InfoAnda - Bangladeshi pioneer of microfinancing faces charges of 'aid anomalies'

Pakistanis angry over detentions in Times Sq. case
Monday, May 24, 2010
ISLAMABAD – Relatives of three men detained by Pakistan for alleged links to the suspect in the attempted Times Square bombing say the men are innocent.
They

Taiwan denies boycotting Australian film festival
Thursday, August 6, 2009

AFP - Thursday, August 6TAIPEI (AFP) - - Taiwan's Beijing-friendly government on Wednesday denied boycotting an Australian film festival amid a row over the e

Merkel's support dips, regional ally resigns International
Thursday, September 3, 2009

By Sarah Marsh and Noah Barkin

BERLIN (Reuters) - Chancellor Angela Merkel suffered a double blow on Thursday as a senior party ally in east German

Minister seeks closure of anti-Berlusconi websites
Wednesday, December 16, 2009
ROME (AFP) - – The Italian government moved Tuesday to close down Internet sites encouraging further violence against Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi, who

Asian markets mixed after Wall Street rally
Wednesday, March 18, 2009

By ELAINE KURTENBACH,AP Business Writer AP - Wednesday, March 18SHANGHAI - Asia's stock market rally seemed to be running out of steam Wednesday, despite an

China's far-west city held in check on bloody anniversary | 5 July 2010
NZ investors seen cheered by election result | 8 November 2008
East Asia agrees on strategy to fight swine flu | 8 May 2009

Federal Government To Conduct Stress Test On Major U.S. Banks | 27 February 2009

Forum Views () Forum Replies ()

Read more with google mobile : Bangladeshi pioneer of microfinancing faces charges of 'aid anomalies'

Yahoo! My Yahoo! Mail More Yahoo! Services Account Options New User? Sign Up Sign In Help Yahoo! Search web search Home Singapore Asia Pacific World Business Entertainment Sports Technology Weekend Edition Australia China India Indonesia Japan Malaysia Philippines Thailand Vietnam Bangladeshi pioneer of microfinancing faces charges of 'aid anomalies' ANN - Friday, December 3 Send IM Story Print Dhaka (The Daily Star/ANN) - Norway says it is examining allegations that Grameen Bank, founded by Nobel Peace Laureate Muhammad Yunus, has diverted millions of dollars of aid money to one of its sister concerns, reports BBC online. International development minister Erik Solheim said that it was "totally unacceptable that aid is used for other purposes than intended". A documentary maker has alleged that cash was diverted from Grameen Bank to other parts of Grameen. In a statement, the Bank said that the allegations were false. It said that a full explanation with more details would be provided at the "earliest convenient time". Our staff correspondent adds: The documentary has alleged that Grameen Bank (GB) had transferred about US$100 million it received from donors to Grameen Kalyan in 1996 and then got back the money as loan in breach of agreement. This led to a spat between the Norwegian government and Grameen Bank. But Dr Muhammad Yunus, who pioneered microfinancing through the Grameen Bank and won Nobel Peace Prize for it in 2006, has defended himself saying this had been done to ensure maximum transparency and responsible use of the Bank's revolving fund. The documentary, titled Fanget i Mikrogjeld (Caught in Micro debt), was aired on Tuesday (November 30) on the National Norwegian Television, NRK. The whole episode took place about one and a half decades ago. And then it was presumably ironed out, as the documentary showed a compromise had been reached concerning transfer of the funds Norway granted to Grameen Bank. Under the agreed compromise, 170 million Norwegian kroners ($27.9 million) was transferred back to GB. Contacted, Grameen Bank said the allegations of fund misuse are false. It will release a detailed statement on the affairs soon. The Bank is already working on the issue, but since the incident took place about 14 years ago, it is taking some time to get all the facts together. The documentary claimed the Norwegian embassy in Dhaka at a meeting with the Bank at its office on Dec 3, 1997 came to know about the May 7, 1997 agreement between Grameen Bank and Grameen Kalyan, which became effective on Dec 31, 1996 for transfer of funds of 3.914 billion taka (US$55 million). In a letter to Yunus on Dec 15, 1997, the embassy said: "In line with the agreement, Grameen Bank transferred all funds accumulated up to Dec 31, 1996 received from donors for revolving funds, to Grameen Kalyan, which at the same date transferred the amount to Grameen Bank as a loan. 1.927 billion taka (US$27 million) of the amount was related to the revolving fund for housing loans. Grameen Kalyan is in fact a spin-off created in 1996 by Grameen Bank, which set up an internal fund called Social Advancement Fund (SAF) by imputing interest on all the grant money it received from various donors. SAF has been converted into a separate company to carry out social advance activities related to education, health and technology among Grameen borrowers. It has 30 health clinics across the country. Most of these clinics are attached to Grameen Bank branches. The letter, signed by Ambassador Hans Fredrik Lehne, said: "The agreement concerning these transactions has not made provisions for any interest rates to be charged for this part of the loan, nor any terms of repayment." The agreement was signed between the governments of Norway and Bangladesh on Nov 30, 1994 to support Grameen Bank's Phase IV project. Annex 1, clause 4 of the agreement said: "The amount of the Grant used for housing loans will be used as a revolving fund." The Norwegian embassy was concerned that it had not been informed about the agreement between the two organisations. It said: "The agreement was contrary to the quoted clause of the agreement between the governments." It also observed that the accounts of Grameen Bank as of Dec 31, 1996 did not reflect any revolving fund for housing loan in operation under the Bank. The embassy said "the ownership of Grameen Kalyan is of another nature, and Norway has not entered into an agreement with Bangladesh to provide funds to Grameen Kalyan for lending to Grameen Bank". "The agreement has further left uncertainty about future repayment of the loan to Grameen Kalyan, since it is not regulated by the agreement. "The agreement is also silent about Grameen Bank's use of the loan from Grameen Kalyan." The embassy in that consequence considered the agreement between Grameen Bank and Grameen Kalyan "as a change which affects two agreements between the two governments to support Grameen Bank". It also requested Yunus to explain in writing "why Grameen Bank entered into the agreement with Grameen Kalyan, and of the consequences for the owners of Grameen Bank and the beneficiaries of the housing loans". In a letter to the head of Norad in 1998, Yunus wrote: "Some misunderstanding has crept up between us and Norad/Dhaka. Norwegian embassy/Dhaka has written a letter to the government of Bangladesh making an allegation that Grameen is transferring donor money (including that of Norad) to various enterprises outside of Grameen Bank. This allegation will create a lot of misunderstanding within the government of Bangladesh." Interestingly, the news about this spat between Norway and Grameen Bank was publicised as if Nobel Peace Prize winner Yunus had himself pocketed the donor money, which is totally removed from the fact. The fact remains that he never had gained from this transfer. The money was transferred just as a matter of organisational accounting to another sister company to carry out the same task - fighting poverty. Grameen Bank's response as written by Yunus to the allegations was also not carried by newspapers. In his reply to the Norwegian ambassador , Yunus said the agreement between Grameen Bank and Grameen Kalyan was made so that Grameen's financial resources and assets could be managed more professionally and effectively to get the maximum benefits for Grameen's customers. Grameen Kalyan was established as a separate legal entity to accelerate the pace of social and economic development of Grameen's targeted clientele and also to ensure continued access to loans and other financial services they have been getting from Grameen Bank, he explained. Yunus said the agreement to transfer funds from the Bank to Kalyan was to ensure maximum transparency and responsible use of the revolving fund. He argued that in earlier system, the money would have been owned by the Grameen Bank which would use it on a revolving basis. Under the changed situation, he argued, the money will be used for the same purpose but GB will now receive it as a loan from separate legal entity. The idea of revolving fund was to ensure its continuous reuse for the same purpose and to harness maximum benefit in terms of servicing more clients, Muhammad Yunus said, adding: "But since in the earlier approach the fund was available within the same management structure, in spite of the policy compulsion to revolve it, there remained the possibility that the required financial discipline to recover the money and exercise appropriate caution to effectively monitor the loan operation, may not be enforced." This led them to find an alternative method though GK to implement the intention and the spirit of the revolving fund concept. The revolving fund has got an institutional structure so that it can never be absorbed by multifarious other demands of the Bank, he said, adding further that the GK can be viewed as a company set up exclusively to manage the revolving fund. "We believe that the new arrangement does not in any way violate any of the clauses of the agreement between Norway and GOB, rather it strengthens professionally the financial operation of GB for eradication of poverty," Dr Yunus said. He further said that the GB board of directors took the decision within the scope of the agreement with the donors. "It in no way threatened to interfere with the successful utilisation of the grant [and] that is why we did not think of informing the donors." On charging interest for the housing portion of the loan given to GB, Dr Yunus said, the GK management consciously decided to avoid charging the interest to keep the interest burden low on the ultimate borrowers. "Adding interest on this loan would have made the fund costly for the GB to transfer it to the borrowers at the existing rate of 8 per cent." He, however, added: the issue of adding interest can be reviewed if deemed appropriate by the lending and borrowing organisation. Prof Yunus said the decision to transfer the money, instead of adversely affecting the owners, has enhanced their interests "by ensuring more efficient and prudent fund management and accountability on the part of GB". "This process of mutual obligation and accountability on the part of two organisations has enhanced the immunity of the fund from being eroded due to lack of accountability if handed by a single organisation as was done prior to its transfer to Grameen Kalyan." The grant money received from different donors reckoned has increased the liquidity of the loanable funds for Grameen Bank, he added. Dr Yunus also wrote the ambassador that establishment of GK with endowment fund from GB has broadened the scope for them to address the issue of eradication of poverty and hunger by undertaking different projects and activities. The profits and income earned by Kalyan, he said, offer the scope for such initiatives to be undertaken for the poor, he said, adding that it was the initial purpose of creating the Social Advancement Fund. Recommend Send IM Story Print Related Articles Samsung promotes chairman's son, daughter AFP - 25 minutes ago Japan confirms 1st high-risk bird flu on farm since '07 Reuters - 49 minutes ago Execs in India bribery probe ordered to judicial custody Reuters - 1 hour 17 minutes ago Christie's sets Hong Kong auction record AFP - 1 hour 35 minutes ago Triple despair in Asia as World Cup goes to Qatar AFP - 1 hour 50 minutes ago News Search Top Stories Fears grow over length of US jobs crisis NASA finds new form of life... on Earth Suspect in Hollywood PR shooting commits suicide Forest fire inferno kills 40 in northern Israel Ouattara named winner of I.Coast election More Top Stories » ADVERTISEMENT Most Popular Most Viewed Most Recommended Finger length predicts prostate cancer risk: study NASA finds new form of life... on Earth 'Critical safety issue' with Rolls A380 engine FA condemn pitch invasion on eve of 2018 vote ECB extends bank loans, holds fire on bond buying More Most Viewed » Pilgrims stone 'devil' as Muslims celebrate Eid World leaders scramble for funds to save the tiger US, S.Korea plan war games after N.Korean attack Obama gets 12 stitches after 'elbow in the lip' More Most Recommended » Elsewhere on Yahoo! Financial news on Yahoo! Finance Stars and latest movies Best travel destinations More on Yahoo! News Home Singapore Asia Pacific World Business Entertainment Sports Technology Weekend Edition Subscribe to our news feeds Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS » More news feeds | What are news feeds? Also on Yahoo! Answers Groups Mail Messenger Mobile Travel Finance Movies Sports Games » All Yahoo! Services Site Highlights Singapore Full Coverage Most Popular Entertainment Photos Yahoo! News Network Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved. Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | Community | Intellectual Property Rights Policy | Help

Other News on Friday, 3 December 2010
Snow batters Europe and Britain grinds to halt
Karzai says coalition killed former local official
Gowalla app syncs with Foursquare and Facebook
Lawyer for WikiLeaks' Assange denies warrant valid |
Forest fire inferno kills 40 in northern Israel
Swedish police to issue new warrant for WikiLeaks head
US space agency finds new form of life... on Earth
Acer sees shortages as smartphone demand surprises
Ouattara named winner of I.Coast election
Time Warner's Bewkes skeptical of Netflix plan
Protest in Haiti capital demands rerun of elections |
ECB extends bank loans, holds fire on bond buying
US jobless claims tick up
Egypt says may seek atomic arms if Iran does: WikiLeaks cables |
ECB to continue buying government bonds: Trichet
Motorola mobile division expects first quarter loss
Huge Israel forest fire kills dozens: rescue services |
South Sudan army says northern ambush kills 12 |
China says hard to keep 'friendly' Norway ties after Nobel
Boos, jeers as Australia misses out on 2022
Tokyo pledges future bid for World Cup
Kyoto feud casts shadow on climate talks
Thai police link forgery arrests to huge terror cell
Taiwan to retire one in four generals
US cables reveal bribe fears in Thai Bout arms case
Chinese artist Ai Weiwei blocked from leaving China
UN atomic watchdog has 'great concern' over N.Korea
Ebay buys local shopping website Milo |
Google: satellite platform to aid forest efforts |
RIM buys Swedish firm to improve screen design |
Clearwire plans to sell over $1.1 billion in debt |
DirecTV to add more than 200,000 U.S. subs in Q4 |
Aretha Franklin to undergo surgery, reason undisclosed |
Ellen DeGeneres would be best holiday party guest: poll |
US-TECH Summary
RIM buys Swedish firm to improve screen design
DirecTV to add more than 200,000 U.S. subs in Q4
Google alters algorithm to combat abusive sellers
Diller out as IAC CEO, Liberty sells stake
Chinese army must deal with cyberwarfare: state media
Motorola mobile division expects first quarter loss
Google: satellite platform to aid forest efforts
UK forces in Helmand 'made mess of things': WikiLeaks
South Korea will bomb North if attacked again |
Ebay buys local shopping site Milo
US alarmed at 'corrupt, paranoid' Afghans: leaks
Ivory Coast poll winner named, army seals borders |
Lawyer for WikiLeaks's Assange denies warrant valid |
US congressman plans 'Do Not Track' bill for children
Israel struggles to contain deadly wildfires
Israel struggles to contain deadly wildfires |
Egypt opposition party to abandon seats won in vote
Suspect in Hollywood PR shooting commits suicide
Zynga buys rising mobile game star Newtoy
India expects to break logjam in climate talks |
Fears grow over length of US jobs crisis
Iran says arrests people behind scientist murder
Google to pay couple one dollar for trespassing
Qantas pilots saved crippled Airbus, investigator says |
Leave "path of confrontation," West tells Iran
Clearwire plans to sell over $1.1 billion in debt
Top Guinea court confirms Conde as president |
In Afghan cauldron, realism can trump the rulebook
China's U.N. influence rising, West should be careful: institute |
Afghan president: NATO killed ex-local official
Execs in India bribery probe ordered to judicial custody
OSCE fails to gain powers as old conflicts smolder |
Samsung promotes chairman's son, daughter
Christie's sets Hong Kong auction record
Ryan Gosling fired from film after ice cream binge
Triple despair in Asia as World Cup goes to Qatar
"Social Network" named best film by National Board of Review
Malaysia to deport Indonesian terror suspect
Global Weather-Celsius
Biggest US-Japan naval drill starts amid N.Korea crisis
Hussey leads Aussie Ashes fightback after early wickets
Germans strip to protest sky-high rents
Wine buffs take 'Golden Spitter' test
U.S., Japan stage joint drill amid regional tensions
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Bangladeshi pioneer of microfinancing faces charges of 'aid anomalies'
Disney's hairy princess could take box office crown
Future of TV? Snapping, swiping and surfing |
Seoul shares gain as Samsung Elec rallies
Ousted CBS weatherman: "It's a cruel business"
Japanese whaler leaves for Antarctic waters: Greenpeace
China to tighten monetary policy in 2011: Xinhua
Republicans cool to do not track Web plan |
Ryan Gosling fired from film after ice cream binge
Amazon blocks out WikiLeaks, but denies U.S. pressure |
Drummer says Jim Morrison never exposed himself
Amazon, eBay, Google going local |
China will pump 40 billion into Venezuela energy
Aretha Franklin says surgery "highly successful"
"Social Network" named best film by key group
S.Korea won extends gains to one-wk high on stocks
New wine case possible for US Supreme Court
Taiwan 2011 government bond issuance seen below 2010
Seoul shares end higher, Samsung Elec rallies
US, South Korea continue hunt for trade deal
S.Korea 3-yr treasury bonds firmer; curve steeper
Chairman's son becomes Samsung Electronics president
Korea Hot Stocks
Bristol Palin defends herself against Olbermann |
Disney's hairy princess could take box office crown |
'Dexter' stalks Season 6 renewal |
Ryan Gosling fired from film after ice cream binge |
Ricky Gervais and Emily Blunt join Muppets movie |
Drummer says Jim Morrison never exposed himself |
Another US company pulls plug on WikiLeaks
Ousted CBS weatherman: It's a cruel business |
Angelina Jolie defends Bosnian directorial debut |
WikiLeaks 'tweets' Kennedy speech on secrecy
Republicans cool to "do not track" Web plan
Clinton says Iran and North Korea could spark arms races
WikiLeaks' site back with Swiss name after cyber attacks
Mobile firms seeing ads coming to handsets
Saudi king to go undergo more surgery on Friday
Karzai seen as weak by U.S., own cabinet: WikiLeaks |
Euro is "credible," not in crisis: Trichet
Google ramps up fight against online piracy
Civilians displaced as Nigeria raids oil delta camps |
Amazon blocks out WikiLeaks, but denies U.S. pressure
WikiLeaks: Bribery, graft rampant in Afghanistan
International crews help Israel fight forest fire |
Amazon, eBay, Google going local
Future of TV? Snapping, swiping and surfing
Egypt pressed for delay in Sudan referendum
Executives in India bribery probe granted bail |
Formidable Israel lacks fire-fighting planes |
Northern Europe freeze kills 12 in Poland, disrupts transport |
Thai AirAsia launches Bangkok-Delhi, Bangkok-Kolkata routes
Berlusconi in Russia amid revelations of US concern
Philippines, communists to resume peace talks
Susan Boyle to regain chart crown as Peas flop
Oil leak possible cause of A380 blast: investigators
Bristol Palin defends herself against Olbermann
'Dexter' stalks Season 6 renewal
US missionary smashes portrait of N.Korea leader Kim
Ricky Gervais and Emily Blunt join Muppets movie
Japan confirms 1st high-risk bird flu on farm since '07
Mobile firms seeing ads coming to handsets |
British bank RBS to sell Uzbekistan unit to KDB
China vows to tighten monetary policy in 2011
Samsung promotes heir apparent, shares hit record |
Four Taiwan firms confirm AIG Taiwan unit bids
SAP open to expanding cooperation with HP: paper |
Taiwan's Cathay Fin confirms AIG Taiwan unit bid
France seeks to bar hosting WikiLeaks website |
Pakistan
WikiLeaks moves site to Switzerland amid U.S. fury |
Sands China loses bid for lucrative Macau land
France to auction 4G wireless frequencies by summer |
Nissan sets December 20 launch date for electric Leaf
Four global retailers seek stake in Indonesian retailer
Interview: One flash of her neck and Johnny Depp was done for |
Susan Boyle to regain chart crown as Peas flop |
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights

USD EUR - 1 year graph		BlogMeter 1.01