InfoAnda - Foreign-language Oscar a magnet for controversy

Pakistanis angry over detentions in Times Sq. case
Monday, May 24, 2010
ISLAMABAD – Relatives of three men detained by Pakistan for alleged links to the suspect in the attempted Times Square bombing say the men are innocent.
They

Taiwan denies boycotting Australian film festival
Thursday, August 6, 2009

AFP - Thursday, August 6TAIPEI (AFP) - - Taiwan's Beijing-friendly government on Wednesday denied boycotting an Australian film festival amid a row over the e

Merkel's support dips, regional ally resigns International
Thursday, September 3, 2009

By Sarah Marsh and Noah Barkin

BERLIN (Reuters) - Chancellor Angela Merkel suffered a double blow on Thursday as a senior party ally in east German

Minister seeks closure of anti-Berlusconi websites
Wednesday, December 16, 2009
ROME (AFP) - – The Italian government moved Tuesday to close down Internet sites encouraging further violence against Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi, who

Asian markets mixed after Wall Street rally
Wednesday, March 18, 2009

By ELAINE KURTENBACH,AP Business Writer AP - Wednesday, March 18SHANGHAI - Asia's stock market rally seemed to be running out of steam Wednesday, despite an

Wynonna Judd Releases Exclusive Album, Products To Cracker Barrel Stores | 25 May 2010
Drug gang revenge attack kills Mexico marine's family | | 23 December 2009
New Zealand slump may have deepened, job market weakens | 4 May 2009

Nigeria says Saudi deports 150 female pilgrims, holding 1,000 | | 27 September 2012

Forum Views () Forum Replies ()

Read more with google mobile : Foreign-language Oscar a magnet for controversy | Entertainment |

My Profile Holiday Gift Guide Gift ideas & reviews for this holiday season Start Browsing You are here: Home > News > Entertainment > Article Home Business & Finance News U.S. Politics International Technology Entertainment Film Music People Television Arts Industry Sports Lifestyle Oddly Enough Environment Health Science Special Coverage Video Pictures The Great Debate Blogs Weather Reader Feedback Do More With Reuters RSS Widgets Mobile Podcasts Newsletters You Witness News Make Reuters My Homepage Partner Services CareerBuilder Affiliate Network Professional Products Support (Customer Zone) Reuters Media Financial Products About Thomson Reuters Foreign-language Oscar a magnet for controversy Tue Dec 23, 2008 4:24am EST Email | Print | Share | Reprints | Single Page [-] Text [+] By Steven Zeitchik LOS ANGELES (Hollywood Reporter) - Pity the foreign-language committee of the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences. No group works as hard watching so many difficult films. And yet no group takes as much grief for its choices. That's what happens when the normal discontentment about Oscar choices goes global. The complaining can get loud. This year, the rules for the foreign-language category again have been tweaked to limit oversights, and committee leaders generally are trying to learn from past flare-ups. No language controversies, the Academy hopes, a la the one over Israel's "The Band's Visit" last year. No debates over whether a submission actually comes from a bona fide country, like the flap over Palestinian entry "Divine Intervention" in 2002. No snubs of difficult material, like Romania's abortion-focused "4 Months, 3 Weeks and 2 Days" last year. This year, it's going to be different. But given the history of this difficult category -- voters, after all, have to compare dozens of divergent films and film cultures -- should we really be surprised if the announcement of the shortlist of nine next month brings more hand-wringing? First, a quick history. After years of getting tarred with the tag of predictability, the foreign-language committee two years ago overhauled its system. Instead of having several hundred members choose five nominees, that group could now name nine. A separate body of 30 members would then be convened to narrow the list to five nominees. The premise was that by allowing nearly twice as many films on the shortlist, there'd be fewer possibilities for an oversight. That seemed like a good idea -- until last year, when such edgier films as "4 Months" and France's "Persepolis" were excluded from the nine by the seemingly conservative voting committee. It turns out that giving a group more nominee slots doesn't change their sensibility; it just gives them more chances to make head-scratching choices. So this year, the executive committee of the foreign-language committee -- yes, the bureaucratic names can be more impenetrable than a Fassbinder film -- is taking back some of the power it delegated. It's allowing the larger group to choose only six of the nine. Then the executive committee is coming in and choosing three films of its own. "Historically, the general committee has a particular kind of member that may overlook something formally or thematically new or different or challenging. And though I don't love the word, I think we might be able to correct that a little," says Mark Johnson, chairman of the Academy's foreign-language film committee. The foreign-language group is like a constant gardener: It's always pruning, hoping the field looks better today than it did yesterday. And in many ways, it does. The lists of five nominees now, as a rule, contain fewer gaffes or serious omissions, even as the Academy must cope with a mindblowingly large pool of films thanks to burgeoning film regions including Eastern Europe and Latin America. But this year's rule changes, while solving one problem, open the door to another. If the executive committee's three slots are meant as a corrective, might it be tempted to use that power for reasons of politics instead of substance? Let's say the initial group doesn't choose "The Class." French filmmaker Laurent Cantet's picture is, undeniably, a great film and should be nominated. But will the executive committee feel pressure to choose it simply because it would be too embarrassing to omit a Palme d'Or winner? What happens, then, in a year when a more questionable Palme choice is made? There's another long-standing problem that the new rules don't address: Unlike the Globes, the Oscars use a "one country, one submission" procedure. The system is designed to manage the overall number of films (a record 67 were submitted this year) while giving every country an ostensibly equal shot at the prize. That's all well and good. The problem, though, is that it means worthy candidates are overlooked even before the Academy gets a chance to weigh in. Last year, France had to decide between "Persepolis" and "La Vie en Rose"; this year, Gauls had to pick among "The Class" and the equally worthy "A Christmas Tale" and "I've Loved You So Long." Filmmakers like Pedro Almodovar have been snubbed by their country. One film per country means some of the best movies are eliminated right off the bat. The Academy leadership acknowledges the problem but says there isn't much it can do; it doesn't want to wade into the politics of each country by choosing for it, and it can't throw open the doors to multiple submissions because it can't reasonably be expected to consider hundreds of films. But why not do something else? Why not allow a country to claim a wild card, say, once every five years? If France feels it has a particularly strong year -- or, for that matter, if the Academy does -- it could use the card to get two French films in that year. This way, the number of films stays manageable but a great film isn't excluded simply because it shares a homeland with another strong title. Continued... View article on single page Share: Del.icio.us Digg Mixx My Web Facebook LinkedIn Next Article: An appreciation of some underrated movies Also on Reuters Spacewalkers install probe outside space station Interpreters break down language barrier on the border Slideshow Slideshow: Jews mark the start of Hanukkah Video Talk of the Town:Johansson's sneeze Play Video More Video... Editor's Choice Slideshow A selection of our best photos from the past 24 hours. Slideshow Most Popular on Reuters Articles Video Recommended Eyes on U.S. GDP as world economies limp to Christmas | Video Two dead in Texas freeway shooting spree Housing crisis worsens as economy weakens Emerging market consumers hurting with rest of world | Video Police probe assault on 50 "witches" Grumpy miracle pig voted most popular animal Downturn hits vacation enclave of New York elite Buffeted "quants" are still in demand Madoff scandal stuns Palm Beach Jewish community Decapitated soldiers new blow to Mexico in drug war Most Popular Articles RSS Feed Video Mexico's drug war claims 9 lives Report:Braking caused crash? Obama presses for large stimulus Talk of the Town:Johansson's sneeze Toyota falls into red Obama raises job target Bout trial begins FARC 'will free six hostages' Illinois Governor arrested Rivals vow to end Hamas rule in Gaza Most Popular Videos RSS Feed Reuters Deals The global destination for corporate leaders, deal-makers and innovators Knowledge to Act Reuters.com: Help and Contact Us | Advertise With Us | Mobile | Newsletters | RSS | Interactive TV | Labs | Reuters in Second Life | Archive | Site Index | Video Index Thomson Reuters Corporate: Copyright | Disclaimer | Privacy | Professional Products | Professional Products Support | About Thomson Reuters | Careers International Editions: Africa | Arabic | Argentina | Brazil | Canada | China | France | Germany | India | Italy | Japan | Latin America | Mexico | Russia | Spain | United Kingdom | United States Thomson Reuters is the world's largest international multimedia news agency, providing investing news, world news, business news, technology news, headline news, small business news, news alerts, personal finance, stock market, and mutual funds information available on Reuters.com, video, mobile, and interactive television platforms. Thomson Reuters journalists are subject to an Editorial Handbook which requires fair presentation and disclosure of relevant interests. NYSE and AMEX quotes delayed by at least 20 minutes. Nasdaq delayed by at least 15 minutes. For a complete list of exchanges and delays, please click here.

Other News on Tuesday, 23 December 2008
Karzai presses top US military leader
Sri Lanka says 67 killed in northern fighting
Internet economy could shrink in 2009: OECD
Singaporean woman in custody in Philippines for links to alleged baby trafficking
Turkmenistan issues parliamentary election results
India gives Pakistan surviving gunman's letter
Suspected US missiles kill 8 in northwest Pakistan
Foreign Affairs Minister George Yeo congratulates new Thai counterpart
Juergen Flimm to manage Berlin opera
Cabbie helps police arrest convenience store robber
Robert Mulligan, director of `Mockingbird,' dies
India gives Pakistan Mumbai gunman's letter
MOM’s survey shows more employers providing family—friendly benefits
Hamas signals thaw; Israel sets up Gaza offensive
Kirsten Dunst granted restraining order
Review: `Marley & Me' yanks at heartstrings
Review: Cruise distractingly bad in `Valkyrie'
More than 100 killed in S.Lanka fighting: Tigers
Thai king calls for peace after political turmoil
FIDReC expands resources to handle expected increase in complaints
Yachting: Telefonica Blue team first to reach Singapore in Volvo Ocean race
Suspected US missiles kill 8 in northwest Pakistan
Review: Sandler's `Bedtime Stories' feeling tired
HDB to offer 4,000 smaller flats over the next two years
Game news: Rockin' around the Christmas tree
Ministry of Home Affairs to hold biggest recruitment drive
UN extends protection for Iraqi assets
Decapitated soldiers new blow to Mexico in drug war | International |
Unisys cuts 1,300 jobs, suspends raises
Georgia furious as OSCE observer mission scrapped
Israelis unearth Byzantine gold hoard
Doctors aid group lists top 10 humanitarian crises | International |
Colorado newspaper employees go online with survival plea
World stocks mostly drop in pre-Christmas trading
Bomb scare on Athens-Moscow flight
Iraqi PM: Shoe-thrower blames throat-slitter
China quake ruins cleared, but school anger unbowed | International |
OECD forecast deepens gloom as world stocks slip
Two Chinese giant pandas head for Taiwan
Fate of British troops in Iraq in doubt after vote derailed
Suspected U.S. drones kill 7 in Pakistan: agents | International |
Iraq MPs delay vote on foreign troops
Colombia rebuffs foreign help in hostage release | International |
Russia denies delivering S-300 missiles to Iran
Polar bear Knut opts for meat over intruder | International |
South Africa should cut off Zimbabwe electricity: Australian ex-PM
Sudan man accused of aiding Darfur war crime court | International |
US warns Russia against selling missiles to Iran
Singapore Hot Stocks-CapitaLand, Keppel, Ascendas India in focus
Mobile teleconsulting can evaluate stroke patients | Technology |
Toyota projects first loss in 70 years
US military buildup in Afghanistan taking form
MOVES-Pioneer Investments, Baker & Hostetler, FBR
Will Ferrell site, Funny Or Die, raises $3 million | Technology |
Seoul shares open down, led by Hynix Semiconductor
Japan emperor turns 75, pledges to care for family
Warner Music pulls videos from YouTube | Technology |
Toyota projects first loss in 70 years
China seeks WTO probe of US taxes on Chinese goods
Alleged arms dealer tries to evade handover to US
India awards oil and gas exploration rights
Chinese Internet porn sensation detained by police | Technology |
India FM: We will act on Mumbai if Pakistan won't
Alleged arms smuggler Bout testifies in Thailand
Tourism to Goa takes beating after Mumbai attacks
Aniston and Wilson explore marriage in Marley & Me | Entertainment |
Samantha Ronson recuperates from brief hospital stay | Entertainment |
Will Ferrell site, Funny Or Die, raises $3 million | Entertainment |
Recession -- the ultimate aphrodisiac
Obama invites poet Elizabeth Alexander to read at his inauguration
Berlin State Opera taps Flimm as artistic director
Grosses tumble at a Piven-less 'Speed-the-Plow'
David Spade helps Phoenix police buy rifles
Fans say yea as Carrey's `Yes Man' opens to $18.3M
Celebrities share adoption stories for TV special
Concert industry posts record year despite economy
`Titanic' duo DiCaprio and Winslet sail again
Review: `Button' dazzles visually, emotionally
'Sopranos' actor cleared of murder in NYPD death
Indonesian booze shortage halts Christmas fun
Fiji drops threat to expel New Zealand ambassador
GLOBAL MARKETS-Asia stocks drop for 3rd day as 2008 winds down
Behind the YouTube, Warner divorce
In central Jakarta, ruins of Indonesia's colonial past
Report: US asks SKorea to move troops to Afghan
US wants SKorea troops in Afghanistan: report
U.S. military chief urges India, Pakistan work together | International |
Chai and combat: French train Afghan army at frontline
Georgia in secret talks on restoring Russia ties: report
Olmert in Turkey for indirect Israel-Syria peace talks
Cuba's Raul Castro welcomes visiting Russian naval ships
Weak sales could topple US carmakers despite bailout
Veteran Guinea President Conte dies | International |
Earthly organisms developed in two sets of fits and starts: study
Drug gang violence surges in Honduras: study | International |
Investigators probe Denver jet accident
Males dominated 'out-of-Africa' migration 60,000 years ago
Japan emperor turns 75, frets over economy, health | International |
East Timor seen still on brink of anarchy | International |
Mauritanian president's release 'falls far short' of demands: US
Song and dance as China pandas take off for Taiwan | International |
China ready to use force on Somali pirates
Steinberg to be named deputy secretary of state
Road diversion trial at Woodlands Centre Road to be extended
Seoul shares drop 3 pct; carmakers slide on outlook
Investigators probe airplane's Denver runway skid
Fiji expels New Zealand ambassador
Taiwan auctions 10-yr bonds, yield below forecasts
China pandas lift off for Taiwan
Seoul shares fall 3 pct led by carmakers, Hynix
US has assurances from Iraq on Iranian rebels: official
China to make millions more eligible for poor relief: report
Toyota to replace president amid business slump: report
India says 3G entrants to also get 2G spectrum | Technology |
Two soldiers, 15 militants killed in Pakistan's Swat valley
US military deaths in Iraq war at 4,212
China's Sina to buy large part of digital ad giant's business
China's goodwill pandas lift off for Taiwan
NZ dollar steady as weak GDP data meets forecasts
Prominent writers call for release of Chinese activist
SKorean shipyards and builders face forced restructuring
Australia admits errors made in Indian 'terror' doctor case
Michael Jackson camp denies health problems | Entertainment |
Macau's Venetian sacks further 500 staff as credit crunch bites
Malaysia Islamic party revives contentious plan
Seoul shares extend decline on Hynix, automakers
Taiwan dlr falls to 1-wk low on c.bank move, jobs
Chow drops out as director of 'Green Hornet'
Saudis indulge long banned passion for silver screen
Italian army cannot defeat Mafia, says 'Gomorrah' director
Actors guild delays vote on strike authorization
Chow drops out as director of 'Green Hornet'
Paolini, Pullman with books coming to iPhones
Court agrees to pay Spears' father $75/hour
Capsule reviews of `Valkyrie' and other films
China earthquake parents sue over school collapse
Japan emperor turns 75
Asia couchsurfers travel cheap, face culture clash
Hollywood actors' union postpones strike vote
Chinese hackers to face up to seven years in jail: report
Seeking Happiness as a street artist in China
Chinese official under fire for lavish lifestyle
Accused Mumbai gunman requests Pakistan's help
Karzai attends memorial for 3 killed in US raid
Fiji and New Zealand trade diplomatic expulsions
S’pore woman in Philippines out of jail, pending further investigations
China to consider building aircraft carrier
Temporary viaduct in CBD to open to traffic on Sunday
3 Bangladesh militants to die for attack on envoy
Karzai attends memorial for 3 killed in US raid
Detained Iraqi security officials released on bail
Taliban's Omar rejects reports of peace formula | International |
British economy shrinks sharply in third quarter
Seven Russian tourists dead in Egypt coach crash
New Russian sea-based missile fails again in test: report
Heartbreak for Gambhir as Ind-Eng Test drawn
Hamas says may extend Gaza truce
Iraq political row threatens British troop vote | International |
Tremont hedge 'loses $3.3 bln in Madoff scandal'
Five Iraqi police killed in bombing
Mugabe dismisses U.S. stand on power-sharing pact | International |
Russian strategic missile test fails: report | International |
Army captain launches coup in Guinea after president's death
Russia demands changed mandate for OSCE in Georgia | International |
Decapitated soldiers new blow to Mexico in drug war | International |
Up to 6,000 child soldiers recruited in Darfur: U.N. | International |
Obama report due on Senate seat scandal
Indian PM: 'Nobody wants war' after terror attack
Hillary Clinton plans a more powerful State Dept: NY Times
Singapore Flyer grounded to a halt due to technical fault
China urges US to prevent trade protectionism
Indian leader: Nobody wants war
D.Telekom, Vodafone combine to expand German VDSL | Technology |
Taiwan Nov export orders slump, signal harsh slowdown
Police say they foiled attack in Indian Kashmir
Taiwan plans to issue T$110 bln govt bonds in Q1
Indonesia sees drop in tourism spending next year
China calls for return of Guantanamo Bay inmates
SKorean portals indicted over online piracy case
Philippines names 3 to panel for rebel peace talks
Hong Stock index drops 2.8 percent
Chinese court backs local firm in cellphone suit
Gas states meet in Russia amid 'gas OPEC' fears
Gas states meet in Russia amid 'gas OPEC' fears
Divided U.S. actors union delays strike vote | Entertainment |
Rare rhino calves found in Indonesian jungle
Taiwan shares slump on jobless news
Aniston and Wilson explore marriage in Marley & Me | Entertainment |
China's Shanghai stock index falls 4.6 pct
Foreign-language Oscar a magnet for controversy | Entertainment |
Fred Thompson lands daily radio show | Entertainment |
Beijing to build a Chinese Broadway: report | Entertainment |
Warner Bros. skips China release for 'Dark Knight'
Hollywood actors' union postpones strike vote
Warner Bros. skips China release for 'Dark Knight'
Annie Yi displays professionalism on stage but declines media interviews
Wu Jing: I respect all forms of martial art
Facebook users garner support for Chew Chor Meng
YES 933 DJ Christina Lim debuts in tele-movie
Rights group: Sri Lanka hampers aid to displaced
American Samoa letter sent to Honolulu for testing
Nepal media protest against Maoist union attack
Australia's anti-terror laws to be reviewed
Global minimum and maximum temperatures
Fiji and New Zealand trade diplomatic expulsions
Scholars, lawyers call for release of China critic
India flirts with military response to Mumbai attacks
Nepal media protest attack by ex-rebels
Malaysian activists call off nude protest
Documents offer look at big tobacco's tactics
Chinese city apologizes again for water pipes
Police say they foiled attack in Indian Kashmir
Builders must be licensed by June 2009 to carry out building works
Companies still partying on at year—end but on smaller budgets
HDB calls for tender for wet market at Sengkang Square
NKorean general threatens SKorea amid tensions
Bank of America denies China pressured it to drop bank stake sale
Greece at new risk of being pushed off euro
Bodies of missing Tenn. mom, Jo Ann Bain, and daughter found
Female Breasts Are Bigger Than Ever
AMD Trinity Accelerated Processing Units Now in Volume Production
The Avengers (2012 film), made the second biggest opening- and single-day gross of all-time
AMD to Start Production of piledriver
Ivy Bridge Quad-Core, Four-Thread Desktop CPUs
Islamists Protest Lady Gaga's Concert in Indonesia
Japan Successfully Broadcasts an 8K Signal Over the Air
ECB boosts loans to 1 trillion Euro to stop credit crunch
Egypt : Mohammed Morsi won with 52 percent
What do you call 100,000 Frenchmen with their hands up
AMD Launches AMD Embedded R-Series APU Platform
Fed Should not Ignore Emerging Market Crisis
Fed casts shadow over India, emerging markets
Why are Chinese tourists so rude? A few insights

USD EUR - 1 year graph		BlogMeter 1.01