Forum Views ()
Forum Replies ()
Read more with google mobile :
Turkey in transition seeks closure on troubled past
Yahoo!
My Yahoo!
Mail
More Yahoo! Services
Account Options
New User? Sign Up
Sign In
Help
Yahoo! Search
web search
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Africa
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
North America
Turkey in transition seeks closure on troubled past
Reuters - Thursday, April 22
Send
IM Story
Print
By Simon Akam
ISTANBUL - In Court Number 6 in Diyarbakir, the main city in the mainly Kurdish southeast, Turkey is examining its recent history.
Along with six others, Colonel Cemal Temizoz stands accused of at least 20 killings during his time as a paramilitary commander in Cizre, a town in Sirnak province on the Syrian border, between 1993 and 1995.
Never before has such a senior uniformed figure faced trial for crimes committed during Turkey's bloody counter-insurgency campaign against ethnic Kurdish separatists.
Lurid testimony has been given of severed ears threaded as prayer beads and corpses disposed of in wells of acid. The web of evidence includes jailhouse testimony from a brother of Cizre's former mayor and the discovery of human remains.
For over 25 years the Kurdistan Workers' Party or PKK, a group designated a terrorist organisation by Turkey, the European Union and the United States, has fought an armed struggle in pursuit of a separate Kurdish state.
The conflict has cost tens of thousands of lives and led to a stream of internal migration away from the affected areas.
While human rights campaigners and the families of the dead have welcomed the Temizoz trial, the case also highlights the problems Turkey faces in reaching any settlement with its past.
Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan, the leader of the Islamic-leaning Justice and Development Party or AK, has tried to expand the rights of minority Kurds.
Nationalist rivals fiercely oppose Erdogan's initiatives, but so do many AK supporters. An election is due next year, and the AK has to protect its vote bank to win a third term.
The influence of conservative, secular nationalists opposed to AK has waned, but they remain a force to be reckoned with in a country that has become increasingly polarised since the AK shot to power in 2002.
The old elite's strongholds remain the military and the judiciary and the courts have become a battleground.
"Turkey is dealing with issues of transitional justice while the transition is not over yet," said Gerald Knaus, a fellow at the Carr Centre for Human Rights Policy at Harvard University.
While South Africa and some Latin American nations have tried to address past human rights abuses after a complete change of regime, Turkey is trying to address its past without such a dividing line between old and new governments.
At the same time it is taking steps to strengthen its democracy, having seen its military topple four governments in the last 50 years.
"What is happening in Turkey at the moment does not happen usually in countries where there is no big rupture," said Kerem Oktem, an academic at St. Anthony's College in Oxford.
RESPECT FOR MILITARY
For decades the idea endured that the military stood above civilian authorities as guardian of the secular values of the modern republic founded in 1923 by Mustafa Kemal Ataturk.
Today that notion is changing. There is still enormous respect for the military and Ataturk's portrait adorns classroom and office walls across the country.
But Turks, confident that democracy will bring prosperity and opportunity, do not want any more coups, and many believe the armed forces must be subject to the same laws as the rest of the country.
The ruling AK party has drafted constitutional amendments that would, among other changes, make military officers liable for prosecution in civilian, rather than military, courts.
Much of the current focus on the past stems from the Ergenekon investigation, a probe into the supposed 'deep state' -- a secret group of hardline nationalists in the security forces and bureaucracy determined to uphold secular values.
Named after a mythical Central Asian valley where Turks are said to have been saved from annihilation by a wolf that led them past their enemies, the Ergenekon network was said to have been planning the overthrow of Erdogan's government.
The investigation began in 2007 and as it gained ground, Turks watched in amazement as a procession of senior military figures, both serving and retired, appeared before prosecutors.
There was public support from the outset, but some have voiced the suspicion that the AK may have been using the probe to attack its political opponents.
Some think the number of cases, which has expanded to include events that happened after the Ergenekon investigation began, is too big for the judicial system to handle.
Others doubt whether the Ergenekon network even exists.
But Ergenekon has certainly broken taboos -- in particular by bringing previously untouchable military figures before prosecutors -- and opened the way for other investigations.
It has also proved the value of liberalizing statutes passed as part of Turkey's bid for EU membership.
"The Ergenekon investigation created an atmosphere which allowed us to deal with the other cases," said Orhan Kemal Cengiz, a columnist for the Turkish newspaper Today's Zaman.
Emma Sinclair-Webb, a researcher with Human Rights Watch in Turkey, said Ergenekon helped make it possible to bring the Temizoz case to court.
"It provided the inspiration and an impulse in the region for people to come forward, and for the press to cover the issue," she said.
In Diyarbakir, Temizoz is under arrest but is still commander of the provincial gendarmerie battalion, and Tahir Elci, a lawyer for the victims' families, fears the trial could end up in a military court.
"Until now I am happy with the case, but I also worry about future developments," he said. "The other side is trying to transfer the case to the military courts."
Recommend
Send
IM Story
Print
Related Articles
S.African luxury train derails, killing two AFP - Thursday, April 22
Missing found after Gulf of Mexico oil rig blast: report AFP - 2 hours 20 minutes ago
Ukraine extends Russia naval base lease for 25 years AFP - 2 hours 46 minutes ago
Former IOC chief Juan Antonio Samaranch dead at 89 AFP - Thursday, April 22
Europe's airspace reopens for business AFP - Thursday, April 22
News Search
Top Stories
Greece races to finalise aid deal by May 15
Global recovery patchy but quicker than expected: IMF
Former IOC chief Juan Antonio Samaranch dead at 89
Boeing profit falls 15% in first quarter
Iceland turns to jokes -- and soul-searching
More Top Stories »
ADVERTISEMENT
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Recommended
Apple engineer loses iPhone prototype
Iceland turns to jokes -- and soul-searching
Goldman Sachs' profits surge amid fraud scandal
Airlines lost '$1.7 bln' from ash chaos
EADS opts to compete against Boeing in US air tanker deal
More Most Viewed »
Two-million-year-old hominid sheds light on evolution
Apple engineer loses iPhone prototype
Taiwan's male 'Susan Boyle' a web sensation
EU emergency talks as volcano cloud havoc worsens
More Most Recommended »
Elsewhere on Yahoo!
Financial news on Yahoo! Finance
Stars and latest movies
Best travel destinations
More on Yahoo! News
Home
Singapore
Asia Pacific
World
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Technology
Subscribe to our news feeds
Top StoriesMy Yahoo!RSS
» More news feeds | What are news feeds?
Also on Yahoo
Answers
Groups
Mail
Messenger
Mobile
Travel
Finance
Movies
Sports
Games
» All Yahoo! Services
Site Highlights
Singapore
Full Coverage
Most Popular
Asia Entertainment
Photos
World Cup 2010
Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd. (Co. Reg. No. 199700735D). All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Service |
Privacy Policy |
Community |
Intellectual Property Rights Policy |
Help
Other News on Thursday, 22 April 2010 NATO ministers to meet on Afghan trainers, nuclear policy
Ukraine extends Russia naval base lease for 25 years
Turkish soldier killed, another hurt, in blast
eBay founder's online Hawaii news service launches
Former IOC chief Juan Antonio Samaranch dead at 89
Greece races to finalise aid deal by May 15
Afghanistan 'peace jirga' delayed until end of May
Greek debt costs soar at start of EU/IMF talks
|
Visa buying CyberSource for two billion dollars
Turkey in transition seeks closure on troubled past
Global recovery patchy but quicker than expected: IMF
Russia, Ukraine extend Black Sea fleet lease
Inventors float novelties at Geneva fair
American Airlines Parent, AMR, Posts $505 Million Q1 Loss
International anti-counterfeit plans published, EU reassures
50 years on, Brazil's utopian capital faces reality
|
Mo'Nique Upset About Oprah's Interview With Sexually Abusive Brother
Apple shares hit record high, slides
Police battle Bosnians protesting IMF-imposed cuts
|
McDonald's Q1 Profit Tops Estimates On Strong Global Sales
Florida Police Search For Man; Found Napping
1 Dead, 3 Survive Fishing Vessel Sinking In Gulf of Alaska
Wells Fargo Q1 Profit Dips On Credit Costs
U.S. warns Syria again on alleged Scud transfers
|
Josh Groban, Olivia Newton-John Guest Star On "Glee" Finale
Justin Bieber Holds #1 For Third Week On Billboard Albums Chart With "My World 2.0"
Patriot battery seen in Poland late May
|
Men Who Tunneled Into Medical-Marijuana Dispensary Arrested
Bomb-hit India fights to secure major sports events
|
EADS To Bid For Pentagon Tanker Contract; Seeks U.S. Partner
Missing found after Gulf of Mexico oil rig blast: report
Cargo plane crashes in the Philippines; 3 dead
6.2-magnitude earthquake strikes Samoa
Cargo plane crashes in the Philippines; 3 missing
Antonov aircraft crashes in Philippines; 3 missing
Facebook's Zuckerberg says site use increasing
|
Tibetan monks ordered out of China's quake zone
Popular ex-minister quits Japan's main opposition party
Sri Lankan president tightens grip on power
Target to carry Kindle at stores in late April
|
Indian guru arrested over sex scandal: police
IMF backs stronger Chinese currency as Asia powers ahead
AmEx to issue travelers checks in Chinese yuan
Day of mourning for China's earthquake victims
Sotheby's to auction manuscript by America's Mark Twain
Irish top Europe's binge drinking chart: EU survey
US-ENTERTAINMENT Summary
Weller on course for 6th no.1 album in UK charts
Iceland turns to jokes -- and soul-searching
Japan says 'sayonara' to Tokyo's kabuki theatre
Russia bans texts by Scientology founder
France to ban full Islamic veil from public spaces
Police Pinch Lady Claiming Lost Purse Containing Cocaine
Florida Police Search For Man; Found Napping
Men Who Tunneled Into Medical-Marijuana Dispensary Arrested
Muslim group issues warning to South Park show
|
Green Day musical no time of your life: critics
|
Billy Joel, ex-drummer settle royalty lawsuit
|
Weller on course for 6th no.1 album in UK charts
|
Iran Guards start three-day military exercise
Deutsche Bahn buys Britain's Arriva for 1.585 bln GBP
Rogue McAfee update paralyzes PCs worldwide
Ahmadinejad plans exodus to avert Iran quake disaster
Building up Afghan capacity seen as key challenge
|
Facebook seeks to spread across Internet
NATO ministers meet on Afghan trainers, nuclear policy
Blocking single gene 'aids spinal cord injuries'
China military paper spells out nuclear arms stance
|
UN launches website to track Haiti aid use
Obama Syria outreach under fire amid Scud reports
Airlines want compensation as Europe's skies reopen
Kindle to be sold in Target stores in first for Amazon
GM has repaid all government loans: CEO
US-TECH Summary
Ahmadinejad plans exodus to avert quake disaster
|
Target to carry Kindle at stores in late April
Option of striking Iran never off the table: Pentagon
|
Fast-growing Facebook aims for more social Web
North Korea torpedoed South's navy ship: report
|
Kyrgyzstan to hold election on Oct 10
|
Bill Gates and Geithner to launch agri-fund for poor
|
Tension deepens in Bangkok, fears unrest may spread
|
New warnings for tourists in New Delhi
Microsoft charters flights for stranded workers
|
China GoMe tycoon goes on trial for graft
Building up Afghan capacity seen as key challenge
Challenge to IPCC's Bangladesh climate predictions
Snow the latest challenge in China quake recovery
11 missing after Gulf of Mexico oil rig blast
Foot-and-mouth spreads on mainland S.Korea
Anger rises against Red Shirt protests in Bangkok
US warns Syria over 'supplying' missiles to Hezbollah
Gales and snow hit China's quake zone
U.S.'s Geithner, Bill Gates to launch agri-fund for poor
Sri Lanka former army chief demands 'rule of law'
Sri Lanka's former army chief demands freedom
North Korea torpedoed South's navy ship
Moody's lowers Toyota debt rating
Privacy chiefs keep watch over Facebook
|
Japan exports recover after record fall
Brazil tops world asking Google to remove content
|
Hyundai Motor's Q1 net profit hits record high
China puts appliance tycoon on trial
Seoul shares slip; Hynix, Hyundai Motor advance
S.Korea spotted buying dlrs to stem won's rise-traders
Japan's exports rise for 4th straight month
S.Korea's Samsung Heavy wins major order
Hyundai Motor's Q! net profit hits record high
Himalayan trail takes trekkers across top of world
Hyundai Heavy 1st-quarter net profit hits record
'Cove' director defiant of base ban, harassment
"South Park" airs censored episode after threat
Commercial paradigm brings inventors down to earth
Ogre "Shrek" looms in 3D to open Tribeca festival
Tim Urban out as "Idol" raises millions for charity
Weinsteins, Burkle continue exclusive talks with Disney
'South Park' creators draw radical Muslim ire
No drug role in suicide of Marie Osmond's son: officials
South Park airs censored episode after threat
|
Ogre Shrek looms in 3D to open Tribeca festival
|
Tim Urban out as Idol raises millions for charity
|
Patti Smith rescued from penury by song royalties
|
No drug role in suicide of Marie Osmond's son: officials
|
We still don't know Jack, despite Pacino's efforts
|
Weinsteins, Burkle continue exclusive talks with Disney
|
Networks blasted for shunning plus-sized models
|
Lisa Ray -- cancer-free and ready to re-embrace India
|
New Afghan elections chief sworn in
UK Catholic Church apologises for abuse scandal
German bishop tenders resignation to pope
Armenia halts ratification of Turkey peace deal
Greece plunges deeper into debt turmoil
Study launched on health impact from mobile phones
Iran tests speed boats in major Gulf war games
|
Greek 2009 deficit surges to 13.6% of GDP: EU
Jordan confirms blast near Israeli city
Japan eyes 'mind-reading' devices, robots 'by 2020'
European flights back to normal Thursday
|
Obama says US economy doomed without finance reform
Rockets fired at Israel fall in Jordan
Sony brings streaming baseball games to PS3 console
Obama urges Wall Street to back finance reform
Rockets fired at Israel fall in Jordan: source
|
U.S. Mideast envoy launching new mission
Belgium, France, move against full Islamic veil
Nokia slashes prices, to delay new software
Bomb halts Iraq-Turkey oil pipeline flow
Goldman chief says US charges are political: report
Privacy chiefs keep watch over Facebook
France wants to apply burqa ban to tourists
|
Iran tests speed boats in "major" Gulf war games
ICC prosecutor seeks ruling against Sudan over warrants
Riding surge in support, UK's third party in spotlight
|
Two rockets fall near Israeli city of Eilat: TV
Pakistani troops kill 20 Taliban in Orakzai
|
Study launched on health impact from mobile phones
Armenia halts ratification of Turkey peace deal
|
Sony brings streaming baseball games to PS3 console
Nokia slashes prices, to delay new software
Belgian government collapses, economy at risk
|
Iran president on controversial visit to Zimbabwe
|
Thai army threatens new crackdown on protesters
Bristol Palin: Hacked e-mail meant harassing calls
Cigarette sponsor pulled from Kelly Clarkson show
Pakistan announces measures to save energy
3 Kashmiris sentenced to death for India bomb
Motorcyclist deaths drop, sour economy cited
Series of grenade blasts wound 50 in Bangkok
Sri Lanka's Fonseka says govt trying to silence him
New animal species discovered in Borneo
Defector accuses N.Korea over S.Korea ship blast
China to punish those who dumped babies at river
S.Korean warship 'hit by N.Korean torpedo'
Sony brings streaming baseball games to PS3 console
|
Hyundai Heavy 1st-quarter net profit hits record
Study launched on health impact from mobile phones
|
Pakistani stocks rise; rupee firms; o/n rates down
Pakistan's forex reserves flat at $15.05 bln
Pakistan's budget deficit to overshoot target
Nokia slashes prices, to delay new software
|
Hyundai Motor's Q1 net profit hits record high
"Shrek" series finally ends with tired 3D outing
Fresh Greek debt woes send Asian markets down
Cartoon Network reviving "Looney Tunes"
LG Display turns Q1 profit as sales, prices gain
"The Losers" an action film for ADD sufferers
Moody's lowers Toyota debt rating
Kelly Clarkson flies into smoke storm
Moody's downgrades Toyota credit rating
Don't blame sports stars for young fans boozing: study
US, China announce anti-dumping steps
Lebanon's 'Shankaboot' brings Arab drama online
Indonesian workers protest against foreign manager
Patti Smith rescued from penury by song royalties
Kelly Clarkson refuses to cancel Indonesia concert
Film fetes small steps to address climate change
|
Kelly Clarkson flies into smoke storm
|
Punk pioneer McLaren to be buried in London
|
Cartoon Network reviving Looney Tunes
|
The Losers an action film for ADD sufferers
|
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights