Forum Views () 
Forum Replies ()  
 
 
Read more with google mobile :
Canadian's battle role cast in doubt at Guantanamo
| International
|  
 
 
  
  	
  	  
			 
  
  
    
    
    	
		
			
                
                    
 
                    
                
            
			
			
				
                    
             
                
				
					My Profile 
					 
                    
            
            
                
			
		
  
	
	
	
    
		
          
	
     
Holiday Gift Guide
Gift ideas & reviews for this holiday season
Start Browsing
  
	
  
	
	
	
    
		
	 
	 
         
         
        
        
	
        
	
  
  
  		
  	You are here:
  
    Home
    
      >
      News 
      
      >
      International 
      
      >
      Article
	
    
		
	
  
 
          
	
    
Home
        
Business & Finance
        
News
        
U.S.
                
Politics
                
International
                
Technology
                
Entertainment
                
Sports
                
Lifestyle
                
Oddly Enough
                
Environment
                
Health
                
Science
                
Special Coverage
                
Video
                
Pictures
                
You Witness
                
The Great Debate
                
Blogs
                
Weather
                
Reader Feedback
                
	
    
		
	 
	 
         
         
        
        
	
        
	
  
	
Do More With Reuters
		
RSS
		
Widgets
		
Mobile
		
Podcasts
		
Newsletters
		
You Witness News
		
Make Reuters My Homepage
	
Partner Services
		
CareerBuilder
		
Affiliate Network
	
Professional Products
		
Support (Customer Zone)
		
Reuters Media
		
Financial Products
	
About Thomson Reuters
 
    
      
    
	
		
Canadian's battle role cast in doubt at Guantanamo
	
Fri Dec 12, 2008 6:00pm EST
 
	 
               
       
	
	
	 
		
			Email | Print | 
Share
 | Reprints | Single Page   
	
			[-]
			Text
			[+]
	
	
	
	
       
		
    
By Jane Sutton
    
GUANTANAMO BAY U.S. NAVAL BASE, Cuba (Reuters) - A Canadian teen was buried under the rubble of a bombed-out compound when someone threw the grenade that killed a U.S. soldier in Afghanistan, according to a soldier's report cited at the U.S. war crimes tribunal at Guantanamo on Friday.
    
The account raised doubts about whether Canadian defendant Omar Khadr, who is charged with murdering U.S. Army Sgt. 1st Class Christopher Speer, could have thrown the grenade that killed Speer during the 2002 firefight in a suspected al Qaeda compound in Afghanistan.
    
Defense lawyers want the soldier who gave that account of the battle to testify at Khadr's January 26 trial at the U.S. naval base in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba.
    
They debated the witness list in a court session on Friday even as they hoped that U.S. President-elect Barack Obama will pull the plug on the Guantanamo tribunals before Khadr's trial begins.
    
Obama takes office on January 20 and has said he would move the Guantanamo trials into the regular civilian or military courts. He has not specifically addressed how he would handle Khadr's case or 16 others already pending in the Guantanamo tribunals, which were established by the Bush administration to try foreign captives on terrorism charges and have been widely condemned by human rights activists and foreign governments.
    
Khadr, now a tall and bearded 22-year-old, was 15 when he was captured by U.S. forces who entered the compound after the aerial bombing ended. Speer was in the lead and was hit with a grenade but accounts of what happened next varied widely.
    
Khadr was sitting up and moving when a U.S. soldier shot him twice in the back, believing he had thrown the grenade that hit Speer, according to the shooter's report on the incident.
    
But another participant, identified in court documents only as Soldier No. 2, gave a military investigators a conflicting account of what he found upon entering the compound.
    
"Mr. Khadr was so covered in rubble that soldier No. 2 inadvertently stood on top of him and thought he was standing on a trap door because the ground did not seem solid," according to a court document based on that soldier's report to military investigators.
    
"He bent down to move the brush away to see what was beneath him and discovered that he was standing on a person and that Mr. Khadr appeared to be 'acting dead.'"
    
Defense lawyers also want to call as witnesses other U.S. soldiers who told investigators that U.S. forces were also throwing grenades at the time, suggesting Speer might have been killed by friendly fire.
    
Khadr, the Toronto-born son of an alleged al Qaeda financier, is one of two Guantanamo prisoners captured as juveniles and charged with crimes that carry a maximum penalty of life in prison. He has claimed he was abused and threatened with rape in U.S. custody in Afghanistan and at Guantanamo.
    
Prosecutors have scoffed at claims that he is a "child soldier" deserving of rehabilitation rather than prosecution under international treaties. Their evidence against him includes videotape of him building and planting roadside explosives in Afghanistan.
    
He is charged with murder, attempted murder, conspiring with al Qaeda, providing material support for terrorism and spying on U.S. forces who invaded Afghanistan to route al Qaeda after the September 11 attacks.
    
(Editing by Jackie Frank)
    
    
    
      
      
      
          © Thomson Reuters 2008 All rights reserved
    
               
      
	
    
		
 
	
		
 
		
Share:
		
Del.icio.us
		
Digg
		
Mixx
		
My Web
		
Facebook
		
LinkedIn
	
	
  
      
               
      
 
	
			
 
		
  		    Next Article:
		Obama seeks early January move to Washington
		
 
			
		
 
	
      
 
 
 
 
 
 
	 
China Now
The world's fourth biggest economy is at a crossroad as it celebrates 30 years of reforms.  Full Article 
Fruits of reform can be bitter
"Cancer village" pays ultimate price
Timeline: Milestones since 1978
Slideshow: Scenes from the past
Blog: Reporters' notes from China
	
	
     
  
  
	
    
  
	
        
	
    
     
     
    
    
        
        
	
		
		 
	
		
     
		
	 
               
       
      
               
       
      
	
	
 
	
		
	
    
		
	
  
          
	
    
		
	
	
	
    
		
	
	
  
	
	
  
	
    
		
Editor's Choice
	
     
Slideshow 
A selection of our best photos from the past 24 hours.  Slideshow 
  
	
  
	
    
		
          
	 
	 
         
         
        
	
  
 
 
	
    
				
Most Popular on Reuters
				
					
					
Articles
					
Video
					
Recommended
					
				 
			
			
  
               
      
	
	
		
		
			
Jim Rogers calls most big U.S. banks "bankrupt"
				
		
			Bush may tap bailout fund to aid automakers
				
		
			Bernard Madoff arrested over alleged $50 billion fraud
				
		
			1950s pin-up queen Bettie Page dies
				
		
			Ice storms knock power out across NY, New England
				
		
			Obama can sign U.N. climate pact before U.S. law: Kerry
				
		
			Detroit workers stunned, angered as bailout stalls
				
		
			Visa CEO loses his credit cards
				
		
			Legal experts see wide fallout from Madoff case
				
		
			Keanu Reeves falls to "Earth" in silly remake
				
		
		
			
			
Most Popular Articles RSS Feed
		
		
      
               
      
	
	
		
            
                  
                  
										
                  Video 
		
    
			
 Fresh riots grip Athens
    
			 Enough Troops?
    
			 Peru student clashes
    
			 Anger over Mumbai arrests
    
			 Auto bailout held up
    
			 Obama: Illinois Gov. should resign
    
			 Obama nativity a bestseller
    
			 al Qaeda arrests near EU summit
    
			 Daytime clashes in Athens
    
			 Talk of the Town-Golden Globes
    
	
		
		
Most Popular Videos RSS Feed
	
	
      
	
	
		
	 
Congo
Death all around 
Witness
Award winning Reuters photographer Finbarr O'Reilly recounts the horrors of living on the front line of the conflict in eastern Congo.  Blog 
Slideshow: Images from Congo
Video: The long wait for refugees
Blog: Caught in Chad rebel offensive
	
	
    
		
	
  
 
 
	
      
Reuters Deals
 
The global destination for corporate leaders, deal-makers and innovators
Knowledge to Act
  
	
    
		
 
 
	
  
          
  
    
Reuters.com: 
    Help and Contact Us  | 
    Advertise With Us  | 
    Mobile  | 
    Newsletters  | 
    RSS  | 
    Interactive TV  | 
    Labs  | 
    Reuters in Second Life  | 
    Archive  | 
    Site Index  | 
    Video Index
    
Thomson Reuters Corporate: 
		Copyright  | 
		Disclaimer  | 
		Privacy  | 
		Professional Products  | 
		Professional Products Support  | 
		About Thomson Reuters  | 
    Careers
  	
 
  	
International Editions:
  	
  	Africa  | 
  	Arabic  | 
  	Argentina  | 
  	Brazil  | 
  	Canada  | 
  	China  | 
  	France  | 
  	Germany  | 
  	India  | 
  	Italy  | 
  	Japan  | 
  	Latin America  | 
  	Mexico  | 
  	Russia  | 
  	Spain  | 
  	United Kingdom  | 
  	United States
    
 
    
Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests.
    
NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.
  
 
     
 
 
 
 
 
 
    
 
Other News on Saturday, 13 December 2008 Taiwan's ex-president Chen indicted for corruption  
US gives digital diplomacy a chance, on YouTube  
Luke Skywalker light saber auctioned for $240,000  
Hugh Jackman to host new-look Oscars  
Hugh Jackman to host new-look Oscars  
CNN names new White House team  
Pakistan investors brace for stock index floor removal  
India's industrial production shrinks in October  
Sarkozy defends 'European values' on Tibet  
Confiscating toy guns part of US mission in Iraq  
Iraq clerics call for calm after bombing  
Italian investor group formally takes over Alitalia  
Car key blocks mobile phone use while driving  
Iraqi official urges austerity measures  
Shareholders approve Britain's HBOS-Lloyds TSB merger  
Ecuador defaults, says to fight monster creditors
| International
|  
India plans 3G spectrum sale Jan 15: report  
White House mulls urgent new steps on autos  
Nobel laureates crown U2's Bono 'man of peace'  
Colombia extradites suspected drug lord to U.S.
| International
|  
Videogame sales shine despite economic gloom: report  
Athens anger resurfaces as Greek premier dismisses quit calls  
Brazilian's family blast police after anti-terror shooting verdict  
Vatican condemns embryo stem cell research, cloning
| International
|  
Ireland to hold second treaty vote after summit deal  
Museum to Chile's Pinochet sickens victims
| International
|  
US Treasury ready to stave off auto sector collapse  
Unanimous agreement on climate package: Sarkozy  
US gives visa to mother of Ecuadorean beaten in NY  
U.S. and Russia seek U.N. council agreement on Middle East
| International
|  
Armed guards would deter Somali pirates: U.S. Navy
| International
|  
US arms control official to hold talks in Moscow  
Navy commander questions land attacks on pirates  
UN talks set programme to landmark climate pact in '09  
Canadian's battle role cast in doubt at Guantanamo
| International
|  
S’pore congratulates Austrian city on winning winter YOG hosting bid  
Jimmy Carter regrets not meeting with Hezbollah  
EU hails climate deal as example for the world  
Zimbabwe seeks all support we can get on cholera
| International
|  
China welcomes EU climate deal, says US must do more  
Poor nations to get funds to fight climate change  
Prosecutors indict Taiwan's Chen on graft charges  
Highlights of EU deal to fight climate change  
Thai protesters warn against pro-Thaksin PM  
Unanimous agreement on climate package: Sarkozy  
UN confirms Afghan mass grave site disturbed  
Ex-chairman urges Intel to make car batteries: report
| Technology
|  
UN chief urges US to join UN rights body  
US troops kill 4 Afghans on bus that wouldn't stop  
Pakistan says India must give evidence on Mumbai  
Mumbai attacks spark upper-class calls for change  
Taiwan court to release indicted ex-leader on bail  
Hugh Jackman to host new-look Oscars
| Entertainment
|  
Nobel laureates launch appeal for Aung San Suu Kyi  
Actors' strike threat casts shadow over Oscars
| Entertainment
|  
1950s pin-up queen Bettie Page dies
| Entertainment
|  
Actor Van Johnson dies, aged 92
| Entertainment
|  
Actor Van Johnson, '40s heartthrob, dies at 92  
Marilyn Monroe photo may fetch record price
| Entertainment
|  
Winslet, Law and Owen to lead line-up at Berlin film fest  
Q&A: R&B star Chris Brown inspires avid fans
| Entertainment
|  
Iconic Marilyn Monroe photos to auction  
Nude Virgin of Guadalupe graces Playboy Mexico cover  
Blur reunion gig sells out in two minutes  
Dumas show explores birth, death and in-between  
'American Idol' may ax its charity after 2 years  
Celeb lunchboxes to benefit hunger relief  
Tokyo train stations to ban smoking  
1940's heartthrob Van Johnson dies at 92  
2008: The year politics saturated our pop culture  
After-parties feel heat from meltdown, SAG threat  
'American Pie' star Tara Reid checks into rehab  
Century mark: composer Elliott Carter turns 100  
Academy Awards hosts through the decades  
Singapore to boost construction, help airlines-report  
Philippine security forces foil bombings in Manila  
Asian powers in rare summit on economic crisis, NKorea  
Reporter's blog on Chicago sit-in to become book  
Screen Actors Guild faces dissension from NY board  
Gas-rich Turkmenistan holds parliamentary vote  
Italian police: Rocker stabbed, band members held  
New clashes in Athens, PM says people safe
| International
|  
Scotland Yard slammed after killing verdict  
U.S. halts N.Korea fuel aid until deal
| International
|  
Colombia extradites suspected drug lord to U.S.
| International
|  
Italian quits just short of rowing the Pacific solo
| International
|  
Panel urges U.N. to expand Congo sanctions list
| International
|  
Canadian's battle role cast in doubt at Guantanamo
| International
|  
Top Colombian drug trafficker arrives for trial in US  
Taiwan media urge fair trial for indicted ex-president  
Illinois moves to oust governor amid graft scandal  
Sri Lanka says 10 rebels killed in fighting  
US military deaths in Iraq war at 4,209  
UN talks set programme to a landmark climate pact in '09  
Voters head to polls in Indian Kashmir  
In-the-works video games cater to music fans
| Technology
|  
Pakistani cenbank sells 13.5 bln rupees of T-bills  
Japan, SKorean leaders regret NKorean talks failure  
Lawmakers urge FCC to delay contentious actions
| Technology
|  
German bourse opens office in Beijing: statement  
North Korea warns nuclear dismantling might slow  
US auto industry on brink as EU seals huge recession package  
Radio stations untangle more direct Web connections
| Technology
|  
S.Korea approves 11.5 pct rise in budget for 2009  
SKorea, China, Japan show unity at first summit  
Police: Pakistan militants kill 2 alleged US spies  
South Korean parliament passes 2009 budget despite boycott  
Malaysia burglar stuck for 3 days in haunted house  
China Eastern Airlines in management reshuffle  
Toyota to suffer 1.1 billion dollar loss for 2nd half: reports  
U.S. says N.Korea fuel aid halted until deal  
China's Baidu cuts revenue forecast on ad scandal  
Doubt made easy -- the hard way
| Entertainment
|  
Chinese Democracy shows limits of retail exclusives
| Entertainment
|  
Brian d'Arcy James is an unlikely ogre as Shrek  
US says no more fuel shipments to NKorea until nuke verification  
Pakistan militants destroy NATO vehicles: police  
China likely to miss energy saving goal for 2008: report  
Former Thai PM supporters gather for rally  
Former Myanmar dictator's daughter released from house arrest  
Cyclist Evans denies riding in 2009 Giro  
Pachuca beat Al Ahly 4-2 in extra time  
Judge jails man who offered Winehouse drugs  
Ousted Thai PM Thaksin to address thousands from exile  
UN chief urges China to continue Tibet dialogue  
US team meets Iraqis over Blackwater shooting  
Britain's Brown arrives in Afghanistan  
X Factor finalists set for showdown in Britain  
Iraqi PM rejects view U.S. troops needed for decade
| International
|  
Fort Hood soldiers to participate in marathon  
Russian troops move back into disputed village: Georgia  
Russia retakes Georgia border village
| International
|  
Gates warns US adversaries not to test Obama  
Russian FM sees roadblocks to future cooperation with NATO  
Police fire bullets against Kashmir protesters
| International
|  
US commander focuses on Sons of Iraq transition  
Zimbabwe seen eyeing fresh polls
| International
|  
Indian navy arrests 23 pirates in Gulf of Aden  
Training centre set up to meet demand for pre—school education professionals  
SKorea, China, Japan show unity at first summit  
British PM visits UK troops near Afghan front line  
3 killed, 3 kidnapped by Philippine militants  
Malls haven’t cut back on festive decor despite gloomy economic outlook  
British PM visits troops near Afghan front lines  
Mumbai's Taj Mahal hotel to reopen in a week: owners  
Pakistan: Police say Taliban kill alleged US spies  
Rower rescued off Australia after 10-month journey  
19 Mercy Relief volunteers honoured for disaster—relief in Myanmar, Yemen  
Springsteen memorabilia returned to NJ library  
Pakistan sends troops to guard NATO supply trucks  
8 artists display works at exhibition in the business district  
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro  
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found  
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever  
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production  
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time  
AMD to Start Production of piledriver  
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs  
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia  
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air  
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch  
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent  
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up  
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform  
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis  
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets  
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights