Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
FACT CHECK: Obama uses iffy math on deficit pledge
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
Yahoo! Search
Search:
Sign InNew User? Sign Up
News Home -
Help
Navigation
Primary Navigation
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Secondary Navigation
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Search
Search:
FACT CHECK: Obama uses iffy math on deficit pledge
By CALVIN WOODWARD and ERICA WERNER,Associated Press Writers AP - Thursday, September 10
WASHINGTON - President Barack Obama used only-in-Washington accounting Wednesday when he promised to overhaul the nation's health care system without adding "one dime" to the deficit. By conventional arithmetic, Democratic plans would drive up the deficit by billions of dollars.
ADVERTISEMENT
The president's speech to Congress contained a variety of oversimplifications and omissions in laying out what he wants to do about health insurance.
A look at some of Obama's claims and how they square with the facts or the fuller story:
___
OBAMA: "I will not sign a plan that adds one dime to our deficits either now or in the future. Period."
THE FACTS: Though there's no final plan yet, the White House and congressional Democrats already have shown they're ready to skirt the no-new-deficits pledge.
House Democrats offered a bill that the Congressional Budget Office said would add $220 billion to the deficit over 10 years. But Democrats and Obama administration officials claimed the bill actually was deficit-neutral. They said they simply didn't have to count $245 billion of it _ the cost of adjusting Medicare reimbursement rates so physicians don't face big annual pay cuts.
Their reasoning was that they already had decided to exempt this "doc fix" from congressional rules that require new programs to be paid for. In other words, it doesn't have to be paid for because they decided it doesn't have to be paid for.
The administration also said that since Obama already had included the doctor payment in his 10-year budget proposal, it didn't have to be counted again.
That aside, the long-term prognosis for costs of the health care legislation has not been good.
CBO Director Douglas Elmendorf had this to say in July: "We do not see the sort of fundamental changes that would be necessary to reduce the trajectory of federal health spending by a significant amount."
___
OBAMA: "Nothing in this plan will require you or your employer to change the coverage or the doctor you have."
THE FACTS: That's correct, as far as it goes. But neither can the plan guarantee that people can keep their current coverage. Employers sponsor coverage for most families, and they'd be free to change their health plans in ways that workers may not like, or drop insurance altogether. The Congressional Budget Office analyzed the health care bill written by House Democrats and said that by 2016 some 3 million people who now have employer-based care would lose it because their employers would decide to stop offering it.
In the past Obama repeatedly said, "If you like your health care plan, you'll be able to keep your health care plan, period." Now he's stopping short of that unconditional guarantee by saying nothing in the plan "requires" any change.
___
OBAMA: "The reforms I'm proposing would not apply to those who are here illegally." One congressman, South Carolina Republican Joe Wilson, shouted "You lie!" from his seat in the House chamber when Obama made this assertion. Wilson later apologized.
THE FACTS: The facts back up Obama. The House version of the health care bill explicitly prohibits spending any federal money to help illegal immigrants get health care coverage. Illegal immigrants could buy private health insurance, as many do now, but wouldn't get tax subsidies to help them. Still, Republicans say there are not sufficient citizenship verification requirements to ensure illegal immigrants are excluded from benefits they are not due.
___
OBAMA: "Don't pay attention to those scary stories about how your benefits will be cut. ... That will never happen on my watch. I will protect Medicare."
THE FACTS: Obama and congressional Democrats want to pay for their health care plans in part by reducing Medicare payments to providers by more than $500 billion over 10 years. The cuts would largely hit hospitals and Medicare Advantage, the part of the Medicare program operated through private insurance companies.
Although wasteful spending in Medicare is widely acknowledged, many experts believe some seniors almost certainly would see reduced benefits from the cuts. That's particularly true for the 25 percent of Medicare users covered through Medicare Advantage.
Supporters contend that providers could absorb the cuts by improving how they operate and wouldn't have to reduce benefits or pass along costs. But there's certainly no guarantee they wouldn't.
___
OBAMA: Requiring insurance companies to cover preventive care like mammograms and colonoscopies "makes sense, it saves money, and it saves lives."
THE FACTS: Studies have shown that much preventive care _ particularly tests like the ones Obama mentions _ actually costs money instead of saving it. That's because detecting acute diseases like breast cancer in their early stages involves testing many people who would never end up developing the disease. The costs of a large number of tests, even if they're relatively cheap, will outweigh the costs of caring for the minority of people who would have ended up getting sick without the testing.
The Congressional Budget Office wrote in August: "The evidence suggests that for most preventive services, expanded utilization leads to higher, not lower, medical spending overall."
That doesn't mean preventive care doesn't make sense or save lives. It just doesn't save money.
___
OBAMA: "If you lose your job or change your job, you will be able to get coverage. If you strike out on your own and start a small business, you will be able to get coverage."
THE FACTS: It's not just a matter of being able to get coverage. Most people would have to get coverage under the law, if his plan is adopted.
In his speech, Obama endorsed mandatory coverage for individuals, an approach he did not embrace as a candidate.
He proposed during the campaign _ as he does now _ that larger businesses be required to offer insurance to workers or else pay into a fund. But he rejected the idea of requiring individuals to obtain insurance. He said people would get insurance without being forced to do so by the law, if coverage were made affordable. And he repeatedly criticized his Democratic primary rival, Hillary Rodham Clinton, for proposing to mandate coverage.
"To force people to get health insurance, you've got to have a very harsh penalty," he said in a February 2008 debate.
Now, he says, "individuals will be required to carry basic health insurance _ just as most states require you to carry auto insurance."
He proposes a hardship waiver, exempting from the requirement those who cannot afford coverage despite increased federal aid.
___
OBAMA: "There are now more than 30 million American citizens who cannot get coverage."
THE FACTS: Obama time and again has referred to the number of uninsured as 46 million, a figure based on year-old Census data. The new number is based on an analysis by the Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured, which concluded that about two-thirds of Americans without insurance are poor or near poor. "These individuals are less likely to be offered employer-sponsored coverage or to be able to afford to purchase their own coverage," the report said. By using the new figure, Obama avoids criticism that he is including individuals, particularly healthy young people, who choose not to obtain health insurance.
___
Associated Press writer Jim Kuhnhenn contributed to this report.
Email Story
IM Story
Printable View
Blog This
Sign in to recommend this article »
0 users recommend
Related Articles: World
Health care issues: Medical malpractice lawsuitsAP - 1 hour 47 minutes ago
Number without health insurance at 46.3 millionAP - 1 hour 51 minutes ago
DOD lawyer stops short of assuring Gitmo closingAP - 1 hour 54 minutes ago
Space tourist uses $35M trip to back water issuesAP - 1 hour 56 minutes ago
221 missing after Sierra Leone boat capsizesAP - 1 hour 57 minutes ago
Most Popular – World
Viewed
Greenspan says further financial crisis 'inevitable'
Giant statues reveal red hat secrets: study
Refurbished Hubble reveals cosmic wonder
Anti-piracy equipment dazzles defence fair
Hershey considers rival Cadbury bid: report
View Complete List »
Search:
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Top Stories
Most Popular
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy
- Terms of Service
- Community
- Intellectual Property Rights Policy
- Help
Other News on Thursday, 10 September 2009 As violence ebbs, Baghdad revives a watery romance
Home power plants project unveiled in Germany
Hitler AIDS ad pulled from YouTube
OPEC ministers reach 'consensus' to hold output: Kuwait
Mexican hijack over, passengers safe
| International
|
X-rated movies household phenomena in France
Venezuela's Chavez wants 'union' with ally Belarus
Greenspan says further financial crisis 'inevitable'
US manned space program 'too expensive'
Rare medieval Hebrew prayer book to go on display
Facebook blocked for Indonesia city employees: official
Chavez visits Russia to discuss arms, energy deals
| International
|
Berlin's electronics fair pushes greener future
Iraqi officials cleared of British troop murders
Iran's Mousavi urges calm despite arrests: website
| International
|
EU cracks down on 'cheating' electronics e-traders
Nokia to skip operator tailoring for Linux phones
Seven killed in Iraq car bomb blunder: police
Beatles re-mastered CDs, videogame launched
Iran presents proposals as West ups nuclear pressure
Nokia to skip operator tailoring for Linux phones
80 killed in Sierra Leone boat wreck: police
| International
|
Iran delivers nuclear proposals to world powers
Ally of Iran's Mousavi detained, websites say
Recent kidnappings of foreigners in Afghanistan
Thai police chief resigns after forced transfer
Thin-looking Steve Jobs returns to Apple stage
| Technology
|
Can Beatles revive video game industry?
| Technology
|
Myanmar says Chinese tip-off led to border clash
China couples flock to marry on auspicious 09/09/09
Obama near choosing cyber security chief: source
| Technology
|
Asian governments pledge shift to greener industry
Chinese media say 13 killed in gold mine fire
Nation's oldest nuclear plant showing its age
N.Korea intentionally caused flood: Seoul minister
NYT reporter freed in raid; Afghan translator dies
Federal judge says wolf hunts OK in Idaho, Montana
Convicted ex-priest challenges repressed memories
Cambodia PM ratchets up tirade against tribunal
Garrison Keillor hospitalized after minor stroke
WHO warns of winter swine flu surge in Asia
Methodology for AP poll on health care
Settlement sought for teen cleared in twin's death
Obama to make case for big U.S. healthcare changes
Move over, Rush: Ex-US Rep. Foley has radio show
NY Times: Reporter freed as situation worsened
Minn. town mourns toddler's baseball bat slaying
Lindsay Lohan named Ungaro fashion 'muse'
De Niro, Springsteen among 2009 Kennedy honorees
Ungaro hires Lindsay Lohan as fashion adviser
Bollywood embraces disability in quest for realism
Mitsubishi delays delivery of Japan's first passenger jet
Sweden's Koenigsegg teams up with China's BAIC to buy Saab
'Sick leave' strike grounds India's Jet Airways
Taiwan ministers culled after typhoon criticisms
List of CMA nominations
S.Korea, US sign $45m weather supercomputer deal
Beatlemania is back: fans grab remastered albums, video game
S.Korea firm to buy Inmet stake for $363 mln-paper
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
WRAPUP 2-S.Korea house loans raise stakes for central bank
De Niro, Springsteen among 2009 Kennedy honorees
S.Korea market sees hefty rate rise by year-end -analyst
Meet the teams on new season of 'The Amazing Race'
Ungaro hires Lindsay Lohan as fashion adviser
| Entertainment
|
Is Chevron scared of Crude the movie?
| Entertainment
|
Bobby and Jackie; a modern American Greek tragedy
Indonesia's Aceh to stone adulterers under Islamic law
Clooney, Fantastic Mr. Fox to open London festival
Brad Paisley nominated for six Country Music Awards
| Entertainment
|
Ungaro hires Lindsay Lohan as fashion adviser
De Niro, Springsteen among 2009 Kennedy honorees
| Entertainment
|
Marriott plans 21 new Asian hotels amid global downturn
Bollywood embraces disability in quest for realism
Bobby and Jackie; a modern American Greek tragedy
| Entertainment
|
Clooney, Fantastic Mr. Fox to open London festival
| Entertainment
|
Questions raised over Afghan raid to free journalist
El Salvador police hold 4 in journalist murder probe
US-TECH Summary
OPEC holds oil output unchanged: statement
17 dead in Iraq truck bomb attack: police
Polo Rugby line launches iPhone app for custom shirts
Stormy Iraq-Syria talks on militants issue
OPEC oil states meet on economy, climate
Truck bomb in northern Iraq kills 19
| International
|
NATO chief defends 'progress' as Afghan criticism mounts
Google expects increasing video in search ads
Refurbished Hubble reveals cosmic wonder
Google defends book deal as competitive, helpful
Google developing payment platform for newspapers: Nieman
OPEC 'optimistic' worst of recession over: president
'I'm vertical. I'm back,' says Apple's Jobs
U.N. envoy Bill Clinton chides donors over Haiti aid
| International
|
Heaviest rains in 80 years kill 31 in Turkey
Netanyahu risks US anger by building settlements
US voices bomb fears as Iran submits nuclear proposals
Iran presents proposals as West ups nuclear pressure
Challengers say vote fraud will hurt Afghanistan
Sugar shortage makes Pakistani PM take sweets off menu
| International
|
Steve Jobs strides back onto Apple stage
| Technology
|
Frenchman makes history at NATO supreme command
Polo Rugby line launches iPhone app for custom shirts
| Technology
|
U.S. cuts off $11 million in aid to Honduras
NYT reporter freed; Afghan aide killed in rescue
Obama issues bold demand for health care action
Taiwan names ministers in post-typhoon reshuffle
Google defends book deal as competitive, helpful
| Technology
|
Analysis: Obama gambles on making nice, no vetoes
U.S. Democrats seek to build healthcare momentum
Karzai backs Afghan election commission
Obama credits McCain on health coverage plan
Tension as under-fire Thai police chief quits
Japan's next leaders form governing coalition
US military deaths in Afghanistan region at 745
Google expects increasing video in search ads
| Technology
|
German general backs officer in Afghan airstrike
Individuals would have to carry health insurance
Severed hand, torso found in valley near LA
Texas couple pleads guilty in Afghanistan fraud
CBS renews "Big Brother"
S.Korea says in stake talks with copper miner Inmet
Economic jitters hit OPEC oil cartel at talks
Seoul shares rise; reaction to rate decision muted
Seoul shares gain; eyes on rate decision, comments
S.Korean bond futures up ahead of rate vote
Japan's Suntory eyes Orangina: report
CHRONOLOGY-S.Korea c.bank holds rates for 7th mth
NZ central bank holds key interest rate steady
NZ c.bank less inclined to cut rates, recovery fragile
RPT-SCENARIOS-NZ cen bank to hold rate, eyes on policy stance
Miami-set "Wartime" a bold comedy about forgiving
Source: DeGeneres is new 'American Idol' judge
Romero's new zombie picture is deathly fun
AP NewsAlert
Chevron taken to task in "Crude" documentary
Ungaro hires Lindsay Lohan for fashion "electro-shock
Hugh Hefner files for divorce from wife
Whitney Houston's comeback tops U.S. pop chart
Hugh Hefner files for divorce from wife
| Entertainment
|
Documentary to focus on Obama's mother
U.S. release planned for Linklater's Orson Welles
| Entertainment
|
CBS' `Big Brother' gaining in viewers
Ellen DeGeneres joins American Idol as 4th judge
| Entertainment
|
Is Chevron scared of Crude the movie?
| Entertainment
|
CBS renews Big Brother
| Entertainment
|
Whitney Houston's comeback tops U.S. pop chart
| Entertainment
|
Truck bomb in north Iraq Kurd village kills 20
Venezuela's Chavez in Russia for arms, energy talks
Taliban presence seen across almost all Afghanistan
| International
|
GM to sell Opel to Canada's Magna: Merkel
Google plans new mirror for cheaper solar power
Netanyahu draws fire in Israel over secret trip
Hong Kong named world's spam capital
Lebanon's Hariri abandons effort to form government
| International
|
Iraq market bombs kill four, wound 29
Iran commander says 36 died in vote unrest: report
| International
|
Backlash over journalist's rescue in Afghanistan
Victims of Cambodian forced evictions speak out
| International
|
No suspension of uranium enrichment: Iran
Fraud watchdog annuls votes in Afghan election
| International
|
Plot thickens over Israeli PM's secret trip
Iran official says 36 killed in post-vote unrest
Israel: anti-assimilation ads yanked over uproar
Netanyahu draws fire in Israel over secret trip
| International
|
NATO probe faults officer over Afghan raid: report
Venezuela's Chavez recognizes Georgian rebel regions
| International
|
Kazakh leader asked to stay for life
| International
|
Dozens more feared dead in Sierra Leone boat wreck
| International
|
Google plans new mirror for cheaper solar power
| Technology
|
Japan's death row conditions 'breed insanity'
Chinese woman spends $600,000 on dog: report
NKorea seeks 'fruitful' ties with Japan's next govt
Labor Department exposes goods made by child labor
North Korea eyes fruitful ties with next Japan PM
Report: Gov't agency waives rules for shippers
Challenges face Aquino son in bid for presidency
FACT CHECK: Obama uses iffy math on deficit pledge
Oil majors propping up Myanmar regime: rights group
Analysis: Obama willing to deep-six public option
Lawmakers denounce 'You lie' outburst at Obama
Japan must end Afghan mission: coalition party
Obama: Statistics show need for overhauling health
Japan town presses on with annual dolphin hunt
Samoans stranded with buses off roads
Commonwealth envoy barred from Fiji opposition meet
Museum scours world for new videos of 9/11 attacks
Trade, jobless claims figures show recession fades
Ellen DeGeneres named 4th 'American Idol' judge
Taiwan to resume trade talks with China 'soon'
MARKET SIGNALS-Taiwan equities set for bigger bounce
China's premier says too early to end stimulus
Bank of Korea keeps key rate at record low
China cool on idea of 'G2' with US: Beijing envoy
Pakistani forex reserves slip to $14.24 bln
Jackson concert line-up still unsure, brother says
| Entertainment
|
Seoul shares rise; KOSPI shrugs off BOK comments =2
Muslim women get pig-free cosmetics
TABLE-Foreign trading in Taiwan stocks 6th highest ever
Future, past useless at my age, says actor Sharif
| Entertainment
|
China shares fall on profit-taking
China action to control online music: state media
Asia rebound after crisis points to new order
Slovak first law sparks war of words with Hungary
In Venice, India's Mehra tackles outdated mindset
Indonesia warns Australia on war crimes probe
Aussie daredevils kite-surf notorious Bass Strait
Australia says no Indonesia rift over 'Balibo' probe
Ellen DeGeneres named new judge of 'Idol'
Prince Charles under fire over architecture campaign
CBS renews "Big Brother"
U.S. release planned for Linklater's "Orson Welles"
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights