wrong with the military plan in the May 31 raid, which sparked an international outcry.
IDF commandos failed to clear the decks with stun grenades they used, and rappelled from their helicopter straight into a brawl with men wielding iron bars and knives and were even met by gunfire, Ashkenazi said.
The raid quickly became "chaotic," he said. "After the first soldier went down the rope there was no choice but to continue with the plan."
International condemnation of the raid persuaded Israel to ease its Gaza blockade, which it says is aimed at preventing arms reaching the Hamas-ruled territory but also aggravates the privations of 1.5 million mostly aid-dependant Palestinians.
The nine activists killed were Turks. The raid almost ruptured Israel's relations with once-close Muslim ally Turkey.
The raid was seen at home as a debacle for Israel in terms of public relations and international image, although most Israelis consider the interception justified in principle.
Ashkenazi was the third senior figure to address the inquiry this week after Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Defense Minister Ehud Barak appeared before it.
The commission offers a closely-managed forum in which Israeli leaders can argue their case and is separate from an independent investigation which opened at the United Nations in New York on Tuesday.
CLEAR THE DECKS
The operation to stop the ship from reaching the Gaza Strip, under blockade by Israel and Egypt, depended for its success on getting as many commandos on deck as possible in the shortest time, Ashkenazi said. But that did not happen.
Accurate suppressing fire from alongside the ship would have cleared the deck of anyone ready to violently resist the boarding, the general said. This was "a lesson we have learned."
The first commandos were armed with paintball guns and holstered sidearms in anticipation of only light resistance. The second soldier down the rope was shot in the stomach, he said.
Asked about Turkey's claim that activists were shot dead from close range, Ashkenazi said much of the fighting happened in close quarters. He told how a soldier shot one Turkish man about to swing an axe at him.
Ashkenazi also showed previously unpublished video of the raid which included images of three wounded Israeli commandos dragged to a lower deck and held by activists.
Israeli leaders insist Israel was legally within its rights to stop a deliberately provocative bid to break its naval blockade of the Gaza Strip.
The investigating panel has so far heard mostly pre-scripted statements. Cameras are turned off and reporters excluded for a closed-door question session. It is not the sort of public grilling familiar to viewers of televised U.S. Congressional hearings.
Israeli media have treated the inquiry with skepticism, focusing predominantly on what they see as buck-passing and finger-pointing in the top ranks of the leadership.
Netanyahu, Barak and Ashkenazi conceded that intelligence was imperfect. Ashkenazi said "we didn't know enough" about the Turkish activist group whose members were on deck.
(Additional reporting by Dan Williams; Writing by Douglas Hamilton; Editing by Janet Lawrence)
World
Comments
See All Comments (10) | Post Comment
Aug 11, 2010 8:14am EDT
IDF only came prepared to kill the activists, of course! Classic IDF tactic”! ‘Kill them first, then arrest the deceased and after which, bring them in for in-terro-gation.
Banned
Report As Abusive
Aug 11, 2010 8:21am EDT
“…ended up killing nine pro-Palestinian activists.”! No, correction …nine defenseless foreign nationals, Turkish and American! I guess only when it comes to Israel is an American life insignificant, truly in-valuable! So much for no man left behind, excellent reason to change the 14th Amendment!
Banned
Report As Abusive
Aug 11, 2010 8:39am EDT
“International condemnation of the raid persuaded Israel to ease restrictions of its Gaza blockade …” “…which is aimed at preventing arms reaching the territory but also aggravates the privations of 1.5 million mostly aid-dependant Palestinians.” Why does the press always find it necessary to defend State repression and tyranny of occupied people? Do you also explain the rational and motivation for which suicide bombers carry out their devastating and detrimental actions? These explanations justifying Israeli demonic actions are gross cruelty on the part of the Press, and a second indignation of these repressed and displaced innocent people. Please let’s stop making excuses for inexcusable state sponsored behavior. Otherwise, shouldn’t we also make excuses for the Nazis, I’m sure they could come up with very dark rationale for the evil besieged upon the lives of innocent European civilians that happened to be Jews!
“The nine activists who were killed were all Turks …”. One of the activists killed was an AMERICAN, A FULL U.S CITIZEN. Disposable only because he happen to be born of Muslim origin!
Banned
Report As Abusive
Aug 11, 2010 9:12am EDT
Israel attacked a ship in international water and they expect no resistance? If it was not a planned attack by Israel, why was it carried out at nighttime? If Israel had nothing to hide, why not conduct the operation in daytime and why jammed all communication links?
Castlecrag
Report As Abusive
Aug 11, 2010 9:13am EDT
Israel should treat every life like she treats one of her own! ‘Of course, this is wishful thinking,’ …but this could be a truly thoughtful experiment to the psyche of a Nation without a commendable moral structure or ‘compass’. …At least, not from the view point of her detractors. Maybe, then, Israelis will grasp the reality regarding why much of the world outside the spellbind U.S public regard her as a renegade and illegitimate nation.
So far, not so much as an iota of apology for the innocent lives lost. …Only stubborn, self aggrandized and guilt-filled arguments to justify deadly actions taken and Israeli positions. NOT AN IOTA, THE TINIEST SHRED, OF APOLOGY FOR THE UNFORTUNATE LOSS OF HUMAN LIFE. This screams everything about Israel and how she views the rest of the world that anyone needs to know.
Just say we are sorry, we had good reason for keeping these flotillas from reaching the Gaza coastline, but we are very sad and deeply regret the loss of activist lives. Anytime there is a loss of human life during our security and defense operations are profoundly regrettable, we take it very personal and deeply regret any contributing actions and we will continue to engage in tangible measures to prevent such and any loses in the future.” Simple display of your humanity will go a long way to make people understand. Not this stubborn, screw y’all, what are you going to do about it attitude.
Trust me; the attitude is why much of Europe turned blind eye during the holocaust, until when it was a little too late. It is why the world may just turn the blind eye once again. Wake up, Israelis!
Banned
Report As Abusive
Aug 11, 2010 9:35am EDT
Finally! We can hear both sides of the story. This makes it very clear the Israelis were totally set up by the people on the ships.
The people on the ships were ready to kill, and the Israeli’s were only ready for crowd control carrying only paint ball guns that are not even lethal.
Thanks Reuters for publishing, so we can see the whole story. It jives with the videos of the attacks on the soldiers when they boarded the ships violating their blockade.
Thank God we don’t have Canada firing thousands of rockets at NYC each year. That is what Gaza is doing to Israel.
We need peace in the Middle East!
BR7
Report As Abusive
Aug 11, 2010 10:15am EDT
Since when do “peaceful activists” arm themselves and use iron pipes, knives, and axes with the goal of breaking a nations blockade or achieving martyrdom? They got the martyrdom they wished for and they got great PR for their cause. But they also put the genuine peace activists on the ship in great danger.
Edwardx
Report As Abusive
Aug 11, 2010 10:28am EDT
Edwardx wrote “Since when do ‘peaceful activists’ arm themselves and use iron pipes, knives, and axes with the goal of breaking a nations blockade or achieving martyrdom?” Since IDF regarded attacking Peaceful Activists with heavy armor and live ammunition. Oops, sorry, forgot that this is IDF’s engraved stone cold policy since her established. Oh, and we only have the IDF’s version of records. If IDF was so confident that they did no wrong, why confiscate all electronic media seized from the flotilla, why not release them to their rightful owners and the world. Mate, Israel is never on the right, and they will never be on the right. There is always a contrived motivation for all her actions, good or bad. Best yet; just don’t recognize her to the point where you succumb to her dark influences.
Banned
Report As Abusive
Aug 11, 2010 10:36am EDT
isnt it strange that no matter how much you post, banned, it still doesnt become the truth?
that ship didnt contain peaceful activists. it didnt contain humanitarians and it didnt contain people seeking peace.
anyone with the best of gaza in mind would have shipped the humanitarian aid through the official channels so that it would actually get to the poor civilians in gaza.
instead they sought confrontation and violence. israel is in this case only rightfully protecting its civilian population as any other nation would. breaking a blockage and supporting extremists random blowing up innocent civilians triggers a confrontation- one that isnt needed if the activists had the best intentions and peace at mind.
ben-noon
Report As Abusive
See All Comments (10)
Add a Comment
*We welcome comments that advance the story directly or with relevant tangential information. We try to block comments that use offensive language or appear to be spam and review comments frequently to ensure they meet our standards. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters.
© Copyright 2010 Thomson Reuters
Editorial Editions:
Africa
Arabic
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
China
France
Germany
India
Italy
Japan
Latin America
Mexico
Russia
Spain
United Kingdom
United States
Reuters
Contact Us
Advertise With Us
Help
Journalism Handbook
Archive
Site Index
Video Index
Reader Feedback
Mobile
Newsletters
RSS
Podcasts
Widgets
Your View
Analyst Research
Thomson Reuters
Copyright
Disclaimer
Privacy
Professional Products
Professional Products Support
Financial Products
About Thomson Reuters
Careers
Online Products
Acquisitions Monthly
Buyouts
Venture Capital Journal
International Financing Review
Project Finance International
PEhub.com
PE Week
FindLaw
Reuters on Facebook
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
Other News on Wednesday, 11 August 2010 Kabul attack kills two as Afghan civilian casualites rise
Burning Russia battles to defend nuclear sites
Putin wants Russian satnav system in new cars from 2012
InterContinental Hotels to create 160,000 jobs worldwide
US Fed promises stimulus to help slowing recovery
US-TECH Summary
Central African Republic asks U.N. council for help
|
WHO declares swine flu pandemic is over
Florida to sue major LCD makers for price fixing
Libya to fund Gaza homes after Israel approves aid
U.N. panel on Gaza flotilla incident begins work
|
A long, hot Ramadan for many devout Muslims
Iran plans help to Lebanon army as U.S. blocks aid
US productivity dips for first time since 2008
UK's Cameron pledges crackdown on welfare fraud
|
Saudi watchdog backtracks on BlackBerry ban
WHO chief says swine flu pandemic is over
Netflix and Epix strike programming deal
Israel weighed all options in Gaza boat raid
Nvidia chip team gets 25 million dollars from US military
Human rights groups ask WikiLeaks to censor files
Indonesia to crack down on porn over Ramadan
UN: Afghan civilian deaths rise sharply this year
Australian opposition plans to scrap broadband network
N.Korea goes YouTube for propaganda
Chinese 'peel' widget converts Apple Touch to phone: report
RIM to share some BlackBerry codes with Saudis: source
|
First Guantanamo trial under Obama opens
Dell to sell tablet for $300 with AT&T contract
|
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Over-40 actresses dominate September magazine covers
Dubai 'hot spots' freeze over as Ramadan nears
Hundreds of Muslims attend anti-terror summer camp
Captain Underpants' creator returns with more poopypants
Julia Robert's new movie worth the weight
Radical Indonesia preacher could face death penalty
Teachers face death in Thailand's troubled south
Saudis hoping giant clock will set 'Mecca Time'
'Spider-Man' musical set to open on Broadway
|
Over-40 actresses dominate September magazine covers
|
Elvis' granddaughter eyes Mad Max role
|
NATO: Roadside bomb kills 3 Afghan civilians
Anger grows in Russia press over slack fire response
Pakistani militants urge rejection of Western aid
|
U.N. panel on Gaza flotilla incident begins work
Obama signs 'libel tourism' bill
Supermodel Campbell defends war crimes testimony
U.N. report says Afghan civilian toll up 31 percent
|
Downpours bring more worries for China landslide town
|
Euro football championship advance vital for Spurs
NZ soldier buried after death in Afghanistan
Signs of movement towards Middle East peace talks
New superbugs spreading from South Asia: study
Chelsea agree Carvalho fee with Real
Taliban blamed for sharp rise in Afghan casualties
Bomb kills eight Iraqi soldiers, wounds four
|
BP spill cases to be heard in New Orleans
Virus sends costly messages from Android phones
Naomi Campbell says nothing to gain from diamonds
|
Colombia's Santos, Venezuela's Chavez restore ties
|
"Mad Men" ratings plunge 24 percent
Australian leaders to face 'Battle of Rooty Hill'
Sri Lankan war probe opens
Vatican US child sex abuse cases 'falling apart'
Pakistani militants urge rejection of Western aid
Pakistani Taliban urge rejection of foreign flood aid
Global Weather-Celsius
India may decide BlackBerry fate on Thursday
|
Downpours bring more worries for China landslide town
China mudslide rescue hopes fade as toll tops 700
"Mad Men" ratings plunge 24 percent
"Heartbroken" Fantasia overdoses over married man affair
Racing against time to preserve India's Parsi past
Japan's machinery orders up 1.6 percent in June
Stars of "Eat Pray Love" say it changed lives
Fiji wants to replace Pacific allies with China
China's inflation up after devastating floods
Elvis' granddaughter eyes "Mad Max" role
S.Korea urges N.Korea to return boat
Britney Spears to have cameo in "Glee"
Toyota suspends auto exports to Iran
'Spider-Man' musical set to open on Broadway
Nepal court to rule on 'Himalayan Viagra' murders
Taiwan stocks end down; Acer falls on weak sales
Seoul shares slip as Hynix leads tech slide
CORRECTED
New Zealand farmers most confident in 2 years -survey
Most 'failed to brake' in runaway Toyota crashes
S.Korean bonds rise early after U.S. Fed move
Heartbroken Fantasia overdoses over married man affair
|
Stars of Eat Pray Love say it changed lives
|
Korea Hot Stocks
Jane Lynch confirmed to host SNL
|
Mad Men ratings plunge 24 percent
|
Virus sends costly messages from Android phones
Google Street View throws light on web privacy
Israel wasn't ready for flotilla resistance-general
Russia deploys air defence missiles in Abkhazia
Direct talks in sight as U.S. envoy sees Netanyahu
|
Plastic Logic scraps long-awaited e-reader QUE
Top Iraqi officer warns US must stay past 2011
Pakistan issues fresh flood warning
Russia deploys missiles to protect Georgia rebels
|
British unemployment shows biggest drop for three years
New superbugs spreading from South Asia: study
Militant attack kills 8 Iraqi soldiers, 3 others
Israel wasn't ready for flotilla resistance: general
|
Industrial demand boosts Adecco net profit
Bodies of 4 American medical workers headed home
Nestle profits grow ahead of expected slowdown
Lebanon says aid to army must be unconditional
|
Lebanon court asks evidence from Hezbollah head
|
Russia says fires burn Chernobyl-tainted forests
|
Rwanda's Kagame wins election by landslide
|
Italy opposition wants united front vs Berlusconi
|
Setback for BlackBerry in India
|
Germany to keep close eye on Google Street View
|
R&B guitarist Phelps "Catfish" Collins dead at 66
Apple says to replace overheating iPods in Japan
|
Teri Hatcher sued by former business associate
Wi-Lan settles patent litigation with UTStarcom
|
Beijing resumes radio exercise sessions
India's Bharti profit slides as price war bites
Pakistani stocks, rupee end lower; o/n rates up
Tug of war over Czech Art Nouveau gem
Plastic Logic scraps long-awaited e-reader QUE
|
Jane Lynch confirmed to host "SNL"
Apple Japan offers to replace overheating iPod nano
Seoul shares end down 1.3 pct on growth woes
US dollar falls to a 15-year low against the yen
Heartbroken Fantasia overdoses over married man affair
|
R&B guitarist Phelps Catfish Collins dead at 66
|
Tiger Woods' TV allure: the train wreck factor
|
Teri Hatcher sued by former business associate
|
Busy mogul Nick Cannon finds time for pillow talk with Mariah
|
Old Spice hunk exchanges roles in Tyler Perry films
|
Wi-Lan settles patent litigation with UTStarcom
Apple says to replace overheating iPods in Japan
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights