">Forum Views ()
">Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
White House memo challenges EPA finding on warming
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Search
Search:
White House memo challenges EPA finding on warming
By DINA CAPPIELLO,Associated Press Writer AP - Wednesday, May 13
WASHINGTON - An Environmental Protection Agency proposal that could lead to regulating the gases blamed for global warming will prove costly for factories, small businesses and other institutions, according to a White House document.
ADVERTISEMENT
The nine-page memo is a compilation of opinions made by a dozen federal agencies and departments during an internal review before the EPA issued a finding in April that greenhouse gases pose dangers to public health and welfare.
That finding could set in motion for the first time the regulation of six heat-trapping gases from cars and trucks, factories and other sources under the Clean Air Act.
The document, labeled "Deliberative-Attorney Client Privilege," says that if the EPA proceeds with the regulation of heat-trapping gases, including carbon dioxide, factories, small businesses and institutions would be subject to costly regulation.
"Making the decision to regulate carbon dioxide ... is likely to have serious economic consequences for regulated entities throughout the U.S. economy, including small businesses and small communities," the document says.
An official with the Office of Management and Budget, which compiled agency opinions on the EPA's proposed finding, said the cost critique came from the Office of Advocacy at the Small Business Administration. The official, who asked to remain anonymous to avoid harming the integrity of interagency reviews, said the SBA office was under the direction of a Bush administration official who had not yet been replaced.
On his blog Tuesday, OMB Director Peter Orszag reiterated that his office did not object to the EPA finding.
"The bottom line is that OMB would have not concluded review ... if we had concerns about whether EPA's finding was consistent with either the law or the underlying science," Orszag wrote.
When the Bush administration unveiled its proposal to use the Clean Air Act to regulate greenhouse gases, it released full comments from each individual agency _ many of which were critical. The Bush White House ultimately decided against using the Clean Air Act, saying it was an imperfect tool that would burden the economy.
Unlike Bush, Obama has offered an alternative _ a new law that would limit and put a price on greenhouse gas pollution.
"The president has, on many occasions, discussed the strong desire to instead seek a legislative solution for dangerous greenhouse gases," said White House press secretary Robert Gibbs.
New legislation, currently being considered by the House, would mostly pre-empt the agency from regulating greenhouse gases under existing law. The bill may also help mitigate some of the costs to businesses by distributing some of the permits for free.
Still, Republicans and business groups immediately used the document to bolster their arguments that controlling greenhouse gases would hurt the economy.
They also highlighted parts of the document that fault how the EPA reached its conclusion that greenhouse gases endanger human health and welfare, since the gases by themselves do not pose any harm.
The memo says the EPA could have been "more balanced" in its analysis by also highlighting regions of the country that would benefit from global warming, such as Alaska, which would have warmer winters. It also says the EPA seemed to stretch the precautionary principle to support regulation despite the "unprecedented uncertainty" in linking emissions of greenhouse gases and the warming that will result to health effects.
"It really appears to me that the decision was based more on political calculations than on scientific ones," said Sen. John Barrasso, R-Wyo., who called the document "a smoking gun" during a hearing Tuesday on the Obama administration's proposed EPA budget.
"The counsel in this administration repeatedly questions the lack of scientific support that you have for this proposed finding," he said.
EPA administrator Lisa Jackson responded by saying the EPA's finding in April was required by law, stemming from a 2007 Supreme Court decision that said the agency should classify greenhouse gases as pollutants. Jackson also said the agency's determination was preliminary and would not necessarily result in regulation.
"I have said over and over, as has the president, that we do understand that there are costs to the economy of addressing global warming emissions, and that the best way to address them is through a gradual move to a market-based program like cap and trade," Jackson said.
___
On the Net:
Office of Management and Budget blog: http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/blog/
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Sign in to recommend this article »
0 users recommend
Related Articles: Climate Change
Nations want oceans on agenda of climate talksAFP - Thursday, May 14
Coral Triangle could die by century's end: WWFAFP - Thursday, May 14
House Dems scale back plans to curb global warmingAP - Wednesday, May 13
White House memo challenges EPA finding on warmingAP - Wednesday, May 13
Related Articles: World
Geithner says financial system 'starting to heal'AFP - Thursday, May 14
Ex-Nazi guard fit enough to stay in jail: prisonAFP - Thursday, May 14
Britain faces 'slow' economic recovery: BoEAFP - Thursday, May 14
US journalist in Iran had secret report on Iraq warAFP - Thursday, May 14
Atlantis astronauts close in for Hubble captureAFP - Thursday, May 14
Related Full Coverage
climate change
climate change
All Full Coverage
Most Popular – World
Viewed
Australian zoo evacuated after orangutan escape
British store admits it boobed in bra row
Obese young men have less hope of marriage: study
Venezuela oil takeovers may leave 22,000 jobless
$70-80 good price for oil: French economy minister
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Thursday, 14 May 2009 Candidates set woo votes in murky IAEA election
| International
|
Nigerian militants warn oil firms to evacuate staff
| International
|
China arrests returned Tiananmen leader: family
| International
|
Craigslist to drop erotic services ads
| Technology
|
Electric bike adds style and speed to virtue
| Technology
|
O'Neal says Fawcett has had terrible time
| Entertainment
|
Pageant chief resigns after Prejean keeps crown
| Entertainment
|
Eminem's new Hollywood posse: Detroit auto workers
| Entertainment
|
Robin Williams hitting road after heart surgery
| Entertainment
|
Anna Nicole boyfriend pleads not guilty in drug case
| Entertainment
|
Sexy Venus may be oldest figurine yet discovered
| Entertainment
|
Alberta Pork Producers Offer Free Sandwiches To Convince Canadians Meat Is Safe
City Of Cleveland Orders Crosses, Decorations Be Removed From Graves
Mob Boss Daughter Victoria Gotti's Mansion Up For Foreclosure
Kate Winslet Still Wears Gold Ring "Titanic" Co-Star Leonardo DiCaprio Gave Her
Madonna Turns To Psychic 'Mama Love' For Advice
Joseph Fiennes' 'Cyrano' Prosthetic Nose Almost Causes Car Crash
After 22 Years On Death Row, DNA Evidence Frees Tennessee Man, Clearing Him Of Murder Charges
Serial Robber Of Apple Customers Nabbed In New York
Tattooed Australian Man Donating Skin To National Gallery
Oops: High School Prom Hands Out Shot Glasses As Souvenirs
Obama urges action to avert Sri Lanka catastrophe
| International
|
US urges probe into Afghan school poisonings
Myanmar's Suu Kyi to be charged over U.S. intruder
| International
|
Security Council voices concern over Gaza report
Chrisette Michelle Earns Her First #1 Debut On Billboard Albums Chart
Japan's Hatoyama in lead to head opposition party
| International
|
"The Addams Family" To Be Made Into Broadway Musical
North Korea to put U.S. journalists on trial in June
| International
|
Soldier charged in comrades' deaths showed stress
"House" Thirteen Olivia Wilde Tops Maxim Magazine's Hot 100 List
Geithner says financial system 'starting to heal'
Big blast in south Afghan border town: witnesses
| International
|
Lindsay Lohan's House Mess Not Caused By Burglars
Exit polls suggest India heading for weak coalition
| International
|
David Hasselhoff's Ex-Wife Wants Spousal Support Even After His Death
Mexico flu slowing, death toll not over 100
| International
|
EU fines Intel record 1.06 bln euros
Victoria Gotti's Mansion Up For Foreclosure
UAE nuclear deal may stall as U.S. condemns torture
| International
|
US foreclosures hit record high for second month
Lindsay Lohan's Home Targeted By Burglars
U.N. council voices concern about Gaza war report
| International
|
Trump Says Miss California Can Keep Crown
Carrie Prejean Keeps Title As Miss California USA
John Lennon's "Imagine" To Be Played At Liverpool Cathedral Bells
Ten Haitians killed as boat capsizes off Florida: US
Obama opposes Pentagon plan to release detainee abuse photos
Cell phones, TVs undo efficiency gains: study
| Technology
|
Brazil puts dictatorship files on the web
Verizon Wireless to sell HP netbook computers
| Technology
|
Web 'prime tool' for hate groups: Wiesenthal Center
US journalist in Iran had secret report on Iraq war
EU fines Intel record billion euros in new battle
French bill to combat Internet piracy clears final hurdle
Top US Democrat under fire over 'torture' briefings
Update: President Obama Gives Commencement Address At Arizona State University
UK Lobby group urges police probe into expense row
SKorea to spend $3.4 bln on green IT: officials
Aung San Suu Kyi, Maids To Be Tried Over Secret Visit Of American
Verizon, Frontier in 8.6 bln dlr land line deal
Virginia Prison Escapee Recaptured After 27 Years Of Hiding In Georgia
Former U.S. Navy Machinist Wins $12M Compensation In Asbestos Lawsuit
Spain's Mediapro sees sector mergers 'very shortly'
IEA urges more energy-efficient gadgets
Pope Calls For Palestine to be Own Country
Craigslist dropping 'erotic services' ads
Bomb Squad Clearing Booby Trapped California Home, Former Resident Arrested
Famed TED talks available in multiple languages
Craigslist Changing 'Erotic Ads' List With 'Adult Services' Section
IEA urges more energy-efficient gadgets
H1N1 Spreads To 3 New Countries; Alert Level Unchanged
Dems Fail To Close Debate On Interior Nominee
Intel To Appeal $1.45 Billion E.U. Fine For Unfair Competition
Japanese royals arrive for visit to Bulgaria
S.Korea march into Sudirman Cup badminton semis
Polls put Congress ahead as India's vote ends
China, Hong Kong confirm second swine flu cases
China confirms second case of swine flu
Martin Scorsese to direct Frank Sinatra movie
| Entertainment
|
Hong Kong confirms second case of swine flu
Bruce Springsteen keeps his bar band on its toes
| Entertainment
|
Queen, Paul Rodgers split up
| Entertainment
|
NKorea increases activity around plutonium plant
American Idol ousts Gokey as finale looms
| Entertainment
|
Malaysia police to shame thieves
Reeve's Superman costume up for auction
Oprah apologizes for slamming author James Frey
| Entertainment
|
Empire State Building becomes green giant
24 star promises show will finally get real
| Entertainment
|
Asia-Pacific poll shows pessimism on economy
US on track to be top investor in Vietnam
Ol' Blue Eyes is back: Scorsese to make Sinatra biopic
India's DLF raises almost $800 mln in share sale
Elvis shakes up iPhone
Bank of America sells China bank stake for $7.3 bln
Pixar chief looks to 3D as storyteller's new ally
Daimler says it will close Japan, Thailand plants
Weisz, Jackman set for Western epic
Spacey to play disgraced lobbyist Abramoff
Pakistan sees $10 bln in foreign investments by Sept
Simon Rattle to stay at Berlin Philharmonic til 2018
Bank chief tapped for Indonesian VP candidate
Japan cellphone sales log record drop
Nicole Kidman pulls out of Woody Allen film: report
Japan's NTT posts big profit despite recession
Barber of Seville comes to Libya
WRAPUP 1-S.Korea job losses decline but worst may not be over
Communist party gains as Japan economy sinks
Thousands cross lagoon to flee Sri Lanka fighting
| International
|
Afghan suicide attack kills one policeman
Pakistan will defeat Taliban, must win hearts: PM
| International
|
Pope celebrates mass in Nazareth
Pope, in Nazareth, says world needs family values
| International
|
China's Zhao decries June 4 tragedy from the grave
| International
|
Mubarak to Israel: Progress before recognition
British sleaze row claims first political casualties
| International
|
H1N1 flu cases, death toll rise: WHO
| International
|
Netanyahu sees Abdullah in prelude to Obama talks
| International
|
Nations want oceans on agenda of climate talks
House Dems scale back plans to curb global warming
Spielberg makes videogames to keep his family happy
| Technology
|
Atlantis astronauts set for first Hubble spacewalk
White House memo challenges EPA finding on warming
Massachusetts stops transit drivers carrying cell phones
| Technology
|
Shuttle astronauts capture Hubble Space Telescope
Konica Minolta to expand LCD film offerings
| Technology
|
BT to axe up to 15,000 more jobs after losses
Electric bike adds style and speed to virtue
| Technology
|
Ailing Farrah Fawcett shaved own hair in video diary
| Entertainment
|
Slumdog child star's Mumbai shanty home torn down
| Entertainment
|
Thai buyers' confidence hits new low in April
Russia to build 12 fighters for Vietnam: report
Tatas rue global ambitions as troubles pile up
NEC to exit Japan-backed supercomputer project
S.Korea may tighten policy before yr-end -KDI
US lawmakers target China currency policy
Seoul shares open lower; MSCI shares up
NZ manufacturing falls for 12th month in April
In Peru's jungles, drugs offer youths a way out
Nations want oceans on agenda of climate talks
US charity's 'choc' treatment getting kids to read
Zimbabwe emigrant's tale steals show
Art market claims to detect signs of life
World's consumers heed environmental needs: study
Christie's art auction nets 94 mln dlrs
Iraqi archaeologists dig Chicago museum
Robin Williams Jokes About "Cow Valve" In His Heart
Michael Jackson's Pale Skin "Glows In The Dark"
Virginia Prison Escapee Recaptured After 27 Years Of Hiding In Georgia
Bomb Squad Clearing Booby Trapped California Home, Former Resident Arrested
Chicago Seventh-Graders Create Mathematics iPhone App
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights